The Alien Enemies Act - 1798

[ll74]

A judge has ordered the return of Garcia.
The Administration is defying the ruling
Of course they are.
A reminder, Garcia was legally here.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...p-deportation-el-salvador-prison/82865362007/

 

[HisArpy]

A judge has ordered the return of Garcia.
The Administration is defying the ruling
Of course they are.
A reminder, Garcia was legally here.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...p-deportation-el-salvador-prison/82865362007/

The admin MUST apply for a court order in the country where he's being held as a "sister state" having jurisdiction.

Just like if the gov in one State wants someone arrested and extradited in another State. If the foreign State refuses, there isn't anything the gov can do.

That's not defiance, it's the way the law works.

 

[ll74]

The admin MUST apply for a court order in the country where he's being held as a "sister state" having jurisdiction.

Just like if the gov in one State wants someone arrested and extradited in another State. If the foreign State refuses, there isn't anything the gov can do.

That's not defiance, it's the way the law works.

The administration could easily get him back. We have a contract with El Salvador.

As a reminder,.Trump got the Tate brothers back.

The administration is blatantly defying the judge and taunting him for political gain.

 

[HisArpy]

The administration could easily get him back. We have a contract with El Salvador.

As a reminder,.Trump got the Tate brothers back.

You BELIEVE they could. The reality may be something else. Neither sufficies in a court of law where THE LAW requires that the government apply with El Salvador courts for an order authorizing the extradition.

The US court cannot fault the government for applying as the law requires. Nor can they attribute any delay or denial to the US government.

 

[ll74]

You BELIEVE they could.

I know they could. You're an idiot if you believe otherwise.

 

[HisArpy]

I know they could. You're an idiot if you believe otherwise.

You believe. And what you believe isn't the law, it's a belief. Being stubborn about it doesn't help you.

 

[ll74]

You believe. And what you believe isn't the law, it's a belief. Being stubborn about it doesn't help you.

Yes, you're an idiot.

The President deported a man who was legally here and has consistently lied about it.

 

[SgtSpiderMan]

You believe. And what you believe isn't the law, it's a belief. Being stubborn about it doesn't help you.

But somehow what you believe (and not the judge) IS law?

 

[HisArpy]

Yes, you're an idiot.

The President deported a man who was legally here and has consistently lied about it.

And? What's that got to do with the process of getting him back?

 

[HisArpy]

But somehow what you believe (and not the judge) IS law?

I understand you're stupid and commiserate with your parents about it, but please refrain from commenting unless you have something intelligent to say (which is never).

 

[SgtSpiderMan]

I understand you're stupid and commiserate with your parents about it, but please refrain from commenting unless you have something intelligent to say (which is never).

I’m sorry you had to resort to a personal attack instead of answering a question.

 

[ll74]

And? What's that got to do with the process of getting him back?

They can and they won't and are lying about it

 

[HisArpy]

They can and they won't and are lying about it

Which is, again, what you BELIEVE. Worse, you believe it to be so despite have ZERO evidence to support that belief.

 

[ll74]

Which is, again, what you BELIEVE. Worse, you believe it to be so despite have ZERO evidence to support that belief.

They have zero evidence he was in a gang yet continue to lie about it

Are you asserting that a country we have a contract with to jail deportees isn't agreeable in our requests?

 

[HisArpy]

They have zero evidence he was in a gang yet continue to lie about it

Are you asserting that a country we have a contract with to jail deportees isn't agreeable in our requests?

He's a Salvadoran citizen, we have NO JURISDICTION over him regardless of our contract with El Salvador. To bring him back to the US we have to extradite him via the courts.

Or didn't you know that before you spewed your tripe?

 

[ll74]

He's a Salvadoran citizen, we have NO JURISDICTION over him regardless of our contract with El Salvador. To bring him back to the US we have to extradite him via the courts.

We can get him back.

Our administration is failing to do so.

And they are doing so for political gain while his autistic son is at home without his non gang affiliated father.

Or didn't you know that before you spewed your tripe?

I know what this administration is. Their behavior is shameful

 

[HisArpy]

We can get him back.

Our administration is failing to do so.

This is what you BELIEVE. The truth is slightly different.

And they are doing so for political gain while his autistic son is at home without his non gang affiliated father.

He had a removal order signed by a judge. That the removal order was stayed because he claimed (to a different judge) that he'd be persecuted doesn't change the FACT that he was here ILLEGALLY and had been ordered removed from the country.

