Sessions Is Out

Let us not forget that the State of NY is also chomping at the bit to see those returns.
 
An "acting" AG only need to have been confirmed at some point in the past for an appointed position. Whittaker has been confirmed by the Senate in the past. Under the law that makes him eligible to be the acting AG.
Cite?
And I don't mean Trump's claim of that.
 
I'm not. Trust me, I'm not a Leftist or Progressive. Socially and politically, I'm just to the right of center.
I could only assume you are since you were complaining about "lefties" not being able to comprehend what they read, then replied to my post by making some hypothetical scenario unrelated to my statements.
 
You take Trump's use of the word "can't" as if there's some legal authority preventing it without considering other possibilities..
Because that's what he meant by "can't", hoping no one would notice it was BS, just like 80% of what he says.

Now that he's realized people are noticing it's BS, he's changed his story to there's no point in releasing them because no one would understand them.
Look, as I’ve told you, they’re under audit. They’re extremely complex. People wouldn’t understand them.

They’re done by among the biggest and best law firms in the country, same thing with the accounting firms. The accountants are very, very large power firms from the standpoint of respect, highly respected. Big firms.

But people don’t understand tax returns.
He's just throwing shit at a wall hoping some will stick.
 
Cite?
And I don't mean Trump's claim of that.

There isn't any citation. The law says that the acting AG must be someone who was confirmed by the Senate and who also works inside the DOJ.

Facts to know:

Whittaker was employed as Chief of Staff to Sessions at the time Sessions resigned.
Whittaker was previously appointed and confirmed by the Senate to a position as a US District Attorney in 2004.

There is no precedent on whether a prior confirmation is sufficient if the person named to be acting AG is not currently working in that appointed position. There's a lot of opining going on, but there's no authority either way. The Courts will have to sort it out.
 
Because that's what he meant by "can't", hoping no one would notice it was BS, just like 80% of what he says.

Now that he's realized people are noticing it's BS, he's changed his story to there's no point in releasing them because no one would understand them.He's just throwing shit at a wall hoping some will stick.

The problem is that he's under no obligation to reveal them yet some people think he is.

He can make excuses all day long and that still doesn't mean he has to reveal his tax returns. He can change his reasoning every day and twice on Sunday and it still doesn't change the basic fact that his tax returns are private information and he is not required to provide them for public scrutiny. That others have done so is also not a requirement that he follow suit. That his reasons are specious is not evidence of anything except he doesn't want to provide the information to the public or the government.

Nor can his decision to not provide his tax returns prove he is attempting to conceal criminal wrongdoing. He has a Right under the 4th Amendment, as well as statutory authority, to keep his tax return information private if he wishes. Nor can the exercising or Constitutional of statutory rights, under the law, be used to say he is guilty of a crime or attempting to conceal criminal culpability.

It can be total and complete BS. But he has a right to say no for whatever reason he wishes. You may not like it, but the answer to that is; *shrug*.
 
He is if subpoenaed. More importantly, the IRS is.

In order for any such subpoena from the House finances Committee to be valid, there has to be a nexus to an official investigation within the purview and authority of the committee.

At this point in time, there is no such investigation. Nor does the D wish of wanting to investigate Trump's taxes create one. The committee may subpoena an individual's tax information ONLY IF there is a legitimate basis for the subpoena. They cannot subpoena the return in order to engage in a fishing expedition.

Trump's refusal to reveal his taxes does not create a valid basis for the subpoena.
 
In order for any such subpoena from the House finances Committee to be valid, there has to be a nexus to an official investigation within the purview and authority of the committee.

At this point in time, there is no such investigation. Nor does the D wish of wanting to investigate Trump's taxes create one.

Of course it does. The returns might contain information relevant to collusion with Russia. Remember that the Mueller team is authorized to investigate that and anything else their investigation might lead to, such as corrupt business dealings unconnected with the 2016 campaign; and the House can do the same.

A more interesting question is whether Trump can be impeached for things he did before he took office -- but, if not, obstruction of justice is still good grounds.
 
