I'd disagree. Kirk was a "shoot from the hip" sort of character, yes, but he wasn't a vindictive, self opportunist. That's how I see JJ's version as being, actually, all of JJ's universe seem out for themselves only. He portrayed Spock as being virtually unhinged, Chekov looked like he was on "uppers" and he definitely wasn't a "go to" guy...
I haven't seen anybody who did, but if they were alive at that time, then shame on them! Younger people who, obviously, weren't around at the time I tend to make excuses for. They were spoon fed years of great special effects and green screens and can't imagine that that technology was rather "recent". Then again, most kids my age (when I was a kid) scoffed at F/X from old serials like Flash Gordon (because of strings, etc). Likewise special effects at that time was in it's infancy, and should have been respected for what they were.
I would disagree on this, but without summoning the dead, we'll never know.
True, but my reasoning for questioning the age of Spock in JJ's movie, is; In TOS, Spock served with Captain Pike (presumably there were other commands he was under as he worked up in the ranks) until he was second in command of the Enterprise. He would have also go to Starfleet training, etc etc.
In JJ's bizzaro alternate universe, Spock has gone to starfleet (for training), worked up in the ranks, and had become a star fleet instructor in all of about 2-5 years??? Okay, he's Vulcan and could have done the fast track but it is still a "LITTLE" reaching. The problem as I see is is simply this; Hollywood has a limited amount of people to use to cast for roles. Also, they do tend to swing everybody as young as they can because "that's what young people who go to movies want to see; young actors".
I personally feel Spock was 20-40+ years older than Kirk. Physically, they would look the same age, but emotionally, I would expect Spock would be ...more mature, meaning JJ's script was shite.
But even with some of the spin off TV series, I think they have a bit of a paradox in the scripts for time lines. For instance, (I forget the exact numbers) I think Spock's father is still alive after 500-700 years. (Who knows how old he was in TOS, and he was still alive and kicking in TNG. This sets a precedent on how old Vulcans can become. It was implied (or stated) he had more than one wife (three?) after Amanda. or you could use T'pau who was an old woman in TOS and a young woman in ST:E. (which is also a timeline error, because it has been suggested that Capt Archer was about 30 years before Capt Kirk and that they knew each other. But if T'pau looks 50-60+ human years older, then about 500 years have passed between ST:E and TOS)
However, the idea was stated, in various series, that Surak (father of modern Vulcan logic and reasoning) lived (implied (legendary)) many generations ago.
Then in ST:E, they said ~1000 years ago, which, for a Vulcan would mean maybe 2-3 generations ago??
"Generations" is a subjective term because it depends on how old a Vulcan becomes before they grind out another generation. Now, Vulcans mate every 7 years, yet Spock didn't have any siblings nor 1/2 brothers/sisters. This suggests that Vulcans don't have large families despite their longevity. So, I'm guessing a generation is ~200-300 years.
Unfortunately, I notice little nuance details like this which, for me, spoils the enjoyment.
You're confused on T'Pau. T'Pau is TOS. T'Pol is a different vulcan female in ST Enterprise. Similar in sound and spelling, but 2 different characters.
Spock of TOS does indeed have one 1/2 brother from his father's side, but kept it secret from others. His 1/2 brother was explained in one of the TOS movies before the TNG movies and actually the primary focus of one of those movies. Which explains that Sarek (Spock's father) either had more than one wife or a previous wife.
Maybe this link will help explain the ST universe. http://www.startrek.com/database_article_navigator/star-trek-the-original-series
Last edited:
