The Chicago Killing Fields

The CDC would beg to differ.
No, they wouldn't.

Also when someone slaughters twenty children with a hammer in under a minute you'll have a case, until then the effectiveness of the weapon is a major detail.
How about slaughtering 168 people with a truck full of fertilizer?

Or 3,000 people with box cutters?
 
Annual suicides per 100,000 people

1 Greenland 108.1
2 South Korea 31.7
3 Lithuania 31.6
4 Guyana 26.4
5 Kazakhstan 25.6
6 Belarus 22.9
7 China 22.23
8 Slovenia 21.8
9 Hungary 21.7
10 Japan 21.7
11 Sri Lanka 21.6
12 Ukraine 21.2
13 Russia 20.2
14 Croatia 19.7
15 Latvia 18.2
16 Moldova 17.4
17 Serbia 17.3
18 Belgium 17
19 Finland 16.8
20 Bhutan 16.2
21 Uruguay 15.8
22 South Africa 15.4
23 Poland 15.4
24 Taiwan 15.1
25 Estonia 14.8
26 France 14.7
27 Suriname 14.4
28 Bosnia and Herzegovina 13.3
29 Austria 12.8
30 Czech Republic 12.8
31 Cuba 12.3
32 Bulgaria 12.3
33 Romania 12.0
34 United States 12.0
35 Sweden 11.9
36 Norway 11.9
37 United Kingdom 11.8
38 New Zealand 11.5
39 Portugal 11.5
40 Canada 11.5
41 Ireland 11.4
42 Denmark 11.3
43 Iceland 11.3
44 Chile 11.2
45 Switzerland 11.1
46 Trinidad and Tobago 10.7
47 India 10.5
48 Slovakia 9.9
49 Germany 9.9
50 Australia 9.7
51 Kyrgyzstan 8.8
52 Turkmenistan 8.6
53 Netherlands 8.5
54 Republic of Macedonia 8.0
55 El Salvador 8.0
56 Zimbabwe 7.9
57 Luxembourg 7.8
58 Thailand 7.8
59 Argentina 7.7
60 Spain 7.6
61 Puerto Rico 7.4
62 Ecuador 7.1
63 Singapore 6.9
64 Mauritius 6.8
65 Iran 6.4
66 Italy 6.3
67 Costa Rica 6.1
68 Israel 5.8
69 Nicaragua 5.8
70 Panama 5.5
71 Colombia 4.9
72 Brazil 4.8
73 Uzbekistan 4.7
74 Cambodia 4.6
75 Georgia 4.3
76 Albania 4.0
77 Mexico 4.0
78 Turkey 3.9
79 Honduras 3.8
80 Bahrain 3.8
81 Belize 3.7
82 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 3.7
83 Paraguay 3.6
84 Cyprus 3.6
85 Guatemala 3.6
86 Barbados 3.5
87 Greece 3.5
88 Malta 3.4
89 Venezuela 3.2
90 Tajikistan 2.6
91 Saint Lucia 2.4
92 Dominican Republic 2.3
93 Philippines 2.1
94 Armenia 1.9
95 Kuwait 1.8
96 The Bahamas 1.2
97 Jordan 1.1
98 Pakistan 1.1
99 Peru 0.9
100 São Tomé and Príncipe 0.9
101 Azerbaijan 0.6
102 Maldives 0.3
103 Jamaica 0.1
104 Syria 0.1
105 Egypt 0.1
I'd state the obvious, except that it's... well... obvious.
 
It's also meaningless. Other countries having higher suicide rates merely mean that there are other things in play not that owning guns doesn't increase the frequency and success of suicide.
 
Daley, still?

I did not think even Chicago had such thing as an old-fashioned urban political machine any more. Thought the original Mayor Daley was in the last generation of that.

The Daley family never leaves. Brother Bill is running for Governor. He'll face the inept Speaker of the House's daughter, Lisa "Help Me Daddy" Madigan, and Gov. Pat "My Party Hates Me" Quinn. Democratic Sleaze.

Richard "Selling Off City Assets for a Hundred Year Period" Daley snuck off to get the goodies from all the companies that raped Chicago for decades under his "leadership". Total scumbag.

Now Rahm "Ethics, Eh?" Emmanuel is carrying on the tradition. His political cronies and campaign staff are behind the multi-million dollar Red Light deal for the city. Connections help.

It's all about safety, you know, with Chicago Democrats.

The Machine is LIVE AND WELL.
 
It's also meaningless. Other countries having higher suicide rates merely mean that there are other things in play not that owning guns doesn't increase the frequency and success of suicide.
Oh, no, it's quite meaningful indeed. Wouldn't one expect that if guns increased the frequency of suicide, the US, with its 300 million guns, would have a significantly higher suicide rate than countries where guns are scarcer than 16-year-old virgins?

This would indicate that your "other things in play" make gun ownership a statistically insignificant factor in suicide.
 
Last edited:
What's "widespread enough to be significant" mean?

Doesn't it stand to reason that people who commit violent acts will use what tools are available, whether they're knives, guns, baseball bats, chainsaws, gasoline, explosives, or whatever?

