Supernatural!

Except it never seems to work that way, not in fiction for sure and only slightly better in real life. Having more friends just means more people you have to keep track of. It's not like Spiderman started off smart it took Gwen Stacy dying, Mary Jane sent to another dimenion, his best friend becoming the goblin before he learned. The Winchester boys have literally lost everybody, some of them twice or more before they learned the lesson. The Winchesters aren't brave for allowing people into their lives, their selfish pricks.

As for Harry Potter stories you have to have worthless adults, if you didn't the problem would be solved already. Hell that's almost the frustrating part of Avatar is getting to the end and realizing holy shit, there were adults sitting around not solving this problem mostly because they are lazy shit and with a slight political motivation thrown on for justification. . .for one of them. The rest could easily have solved the problem at any time they pleased though. They'd have been shit outta luck if the Avatar had stayed missing for say One more year out of the hundred he'd been MIA.

Same goes for Buffy, if the cops were competent (which really is more the fault of the Watchers than anybody else. They and Wolfram and Hart are the ones keeping the Masquerade going and if cops knew that if a bullet doesn't phase them switch to holy water balloons. . .hell we'd take over the multiverse in about six months. I don't care what they attempt to show humans are on average the most bad ass things in the entirety of Buffy and really if Witches count as human we're a lot more bad ass in Supernatural than we standardly get credit for. Can you imagine how long a battle between Angels, Demons and humans would last if humans were rocking AKs with Crowley's angel killing bullets forged by Colt? Yeah. About two seconds. In a tough spot, slam that sigil on the wall! So that's not so much lazy as you can't do it any other way. Especially not without answering the the questions that Batman glosses over and every other story outright ignores, which is why don't the cops stop these crazy people?!

Yes people die, at a fairly static rate and Cancer never took someones daughter hostage, a bus never threatened your family if you didn't back off.

You're right there are options other than martyrdom and self importance. As Spike said to Woods. Walk away. Your mother didn't love you enough to walk away and that's the rub itnit?

You stick around and you have no right to complain when your son grows up seeking vengeance because you were killed horribly in a fight you could have walked away from.
 
Except it never seems to work that way, not in fiction for sure and only slightly better in real life. Having more friends just means more people you have to keep track of. It's not like Spiderman started off smart it took Gwen Stacy dying, Mary Jane sent to another dimenion, his best friend becoming the goblin before he learned. The Winchester boys have literally lost everybody, some of them twice or more before they learned the lesson. The Winchesters aren't brave for allowing people into their lives, their selfish pricks.

As for Harry Potter stories you have to have worthless adults, if you didn't the problem would be solved already. Hell that's almost the frustrating part of Avatar is getting to the end and realizing holy shit, there were adults sitting around not solving this problem mostly because they are lazy shit and with a slight political motivation thrown on for justification. . .for one of them. The rest could easily have solved the problem at any time they pleased though. They'd have been shit outta luck if the Avatar had stayed missing for say One more year out of the hundred he'd been MIA.

Same goes for Buffy, if the cops were competent (which really is more the fault of the Watchers than anybody else. They and Wolfram and Hart are the ones keeping the Masquerade going and if cops knew that if a bullet doesn't phase them switch to holy water balloons. . .hell we'd take over the multiverse in about six months. I don't care what they attempt to show humans are on average the most bad ass things in the entirety of Buffy and really if Witches count as human we're a lot more bad ass in Supernatural than we standardly get credit for. Can you imagine how long a battle between Angels, Demons and humans would last if humans were rocking AKs with Crowley's angel killing bullets forged by Colt? Yeah. About two seconds. In a tough spot, slam that sigil on the wall! So that's not so much lazy as you can't do it any other way. Especially not without answering the the questions that Batman glosses over and every other story outright ignores, which is why don't the cops stop these crazy people?!

Yes people die, at a fairly static rate and Cancer never took someones daughter hostage, a bus never threatened your family if you didn't back off.

You're right there are options other than martyrdom and self importance. As Spike said to Woods. Walk away. Your mother didn't love you enough to walk away and that's the rub itnit?

You stick around and you have no right to complain when your son grows up seeking vengeance because you were killed horribly in a fight you could have walked away from.

