The 9/11 Memorial

Cathleen

Summer breeze...
Joined
Feb 11, 2004
Posts
31,006
The museum opens tomorrow, May 15, 2014.

Do you want to go? Feelings about going? Approx how old were you in 2001? Is the memorial more emotion or historical to you?

I've had a stomach ache since hearing about it's opening tomorrow. It still can pull me down in a second. I spent some time looking at the site, found the placement of a hometown person. I don't know if I'd ever be able to visit.

What about you?



https://www.911memorial.org/
 
I was in Denver when the Towers came down. I am not aware if anybody that I knew was lost in the buildings.

Even with that I am not sure if I would want to visit the museum. I do now want to forget. I do not want to relive.
 
I'm not a big fan of Memorials aside from a statue or a monument. I don't think a Museum was a good idea.

I was 40 when it happened. I was asleep and received a phone call from my brother telling me the 1st plane hit. I flipped on the TV and watched as I saw the 2nd pane hit WTC.
 
I'll likely check it out sometime this summer if I'm in the area, but it's not necessarily on my overall "must-see" agenda. I am a bit interested in how it's designed.
 
If I traveled to New York I would most likely go to see it, but NBC did a piece on the news tonight and showed doors specifically labeled as "emergency" exits for people who simply wanted to bail out of the exhibits mid-way through.

That's pretty heavy just to think about.
 
I was in Denver when the Towers came down. I am not aware if anybody that I knew was lost in the buildings.

Even with that I am not sure if I would want to visit the museum. I do now want to forget. I do not want to relive.

Every time I think of 9/11 I still get very angry. No, I won't be going.

I am of the same thought. I looked at the thread Q linked, I couldn't get past but a handful of pages before the painfulness got to be too much.



The wall of photos did me in.
 
I'm not a big fan of Memorials aside from a statue or a monument. I don't think a Museum was a good idea.

I was 40 when it happened. I was asleep and received a phone call from my brother telling me the 1st plane hit. I flipped on the TV and watched as I saw the 2nd pane hit WTC.

Do you think the museum is too much? I curious about what if any kind of "memorial" would be suitable in your view.
 
I'll likely check it out sometime this summer if I'm in the area, but it's not necessarily on my overall "must-see" agenda. I am a bit interested in how it's designed.

I'd be interested in your thoughts about it, if you'd be willing to share. I know it's close to home to you in all ways.
 


If I traveled to New York I would most likely go to see it, but NBC did a piece on the news tonight and showed doors specifically labeled as "emergency" exits for people who simply wanted to bail out of the exhibits mid-way through.

That's pretty heavy just to think about.

Thanks for the link, Q. As Col Hogan said, it's all pretty heavy to think about.


I wonder if Pearl Harbor Memorial evoked the same difficulties with those a generation ahead of me. I'll have to make a few calls.


Thanks for sharing your thoughts. :rose:
 
Do you think the museum is too much? I curious about what if any kind of "memorial" would be suitable in your view.

Cathleen, to answer your question.....

Yesterday was one of the rare occasions I actually had the news on. I don't recall if it was ABC or CBS but they did a story on the 911 Museum opening today. They showed a melted telephone, the firetruck (ladder 9?) that was smashed , a section of staircase and bicycles that still had the ash on them and shoes some woman wore that day to work in the tower etc...

I don't think having a museum at ground zero filled with artifacts from the horror of that day honors the dead. There is nothing wrong with wanting to preserve those things but doing so isn't much of a memorial. A melted telephone only reminds of the horror of the day, it says nothing about the people who perished.

I remember the people jumping from the 100th floor before the networks stopped showing it. Almost 2,800 people died on that site. Their lives...their story should be the focus. If you want a museum make it a living biography of every one who died there and the family members that survive them.

Update it , show how their family continues on, children grow up, get married and start their own families. Thats more of a memorial than the stuff dug from the rubble of that day. IMO.
 