What makes guns seem so peculiar to you compared to anything else?

This entire thread is about gun violence in Chicago. I didn't start the thread. I'm just responding to the topic. Ask vette why gun violence is worthy of discussion while baseball bats aren't. I suspect for him it's tied up with two facts: Obama is from Chicago, and Chicago has the toughest gun laws in the nation. That's my suspicion, anyway. I really don't know.

To answer your first question, I can't define a clear line between what's significant and what's not, but I am pretty sure that gun violence is on one side of that line and hammer violence is on the other.

Did I really use the word "peculiar"? That would be rather peculiar of me.
 
I don't need to read the label. I'm well aware of the risks of antidepressants. But do you think they're really responsible for the gang killings in the inner cities? I heard or read somewhere recently that the average shooter age in gangland killings is something like fourteen. I doubt too many fourteen year old inner city kids are on antidepressants.

Inner city kids do not get their guns legally either. ;) But let's punish the honest people any way, right. :rolleyes:
 
This entire thread is about gun violence in Chicago. I didn't start the thread. I'm just responding to the topic. Ask vette why gun violence is worthy of discussion while baseball bats aren't. I suspect for him it's tied up with two facts: Obama is from Chicago, and Chicago has the toughest gun laws in the nation. That's my suspicion, anyway. I really don't know.
I don't know, either. I was responding to you.

To answer your first question, I can't define a clear line between what's significant and what's not, but I am pretty sure that gun violence is on one side of that line and hammer violence is on the other.
If there's no criteria to determine what a significant level is... what are you saying, exactly?

Did I really use the word "peculiar"? That would be rather peculiar of me.
No, I did. Should I use another?
 
The idea that people commit suicide because a gun is handy is ridiculous.

I never said such a thing. I linked antidepressants to suicide (a documented fact), not guns. I only said a gun was a convenient and effective tool for offing oneself if one happened to be handy (another fact).
 
I never said such a thing. I linked antidepressants to suicide (a documented fact), not guns. I only said a gun was a convenient and effective tool for offing oneself if one happened to be handy (another fact).
So is a pair of nylon hose.

Why mention guns in that context, then?
 
I don't know, either. I was responding to you.

If there's no criteria to determine what a significant level is... what are you saying, exactly?

No, I did. Should I use another?

I'm saying that violence involving guns in America is a significant issue and should be addressed. Apparently everyone else who's responded in this thread thinks so too. Are you suggesting that it's not? I also said that violence involving hammers isn't a significant issue, or at least not nearly so much of an issue as guns (which admittedly was purely a gut response from me, but I do believe that most people would agree - you don't hear about gangland hammer killing sprees at any rate).

And no, I don't care if you use the word peculiar. I actually couldn't remember if I'd said that or not and if I had, it would seem peculiar of me because for some reason it's not a word I often use.
 
I'm saying that violence involving guns in America is a significant issue and should be addressed. Apparently everyone else who's responded in this thread thinks so too. Are you suggesting that it's not? I also said that violence involving hammers isn't a significant issue, or at least not nearly so much of an issue as guns (which admittedly was purely a gut response from me, but I do believe that most people would agree - you don't hear about gangland hammer killing sprees at any rate).

And no, I don't care if you use the word peculiar. I actually couldn't remember if I'd said that or not and if I had, it would seem peculiar of me because for some reason it's not a word I often use.

I don't. The biggest problem is the gang bangers. No one wants to broach that subject. Ignore the obvious.
 
So is a pair of nylon hose.

Why mention guns in that context, then?

Oh come now. Killing oneself with a gun would have to be much simpler than strangling oneself with a pair of nylon hose. If both were available to me, and I was serious about killing myself, I'd choose a gun hands down.

Besides, I only mentioned guns in relation to suicides because this is a thread about gun violence and kbear introduced the topic of prescription drug use as a factor. I agreed that it could be a factor in suicides involving guns (because, you know, we've all been talking about about guns), but not so much so in gang shootings in Chicago.

Why am I feeling like I'm having to reconstruct pages of discussion for you in order to justify what I've said in response to other people?
 
Oh come now. Killing oneself with a gun would have to be much simpler than strangling oneself with a pair of nylon hose. If both were available to me, and I was serious about killing myself, I'd choose a gun hands down.

Besides, I only mentioned guns in relation to suicides because this is a thread about gun violence and kbear introduced the topic of prescription drug use as a factor. I agreed that it could be a factor in suicides involving guns (because, you know, we've all been talking about about guns), but not so much so in gang shootings in Chicago.

Why am I feeling like I'm having to reconstruct pages of discussion for you in order to justify what I've said in response to other people?

You have a President and AG that made it simple for drug gangs to get guns. Did you write you reps about that problem?
 
I don't. The biggest problem is the gang bangers. No one wants to broach that subject. Ignore the obvious.

Yes, you're right. The problem is the gangbangers. I also think gun violence is an issue that should be addressed, and we shouldn't limit the solution to simply killing anybody with a gang tattoo.

You guys are nitpicking. You do remember that I'm a gun owner, right? In this, I'm actually on your side.
 
