Sharia Law

Partly true, but irrelevant to my point.

Common Law is to Christianity

as

Sharia Law is to Islam

True or False?

If you answer true then you probably did really shitty on your SAT's

In some cases yes, in some cases no.

Turkey - no.

Saudi Arabia - yes.

With respect to Sharia v. Islam.


Christianity to common law is harder because I can't think of a "Christian" nation. Nor can I think of a nation that uses the common law exclusively.
 
maybe this will help;

Sharia Law: Shari'a is an Arabic word meaning “path” or “way.” Today the term is used most commonly to mean “Islamic law,” the detailed system of religious law developed by Muslim scholars in the first three centuries of Islam and still in force among fundamentalists today

Common Law: The ancient law of England based upon societal customs and recognized and enforced by the judgments and decrees of the courts. The general body of statutes and case law that governed England and the American colonies prior to the American Revolution.
The principles and rules of action, embodied in case law rather than legislative enactments, applicable to the government and protection of persons and property that derive their authority from the community customs and traditions that evolved over the centuries as interpreted by judicial tribunals.

See the difference?
 
There is nothing to justify trying to defend Sharia Law by pointing out flaws in other religions.

It is more barbaric, insane, and full of flaws than any 5 religions rolled in to one.
Christian, Judaism, etc .... are all filled with ridiculous, contrary bullshit. You would be the first to point it out and so would I.

So the question is why try to defend Sharia?

hypocrisy thy name is.....

there are equally as crazy laws in the bible.
it's just that western society has (mostly) evolved past taking notice of the crazy shit, whereas parts of the middle east seem to be regressing.

anyway, not all islamic laws are bad. they have some laws that we would all agree with too.
 
maybe this will help;

Sharia Law: Shari'a is an Arabic word meaning “path” or “way.” Today the term is used most commonly to mean “Islamic law,” the detailed system of religious law developed by Muslim scholars in the first three centuries of Islam and still in force among fundamentalists today

Common Law: The ancient law of England based upon societal customs and recognized and enforced by the judgments and decrees of the courts. The general body of statutes and case law that governed England and the American colonies prior to the American Revolution.
The principles and rules of action, embodied in case law rather than legislative enactments, applicable to the government and protection of persons and property that derive their authority from the community customs and traditions that evolved over the centuries as interpreted by judicial tribunals.

See the difference?


Read the rest of the wiki article.

Sharia is an aspect of Islam, but not all Islamic states use Sharia as their law.

You are trying to argue that Sharia is a religion. It's not. It's a societal code, like a common law/statutory law system.
 
there are equally as crazy laws in the bible.
it's just that western society has (mostly) evolved past taking notice of the crazy shit, whereas parts of the middle east seem to be regressing.

anyway, not all islamic laws are bad. they have some laws that we would all agree with too.

It ain't the parts of the Bible that I can't understand that bother me, it's the parts that I do understand.

I agree with you on a whole. The thing is no one is put to death for working on the Sabbath.

The same can not be said for the crazy in the Koran.

though we may want to reconsider this one :D

A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent
 
I don't much care for Sharia law or a Sharia-based society. I'd much rather live under the American rule of law.

Having said that, I don't feel the need to denigrate other countries' legal systems. People make their own societal rules.
 
Read the rest of the wiki article.

Sharia is an aspect of Islam, but not all Islamic states use Sharia as their law.

You are trying to argue that Sharia is a religion. It's not. It's a societal code, like a common law/statutory law system.

I am not trying to argue it is a religion, but it is religious based, much more so than common law. I was pointing out the hypocrisy of defending the crazy in one religion (even if it is just a religious based law) by pointing out the crazy in another.

If you read the thread; I am not the one that compared a religious law to a religion. I just ran with it.
 
Last edited:
I don't much care for Sharia law or a Sharia-based society. I'd much rather live under the American rule of law.

Having said that, I don't feel the need to denigrate other countries' legal systems. People make their own societal rules.

So you disagree with Saudi Arabia's suppression of women rights. But feel they have the right to do so?
 
It ain't the parts of the Bible that I can't understand that bother me, it's the parts that I do understand.

I agree with you on a whole. The thing is no one is put to death for working on the Sabbath.

The same can not be said for the crazy in the Koran.

though we may want to reconsider this one :D

A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent

if the bible and the qur'an have pretty much the same amount of crazy, it's not some ancient book that's really the issue. it's that there are societies who will look to it to excuse barbarism.
i think that the west is partly to blame. our god complex and constant meddling in their affairs has created a resentment which some people have harnessed. ''religious leaders'' point out how shit we've been, tell people they should reject all our values, cherry pick rules from old texts to push as the solution.
 
I don't much care for Sharia law or a Sharia-based society. I'd much rather live under the American rule of law.

Having said that, I don't feel the need to denigrate other countries' legal systems. People make their own societal rules.

like hitler did?
 
So you disagree with Saudi Arabia's suppression of women rights. But feel they have the right to do so?

In a perfect world, everyone would have equal rights.

The world, as you may have noticed, is not perfect.

We, as Americans, can urge others to treat everyone equally (even as Rapepublicans work tirelessly within America to restrict the rights of non-whites, non-males, non-straights, and non-Christians).

