Star Trek

I'd disagree. Kirk was a "shoot from the hip" sort of character, yes, but he wasn't a vindictive, self opportunist. That's how I see JJ's version as being, actually, all of JJ's universe seem out for themselves only. He portrayed Spock as being virtually unhinged, Chekov looked like he was on "uppers" and he definitely wasn't a "go to" guy...



I haven't seen anybody who did, but if they were alive at that time, then shame on them! Younger people who, obviously, weren't around at the time I tend to make excuses for. They were spoon fed years of great special effects and green screens and can't imagine that that technology was rather "recent". Then again, most kids my age (when I was a kid) scoffed at F/X from old serials like Flash Gordon (because of strings, etc). Likewise special effects at that time was in it's infancy, and should have been respected for what they were.



I would disagree on this, but without summoning the dead, we'll never know.



True, but my reasoning for questioning the age of Spock in JJ's movie, is; In TOS, Spock served with Captain Pike (presumably there were other commands he was under as he worked up in the ranks) until he was second in command of the Enterprise. He would have also go to Starfleet training, etc etc.

In JJ's bizzaro alternate universe, Spock has gone to starfleet (for training), worked up in the ranks, and had become a star fleet instructor in all of about 2-5 years??? Okay, he's Vulcan and could have done the fast track but it is still a "LITTLE" reaching. The problem as I see is is simply this; Hollywood has a limited amount of people to use to cast for roles. Also, they do tend to swing everybody as young as they can because "that's what young people who go to movies want to see; young actors".
I personally feel Spock was 20-40+ years older than Kirk. Physically, they would look the same age, but emotionally, I would expect Spock would be ...more mature, meaning JJ's script was shite.

But even with some of the spin off TV series, I think they have a bit of a paradox in the scripts for time lines. For instance, (I forget the exact numbers) I think Spock's father is still alive after 500-700 years. (Who knows how old he was in TOS, and he was still alive and kicking in TNG. This sets a precedent on how old Vulcans can become. It was implied (or stated) he had more than one wife (three?) after Amanda. or you could use T'pau who was an old woman in TOS and a young woman in ST:E. (which is also a timeline error, because it has been suggested that Capt Archer was about 30 years before Capt Kirk and that they knew each other. But if T'pau looks 50-60+ human years older, then about 500 years have passed between ST:E and TOS)

However, the idea was stated, in various series, that Surak (father of modern Vulcan logic and reasoning) lived (implied (legendary)) many generations ago.
Then in ST:E, they said ~1000 years ago, which, for a Vulcan would mean maybe 2-3 generations ago?? :rolleyes:
"Generations" is a subjective term because it depends on how old a Vulcan becomes before they grind out another generation. Now, Vulcans mate every 7 years, yet Spock didn't have any siblings nor 1/2 brothers/sisters. This suggests that Vulcans don't have large families despite their longevity. So, I'm guessing a generation is ~200-300 years.

Unfortunately, I notice little nuance details like this which, for me, spoils the enjoyment.

You're confused on T'Pau. T'Pau is TOS. T'Pol is a different vulcan female in ST Enterprise. Similar in sound and spelling, but 2 different characters.

Spock of TOS does indeed have one 1/2 brother from his father's side, but kept it secret from others. His 1/2 brother was explained in one of the TOS movies before the TNG movies and actually the primary focus of one of those movies. Which explains that Sarek (Spock's father) either had more than one wife or a previous wife.

Maybe this link will help explain the ST universe. http://www.startrek.com/database_article_navigator/star-trek-the-original-series
 
Last edited:
You're confused on T'Pau. T'Pau is TOS. T'Pol is a different vulcan female in ST Enterprise. Similar in sound and spelling, but 2 different characters.

Apparently you weren't aware that when Archer and T'pol went to Vulcan "The Forge/Awakening/Kir'shara" they met up with T'pau. This is the "same" T'pau who was in TOS "Amok time"

Spock of TOS does indeed have one 1/2 brother from his father's side, but kept it secret from others. His 1/2 brother was explained in one of the TOS movies before the TNG movies and actually the primary focus of one of those movies. Which explains that Sarek (Spock's father) either had more than one wife or a previous wife.

Okay, you got me on that one, I forgot about that or wasn't paying much attention to that movie...
 
