Taxes & growth

REDWAVE

Urban Jungle Dweller
Joined
Aug 26, 2001
Posts
6,013
One of the articles of faith of right-wing ideologues is that lower taxes are better for the economy than higher taxes. As with most articles of faith, however, there is no evidence that is true. Studies by economists indicate there is no correlation between the rate of taxation and economic growth. Scandinavian countries, for instance, have both high taxes and good economic growth. Reference:

http://www.nytimes.com/2002/10/31/business/31SCEN.html

It is easy to see why higher taxes do not necessarily retard economic growth. With tax monies, governments provide services (roads, schools, hospitals, etc.) and maintain an infrastructure from which both individuals and businesses benefit. If tax monies are spent wisely, they can actually promote economic growth rather than impede it. The fallacy in the arguments of the right-wing ideologues is they assume tax monies just disappear into a rathole, and do not take into account the fact that they are recycled back into the economy.

All forms of government spending can produce some benefit, but military spending is the least efficacious. That is because it goes for things which (at best) are not used, and at worst are used to kill people and destroy things. Spending for social programs produces much more of a "multiplier effect" than does military spending.

The solution to the present economic crisis is fairly simple. Reduce military spending greatly, cancel the tax cuts to the rich, loosen eligibility rules for unemployment insurance, and greatly increase the amount of unemployment benefits. That would put money in the hands of those who most need it, and can be counted on to spend it, mainly for necessities like food, rent, etc. The increased consumer spending would stimulate the economy, and cause a resurgence of business investment.

Or we can continue on our current course to disaster.
 
Tax cuts can work, but we rarely see the right kind applied. Both tax cuts and increase in government spending can have a positive effect on the economy, although government spending has a more direct effect since it does not go through households marginal propensity to save.
 
REDWAVE said:


The solution to the present economic crisis is fairly simple. Reduce military spending greatly, cancel the tax cuts to the rich, loosen eligibility rules for unemployment insurance, and greatly increase the amount of unemployment benefits. That would put money in the hands of those who most need it, and can be counted on to spend it, mainly for necessities like food, rent, etc. The increased consumer spending would stimulate the economy, and cause a resurgence of business investment.

Or we can continue on our current course to disaster.

Back up big dog..... what economic crisis?

And then, lets take more money from the business owners so they can't hire more employees and have to lay off some to cover increased taxes and then we put more people out of work and on entitlemensts and then we have a real FUCKING ECONOMIC CRISIS.....

You are sooo wise, babydoll.:kiss:
 
Sillyman is correct MPS(ave) is the problem and it is influneced by market expectation.

There are two general thrust in recovery Push Economics ( Government ) and Pull Economics (Consumer). When market expectations are poor the government lead recoveries are the way to go. When expectations are high consumer lead recoveries are better but giving consumers greater disposable incomes.

Your generalised problem here is government spending on defence, when there is a sudden increase in this area it is because of a threat. This threat then produces a down turn in the economy are expectations are low and very low.

You need to stimulate the propensity to spend reduce taxes and reduce official money rates stimulate the housing sector with micro economic policies to increase housing starts but 10/15% there is a flow on to all sectors.


Mike
 
Raising taxes will usually result in businesses trying to cut back expenses, and the largest expense is usually employee wages, if they even have employees to begin with. The reverse is not true however. A tax cut does not always mean new workers being hired.
 
Sillyman said:
. A tax cut does not always mean new workers being hired.

In the long run it will even assuming MPS remain the same and expectations remain the same. Assuming the tax cut is large enuf the will be an increase in the overall total of money saved. This increased saving will result in a lowering of official rates and eventually the spending cycle will change. Increased demand might test the elastisity of some prices eventually demand will outstrip supply and additional workers will be needed.

Moral

Tax cuts only work when market expectations are good :)



Mike
 
Sillyman said:
Tax cuts can work, but we rarely see the right kind applied. Both tax cuts and increase in government spending can have a positive effect on the economy, although government spending has a more direct effect since it does not go through households marginal propensity to save.

You read all that?
 
michaelmt1 said:
In the long run it will even assuming MPS remain the same and expectations remain the same. Assuming the tax cut is large enuf the will be an increase in the overall total of money saved. This increased saving will result in a lowering of official rates and eventually the spending cycle will change. Increased demand might test the elastisity of some prices eventually demand will outstrip supply and additional workers will be needed.

Moral

Tax cuts only work when market expectations are good :)



Mike

If it's large enough and reaches enough people, which I think is another factor. Giving even full tax exemption and rebate to ten people isn't going to do anything.
 
I love economics too. I wish I understood it better.

This is a good point, though:
All forms of government spending can produce some benefit, but military spending is the least efficacious. That is because it goes for things which (at best) are not used, and at worst are used to kill people and destroy things. Spending for social programs produces much more of a "multiplier effect" than does military spending.
 
A Desert Rose said:
You guys are all sick.... sick I tell you.

Wait until you hear me qoute Keynes while blowing a guy in a clown suit.
 
REDWAVE said:
It is easy to see why higher taxes do not necessarily retard economic growth. With tax monies, governments provide services (roads, schools, hospitals, etc.) and maintain an infrastructure from which both individuals and businesses benefit. If tax monies are spent wisely, they can actually promote economic growth rather than impede it. The fallacy in the arguments of the right-wing ideologues is they assume tax monies just disappear into a rathole, and do not take into account the fact that they are recycled back into the economy.
Your fallacy is that the amount recycled back is never as much as the amount that's paid in, since you have to account for all administrative costs and red tape in general. Somewhere, the rathole stakes its claim.

Government services are rarely as good as private services. Let the market do the work, and let the government provide prudent regulation. Get them out of my paycheck as much as possible.

TB4p
 
Sandia said:
I love economics too. I wish I understood it better.

This is a good point, though:

Sandria

It is indeed a good point except that in the existing market this sort of spending is used to keep expectation ups. If the spending did not occour people would fear they could me invaded that all their material goods and cash are under threat. So they transfer their welth from cash to gold (gold is generally where it goes). Despite the over supply of money no one want to spend on luxury goods as all they want is gold.

No spending less jobs unemployment goes up.

I guess its a critical balance issue. It is true that the multilyer is reduced some what. The fact that a good is never used tho is not a factor the point is it is purchased and that is all that is needed for the multiplier to activate.



Mike
 
Re: Re: Taxes & growth

teddybear4play said:

Government services are rarely as good as private services. Let the market do the work, and let the government provide prudent regulation. Get them out of my paycheck as much as possible.

TB4p

Absofuckinglutely! Amtrak is a great case in point.
 
Sillyman said:
If it's large enough and reaches enough people, which I think is another factor. Giving even full tax exemption and rebate to ten people isn't going to do anything.


Aint that the truth.




Mike
 
Re: Re: Taxes & growth

teddybear4play said:
Your fallacy is that the amount recycled back is never as much as the amount that's paid in, since you have to account for all administrative costs and red tape in general. Somewhere, the rathole stakes its claim.
TB4p

Government spending increases product demand, just as spending by individuals do. By increasing demand, more jobs will be created as individuals grab onto profit making opportunities. Even money taken by administrative costs and red tape does go into someone's pocket, which increases their income, which increases their spending, which in turn raises demand.

When everyone else is afraid to spend, the government is in the best position to raise demand.
 
Back
Top