Last edited:
I've been to the site and will visit the museum next time in NYC. Very sobering visit to see the waterfalls they created.
 
Its not a memorial, its a for profit museum.

I cannot believe the remains will be in there.

I've been by it, I wont go in.
 
Cathleen, to answer your question.....

Yesterday was one of the rare occasions I actually had the news on. I don't recall if it was ABC or CBS but they did a story on the 911 Museum opening today. They showed a melted telephone, the firetruck (ladder 9?) that was smashed , a section of staircase and bicycles that still had the ash on them and shoes some woman wore that day to work in the tower etc...

I don't think having a museum at ground zero filled with artifacts from the horror of that day honors the dead. There is nothing wrong with wanting to preserve those things but doing so isn't much of a memorial. A melted telephone only reminds of the horror of the day, it says nothing about the people who perished.

I remember the people jumping from the 100th floor before the networks stopped showing it. Almost 2,800 people died on that site. Their lives...their story should be the focus. If you want a museum make it a living biography of every one who died there and the family members that survive them.

Update it , show how their family continues on, children grow up, get married and start their own families. Thats more of a memorial than the stuff dug from the rubble of that day. IMO.

Thank you for sharing that. I don't want to see all that either, I do want to remember but don't want all my senses assaulted with it -- assaulted isn't the right word but that was it feels like at times.

As Amberchgo mentioned, the waterfalls are sobering. I think I would've left it at that. Let the sound of the water attempt to sooth, it seems more humane.
 
Cathleen, to answer your question.....

Yesterday was one of the rare occasions I actually had the news on. I don't recall if it was ABC or CBS but they did a story on the 911 Museum opening today. They showed a melted telephone, the firetruck (ladder 9?) that was smashed , a section of staircase and bicycles that still had the ash on them and shoes some woman wore that day to work in the tower etc...

I don't think having a museum at ground zero filled with artifacts from the horror of that day honors the dead. There is nothing wrong with wanting to preserve those things but doing so isn't much of a memorial. A melted telephone only reminds of the horror of the day, it says nothing about the people who perished.

I remember the people jumping from the 100th floor before the networks stopped showing it. Almost 2,800 people died on that site. Their lives...their story should be the focus. If you want a museum make it a living biography of every one who died there and the family members that survive them.

Update it , show how their family continues on, children grow up, get married and start their own families. Thats more of a memorial than the stuff dug from the rubble of that day. IMO.

I think you've made some excellent points, but from some of the coverage I've seen, I think that your concerns about the focus of the museum have been addressed to some extent. It seemed to me that the was a lot of emphasis on who the victims were, at least in the coverage I saw.

Sometimes, in September, when the sky is a bright blue in the morning, it can jolt me right back to that day.
 
No thank you.

Its not a memorial, its a for profit museum.

I cannot believe the remains will be in there.

I've been by it, I wont go in.

I didn't stop to consider that, LTR. Honestly the whole thing is stuck in my head and I need to move on.

As I said, the waterfall is to me, a memorial and that's enough for me.


Thanks again, everyone.
 
I have friends who lost one of their sons there. I'd go to pay respects, but I am not looking forward to it.
 
I think you've made some excellent points, but from some of the coverage I've seen, I think that your concerns about the focus of the museum have been addressed to some extent. It seemed to me that the was a lot of emphasis on who the victims were, at least in the coverage I saw.

Sometimes, in September, when the sky is a bright blue in the morning, it can jolt me right back to that day.
That New England blue sky was so exceptional and can feel like a kick in the stomach.


I did hear that there are voicemails, recordings etc but it's that damned wall of photos -- all those people gone, it blows me away.
 
I have friends who lost one of their sons there. I'd go to pay respects, but I am not looking forward to it.

That's a lovely thing to do, Adre. It does seem as the surviving families had opportunity to show their loved one(s) personally.

I wish you well when you go.:rose:
 
Back
Top