The Founders And The Second Amendment

I agree with the founders.

The USA should either dismantle its armed forces and rely upon the citizenry to bear arms in defence of the country from foreign invasion...or take the guns away from citizens and maintain its standing armed forces.
 
Not at all. The Constitution grants Congress the power to raise and support an army and a Navy. Doesn't have anything to do with the militia.

Actually, they're all inextricably linked together in your Constitution as a system, along with details like no army being funded for more than 2 years and no military use comprising more than ten square miles.

Your "army & navy" was always intended as temporary bolsters to your militia if needed...the founders were dead set against a government with more firepower than its citizens.

But you'd rather Tax & Spend to maintain the world's largest standing army.

I find that really funny, given your general point of view spewed here over the years about government spending being out of control.

How do you reconcile that?

And, most importantly, can you explain your position without Copying & Pasting other people's words?
 
Last edited:
If we're going to read between the lines of the Constitution, let's enforce separation of church and state too.
 
I don't think it's a question of reading between the lines...the whole idea behind Americans being "self-armed" was as an alternative to the British model of the Government being in charge of all the guns.

Americans wanted to be free of an armed government that could lord over its citizens.

It's the most fundamental "check & balance" behind what made America different from the "oppressive regime" it revolted against.

In the USA, if the people elect a government that "turns" on the People...the People can, if necessary, march the Government out of office at gunpoint.

Plus, an armed and trained citizenry can quickly mobilize as a militia to defend against invasion...with the option of raising a formal Army if need be...for a short period of time.

It was an excellent idea.

However, it's obviously been bastardized.
 
I love how he runs away whenever anyone replies on-subject.

Take away his homoerotic and C&P responses... and he's a shell.
 
I don't think it's a question of reading between the lines...the whole idea behind Americans being "self-armed" was as an alternative to the British model of the Government being in charge of all the guns.

Americans wanted to be free of an armed government that could lord over its citizens.

It's the most fundamental "check & balance" behind what made America different from the "oppressive regime" it revolted against.

In the USA, if the people elect a government that "turns" on the People...the People can, if necessary, march the Government out of office at gunpoint.

Plus, an armed and trained citizenry can quickly mobilize as a militia to defend against invasion...with the option of raising a formal Army if need be...for a short period of time.

It was an excellent idea.

However, it's obviously been bastardized.

Of course it is.

Vetteman woke up this morning and realized just how tenuous the DC v Heller and McDonald v Chicago decisions were in the context of the current Supreme Court and is now attempting to 'channel' the Framers of the Constitution to bolster his position that every citizen should be able to own a firearm.

Nevermind the fact that the Framers themselves saw fit to not make it explicit in the Constitution, leading to centuries of debate on the matter.

Maybe vette's so old that he knew these guys and can speak on their behalf. It would explain his sclerotic way of thinking.
 
Those who wrote and signed the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution were intelligent and well educated for a time when many Americans did not get any schooling at all. Nevertheless, they were not omniscient. What they had to say about anything should be viewed skeptically.
 
I love how he runs away whenever anyone replies on-subject.

Take away his homoerotic and C&P responses... and he's a shell.

Anyone can find something on the internet that he or she agrees with. The internet should only be used to substantiate factual assertions made in original arguments one composes oneself.

Those who cannot do this should remain silent and respectful in the presence of those who can. The opinions of those with intelligence, literacy, and erudition are worth much more than the opinions of those with none of these qualities.
 
Not at all. The Constitution grants Congress the power to raise and support an army and a Navy. Doesn't have anything to do with the militia.

Article I, Section 8:

To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions;

To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress;
 
Vetteman, why are you wasting time confusing them with facts?

Basic literacy and reading comprehension reveal that with regard to the Constitution there is no gun control debate.

Those who would debate are interested in controlling the masses, which is the very thing the founding fathers fought AGAINST.
 
Last edited:
Those who wrote and signed the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution were intelligent and well educated for a time when many Americans did not get any schooling at all. Nevertheless, they were not omniscient. What they had to say about anything should be viewed skeptically.


Not a bad point.

The framers envisioned an armed citizenry in lieu of and/or to balance against the potential for tyranny from a government-controlled standing army.

However, modern times demand the USA have a large standing army to keep external threats at bay.

Therefore, in order to prevent against the potential for government tyranny, a modern interpretation would call for the citizenry to have weapons equal to those held by the standing army...just in case.

This would support the Vetteman/NRA assertions that you should be able to keep laser-guided missile silos in your back yard next to the pool.
 
1787: No standing army or navy

2013: Standing army, navy, air force, plus reserves and national guard.

Does this mean that civilians need to be armed to assist in the defense of the country?

That's the question for SCOTUS and scholars, people far superior than us.

Opinion:
I say, let people keep their guns...but tax the shit out of the ammo, and make sure that the person purchasing said ammo is licensed to do so, i.e. their gun(s) are registered.
 
Vetteman, why are you wasting time confusing them with facts?

Basic literacy and reading comprehension reveal that with regard to the Constitution there is no gun control debate.

Those who would debate are interested in controlling the masses, which is the very thing the founding fathers fought AGAINST.

If you're using the term "reading comprehension" you haven't read the Constitution.
 
Back
Top