Tax question - 401K

The Heretic

Literotica Guru
Joined
Oct 26, 2002
Posts
28,592
Let's say I put $15K into a 401K. Two years later I need to cash it out, but it is only worth $10K. That is a capital loss right? I would only have to pay the penalty and tax on the $10K right?

TIA
 
Yes, you are correct.

The $5K difference is what is considered a paper loss.

You only pay taxes on what the "actual" amount at the time of withdrawal is. Since you cashed out $10K, you're going to get nailed for taxes. But if you had to do it, you had to do it.
 
Yes, you would only have to pay on the $10,000. They would automatically take 20% federal tax off of that and depending on why you took it out you might also have to pay a 10% penalty when you do your taxes.

With the interest rates nowadays you might want to consider taking out a loan instead. You wouldn't lose all that money to the goverment and you'd be paying the interest back to yourself.
 
I don't think I'd ask for financial advice on a porn board. Maybe that's just me. ;)
 
Guru said:
I don't think I'd ask for financial advice on a porn board. Maybe that's just me. ;)
I can always ask - doesn't mean I have to take it.

I just wanted to quickly confirm what I already thought was true. Either way I don't have to worry about it right now - I may not ever have to cash out my 401K. Hopefully I will get a job before I do - it is down almost 50% from what I put into it, not to mention what is was worth before the stock market went down. If I am going to cash it out I would prefer to do it when its value is much higher.

As for taking out a loan - I already have enough debt, I don't need more, but cashing out the 401K is almost my last resort (last resort is living on my credit cards). I think before I do that I will move to California. I figure that with my latest stock sale, I've got enough now to last until late fall.
 
I did a loan on my 401k about three months before 9-11.

Normaly this is not a good ideal for the long term.

Paying back half my 401k with 10% interest is the only thing that has saved my ass in these bad stock market times!

True i only have about 15k more than i did then, but damn, many people are a hell of a lot worse off!

If the market shoots up in the next year and a half most people will run off and leave me as well as hurting me when it is time to retire. Thats the risk you take.
 
The Heretic said:

As for taking out a loan - I already have enough debt, I don't need more, but cashing out the 401K is almost my last resort (last resort is living on my credit cards).

I work all day long with people who have used their credit cards for this purpose. Rarely is it ever something they successfully overcome.

Even though you pay the penalty for taking out the 401K money, at least it isn't a loan, it is ultimately something with a monetary value.

One thing I know, everyones situation is different. Just because it makes sense for someone else to cash in their 401K doesn't mean it does for you.

As for my own IRAs, they are now worth what they were 5+ years ago when I rolled them over from a pension plan with a previous employer. At their height they were worth just below double the original amount. Oh well, it was all on paper anyway and I've still got 35+ years until I can retire. Plenty of time to build it up again.
 
A home equity loan makes more sense than living off of credit cards if you own your own home. Having the home equity line of credit set up and available while you are still employed is the thing to do. (Mine was only $25 per year to keep it open, whether I used it or not.) Then, if you lose your job, you can temporarily support yourself by borrowing from your equity. The rate was always cheap, too. 1% over prime.
 
Cheyenne said:
A home equity loan makes more sense than living off of credit cards if you own your own home. Having the home equity line of credit set up and available while you are still employed is the thing to do. (Mine was only $25 per year to keep it open, whether I used it or not.) Then, if you lose your job, you can temporarily support yourself by borrowing from your equity. The rate was always cheap, too. 1% over prime.


Smart and has lickable tits.....:p ;)
 
Cheyenne said:
A home equity loan makes more sense than living off of credit cards if you own your own home. Having the home equity line of credit set up and available while you are still employed is the thing to do. (Mine was only $25 per year to keep it open, whether I used it or not.) Then, if you lose your job, you can temporarily support yourself by borrowing from your equity. The rate was always cheap, too. 1% over prime.
I don't have a home - I rent, and I am very glad that I didn't buy a home when I had the chance as my mortgage payments would be at least two to three times what I pay for rent. Also, if I have to move (which I may have to), I can move immediately without having to sell any real estate in a bad market. Yeah the interest rates are way down - but around here there is a very high vacancy rate. It is a good time to be buying (if you have the money or a job), but a bad time to be selling.

BTW, I have a farm for sale (with houses) in the Portland area if anybody wants it - only 1.6 million. ;)
 
Guru said:
I don't think I'd ask for financial advice on a porn board. Maybe that's just me. ;)

Maybe this is the place for people to post anything they want? Who has dictated it's a porn only Board anyway?

Not every post HAS to be porn related.
 
Ukin said:
Maybe this is the place for people to post anything they want? Who has dictated it's a porn only Board anyway?

Not every post HAS to be porn related.
I don't think Guru was trying to be a content policeman - I think he was just expressing reservations the wisdom of seeking financial advice here. Also, please note the ;) at the end of his statement.
 
Back
Top