Just take that scenarion (offering a 3some) and say he freaked out but then change his mind in the fantasy...maybe you could have her waiting in bed when the two of you went upstairs and you two girls pounce on him <wink>
Do you think that strip poker is a believable element in an erotic story? I know that I've done it many times, mostly when I wanted to get into the pants of another player...but I dunno if I'm just a "sick, twisted fuck" or a normal young lady.
PLS, a threesome is every guys fantasy, but you offered him *reality* which is a difference. In a fantasy, everyone cums at the same time and afterwards, everyone leaves happy. The reality is a little different.
Strip poker, as the set-up for a group scene or couple swap, can be a hot scenario. You have built-in anticipation. And the slowness of stripping is a parallel of foreplay.
I believe the English have an equivalent in something called "Drink or Forfeit". Anyone care to enlighten me on whether this might be true?