The Departed

Morcheeba said:
I didn't think she was pretty at first, but her body turned out to be much better than I'd expected.

Too skinny for my taste.
 
Morcheeba said:
Better than 'Goodfellas'?

My beau says it is, I beg to differ.

A better movie than Goodfellas? No. No chance. It's a heck of a flick but let's be reasonable here.
 
Drinking Cap said:
A better movie than Goodfellas? No. No chance. It's a heck of a flick but let's be reasonable here.

Actually, The Departed isn't even as good as Casino, or The Aviator.

It is better than Bringing out the Dead, however.
 
medjay said:
Actually, The Departed isn't even as good as Casino, or The Aviator.

It is better than Bringing out the Dead, however.
Very True
 
Drinking Cap said:
A better movie than Goodfellas? No. No chance. It's a heck of a flick but let's be reasonable here.

Haha, my exact sentiments.
 
Drinking Cap said:
A better movie than Goodfellas? No. No chance. It's a heck of a flick but let's be reasonable here.

I think Goodfellas just isn't as fresh in some people's minds, hence they start with the crazy talk.

Maybe they should go back and watch Goodfellas again so they can see the difference between Scorsese working at the top of his game vs. Scorsese phoning it in.

Granted, a phone-in from Scorsese is still better than most films people will see in a year, but it's still a phone-in.
 
medjay said:
I think Goodfellas just isn't as fresh in some people's minds, hence they start with the crazy talk.

Maybe they should go back and watch Goodfellas again so they can see the difference between Scorsese working at the top of his game vs. Scorsese phoning it in.

Granted, a phone-in from Scorsese is still better than most films people will see in a year, but it's still a phone-in.

Honestly? I haven't been knocked head over heels by a Scorcese flick since Goodfellas. Casino was alright, although I sure as hell hope Scorcese got to throw a fuck into Sharon Stone, but too long. Gangs of New York and the Aviator both were hamstrung, I think, by his casting choices and the less said about Bringing out the Dead the better.

I think Goodfellas was a breaking point for him. He must have been like "What the fuck do I have to do for these people? Awwwww, screw it"
 
medjay said:
I think Goodfellas just isn't as fresh in some people's minds, hence they start with the crazy talk.

Maybe they should go back and watch Goodfellas again so they can see the difference between Scorsese working at the top of his game vs. Scorsese phoning it in.

Granted, a phone-in from Scorsese is still better than most films people will see in a year, but it's still a phone-in.

Whoa, slow down some. I was the one who asked DC his thoughts about Goodfellas vs. The Departed per a discussion I had had with my bf and it wasn't crazy talk. Just a difference of opinion RIGHT after having viewed The Departed. Deep down I know he knows it's not better.

Scorsese "phoning it in" - what the hell?

So if/when he wins this year you're going to say it was a phone-in and that everyone should figure, like you, that it wasn't all that great nor even good. Get off your high horse for once.
 
Drinking Cap said:
Honestly? I haven't been knocked head over heels by a Scorcese flick since Goodfellas. Casino was alright, although I sure as hell hope Scorcese got to throw a fuck into Sharon Stone, but too long. Gangs of New York and the Aviator both were hamstrung, I think, by his casting choices and the less said about Bringing out the Dead the better.

I think Goodfellas was a breaking point for him. He must have been like "What the fuck do I have to do for these people? Awwwww, screw it"

I have to agree with you on that. I've not seen The Aviator or Bringing Out the Dead, but Casino was like Goodfellas - Part Deux and Gangs... was just a snoozefest.
 
Morcheeba said:
Whoa, slow down some. I was the one who asked DC his thoughts about Goodfellas vs. The Departed per a discussion I had had with my bf and it wasn't crazy talk. Just a difference of opinion RIGHT after having viewed The Departed. Deep down I know he knows it's not better.

Scorsese "phoning it in" - what the hell?

So if/when he wins this year you're going to say it was a phone-in and that everyone should figure, like you, that it wasn't all that great nor even good. Get off your high horse for once.

It's funny, but one of the things I really did like about the Departed was what Scorcese did with it. Besides that, I thought the only really good performances in the whole thing came from Damon, Wahlberg and Baldwin.

Is it just me or has Nicholson veered into Pacino-esque self parody?
 
Drinking Cap said:
It's funny, but one of the things I really did like about the Departed was what Scorcese did with it. Besides that, I thought the only really good performances in the whole thing came from Damon, Wahlberg and Baldwin.

Is it just me or has Nicholson veered into Pacino-esque self parody?

As I said, Damon startled me - I was actually anticipating more screen time from him and that's not happened before. I could say more about Wahlberg but don't wanna spoil it for others. Baldwin is always so damn incredible.

Good point about The Jack. I might have watched it in a different fashion than you as I kept wondering in the back of my mind, 'Is this the last big one for him?' Twas then that I sat back and soaked it all up. Self-parody, hair fritzed out like in the Shining at times... I simply enjoyed ever sec that he was on screen.
 
I saw in in the theater, and I quite liked The Departed. Did I like it as much as Goodfellas (also saw in the theater)? No, but it still was quite good. And I barely remember Casino, which makes me think I must not have been blown away by it.
 
Drinking Cap said:
It's funny, but one of the things I really did like about the Departed was what Scorcese did with it. Besides that, I thought the only really good performances in the whole thing came from Damon, Wahlberg and Baldwin.

Is it just me or has Nicholson veered into Pacino-esque self parody?

I completely agree.
 
Morcheeba said:
As I said, Damon startled me - I was actually anticipating more screen time from him and that's not happened before. I could say more about Wahlberg but don't wanna spoil it for others. Baldwin is always so damn incredible.

Baldwin, quite honestly, might be the funniest comic actor in the world.

Morcheeba said:
Good point about The Jack. I might have watched it in a different fashion than you as I kept wondering in the back of my mind, 'Is this the last big one for him?' Twas then that I sat back and soaked it all up. Self-parody, hair fritzed out like in the Shining at times... I simply enjoyed ever sec that he was on screen.

I like the guy, but of all the movies he's made in the last 20 years, is there a single one where he wasn't playing Jack Nicholson? About Schmidt, maybe.

I love Al Pacino in Scent of A Woman too, but only because I'm 99% sure you can actually hear him chewing on the scenery.
 
Morcheeba said:
Scorsese "phoning it in" - what the hell?

So if/when he wins this year you're going to say it was a phone-in and that everyone should figure, like you, that it wasn't all that great nor even good. Get off your high horse for once.

When a director resorts to using the exact same dolly-shots, editing tricks and music cues that are easily recognizable from his other works, I'm afraid it does fall into the category of phoning-it-in. Especially when they're used through the whole movie and not just as a signature shot (like Spike Lee with his silly floating-across-the-sidewalk shot).

I do hope Scorsese wins however; even though it won't be as exciting as having seen him win for one of his more deserving films.
 
medjay said:
When a director resorts to using the exact same dolly-shots, editing tricks and music cues that are easily recognizable from his other works, I'm afraid it does fall into the category of phoning-it-in.

The music, especially, in Scorsese's case. Does the man use Gimme Shelter in every one of his films? I was half expecting to hear it in Gangs of New York.
 
Back
Top