Bringing his kid into the argument doesn't change that at all. Doing it shows how weak your argument actually is because you rely on emotion rather than FACTS to prove your point.

I know what this administration is. Their behavior is shameful

According to who? You? The guy who has to argue emotions rather than facts? The guy who cannot admit facts? The guy who'd rather support an ILLEGAL ALIEN rather than US citizens?

I find your position disingenuous and supported by nothing except hot air.

 

[ll74]

This is what you BELIEVE. The truth is slightly different.

You k know I'm correct

He had a removal order signed by a judge. That the removal order was stayed because he claimed (to a different judge) that he'd be persecuted doesn't change the FACT that he was here ILLEGALLY and had been ordered removed from the country.

He is not a gang member

Bringing his kid into the argument doesn't change that at all. Doing it shows how weak your argument actually is because you rely on emotion rather than FACTS to prove your point.

Yes it does.

According to who? You? The guy who has to argue emotions rather than facts? The guy who cannot admit facts? The guy who'd rather support an ILLEGAL ALIEN rather than US citizens?

He was here legally, lawfully.

I find your position disingenuous and supported by nothing except hot air.

Because you're a fucking idiot

 

[HisArpy]

You k know I'm correct.

You're not but you will continue to believe you are. Because you're a numnutz who cannot admit the truth.

He is not a gang member

I never said he was. I stated quite clearly that he was ordered removed BY A JUDGE and that the removal order was stayed. For humanitarian reasons I believe.

Yes it does.

If you want to believe so, numnutz.

He was here legally, lawfully.

He was here ILLEGALLY but was given asylum. There's a difference between that and "legally."

Because you're a fucking idiot

Takes one to know one.

 

[ll74]

You're not but you will continue to believe you are. Because you're a numnutz who cannot admit the truth.

Don't care

I never said he was. I stated quite clearly that he was ordered removed BY A JUDGE and that the removal order was stayed. For humanitarian reasons I believe.

He was t ordered removed by a judge.

If you want to believe so, numnutz.

Yep

He was here ILLEGALLY but was given asylum. There's a difference between that and "legally.

He wasn't. He came here via legal means to claim asylum, which he was granted

Takes one to know one.

Liar

 

[HisArpy]

Don't care


He was t ordered removed by a judge.


Yep


He wasn't. He came here via legal means to claim asylum, which he was granted


Liar

Everything you need to know is in this article:

https://redstate.com/streiff/2025/0...nt-undo-a-perfectly-good-deportation-n2187538

It lists the actual facts which basically say you're a liar about nearly everything you posted.

 

[ll74]

Everything you need to know is in this article:

https://redstate.com/streiff/2025/0...nt-undo-a-perfectly-good-deportation-n2187538

It lists the actual facts which basically say you're a liar about nearly everything you posted.

The US can absolutely bring him home.
47 refuses to do so.
You don't give a fuck about an innocent man.

That's on you

In 2019, he was arrested on allegations of membership in the violent Salvadoran gang called Mara Salvatrucha, or MS-13.

Hey lawyer, is he a member of Ms13?

Fucking idiot

 

[ll74]

Everything you need to know is in this article:

https://redstate.com/streiff/2025/0...nt-undo-a-perfectly-good-deportation-n2187538

It lists the actual facts which basically say you're a liar about nearly everything you posted.

And finally - a question for you - why does due process matter?

 

[HisArpy]

And finally - a question for you - why does due process matter?

He got due process, he had his court date and the immigration court found his claims about needing asylum insufficient and ordered his removal from the US.

He then hired a lawyer to challenge that decision. Which resulted in more due process.

He was deported and hired another lawyer to challenge that. and the result is more due process.

He got all of the due process he was due and then some so you can stop whining about it now.

 

[ll74]

He got due process,

Not even close

he had his court date and the immigration court found his claims about needing asylum insufficient and ordered his removal from the US.

He actually was here legally because the court found that his claims were credible

He then hired a lawyer to challenge that decision. Which resulted in more due process.

The same lawyer who argued his earlier credible asylum claims validated by the court

He was deported and hired another lawyer to challenge that. and the result is more due process.

Nope

He got all of the due process he was due and then some so you can stop whining about it now.

You're an idiot

The man was granted protection by the court for his asylum claims, which is why he was here legally. He is not a gang member at all which continues to be the administration tag line