I would say that people work well and work well with new threats. Maybe not immediately, but if it can be demonstrated...

Let's give an example of the "impossible" happening. Germ theory. Little beasties in the water? Mad idea. They can't be seen unless you have special, newfangled and possibly malfunctioning equipment, with crazy people who don't shave or bathe and stay in a laboratory all day studying sperm and tooth plaque scrapings.

But germs behave in a certain way. Over time they can be demonstrated, other people can be convinced, other people can buy into the idea and learn that they should wash their hands and apply antiseptics and take precautions.

Then there can be R&D and antibiotics and drugs and hospitals and schools that teach how to deal with this threat and whole industries pushing back disease, Smallpox conquered....

Buf it you're in Harry Potter or Buffy or Supernatural, there has to be one paranoid fucked up scientist that discovers germs, decides people are too dumb to deal with it and the result is five drunk guys trying to cure smallpox one person at a time.

If they just had a press conference and a web series on YouTube for each species. "Here is a vampire, here is how to find one, here is how they behave, here is how you kill one, here's what your sister would behave like if she got bit at last night's kegger"

You know there would be thousands of vampire hunters in a few weeks.

Human beings are not given enough credit by too many people.
 
I'm not against them having a network that communicates. That's entirely different from having friends and family you give a shit about. You need to think about ditching your family when you can say as Buffy did once " Dawn's kidnapped? Must be Tuesday." And nobody laughed.

Though the rest of your post mostly makes my point with one oversight. First yeah if there was Wiki-Monster monsters would get curbstomped overnight most likely (which in Buffy it's implied that this is exactly what happened and monsters after that became so rare that people believed in them just slightly more than you believe in Nessie, Big Foot or Chubacabra) because organized we do a shit ton of damage. Based on what we've seen organized humans would invade Heaven, Hell and have summer homes set up in Purgatory by 2015 easy.

I'm not really sure I look around the world and think your case really holds up. I mean pretty much we owe the 'peace' of the last couple of decades to it being too dangerous for anybody to do anything because we might end everything. And even that didn't stop us from fighting vicious proxy wars. I'm fairly certain that I don't want humans knowing how to use the Croatoa Virus and if Adam were controllable (or if Maggie had programmed him properly. I'm honestly not sure if he was defective or if she worded something wrong. Kinda like Sentinels aren't fucked up, it just turns out the distinction between mutant and human is no different than races in real life, largely imaginary. Poor communications skills kill.) that would be pretty fucked up for people to have too.
 
I'm not against them having a network that communicates. That's entirely different from having friends and family you give a shit about. You need to think about ditching your family when you can say as Buffy did once " Dawn's kidnapped? Must be Tuesday." And nobody laughed.

Though the rest of your post mostly makes my point with one oversight. First yeah if there was Wiki-Monster monsters would get curbstomped overnight most likely (which in Buffy it's implied that this is exactly what happened and monsters after that became so rare that people believed in them just slightly more than you believe in Nessie, Big Foot or Chubacabra) because organized we do a shit ton of damage. Based on what we've seen organized humans would invade Heaven, Hell and have summer homes set up in Purgatory by 2015 easy.

I'm not really sure I look around the world and think your case really holds up. I mean pretty much we owe the 'peace' of the last couple of decades to it being too dangerous for anybody to do anything because we might end everything. And even that didn't stop us from fighting vicious proxy wars. I'm fairly certain that I don't want humans knowing how to use the Croatoa Virus and if Adam were controllable (or if Maggie had programmed him properly. I'm honestly not sure if he was defective or if she worded something wrong. Kinda like Sentinels aren't fucked up, it just turns out the distinction between mutant and human is no different than races in real life, largely imaginary. Poor communications skills kill.) that would be pretty fucked up for people to have too.

Dawn deserved to die. I was kinda hoping Evil Willow would do it and prove that she was even more awesome than she was. C'mon, just one more flaying!

Smart and kind keeps happening whether or not you believe in it.

