Should the 2nd Amendment be repealed?

Should the 2nd amendment right to bear arms be repealed?

  • Yes

    Votes: 26 21.1%
  • No

    Votes: 97 78.9%

  • Total voters
    123
  • Poll closed .
Do you begin all your posts with a summary?

I'd say he accurately summarized your post.

Stone-age tribesmen vs Soviets with logistical support and stingers, same vs us with support from nearly stoneage Iran.

...and they don't have rednecks with barretts and US military training. You also presume a lot if you assume the entire military stays loyal to a corrupt, bloated government.
 
Every officer in the United States Armed Forces must swear an oath to support and defend the Constitution against all enemies - foreign and domestic.

That oath traditionally ends with, So help me God.

The US military will instantly lose at least half of its very best officers if government chooses to become the enemy of the Constitution by directly violating its 2nd Amendment. A vast majority of enlistees will just as instantly quit.

America will righteously submerge into total anarchy, with the illegitimate government only able to secure - at absolute best - the 20% of the land 80% of current Americans occupy; the rest of the 80% of the land will be up for grabs, with large swaths of it either unattractive to the illegitimate government or completely uncontrollable.

One side will be fighting to establish government as king over all, the other side will be fighting in support and defense of the Constitution for the United States of America. And, of course, the good guys will prevail.
 
Nobody is going to wage war against the US government with anything but a fully-equipped military, and no stockpile of personal arms is going to make a dent in the Air Force or even a single Abrams tank.

So if you're truly interested in a domestic uprising that can make a real difference in the way our country is run, the best course of action is to decrease the US military to the point where it can be drowned in a bathtub. That is also something you have the freedom to do.


It's odd that the same people who advocate overthrowing the government are the same people who want to advocate for almost endless military buildup, and increased militarization of police forces across the country.

Who do these fuckwits think they're gonna be fighting?
 
I'd say he accurately summarized your post.

Stone-age tribesmen vs Soviets with logistical support and stingers, same vs us with support from nearly stoneage Iran.

...and they don't have rednecks with barretts and US military training. You also presume a lot if you assume the entire military stays loyal to a corrupt, bloated government.
Like everybody else in the nation, they will be loyal to the people who write the checks.

Stoneage Iran? Really? So they're not at all likely to become a nuclear threat.
 
The Second Amendment of the United States Constitution reads: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

I won't ask for a repeal but I would like clarification on the intent of the militia and whether there are any limitations on arms for said militia.

You do not need a clarification. Not one of the ten amendments was written to do anything other than protect individual rights from the tyranny of a distant and centralized government. Therefore the second amendment clearly meant the right to bear arms for the individual.
 
Most countries in decline experience increasing small arms ownership.
 
Give it a rest Hoser. You would be better off suggesting a bill to deny motherhood.
 
Never!

It's what makes this country.

It's the cost of freedom in it's pure form.
 
USA! USA!

Yes...The freedom to kill each other is celebrated in many great nations.

Like the Congo.

It's ok if we kill each other. It's even ok if we kill a few dozen of our children on occasion.

We just don't want muzzies kiling us. Maybe the 2nd Amendment should have a religious test associated with it.
 
It's ok if we kill each other. It's even ok if we kill a few dozen of our children on occasion.

We just don't want muzzies kiling us. Maybe the 2nd Amendment should have a religious test associated with it.


They do that in most gunhappy countries; you guys need to get with the times.

More Jesus, more Country Music!
 
Every officer in the United States Armed Forces must swear an oath to support and defend the Constitution against all enemies - foreign and domestic.

That oath traditionally ends with, So help me God.

The US military will instantly lose at least half of its very best officers if government chooses to become the enemy of the Constitution by directly violating its 2nd Amendment. A vast majority of enlistees will just as instantly quit.

America will righteously submerge into total anarchy, with the illegitimate government only able to secure - at absolute best - the 20% of the land 80% of current Americans occupy; the rest of the 80% of the land will be up for grabs, with large swaths of it either unattractive to the illegitimate government or completely uncontrollable.

One side will be fighting to establish government as king over all, the other side will be fighting in support and defense of the Constitution for the United States of America. And, of course, the good guys will prevail.

You sound curiously like another blithering idiot who crops up here every few weeks with a new user ID and low post count.

The thread title addresses REPEALING the 2nd Amendment. The Constitution includes provisions for amending itself including REPEAL of previous amendments or entire Articles if CITIZENS through their elected representatives so choose.

REPEAL isn't a "VIOLATION" of anything. Taking an oath to DEFEND the Constitution includes defending the right of citizens to amend and repeal it. The only ENEMY of the Constitution would be anyone subsequently bearing arms against a lawful Constitutional amendment process simply because they did not like what that process produced.

Dumbass.

By the way, do you stockpile new user names in advance so that you can jump right back into the fray every time you're banned?
 
10,000 lives a year. Must bring a smile to Bin Laden's face while he burns in hell.

No Just Pierre Trudeau when he suspened Canadians civil rights with the war measures act in 1970 because of a handful of radicals.

Try that here .......
 
No Just Pierre Trudeau when he suspened Canadians civil rights with the war measures act in 1970 because of a handful of radicals.

Try that here .......

And he went on to rule for years and is rated as the Greatest Canadian. That is how you deal with terrorists and those who would use violence to achieve political ends.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeTsQQ22Uwc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-7_a2wa2dd4

Must confuse the hell out of you Yanks. Thinking us Canucks are a bunch of hippy socialist liberal types yet all about law and order.

POGG
 
Last edited:
You do not need a clarification. Not one of the ten amendments was written to do anything other than protect individual rights from the tyranny of a distant and centralized government. Therefore the second amendment clearly meant the right to bear arms for the individual.

Update - See post #88.

The phrase, "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" does that but the second amendment does not stop with that phrase. The phrase, "A well regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free State" was included. Does that phrase qualify the right to bear arms?

They had just kicked out an overseas monarchy so having a military capability would have been on their minds.

Present day definitions of militia do not help any here as a militia can be of support to a regular army or in opposition to a regular army. Constitutional scholars may have an idea of what it meant to those folks writing the document. One might think that the militia would have been to support a government by the people and for the people.

Who decides what a well regulated militia is? Were the states to regulate the militia? If so, was the federal government to oversee the status of the militia to insure that no state was slacking in their obligation?

Individuals can have arms to form a militia to insure a free State. Was the free State for the individual or for a functional government? There is room for clarification.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. The US military would be defending its home.

You think that a conflict of that nature (which I don't believe will happen) would involve generals saying "Hey pvt. Walt, go defend your house."?

Soldiers would be tasked with protecting assets and rich people, and killing insurgents that are nowhere near their home.

I feel like if that's what you really think, you lack an understanding of how modern conflict has occurred.
 
Last edited:
The phrase, "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" does that but the second amendment does not stop with that phrase. The phrase, "A well regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free State" was included. Does that phrase qualify the right to bear arms?

They had just kicked out an overseas monarchy so having a military capability would have been on their minds.

Present day definitions of militia do not help any here as a militia can be of support to a regular army or in opposition to a regular army. Constitutional scholars may have an idea of what it meant to those folks writing the document. One might think that the militia would have been to support a government by the people and for the people.

Who decides what a well regulated militia is? Were the states to regulate the militia? If so, was the federal government to oversee the status of the militia to insure that no state was slacking in their obligation?

Individuals can have arms to form a militia to insure a free State. Was the free State for the individual or for a functional government? There is room for clarification.

NO!! The Supreme Court long ago dealt with the reference to the militia as NOT adversely qualifying the right of individual gun ownership. If you knew anything about Constitutional law, you would already know that.
 
Back
Top