In order for any such subpoena from the House finances Committee to be valid, there has to be a nexus to an official investigation within the purview and authority of the committee.

At this point in time, there is no such investigation. Nor does the D wish of wanting to investigate Trump's taxes create one. The committee may subpoena an individual's tax information ONLY IF there is a legitimate basis for the subpoena. They cannot subpoena the return in order to engage in a fishing expedition.

Trump's refusal to reveal his taxes does not create a valid basis for the subpoena.


WRONG AGAIN

https://www.npr.org/2018/10/11/6566...-demand-and-get-trumps-tax-returns-here-s-how

By law, taxpayer information is supposed to remain confidential. But as University of Virginia law professor George Yin, author of a 2017 article on the law, told NPR, Congress didn't like being dependent on the executive branch to provide tax records.

When the "committee access" provision, as it's known, became law in 1924, Congress had been dealing with taxpayers' information in the Teapot Dome scandal afflicting the Harding administration and in a controversy involving former Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon. Like Trump, he had served in government while refusing to avoid conflicts of interest by letting go of his holdings.

The committee access provision has rarely been invoked, but here's how it would work:

For the party in control of the House or Senate, making the request is easy. It would come from the chair of the House Ways and Means Committee (the House panel that writes tax law), Senate Finance Committee or Joint Committee on Taxation. Democrats have been badgering the Republican chairs of those panels to act since February 2017 without success.
Once a request is made, no floor action is necessary. The request would go to Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin, who oversees the IRS — not to the taxpayer in the Oval Office, who would officially be out of the loop. Yin said the 1924 law "gave the tax committees the unqualified right to request the tax returns of any taxpayer."
What would happen next is uncharted territory. Based on recent events, Trump might deploy Justice Department lawyers, and perhaps private lawyers, to fight the request in court. The process might resemble the not-infrequent legal battles over congressional subpoenas for executive branch documents. But the committee access provision has never been before a federal judge.
Were Congress to get access to Trump's returns, it would be easy for lawmakers to disclose the information, despite various privacy protections that exist for taxpayers. The chair or committee with Trump's tax returns could submit them to the full House or Senate if there's a legitimate legislative purpose. At that point, the returns would very likely quickly become available for the public to see on the Internet.
 
Of course it does. The returns might contain information relevant to collusion with Russia. Remember that the Mueller team is authorized to investigate that and anything else their investigation might lead to, such as corrupt business dealings unconnected with the 2016 campaign; and the House can do the same.

A more interesting question is whether Trump can be impeached for things he did before he took office -- but, if not, obstruction of justice is still good grounds.

This is a possibility. However, if Mueller finalizes his report and that report says there is no evidence of collusion between Trump and "The Russians" then there is no basis for the committee to claim that possibility.

The committee cannot bootstrap an new investigation once the current investigation finishes and finds no evidence.

BTW, from what I've been able to piece together, Mueller has already seen Trump's returns. If true and he says there's no there, there, then the Committee has zip.
 
WRONG AGAIN

https://www.npr.org/2018/10/11/6566...-demand-and-get-trumps-tax-returns-here-s-how

By law, taxpayer information is supposed to remain confidential. But as University of Virginia law professor George Yin, author of a 2017 article on the law, told NPR, Congress didn't like being dependent on the executive branch to provide tax records.

When the "committee access" provision, as it's known, became law in 1924, Congress had been dealing with taxpayers' information in the Teapot Dome scandal afflicting the Harding administration and in a controversy involving former Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon. Like Trump, he had served in government while refusing to avoid conflicts of interest by letting go of his holdings.