For my case if I'd even been born 100 years ago I would have died before I was born, my mom has Rh - and I have Rh + blood type. Now a shot of RhoGAM fixes that. I have vaccinations and my migraines are treated with Imitrex and not say demon exorcism or trephining my brain. I get to vote. I have a neato computer I can use to make my living and argue with people randomly about stuff.

I think a lot of damned good stuff is available and if people are using it improperly it sucks to be them.
 
By season 6 there were better people to kill than dawn. In Season 5 Buffy should have shown up with a sniper rifle, ended Glory's plans and worried about the fall out later.

Hey I didn't say the modern world isn't awesome. I said I can think of plenty of things that might be better off not letting people know about. It's not like most of this stuff seems to have "good" uses most of them are just weapons. Granted that's unrealistic and in real life we get nuclear power and nuclear weapons and it's just a question of if that's a fair trade.

I think the Syrians who are misusing the chemical weapons aren't the ones it sucks to be. It's the powerless ones who have having it used on them.
 
By season 6 there were better people to kill than dawn. In Season 5 Buffy should have shown up with a sniper rifle, ended Glory's plans and worried about the fall out later.

Hey I didn't say the modern world isn't awesome. I said I can think of plenty of things that might be better off not letting people know about. It's not like most of this stuff seems to have "good" uses most of them are just weapons. Granted that's unrealistic and in real life we get nuclear power and nuclear weapons and it's just a question of if that's a fair trade.

I think the Syrians who are misusing the chemical weapons aren't the ones it sucks to be. It's the powerless ones who have having it used on them.

Yup.

I'm a fan of freer information. No, not everyone is going to handle information well, but that's insufficient reason to keep information out of the hands of people who would excel with it.

It's nice to see that society is heading that way. Being able to capitalize on secrets is a history-long tradition and we're getting to the point where people are becoming offended by that idea. I'm in a cross-over generation where the internet was not there and then there, and it's transformative. Secrets become harder and harder to keep, total ignorance becomes harder and harder to maintain.

I don't at all believe that we live in a time where people are becoming alienated by technology. I think that's a concern for those who are simply using technology too much for their own personal use and should shut it the hell off occasionally and not blame its existence for their lack of judgment. We're going the right way. Eventually we will adapt to it in unforeseen ways, some good, some bad, but the times in history where education and information was only available to a select few is long gone. Good.
 
I think long gone might be an overly optimsitic view, at least if you're crediting technology (the internet mostly) for this change. Sure the net is BETTER than libraries were but you can't just walk into college yet or in the foreseable future and if people by and large were capable of self-educating most of these issues wouldn't exist.

I have to remember that when I blog that Wiki (as "stupid" as people treat it) is NOT written in laymans terms when talking about science stuff and just because I understand lots of the terms of paleontology doesn't mean that anybody reading does and I need to step it down and talk Barney Style. So I think you might still have the cart before the horse.
 
I think long gone might be an overly optimsitic view, at least if you're crediting technology (the internet mostly) for this change. Sure the net is BETTER than libraries were but you can't just walk into college yet or in the foreseable future and if people by and large were capable of self-educating most of these issues wouldn't exist.

I have to remember that when I blog that Wiki (as "stupid" as people treat it) is NOT written in laymans terms when talking about science stuff and just because I understand lots of the terms of paleontology doesn't mean that anybody reading does and I need to step it down and talk Barney Style. So I think you might still have the cart before the horse.

I'm thinking a longer time...back when priests suppressed mathematics or astronomy as heresy. Where reading wasn't permitted.

Hell, now most people are least reasonably literate just so they can text. Cell phones are another underrated thing that people blame for disconnecting us that I think are phenomenal as far as getting the time lag out of communication and making things more efficient. Near instantaneous communication, cameras at events, instantaneous posting to huge potential audiences.

And yet...no real pictures of aliens or Bigfoot or even a demon. Great movies about them though, who needs a fuzzy pic.

People who are ignorant either by limitation or choice will always be there, have always been there. However, if you wish to learn and you are brilliant and you wish to innovate, there's never been a better time to get access to what you are interested in. That's the potential difference. Therefore the potential for someone like Jack Andraka to come up with a screening test for pancreatic cancer when he was 15.