I disagree....ST was NEVER about special effects and technology to make a great space flick/shot...it wasn't really about space, that just happened to be the setting.

ST has and always will be about the human condition, and the great ethical/moral conflicts that come with it, that's what made ST so fucking good......now its' about the special effects budget drawing in the "Owe my balls!" crowd....:rolleyes:

Roddenberry pitched Star Trek as "Wagon Train (a popular tv show then) to the stars".

He had previously worked on "Have Gun, Will Travel", a series of morality plays set in the American West. And Star Trek continued that.

It was not primarily about predicting the future and the technology that would come, it was about putting people in moral dilemmas to make the viewer think about right and wrong.

TOS, at its heart, was about the human condition, not technology and damn sure not special effects.

The comment about the low budget was spot on. One of Star Treks best technology items came about as a result of low budget. They couldn't afford to build models and film shuttles taking the landing party down to planets. So they came up with the transporter. Because it was a lot cheaper to film.
 
Apparently you weren't aware that when Archer and T'pol went to Vulcan "The Forge/Awakening/Kir'shara" they met up with T'pau. This is the "same" T'pau who was in TOS "Amok time"



Okay, you got me on that one, I forgot about that or wasn't paying much attention to that movie...

It can all be confusing. There's so much expansion of the ST franchise over the years, it's hard to fill in the gaps......which is why it's so important to get certain details right. Even when a non-essential character makes a singular reference, it can be the source of an explanation or the focus of a future ST movie/TV series.

But Kirk never knew Archer. (One ST:E show interlinked them via that time continuum thing, but even that involved a vulcan character from the Voyager series who served, I think, with Kirk, Janeway, and Picard.) T'Pau and T'Pol are definately different characters. I believe you're thinking about Vulcan katra. I had this argument w/my daughter and thought the same as you, until she proved me wrong. Another misunderstanding of how Klingons became enemies via some misunderstandings intentionally caused by another race (explained in ST:E), then allies in a TOS movie (not TOS TV series), that paved the way for Klingon (not Romulan) alliance in TNG.

I think ST Enterprise could have been soooo much better in it's last year. It had everything going for it.

I never watched DS9 or the Animated Series much.
 
Last edited:
Roddenberry pitched Star Trek as "Wagon Train (a popular tv show then) to the stars".

He had previously worked on "Have Gun, Will Travel", a series of morality plays set in the American West. And Star Trek continued that.

It was not primarily about predicting the future and the technology that would come, it was about putting people in moral dilemmas to make the viewer think about right and wrong.

TOS, at its heart, was about the human condition, not technology and damn sure not special effects.

The comment about the low budget was spot on. One of Star Treks best technology items came about as a result of low budget. They couldn't afford to build models and film shuttles taking the landing party down to planets. So they came up with the transporter. Because it was a lot cheaper to film.

I know....I totally agree with you. Notice I said it was NOT about SE or even really about space.

And honestly I'm just trolling this thread for wake n' bake entertainment....I mean really...what ruffles feathers like a good hipster douche bag argument? "Oh the new stuff is Sooooooooo over rated...old school....strike that..."vintage" all the way. :cool:"

I thought the new movie was awesome, I thought the 1'st JJ Trek was awesome, wish they would do like an HBO series on the new timeline spin off instead of movies though, that's my only complaint...more.
 
Last edited:
It can all be confusing. There's so much expansion of the ST franchise over the years, it's hard to fill in the gaps......which is why it's so important to get certain details right. Even when a non-essential character makes a singular reference, it can be the source of an explanation or the focus of a future ST movie/TV series.

But Kirk never knew Archer. (One ST:E show interlinked them via that time continuum thing, but even that involved a vulcan character from the Voyager series who served, I think, with Kirk, Janeway, and Picard.) T'Pau and T'Pol are definately different characters. I believe you're thinking about Vulcan katra. I had this argument w/my daughter and thought the same as you, until she proved me wrong. Another misunderstanding of how Klingons became enemies via some misunderstandings intentionally caused by another race (explained in ST:E), then allies in a TOS movie (not TOS TV series), that paved the way for Klingon (not Romulan) alliance in TNG.

I think ST Enterprise could have been soooo much better in it's last year. It had everything going for it.

I never watched DS9 or the Animated Series much.

LWulf is correct, T'Pol and Archer meet T'Pau in the season 4 episode "Awakening". The katra Archer experiences is that of Surak. Check the wiki if you doubt me.
 