The committee access provision has rarely been invoked, but here's how it would work:

For the party in control of the House or Senate, making the request is easy. It would come from the chair of the House Ways and Means Committee (the House panel that writes tax law), Senate Finance Committee or Joint Committee on Taxation. Democrats have been badgering the Republican chairs of those panels to act since February 2017 without success.
Once a request is made, no floor action is necessary. The request would go to Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin, who oversees the IRS — not to the taxpayer in the Oval Office, who would officially be out of the loop. Yin said the 1924 law "gave the tax committees the unqualified right to request the tax returns of any taxpayer."
What would happen next is uncharted territory. Based on recent events, Trump might deploy Justice Department lawyers, and perhaps private lawyers, to fight the request in court. The process might resemble the not-infrequent legal battles over congressional subpoenas for executive branch documents. But the committee access provision has never been before a federal judge.
Were Congress to get access to Trump's returns, it would be easy for lawmakers to disclose the information, despite various privacy protections that exist for taxpayers. The chair or committee with Trump's tax returns could submit them to the full House or Senate if there's a legitimate legislative purpose. At that point, the returns would very likely quickly become available for the public to see on the Internet.

You need to calm down. Your quote states quite clearly that when Congress gave themselves access, it was because they were investigating a scandal. This as well as the Constitution limits the access of Congress to private personal information. (Remember, Congress is not above the Constitution or the law and must abide by those limitations.)

The Committee can make the request. But, in order for the request to be valid, there has to be a basis.

At this time, there is no basis upon which to support such a request. As such, Mnuchin can reject it and the Committee can go pound sand. And there's not much they can do about it.
 
You need to calm down. Your quote states quite clearly that when Congress gave themselves access, it was because they were investigating a scandal. This as well as the Constitution limits the access of Congress to private personal information. (Remember, Congress is not above the Constitution or the law and must abide by those limitations.)

The Committee can make the request. But, in order for the request to be valid, there has to be a basis.

At this time, there is no basis upon which to support such a request. As such, Mnuchin can reject it and the Committee can go pound sand. And there's not much they can do about it.

I'm plenty calm. You got shown the door again.


Are you gonna freak out like you did in the Elizabeth Warren thread?

You are one very poor excuse for a lawyer..other than your narcissism and arrogance. :rolleyes:
 
This is a possibility. However, if Mueller finalizes his report and that report says there is no evidence of collusion between Trump and "The Russians" then there is no basis for the committee to claim that possibility.

He's bound to find something -- Trump is infamous for playing fast and loose with the law throughout his career. He has well-documented ties to Russian mobsters.
 
The problem is that he's under no obligation to reveal them yet some people think he is.

He can make excuses all day long and that still doesn't mean he has to reveal his tax returns. He can change his reasoning every day and twice on Sunday and it still doesn't change the basic fact that his tax returns are private information and he is not required to provide them for public scrutiny. That others have done so is also not a requirement that he follow suit. That his reasons are specious is not evidence of anything except he doesn't want to provide the information to the public or the government.

Nor can his decision to not provide his tax returns prove he is attempting to conceal criminal wrongdoing. He has a Right under the 4th Amendment, as well as statutory authority, to keep his tax return information private if he wishes. Nor can the exercising or Constitutional of statutory rights, under the law, be used to say he is guilty of a crime or attempting to conceal criminal culpability.

It can be total and complete BS. But he has a right to say no for whatever reason he wishes. You may not like it, but the answer to that is; *shrug*.
Hmm, so you make a claim, then when called on it, that "can't" doesn't mean "I choose not to" you come back with another BS claim that people think he's obligated to release them. I think you need to quote the person who made that claim.

Then you ramble on reinforcing your argument against a claim no one made.
 
In the REAL WORLD, if my client lies to me, I have no legal culpability at all unless I knew he lied to me and I acted to further that lie. I won't be arrested. I won't be charged or indicted. I might be questioned, but I won't have to cut any kind of deal. It's called being a witness rather than an accessory.

You keep trying to say that because Trump won't release his taxes, he must have something to hide and that makes him a criminal. You twist and use a lot of meaningless words and ideas to get to that point, but it's the point you're trying to make.

Unfortunately, it's not true.

Dude, this is wrong. You are wrong about this situation. If you knowingly lie for a client, you will go to jail unless you take a plea. I know more about this than you. This is you being wrong about a thing.

Also, I straight up never said I thought Trump had anything to hide or that he was a criminal. I think you're responding to a bunch of people and getting them mixed up in your head.

