Strong statement about 911

peachykeen said:
TC it's not that it's "boring" and "yesterday", it's just that it's all so meaningless unless people actually take direct action in their everyday lives to improve themselves and their communities (including the world community), not just wave some flags (that were probably made in China) and write a bunch of poncy maudlin platitudes.


She's got a point there. A really good point.
 
My thoughts

I wrote this about a year ago (October 10) in response to a friend who sent me some stuff on the "War" (of course, there has been no declaration of war). It still seems appropriate today. I remain fundamentally concerned about the actions of my country, both domestically and internationally. If we continue to allow an erosion of what freedoms are left in our country, that is the onyl victory the terrorists can hope to have.

i wrote this. It is entirely my own work, and does not in any way neccessarily represent the vies or opinions of any others. Flame away!


"Thanks for including me in this. I am unsure what exactly my feelings are about the war. On the one hand, I am outraged at what was done. On the other, I find it difficult to see how military action will result in any change in the underlying situation that has caused such a large portion of the world to abjectly HATE the U.S. The actions on Sept. 11 are, in my opinion, the result of 20 years of bullying foreign policy on the part of the U.S. Foreign policy decisions that are made that have no basis in ideology, but rather that are made in order to achieve some short term advantage over some perceived enemy. It seems to me that the eventual solution is to change our foreign policy to more clearly reflect the will and desires of the American people.

Fundamentally, what is the difference between our bombing a bridge, electrical plant or building in Afghanistan, or Serbia, or Panama, or Columbia, and a terrorist flying a plane into the world trade center? I see very little difference. The people who lived are in terror of the same thing happening to them. The people who died are dead. The world today is not a different place than it was before September 11. We, as Americans, simply have a keener appreciation for the fact that we are not will liked by large portions of the world.

That said, the fact that we are foreign policy bullies does not justify the actions of Osama bin Laden. I have no hope of a purely diplomatic effort seeing him brought to justice. My own preferred way of dealing with bin Laden would be for the President to stand up and say that he is a piss-ant little coward who sends others off to kill themselves because he does not have the balls to die himself, and that he refuses to take responsibility for his actions because he is afraid of what we would do to him. Then we walk away from him, and begin with a purely diplomatic effort to re-integrate ourselves into the world, become a little less convinced that if it is not good for us, then it must be bad (thinking of the War Crimes tribunal and treaty we refused to sign, the Kyoto environmental treaty, the human rights meeting, all of which we left behind because, while good in principle, they might hamper 'American Interests'). If we, as a nation, feel that there must be punishment handed out, then we would seem to have already don't that to the Taliban. We can keep it up, but I doubt that they will feel it too much anyway.

Just some ramblings from the top of my mind...


Carp"
 
There is no difference between WTC and the thousands of civilians killed all over the world. It is all horrible. It's just that WTC was on TV. The only way to capture Americans attention.

The death of all the foreigners working in WTC who were killed as an indirect result of American foreign policy is just as great a tragedy as those Americans killed or as those killed in dozens of other countries. For a thousand different reasons.

Living with terrorism for 40 years in Europe, you are still shocked at the events at the WTC, just as you are when a car bomb goes off in Madrid.

The difference with WTC is that the television coverage awoke a nation of obese ignorants who were itching to get their panties in a knot about something... anything. Oklahoma helped, but damn, it was an American, not an Ay-rab as everyone first hoped. So that faded away. (it wasn't live on TV, either, so that didn't help)

In a country with little history of note, you are eager to create myths as quickly as possible. And you're good at it, too. WTC was a fantastic opportunity.

But while CNN and other American channels, in the days after the event, were interviewing people on the streets saying, "Who would DO such a thing!?", the European and other international channels were less biased, showing New Yorkers saying the above, but also many saying, "America was asking for it".

Fortunately I know that the right-wing, war-mongering opinions of many of these posters do not represent those of every American.

Thank god for that.

You don't have a monopoly on suffering. Take the time to mourn for the innocents killed in Afghanistan, among many other places. Those killed by american weapons as well as all the rest.
 
Re: My thoughts

Carp said:
"Thanks for including me in this. I am unsure what exactly my feelings are about the war. On the one hand, I am outraged at what was done.
<snip>
Just some ramblings from the top of my mind...
Carp"

Thanks for being honest and daring to express yourself as an individual.
 
"It started in August of course, as newspapers and television shows attempted to pre-empt each other with their insights.

"The first of more than 150 books on the subject are already out.

"Our history still repeats itself first as tragedy and then as farce, but most of all as entertainment, with a full line of merchandise and an undertow of nostalgia."

Frank Rich, the New York Times cultural commentator.
 
The most telling part of this blurt was:

LordMagicMan said:

...
I will not pretend to understand.
...

because that was exactly what the poster did pretend to.

Quack

the D
 
What Bullshit....

The counter statements to the thread are exactly opposite of what they post, "the right to say..." what utter trash.

*Thankyou for the thread, please disregard the troublesome gnats! :D
 
I'm going to argue the politically correct argument and I'll let Bill Clinton do my talking...

"Looking at it from the outside, it seems to me we have maximum incentive now for him not to use those weapons and not to give them to anybody because he knows all of America is ready to go after him and would if he did that."



I really want to see a lot more dead people before I just go off tilting at windmills.

I want to see another attack on New York City. We deserve it.

I want Saddam to stand up and openly take credit like the brave warrior he is, for we know only cowards strike in the dark and Saddam is not a coward. He is LOVED by his people who will fight TO THE DEATH FOR HIM just like they did in Desert Storm.

I think we were wrong to be in Afghanistan because we never really ever proved Osama did anything ever, anywhere. I mean it's not like Timmy McVeigh who was so eager to confess and take all the credit like brave men do. Now look! ALL the muslims of the world HATE us. It used to be just Israel. SEE WHAT WE GOT! We deserved it!

We have MILLIONS of people in the United States. Why we should give two shakes of a rat's ass about three thousand of them, many who were just foreigners ANYWAY! And the buildings? Are you crazy? Insured! Someone made some money off that deal.

We need to shut the fuck up. Quit being world bullies and start acting like the Swiss.

Hell, I'm armed to the teeth...











I'm with Bill and weed. By Gawd, hit me again and I'm gonna scream EVEN LOUDER!
 
Back
Top