Blanket condemnation might feel good, and it fits nicely on a bumper sticker, but in the long run I doubt it does much good.

Since you're obviously more attuned to Saudi politics than I am, how would you go about convincing Saudis to treat women equally? (Assuming of course that you feel that they should be treated equally).
 
In a perfect world, everyone would have equal rights.

The world, as you may have noticed, is not perfect.

We, as Americans, can urge others to treat everyone equally (even as Rapepublicans work tirelessly within America to restrict the rights of non-whites, non-males, non-straights, and non-Christians).

Blanket condemnation might feel good, and it fits nicely on a bumper sticker, but in the long run I doubt it does much good.

Since you're obviously more attuned to Saudi politics than I am, how would you go about convincing Saudis to treat women equally? (Assuming of course that you feel that they should be treated equally).

Stop giving them foreign aid. (why the fuck are we giving them aid in the first place)

Stop letting their rich, spoiled little princes and princesses come to the USA with diplomatic immunity.

Stop giving/selling them military hardware
 
Sharia law in non Islamic countries (whether they are Muslims dominated or not):
People are free to set up any rules they want for their community, club, family and so on, as long as the rules, and the enforcement thereof, don't contradict the law of the land.

Sharia law in most Islamic countries: Same as above. But...
a) Some of the laws of the land are based on Sharia principles.
b) Some Sharia practices are still inconsistent with the law of the land and therefore not allowed.
c) Some tolerance in enforcing said laws, especially on foreigners and non muslims.

Sharia law in some orthodox Islamic countries:
More of (a), less of (b) and (c).

It's easy to point at Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan and say "aargh, Sharia!", but the problem is we really don't have anything around to compare it with. The only real theocracies at the moment are Islamic ones, although it has not always been that way and it might change again in the future.

What's the last solid theocracy we had that wasn't Islamic.... or The Vatican? Maybe Tibet, and as much as we're fawning over the Dalai Lama now, it wasn't exactly peachy back before the Chinese occupation there either.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boxlicker101
And it's the truth too. If you read the non-erotic poetry I have written, a lot of it is about my grandchildren. The interests do not conflict with each other. I once even posted a story about sex with a granddaughter, but I took it down because I thught she might see it and recognize herself.


You are a very disturbed individual.

Why do you say that? I don't necessarily disagree; I just wonder why you say that. :confused:

Incest is a very popular category on this site, including first person stories. The granddaughter involved was in her Twenties then, so it is nothing really off the wall. Technically, it was not even Incest, because she is actually my wife's granddaughter from a previous marriage, but it is still classified as Incest.

And the story was fiction, except for some background fact which she might have recognized.
 
Nothing wrong with a grandfather wanting to bang his granddaughter.

It's all the fashion in the southern states.
 
Nothing wrong with a grandfather wanting to bang his granddaughter.

It's all the fashion in the southern states.

And with a granddaughter wanting to bang her grandfather?
 
if the bible and the qur'an have pretty much the same amount of crazy, it's not some ancient book that's really the issue. it's that there are societies who will look to it to excuse barbarism.
i think that the west is partly to blame. our god complex and constant meddling in their affairs has created a resentment which some people have harnessed. ''religious leaders'' point out how shit we've been, tell people they should reject all our values, cherry pick rules from old texts to push as the solution.

They attacked first.
 
Sharia was the most talented Salt-N-Pepa but when she went solo it just didn't click for her.

I blame her management team and, frankly, very poor song choices.

But her hip-hop status remains legendary.
 
Sharia was the most talented Salt-N-Pepa but when she went solo it just didn't click for her.

I blame her management team and, frankly, very poor song choices.

But her hip-hop status remains legendary.


That old 80s song, "My Sharia" still gets stuck in my had now and then.
 
That old 80s song, "My Sharia" still gets stuck in my had now and then.

Ooh my little pretty one, pretty one.
When you gonna give me some time, Sharia?
Ooh you make my motor run, my motor run.
Gun it comin' off the line Sharia
Never gonna stop, give it up.
Such a dirty mind. Always get it up for the touch
of the younger kind. My my my yi woo. M M M My Sharia...
 
That old 80s song, "My Sharia" still gets stuck in my had now and then.

It sounds like a girl I could have taken to junior year prom. Sharia Law. I imagine she's a little slutty but I still didn't get any.
 
In some cases yes, in some cases no.

Turkey - no.

Saudi Arabia - yes.

With respect to Sharia v. Islam.


Christianity to common law is harder because I can't think of a "Christian" nation. Nor can I think of a nation that uses the common law exclusively.

We are not a "Christian" nation. As much as some people want to believe it, we're not. For us to be that, the USA must have an "official" religion, which we will never ever ever have.

Secondly, our Federal judicial system and by extension our states would be more closely follow Louisiana.
 
We are not a "Christian" nation. As much as some people want to believe it, we're not. For us to be that, the USA must have an "official" religion, which we will never ever ever have.

Secondly, our Federal judicial system and by extension our states would be more closely follow Louisiana.

That's pretty much 100% wrong.


Your first paragraph is interesting, but irrelevant to my post, that you replied to.
 
Back
Top