Yes, you're right. The problem is the gangbangers. I also think gun violence is an issue that should be addressed, and we shouldn't limit the solution to simply killing anybody with a gang tattoo.

You guys are nitpicking. You do remember that I'm a gun owner, right? In this, I'm actually on your side.

Killing them is the cheapest method. :cool: Pouring more money into the problem will not work, it never has.
 
You have a President and AG that made it simple for drug gangs to get guns. Did you write you reps about that problem?

My representative called me a few months ago (just a random number, I'm sure) and no, I didn't mention drug gangs and guns because I had a limited amount of time to converse with him and it's not an issue that affects me directly at this time. Instead, we had a conversation about services for people with special needs. It's a matter of prioritization. I'm a busy person.

How did the President and AG make it simple for gangs to get guns, by the way? I don't think there was any shortage of guns on the streets of Chicago before Obama was elected, but I'm more than willing to be educated.
 
My representative called me a few months ago (just a random number, I'm sure) and no, I didn't mention drug gangs and guns because I had a limited amount of time to converse with him and it's not an issue that affects me directly at this time. Instead, we had a conversation about services for people with special needs. It's a matter of prioritization. I'm a busy person.

How did the President and AG make it simple for gangs to get guns, by the way? I don't think there was any shortage of guns on the streets of Chicago before Obama was elected, but I'm more than willing to be educated.

I guess you only read the liberal rags. No surprise. :D
 
I'm saying that violence involving guns in America is a significant issue and should be addressed.
Ok, hold that thought.

Apparently everyone else who's responded in this thread thinks so too.
I don't care what they think.

Are you suggesting that it's not?
I'm suggesting that tools are incapable of independent action.

I also said that violence involving hammers isn't a significant issue, or at least not nearly so much of an issue as guns (which admittedly was purely a gut response from me, but I do believe that most people would agree - you don't hear about gangland hammer killing sprees at any rate).
And what if you did? What if you heard constantly about gangland hammer killing sprees? Would that be evidence of an American Hammer Problem? And if so, how ought that issue be addressed?

"I'm saying that violence involving guns in America is a significant issue and should be addressed."

Are you saying that violence ought to be addressed, or that guns ought to be addressed? Because those two things are completely different.
 
Killing them is the cheapest method. :cool: Pouring more money into the problem will not work, it never has.

I would shed no tears for the loss of some gangbangers, but I would for the loss of their Constitutional rights. What about due process and all that? I suppose it could be argued that they don't deserve them, but if you set the precedent, maybe it'll be your turn next.

Aside from killing them outright, what other simpler, less costly interventions could we entertain? Again, I'm very willing to listen. Illinois doesn't need to be wasting any more money fixing Chicago's problems, that's for sure.
 
Ok, hold that thought.

I don't care what they think.

I'm suggesting that tools are incapable of independent action.

And what if you did? What if you heard constantly about gangland hammer killing sprees? Would that be evidence of an American Hammer Problem? And if so, how ought that issue be addressed?

"I'm saying that violence involving guns in America is a significant issue and should be addressed."

Are you saying that violence ought to be addressed, or that guns ought to be addressed? Because those two things are completely different.

Violence involving guns is an issue within the broader issue of violence in general. It's all about sets and subsets and all that. Oftentimes, compartmentalizing an issue has value, which is also why we distinguish between gun-related homicide and gun-related suicide. They're different and need to be treated as such.

And I don't think I've said that we have an American Gun Problem (if I did, it was a mistake). I said we have an American Gun Violence Problem. That's carries an entirely different connotation.

And yes, if people were running around whacking eighty people in a major city with hammers, and killing eight of them in a single weekend, and hundreds every year, then I would say we have an American Hammer Violence Problem.

In neither case am I blaming the tool. I'm just identifying the tool used most prominently because that has to factor into any solution. The violence itself is the problem, of course. And as kbear said, it's the gangbangers who must bear the brunt of the blame in this instance.
 
I guess you only read the liberal rags. No surprise. :D

Ha. Maybe you're right. So educate me. Send me a link to your conservative rags on this issue and help this blind, sorta-liberal girl to see the light. If the Pres is funneling guns to the gangs, I promise I'll sit up and take notice.
 
Oh come now.
???

Killing oneself with a gun would have to be much simpler than strangling oneself with a pair of nylon hose.
It's not simpler. Bedridden people have killed themselves that way. A gun is more painful and messier, although faster.

If both were available to me, and I was serious about killing myself, I'd choose a gun hands down.
You would be in a minority of women in the United States, only 35% of whom commit suicide with a firearm.

Besides, I only mentioned guns in relation to suicides because this is a thread about gun violence and kbear introduced the topic of prescription drug use as a factor. I agreed that it could be a factor in suicides involving guns (because, you know, we've all been talking about about guns), but not so much so in gang shootings in Chicago.
Guns are used in half of suicides in the US because they're there. If they were removed, other methods would replace them, as they do in other countries. Worldwide, most suicides are accomplished by hanging.

Why am I feeling like I'm having to reconstruct pages of discussion for you in order to justify what I've said in response to other people?
Because I'm not those other people?
 
Back
Top