I'm not trying to make a point. If you expect me to have a concrete reason every time I open my mouth then you have not MET me. Not everything has some big secret agenda. I've just been periodically correcting things you were wrong about.

I've been very open about the reason I want to see those taxes- If they're done correctly, then they're probably done very well, and the textbook examples on how to do international investment returns are not as good as a real-world examples under someone like Weisselburg, who has years of experience doing this very thing, and would be a good person to learn from. I'd like to see his work.

I guess you can't accept that maybe some people don't have hidden political agenda and just want to learn, but that's the truth.

I don't know anything about the dude's moral character, other than who he associates with, but if he DID lie, I can't fault him for it. I won't go to jail for anybody either, but if somebody brings a dumptruck of money up to my house and tells me to keep my mouth shut then I say, "Yes sir, bossman!" Because, shocker of shockers, I LIKE MONEY. I can't fault anyone for doing something I'd unquestionably do myself.

But, like I said before, when the feds came a knockin, I'd sing like a canary and take the plea deal, because I don't go to jail for nobody.

The fact of the matter is, this shit is probably going to come out, because dude is already under investigation and has been for a half a decade. You don't have to like it, but saying otherwise just makes you WRONG about a thing.

I don't know why people have such a hard time being wrong about stuff. I'm wrong about stuff all the time and I don't really internalize it. Usually I just google it, find out I was wrong, and move on with my life. Like... making you right about stuff doesn't make you a good person, or even a smart person. Any dumbass with an internet connection can be right about a thing. I don't get why this is such an issue for people. It's usually older people, too, so I suspect it has something to do with my generation having the ability to gain new information instantly and relying on that ability to the point that whether or not we're factually correct is something we can determine at a glance and therefore can't be more important than, say, hair color.

To me, getting mad that you're wrong is like getting mad that you can't remember something. Like, bragging about being right about a factual thing is no more impressive than that you could remember something. I can look shit up, and I can write shit down to remind myself. That stuff isn't impressive, and not having it isn't a character flaw. It doesn't matter.

I'm not saying, "You were wrong and therefore you're a bad person". I was just saying, "You were wrong and here's why." I expected you to accept it and move on with your life like any normal person would do, which is why I was shocked by the response- not because I had some kind of point to make or agenda to convince you of or anything. Factually, I know how the law around handling other people's finances works, because I have to live it. That's not something we can really argue about, it is just a thing you can be right or wrong about.

It's weird to me when people want to argue facts- because they are what they are. You can look them up.
 
Lol. More spoon feeding.

Hint: This ain't law school cupcake. Do your own homework.

No, but it's a public forum, and you're wrong... kind of a lot. So you can't expect people to believe you without checking your sources, because you're just... you've proven yourself not to be super credible, not to be super knowledgeable on the topic that you're talking about.

When you do that, YOU have to cite the sources, or people will dismiss you out of hand for not knowing what you're talking about.

If you don't, then all we have to go on is the assumption that you don't actually care if we believe you. And if you, who is the one who has the vested interest because you're the one who made the claim, don't care- then why the hell should we? We already didn't believe it or didn't care about it.

Like... that's not a law school thing, that's how human conversations work.

When you say something extraordinary, even in a conversation, you always start out with some kind of source.

"Guys, I just read this article and you're not gonna believe this shit," kind of deal. It doesn't even have to be controversial, it just has to be a claim that is unexpected.

"Guys I just read this article and you're not gonna believe this this- this scientist made glowing puppies. Isn't that fucked up? Glowing puppies are a thing now!"

Edit: Also, not for nothing, but glowing puppies are a thing. What a time to be alive.
 
Last edited:
If you did you'd know the appointment of Whittaker is unconstitutional because he hasn't been confirmed my the senate. And Trump's claim that it's isn't because he was confirmed 14 years ago for a district judge position is typical Trump BS that his ignorant base will say, "Yeah! That!" to.

edit to fix quote

Read 5 USC 3345 (Federal Vacancies Act)to understand how incorrect you are.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top