The next SCOTUS 2nd Amendment case?

The Court should take the case. Civil rights are not dispensed according to "justifiable needs." It is an onerous and illegitimate standard.

The interesting case down the road is where otherwise legal possession of arms in public can be prohibited or restricted and on what grounds. Schools and government buildings for certain, but on what basis would a private business or public gatherings (concerts, sporting events) be justified in prohibiting the carrying of arms.
 
The Court should take the case. Civil rights are not dispensed according to "justifiable needs." It is an onerous and illegitimate standard.

The interesting case down the road is where otherwise legal possession of arms in public can be prohibited or restricted and on what grounds. Schools and government buildings for certain, but on what basis would a private business or public gatherings (concerts, sporting events) be justified in prohibiting the carrying of arms.

Because those are usually private property. A private business can choose (to some extent) who they wish to do business with.
 
Wouldn't private businesses be able to set their own rules?

Because those are usually private property. A private business can choose (to some extent) who they wish to do business with.

Well.....uh......considering that a right is.......uh.....legally distinct......from......well,......a left, then.......

You both raise an interesting point......

Could we just keep this between the three of us? :eek::eek::eek:
 
“ . . . the right of the people to keep and bear arms when serving in the militia shall not be infringed.”

Five words that can change your life.
 
Well.....uh......considering that a right is.......uh.....legally distinct......from......well,......a left, then.......

You both raise an interesting point......

Could we just keep this between the three of us? :eek::eek::eek:

Yeah. You probably could have bluffed through this though. :cool:

I agree that schools and courthouses would be out, I'd be more curious about parks. I'd assume it would get a pass.

If I were to argue it however (and I wouldn't) I'd probably attempt to make the case that guns are inherently offensive not defensive tools. If weapons count as defense I don't see why I can't walk around with an explosive vest on a dead man switch. Not only would nobody fuck with me but people would be in a goddamn hurry to help me if I tripped, or started to choke, or someone looked at me funny.

“ . . . the right of the people to keep and bear arms when serving in the militia shall not be infringed.”

Five words that can change your life.

Yeah. . .we've mostly common sensed our way around it.
 
I was agreeing with retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens that the five words are necessity. It just surprised me because I guessed that you would agree as well.
 
I was agreeing with retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens that the five words are necessity. It just surprised me because I guessed that you would agree as well.

On that I don't have a strong opinion. I just wish the Right would stop pretending it's a tragedy and not a Tuesday when a mass shooting pops up.
 
I think it is well written. The subsequent interpretation seems to be poor, IMO.
 
Because those are usually private property. A private business can choose (to some extent) who they wish to do business with.

So if I don't like somebody's sexual orientation, I don't have to do business with them?
What about their religion? That's a personal choice. So is political affiliation.
 
So if I don't like somebody's sexual orientation, I don't have to do business with them?
What about their religion? That's a personal choice. So is political affiliation.

No, you can't no do business with people because of who they are.

But you don't have to do business with someone not wearing a shirt, who is causing a disturbance or packing heat.
 
So if I don't like somebody's sexual orientation, I don't have to do business with them?
What about their religion? That's a personal choice. So is political affiliation.

Sexual orientation isn't a choice. Can't discriminate based on that.
 
Sexual orientation isn't a choice. Can't discriminate based on that.


So it's okay to refuse service to Sikhs, Jews and Muslims?
That was rhetorical.


Personally I think refusal of service is or should be about behavior, such as breaking laws and regulations, doing things that are unsafe or unsanitary, proselytizing, driving away other customers or otherwise disturbing them, or touching a weapon while discussing prices and service, etc.

Not because a person is wearing a religious headdress, dagger or a pistol.
 
Yeah. You probably could have bluffed through this though. :cool:

I agree that schools and courthouses would be out, I'd be more curious about parks. I'd assume it would get a pass.

If I were to argue it however (and I wouldn't) I'd probably attempt to make the case that guns are inherently offensive not defensive tools. If weapons count as defense I don't see why I can't walk around with an explosive vest on a dead man switch. Not only would nobody fuck with me but people would be in a goddamn hurry to help me if I tripped, or started to choke, or someone looked at me funny.

Like I'm going to give the "Heimlich hug" to someone wearing a suicide vest! :rolleyes::rolleyes:

Sorry, Sean. It's just you, God and the bacon-wrapped scallop.
 
Back
Top