Chances were throughout history the guy would be born as a serf and would just have come up with a way to sharpen the plows and keep the goats happy if he made it to 15 at all.

Success used to mean you had to be born in the right geographic area and to the right parents and with the right genetics. And now those qualifications are being broken down so it's easier to innovate through standing on the shoulders of giants and having access to more knowledge than you could learn in several lifetimes if you just have an internet connection.
 
It wasn't really that reading wasn't permitted. IT was like coding is today, the average person didn't have anybody to teach them nor the time, not that it makes a whole lot of difference why the end effect was the same.

Cell Phone haters can die. The only reason I don't bother with mine very often is because either near my phone or with everybody who has my cell phone number anyway. It's kinda redundant when someone can just shout and get my attention and I don't like typing with my thumbs. Side effect of being able to type for real and pretty fast by most standards, going that slow pisses me off. I also hate small talk so 'hi, how are you, i has eggs for breakfast' is the kind of stupid shit that keeps me off Facebook and Twitter. If I had the ability to mail all those people who do to Abu Dhabi I would. I might send them cute kittens though cus I don't want them to die. I just don't want them to be around anymore.

I'll take your word that now is the best time to innovate. I suppose it's one of those times where it depends on how you look at it. Either we has free time and cool toys so we have more stuff we can do or because technology has expanded our reach so much it's that much harder to get ou from under the big boys because they literally encompass the earth.

Traditionally if you were born a serf you died one. That hasn't changed. Today the greatest predictor of what income group you'll die in is the one your born in and there were always people who bucked the trend, I'd be curious to see any proof that today your statiscally better off. Somehow I doubt it.

I'll chalk that up to you being all sunny though.
 
It wasn't really that reading wasn't permitted. IT was like coding is today, the average person didn't have anybody to teach them nor the time, not that it makes a whole lot of difference why the end effect was the same.

Cell Phone haters can die. The only reason I don't bother with mine very often is because either near my phone or with everybody who has my cell phone number anyway. It's kinda redundant when someone can just shout and get my attention and I don't like typing with my thumbs. Side effect of being able to type for real and pretty fast by most standards, going that slow pisses me off. I also hate small talk so 'hi, how are you, i has eggs for breakfast' is the kind of stupid shit that keeps me off Facebook and Twitter. If I had the ability to mail all those people who do to Abu Dhabi I would. I might send them cute kittens though cus I don't want them to die. I just don't want them to be around anymore.

I'll take your word that now is the best time to innovate. I suppose it's one of those times where it depends on how you look at it. Either we has free time and cool toys so we have more stuff we can do or because technology has expanded our reach so much it's that much harder to get ou from under the big boys because they literally encompass the earth.

Traditionally if you were born a serf you died one. That hasn't changed. Today the greatest predictor of what income group you'll die in is the one your born in and there were always people who bucked the trend, I'd be curious to see any proof that today your statiscally better off. Somehow I doubt it.

I'll chalk that up to you being all sunny though.

Yeah, I don't text much, only with Ulaven and my daughter and son and sister. I didn't even learn how to until this last year.

But for me it's a constant source of science podcasts and audiobooks and Pandora.

Well, let's take your average Russian serf that was born in one spot, owned by the landowner, denied any opportunity to travel or change occupation, provided with no education and only a chance at subsistence if the noble that owned the land wasn't killing you with tithes. Yeah, that's changed.

You may be born poor, but the odds of encountering people from an international viewpoint that don't agree with the way your country is doing things is such that there are only a few places, like North Korea, where you are still terminally fucked.
 
Oh I watch and listen to a fair amount of podcasts. More trivia stuff for games and movies than education but I don't not read education. I just tend to wait until something interesting comes out of it.

Take your average American, only educated enough to be able to work the cash register who's entire income goes to food and rent and a few luxury items like phone and internet.

It's not that serfs couldn't leave, it was that they'd starve if they tried. Like I said, sunny and sweet you be.

Knowing that there are other ways to do something isn't remotely the same as being able to do it. Sure there are definitely worse places to be than America, nobody denied that point. Only that I can safely walk through the south and say none of you people will ever be anything and sure two or three will prove me wrong but the rest will die in trailer parks miles from where they were born because generational poorness is rarely conquered by hard work.
 