But Kirk never knew Archer.

Okay, I am going more by memory than some linked info, but...
As I recall, in some last episode of ST:E, Archer was talking about future captains, and he mentions a (junior officer forgot the exact title) Pike. Now Pike was a captain who was older than, but knew Capt Kirk. In a way, they implied that Archer would have been (maybe an admiral?) in the time of capt Kirk. In JJ's enterprise, Capt Pike was capt of the enterprise when Kirk's father was a junior grade officer. Kirk was 20 when Pike was about 40-50. so the difference there would be Archer would have been 80's when Kirk was in his 20's.

So, according to TOS/ST:E, if Archer was in his 30's when Pike was in his 20's, then Archer would be lets say 15 years older than Pike when Pike is, let's say 45, so Archer would thus be in his 60's when Kirk was in his 30's. +/-10 yrs

That's younger than retirement, and therefore, Kirk and Archer would thus have "known" each other. (NOT via temporal mechanics).

In any event, from the Archer's time to Kirk's time is clearly not the 300-400 years for T'pau to have aged from ST:E to TOS as implied in the series, which is all I was saying, there was a timeline error in script writing.

T'Pau and T'Pol are definately different characters.

I believe you're thinking about Vulcan katra.

Yes, I know that.

Yes, the Katra is a Vulcan soul, for lack of other terminology, which was the focal point concept of The Forge from ST:E.

T'Pau portrayed by :
Celia Lovsky
Betty Matsushita
Kara Zediker (OMG what a hottie! had to add that)

Episodes:
Amok Time (TOS),
Darkling (VOY),
The Forge (ENT) recurring thereafter
A Vulcan who led the Syrranite rebellion against the Vulcan High Command, later presided over the Koon-ut-kal-if-fee ceremony in which Spock is forced to fight Captain Kirk after Spock was rejected by his bride-to-be, T'Pring. She is also the only person ever to turn down a seat on the Federation Council. The English pop group T'Pau was named after the character,[1] as was a fictional Vulcan vessel.
A la Wiki.

BTW, I used to be able to watch All TOS, cartoons and ST:E on some paramount/star trek website.
All franchise episodes could be viewed on the same website... for a price. Unfortunately, there was some coding errors or something and the commercials you had to watch would sometimes play, sometimes not and if they didn't then the episode would lock up. That site died a short while ago, and I threw away the link.
However, they have a new [URL="http://www.startrek.com/]website[/URL] it seems and you can watch the whole franchise there... I haven't tried it out yet so don't hold me to that...
I will strive to find that reference "Archer to Pike to Kirk" reference which would prove the timeline (writer's, not temporal) error I mentioned.
 
In brief:
JJ's enterprise, from Archer to Kirk ~60 years
TOS/St:E, from Archer to Kirk ~30 years

In any event, from the Archer's time to Kirk's time is clearly not the 300-400 years for T'pau to have aged from ST:E to TOS as implied in the series, which is all I was saying, there was a timeline error in script writing.

Or maybe Vulcan women age faster/don't live as long as Vulcan males? :rolleyes:

I must be out of my Vulcan mind!
 
A few points I mentioned the first 3 series because they seem to obey the rules of the universe. Voyager and Enterprise did not, especially the latter.
Abrams is preocupied with action and effects which was not why ST was a sucess.

I may not be the best judge because I thought LOST and Allias sucked too
 
Also the whole differences in Klingons was never really explained...all that was ever said was "We do not talk about that." - Worf

Which is obviously make up technology but it's always been portrayed as though there were 2 different types of klingons that never was explained.

http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/inconsistencies/klingons/klingon-kras-fridayschild.jpg
http://www.startrek.com/uploads/assets/db_articles/876b9439c723afd09c446ce3b18458c6f45dac6c.png

I think that was touched on in Enterprise as being a result of the augment experiments.
 
LWulf is correct, T'Pol and Archer meet T'Pau in the season 4 episode "Awakening". The katra Archer experiences is that of Surak. Check the wiki if you doubt me.