Oh I watch and listen to a fair amount of podcasts. More trivia stuff for games and movies than education but I don't not read education. I just tend to wait until something interesting comes out of it.

Take your average American, only educated enough to be able to work the cash register who's entire income goes to food and rent and a few luxury items like phone and internet.

It's not that serfs couldn't leave, it was that they'd starve if they tried. Like I said, sunny and sweet you be.

Knowing that there are other ways to do something isn't remotely the same as being able to do it. Sure there are definitely worse places to be than America, nobody denied that point. Only that I can safely walk through the south and say none of you people will ever be anything and sure two or three will prove me wrong but the rest will die in trailer parks miles from where they were born because generational poorness is rarely conquered by hard work.

Having a job, choosing a place to live, having opportunity and aid and assistance and being considered legally the same "class" as everybody else is not the same as being born someone else's chattel.

Nah, you're determined to minimize past social atrocities and play up how bad it is now for some reason. Dunno your reason, but comparing the life of an average person working a cash register and watching pirated content (they can choose the content) and having heat and refrigeration and free flu shots at the corner is not even comparable to being born a subsistence farmer and being socially forced to stay that way, dying of frostbite, abuse, alcoholism and malnutrition.

The world's population has exploded for a reason. We used to think we'd never grow enough food, and with advances in farming we have no problem with that. We do have problems with distribution and working social models. Athletes break records at the Olympics for a reason. Although there are loads of people in the middle and on the bottom, we're consistently achieving more physically and mentally.

The highs are getting higher. The lows have been lifted due to education and having better models over time to work with. "Sucks that you're dying of cancer..." but at least people don't call it demon possession any more and burn you at the stake for it. No, we can't cure everything, but we stigmatize and blame less because we know more of the answers.
 
You're mixing the fact that life is better for the poor today than for the rich a century ago with the concept that the poor today have a realistic chance of being rich. These things are not the same. Are you Republican or something? I mean that argument is 100% vetteman, miles, koalabear style there.
 
I don,
You're mixing the fact that life is better for the poor today than for the rich a century ago with the concept that the poor today have a realistic chance of being rich. These things are not the same. Are you Republican or something? I mean that argument is 100% vetteman, miles, koalabear style there.

Beibg rich does not define living well. I'm talking about a higher in general social, medical and intellectual living standard overall. We are statistically doing better across the board. That is not opinion but fact.
 
Well to that I merely say no shit.

You seemed to have been talking about upward mobility earlier, say what you want about North Korea, China, Russia or any other hell hole they still with few exceptions live better than their ancestors did for all the technical reasons you just mentioned.

Not to mention that it could easily be construed as wealth. Just because the game has been fundamentally altered so running water is no longer a luxury item that you are supposed to praise Allah for and is instead something that if you don't have the rest of the world looks at you and tries to figure out ways to unfuck your life. Something something rising tides.

That's still something straight out of the Koalabear playbook. You should tell us about how in your day you had to wait until movies were re-released in movies. None of this catch it on TnT bullshit. If you do that I'll tell kids about how I remember when games were 2 Dimensions and you either played Sonic or Mario and you LIKED IT so I'll hear nothing about their glitchy games!
 
Well to that I merely say no shit.

You seemed to have been talking about upward mobility earlier, say what you want about North Korea, China, Russia or any other hell hole they still with few exceptions live better than their ancestors did for all the technical reasons you just mentioned.

Not to mention that it could easily be construed as wealth. Just because the game has been fundamentally altered so running water is no longer a luxury item that you are supposed to praise Allah for and is instead something that if you don't have the rest of the world looks at you and tries to figure out ways to unfuck your life. Something something rising tides.

That's still something straight out of the Koalabear playbook. You should tell us about how in your day you had to wait until movies were re-released in movies. None of this catch it on TnT bullshit. If you do that I'll tell kids about how I remember when games were 2 Dimensions and you either played Sonic or Mario and you LIKED IT so I'll hear nothing about their glitchy games!