Okay, I am going more by memory than some linked info, but...
As I recall, in some last episode of ST:E, Archer was talking about future captains, and he mentions a (junior officer forgot the exact title) Pike. Now Pike was a captain who was older than, but knew Capt Kirk. In a way, they implied that Archer would have been (maybe an admiral?) in the time of capt Kirk. In JJ's enterprise, Capt Pike was capt of the enterprise when Kirk's father was a junior grade officer. Kirk was 20 when Pike was about 40-50. so the difference there would be Archer would have been 80's when Kirk was in his 20's.

So, according to TOS/ST:E, if Archer was in his 30's when Pike was in his 20's, then Archer would be lets say 15 years older than Pike when Pike is, let's say 45, so Archer would thus be in his 60's when Kirk was in his 30's. +/-10 yrs

That's younger than retirement, and therefore, Kirk and Archer would thus have "known" each other. (NOT via temporal mechanics).

In any event, from the Archer's time to Kirk's time is clearly not the 300-400 years for T'pau to have aged from ST:E to TOS as implied in the series, which is all I was saying, there was a timeline error in script writing.



Yes, I know that.

Yes, the Katra is a Vulcan soul, for lack of other terminology, which was the focal point concept of The Forge from ST:E.

T'Pau portrayed by :
Celia Lovsky
Betty Matsushita
Kara Zediker (OMG what a hottie! had to add that)

Episodes:
Amok Time (TOS),
Darkling (VOY),
The Forge (ENT) recurring thereafter
A Vulcan who led the Syrranite rebellion against the Vulcan High Command, later presided over the Koon-ut-kal-if-fee ceremony in which Spock is forced to fight Captain Kirk after Spock was rejected by his bride-to-be, T'Pring. She is also the only person ever to turn down a seat on the Federation Council. The English pop group T'Pau was named after the character,[1] as was a fictional Vulcan vessel.
A la Wiki.

BTW, I used to be able to watch All TOS, cartoons and ST:E on some paramount/star trek website.
All franchise episodes could be viewed on the same website... for a price. Unfortunately, there was some coding errors or something and the commercials you had to watch would sometimes play, sometimes not and if they didn't then the episode would lock up. That site died a short while ago, and I threw away the link.
However, they have a new [URL="http://www.startrek.com/]website[/URL] it seems and you can watch the whole franchise there... I haven't tried it out yet so don't hold me to that...
I will strive to find that reference "Archer to Pike to Kirk" reference which would prove the timeline (writer's, not temporal) error I mentioned.

Well, shit. I'll have to concede and say I was wrong about T'Pau and T'Pol. I missed most all of ST:E's 4th season. I'm going mostly on memory too, Lwulf. I lost interest somewhere in the middle of the 3rd season of ST:E, so I missed the episode ya'll are talking about. The program schedule on ST:E changed so much, I didn't bother keeping track of it by the 4th season.

About the famed "Enterprise" star ship itself: I thought surely there were some captains not mentioned in the span of decades/centuries between TOS, TNG, and ST:E.

I loved all 3 in different ways, but TOS will always be my favorite simply because it appealed to me as a kid and was the way I envisioned how a futuristic setting for humans in space should be. No prejudice, no political setbacks, different races compromising and living in harmony, etc., yet always doing the best or right thing in the end or defeating a common enemy. The same common issues we face today seemed to be resolved via compromise from all sides - unlike the way we really are today.

And I remember reading a ST novel on TOS characters just prior to them entering Starfleet Academy, before TNG, that TOS Kirk (Shatner) father was chief engineer on a star ship (maybe the Enterprise?) and Kirk was a rebellious teenager in that book. So, the new Kirk in JJ Abram's 'Star Trek' was exactly as I envisioned him to be as a younger man. Also, I was thinking that engineer 'Tripp' was a great-great-uncle somewhere along Kirk's family line. I was hoping that when ST:E was created, that most of the past behind TOS would fill unexplained gaps.

Abram's Star Trek did better filling those gaps in an alternate ST universe. Some minor disappointments, but that's understandable when trying to remain true to the original and reinventing it for a newer generation that never enjoyed TOS.
 
As a long time Trekkie, I will admit to being skeptical as to whether or not J.J could pull it off. I love both films, and while Into Darkness isn't better than the 2009 effort, it's certainly on the same par. Lovely nods and touches to the "true" canon, but carves its own path.
 
I liked JJ's Star Trek, though the big fight scene seemed a bit long to me.

But it's apples and oranges. As has been stated, the original TV series was about the human condition; each show a morality play.

And the really cool thing about it was that anyone could write the show. As long as you stayed withing the characters and Star Trek guidelines you could see your script on TV. How awesome would that be?
 
The first Abrams movie was flashy and fun, but dumb as Hell.

I just got back from Into Darkness, and I definitely enjoyed it more.

The best movie is still Wrath of Khan.
 
I haven't cared since Picard.

Am I the only one who think this constant re-hashing - Star Trek, Star Wars, Bond even - is holding back new original IP?
 
Star trek first contact was great.

Have to agree with you there.

...the big fight scene seemed a bit long to me.

But it's apples and oranges. As has been stated, the original TV series was about the human condition; each show a morality play.

Yup, yup.

But wasn't that what star trek was all about? I mean, if you are going to change something core like that, why not just make up a new movie???

**************​

I didn't see JJ's enterprise in the theater, I bought the DVD in a 7/11 for $5. I expected I'd like it no matter what. I was wrong.
One aspect of JJ's enterprise that just nagged me as, someone said elsewhere, "like going 90 and hitting a speed bump".
Jarring.
The hypo's. The guy that played Kirk, who said he was a fan and saw all the TOS episodes, when he got the hypo (shot) jerked in pain (acted).

Little things. I could accept new characters in the roles, I could take it was more action driven to capture a younger audience. I can't take changing the little details. Also, as people have pointed out, instead of being high ideals, JJ's star trek is just rock-loving hedonism.

The closest I have seen any movie come close to TOS was... galaxy quest. :D
 
Am I the only one who think this constant re-hashing - Star Trek, Star Wars, Bond even - is holding back new original IP?

No you're not. Hollywood is afraid to lose money and when they are afraid to lose money, they don't bank on high risks new concepts. Instead they prefer to rehash older, proven stories.
 
...
Yup, yup.

But wasn't that what star trek was all about? I mean, if you are going to change something core like that, why not just make up a new movie???

May be more of a derivative thing to cash in on a sure thing.

...

The hypo's. The guy that played Kirk, who said he was a fan and saw all the TOS episodes, when he got the hypo (shot) jerked in pain (acted).

...

I don't remember that scene, but it could be an early moment in the development of a character. I loved his small hop down the step to his captains chair at the end of the movie...that was pure Kirk from the original series.

The closest I have seen any movie come close to TOS was... galaxy quest. :D

Wasn't into TOS, but Galaxy Quest was outstanding.
 
I haven't cared since Picard.

Am I the only one who think this constant re-hashing - Star Trek, Star Wars, Bond even - is holding back new original IP?

I don't think it is holding back anything.

How many times has Sherlock Holmes been re-done? Some excellent (Sherlock), some not (Elementary).

StarGate was a marvelous series from a creative movie. Did quite well, ten year run and a couple of spinoffs.

Original work will continue to come. And then it, too, will be copied.

But new things always come up. Just not as often as some of us would like.
 
Even the original series veered from its format more often than not. If you consider the announced mission - to explore new worlds, seek out new life & civilizations and go where nobody had gone before - they only actually did those things in about thirty of the original 79 episodes. In several episodes, they end up carting ambassadors to conferences. Where was that in their job description?
 
Even the original series veered from its format more often than not. If you consider the announced mission - to explore new worlds, seek out new life & civilizations and go where nobody had gone before - they only actually did those things in about thirty of the original 79 episodes. In several episodes, they end up carting ambassadors to conferences. Where was that in their job description?

STFU and take your furry ass back to the shire HATER!

Diplomacy has ALWAYS been a top priority for Starfleet....part of that new civilizations bit.....but you wouldn't get that would you? NO b/c youz from middle fuckin' earth...no shoes and a fuckin' sword? Seriously? I got a fucking phaser bro...Yea yea "DONT PHASE ME BRO!!" harie harr harr.....


w/e YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE, so what you got some ring...I got quantum torpedoes pendejo...
http://www.startrek.com/legacy_media/images/200303/voy-272-voyager-s-new-futurist/320x240.jpg
walk with the fucking trees and climb you a mountain, I'll just nuke the bitch from orbit...it's the only way to be sure.
http://starsmedia.ign.com/stars/image/article/986/986374/aliens-vs-predator-players-wanted-20090526000151286-000.jpg

But seriously.....stfu. :cool:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top