Yeah, there is a greater potential for upward and downward mobility with elimination or relaxation of a rigid and enforced social caste system. You can start rich and lose it all or start poor and gain it all. It isn't easy but it is easier than it was.

I don't really care who else says it. It happens to be true. What I also believe is that we are certainly wealthy enough due to all of this success to care for those who need it, those who are socially, intellectually and medically disadvantaged.
 
Seems contradictory to me. Either the past is irrelevant and we should be striving towards the horizon or we should accept that Koala is right and be content. This other choice is just seeing what we want to see regardless of the facts around us.

And I've still yet to see any evidence that it's any easier to break out of your "caste" today than in days of past. Especially when actual emprical evidence on the middle class shows not only is that not true but the middle is rapidly vanishing because the top is effectively winning the game. As they always have, always will and MUST but still.
 
Seems contradictory to me. Either the past is irrelevant and we should be striving towards the horizon or we should accept that Koala is right and be content. This other choice is just seeing what we want to see regardless of the facts around us.

And I've still yet to see any evidence that it's any easier to break out of your "caste" today than in days of past. Especially when actual emprical evidence on the middle class shows not only is that not true but the middle is rapidly vanishing because the top is effectively winning the game. As they always have, always will and MUST but still.

The past provides objective measurements to compare to now.

Never give up! Never surrender!

I've given lots of examples. Abolishment of caste, votes for minorities and women, advances in social theory, marriage rights for gay people.

I think you are allergic to progress.
 
The past is anything but an objective measuring point where were we ought be for all the reasons you just listed. There were all sorts of terrible things that used to happen and plenty that still do. The fact that it used to be worse isn't a quality reason to be content.

And none of what you mentioned has anything to do with breaking out of your "caste" does it really matter if the reason you die poor is because of a legal construct or lack of remotely equal opportunity? It seems largely semantic to me.

It's not about giving up, it's about being happy you got what you got and not bitching about it.
 
The past is anything but an objective measuring point where were we ought be for all the reasons you just listed. There were all sorts of terrible things that used to happen and plenty that still do. The fact that it used to be worse isn't a quality reason to be content.

And none of what you mentioned has anything to do with breaking out of your "caste" does it really matter if the reason you die poor is because of a legal construct or lack of remotely equal opportunity? It seems largely semantic to me.

It's not about giving up, it's about being happy you got what you got and not bitching about it.

Population is objective. Life expectancy is objective. Medical survival rates are objective. Food supply per acre is objective. Sports world records are objective.
 
Population is objective. Life expectancy is objective. Medical survival rates are objective. Food supply per acre is objective. Sports world records are objective.

But why measure based on the past vs the rest of the MODERN world. I don't want to live longer than my great grandfather, not when my cousin in the UK is likely to outlive me by seven or eight years. Same goes for my medical survival rates.

I guess those last two are "objective" but we currently pay people not to farm because farming is so fucking efficient people can't make a living doing it. (It's still something to strive towards but I'm much more interested in solving the transporting it (and clean water) to people who need it more than actually upping production. Still point made. I'm not overly interested in world records but your right that is objective. So is the biggest yacht, tallest building and a bunch of other things that mostly are just the few accomplishing more. Which isn't a bad thing.
 
But why measure based on the past vs the rest of the MODERN world. I don't want to live longer than my great grandfather, not when my cousin in the UK is likely to outlive me by seven or eight years. Same goes for my medical survival rates.

I guess those last two are "objective" but we currently pay people not to farm because farming is so fucking efficient people can't make a living doing it. (It's still something to strive towards but I'm much more interested in solving the transporting it (and clean water) to people who need it more than actually upping production. Still point made. I'm not overly interested in world records but your right that is objective. So is the biggest yacht, tallest building and a bunch of other things that mostly are just the few accomplishing more. Which isn't a bad thing.

We have some aspects if catastrophic success. Millennia of food-seeking genetics in a glut of food results in obesity. People die from degenerative disease rather than trauma or malnutrition or disease.

But as problems go, although we have loads of work yet to do, I would not choose to live in another era. Those who think bygone eras are somehow better or more pure should consider that you were likely to have scurvy, rickets, polio, smallpox, pellagra and ignorance.
 
Back
Top