This time, ami has a point....

Upon what foundation do you make that assumption? And why should anyone else share it?
In forming a theory, it is necessary to assume something in order to proceed. A well known example would be the Theory of Relativity, which assumes that the highest achievable velocity is that of the speed of light.

Although physics has shown that the speed of light is what Relativity says it is, it does not show that the speed of light is the ultimate velocity. It is possible, and probably likely, that higher speeds are common. Certain experiments in the Quantum world have demonstrated speeds faster than light. This is just to address your question about making an assumption.

To state my post in other words: Imagine a large blackboard filled from top to bottom and side to side with equations and math symbols arranged to explain the universe (something like the blackboard in Professor Whatshisname's study in the 1950's sci-fi movie, The Day The Earth Stood Still).

Erase everything and start Tabula Rasa, excluding any references to space, time, and the space-time continuum. When you finish that, how will the universe appear with space and time absent? I can come to only one conclusion and I was wondering if anyone else reached the same conclusion or if they can show me where I went wrong? Boiled down further, what is the universe like without space or time?
 
Last edited:
Hypothesis Null: All information we process is tangible.
Hypothesis 1: All information we process is tangible but illusive.
Hypothesis 2: All information we process is illusive.
Hypothesis 3: All information we process can be divided between tangible and illusive.

Try your little thought experiments with all the options available.
 
Hypothesis Null: All information we process is tangible.
Hypothesis 1: All information we process is tangible but illusive.
Hypothesis 2: All information we process is illusive.
Hypothesis 3: All information we process can be divided between tangible and illusive.

Try your little thought experiments with all the options available.

Ten-four.

The act of observing, changes that which is observed.
The observer is the observed.

Come back.
 
At the risk of confusing the issue, I think the first question must be whether the universe - and therefore our existence - is deterministic. That is to say... do we operate as free agents in possession of free will?

To be free agents our "minds" must be largely, maybe totally, independent from our "bodies." It's a long story, but basically if we are simply Pavlovically responding to hormones, environmental influences and genetics then we don't have the ability to choose between various options that existence offers us, we can only react biomechanically to stimuli.

Likewise, if the whole universe is deterministic, that is if the first atom bumped into the second and forced it into the third and so on down the line so that if some super being was to possess every physical measurement it could determine the future a billion years hence, then we have no free will either. (Any neither would the super being, for that matter.)

Before one decides if we live in a deterministic universe or indeed have free will consider that either way we clearly possess the "illusion" of free will due to the nature of time which seems to us to travel only in a single direction. Causality and the the laws of thermodynamics combine to reinforce the feeling that we control our destiny whether or not we do.

If we have no free will then there can be no morality and it would be fine for us to collectivize and become like an insect society beholden to a hive mind. Communism would be therefore completely rational.

However, if we are independent agents capable of freely choosing (creating even) our own destiny then any variety of collectivism is the ultimate crime against humanity.
 
One of my favorite science types was Richard Feynman. He worked on the Manhattan Project and then went on to do valuable work in quantum physics, particularly in quantum electrodynamics (the interactions between light and matter). He was a Nobel Laureate in physics and had this to say about the philosophy of science...

"Philosophy of science is about as useful to scientists as ornithology is to birds."


He had this to say about birds...

"You can know the name of a bird in all the languages of the world, but when you're finished, you'll know absolutely nothing whatever about the bird... So let's look at the bird and see what it's doing -- that's what counts."

He also weighed in on economics...

"There are 10^11 stars in the galaxy. That used to be a huge number. But it's only a hundred billion. It's less than the national deficit! We used to call them astronomical numbers. Now we should call them economical numbers."

And for Stella, this is his take on sex...

"Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it."
 
Last edited:
I invite anyone who is part of this discussion to consider their personal beliefs/philosophies, by assuming that space and time are illusions, conditions of consciousness. Then report back here and reiterate your philosophy as it appears when viewed through that prism. I believe if you do this, there is only one possible conclusion.

Why should I bother to extrapolate anything from an assumption I believed to be false. Is anyone that bored and in the need for something totally worthless to do?
 
One of my favorite science types was Richard Feynman.

And for Stella, this is his take on sex...

"Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it."

I have Feynman's lectures on tape around here somewhere.

I once asked a professor to explain the difference between science and engineering. He said, "Engineers are concerned foremost with practical results and find facts in tables to ensure results. Scientists create the tables."
 
Ten-four.

The act of observing, changes that which is observed.
The observer is the observed.

Come back.

So that is:

Hypothesis 4: All information we process is used to manipulate the source of the information?
 
I have Feynman's lectures on tape around here somewhere.

I once asked a professor to explain the difference between science and engineering. He said, "Engineers are concerned foremost with practical results and find facts in tables to ensure results. Scientists create the tables."
I would also say; Scientists can learn as much from their mistakes as from their successes, while engineers can't afford to be wrong.
 
In various posts in this thread I've tried, repeatedly and unsuccessfully to convince ami that science doesn't deal with absolute truths and certainties. I'm not sure if he truly understands that it doesn't but keeps saying it does just to get me riled, or if he truly doesn't understand.

He'll never change his mind because of anything I write, so I'll toss in one more quote from physicist and Nobel Laureate Richard Feynman...

“If you thought that science was certain - well, that is just an error on your part.”
 
Why should I bother to extrapolate anything from an assumption I believed to be false. Is anyone that bored and in the need for something totally worthless to do?

All were invited to participate in this, which amounts to mental arm-wrestling. Those who are excluded, exclude themselves.
 
So that is:

Hypothesis 4: All information we process is used to manipulate the source of the information?

I just don't know. I have a feeling that Man has a built mechanical limit to what can be observed and understood. We may be near that limit or we are very far from it. Once that limit has been reached, any further inquiry would be the equivalent of spinning our wheels.
 
I just don't know. I have a feeling that Man has a built mechanical limit to what can be observed and understood. We may be near that limit or we are very far from it. Once that limit has been reached, any further inquiry would be the equivalent of spinning our wheels.
That's a hypothesis. How will you explore it?
 
I just don't know. I have a feeling that Man has a built mechanical limit to what can be observed and understood. We may be near that limit or we are very far from it. Once that limit has been reached, any further inquiry would be the equivalent of spinning our wheels.

I'm not at all sure about a mechanical limit to what can be observed. If you consider particle physics and the amounts of energy needed to probe deeper and deeper (more energy is needed to probe the smaller) the Large Hadron Collider in Europe may be a limit for a while. The thing has cost a bagillion amount of money and it's unlikely that any group of countries is going to try and build something bigger for some time. But that is a question of economic ability, not one of scientific or engineering ability.

All you have to do to probe the limits of the smallest and most energetic (the Planck scale) and find out if string theory is on track, is to build a collider about the diameter of the galaxy and power it up. How difficult could that be? :D
 
actually, I don't see what perceptive limits have to do with the space-time continuum. The cosmos exists regardless of our limitations.

Apples were falling on heads before the word "gravity" was ever invented. The sun was coming up and stars were twinkling in the sky long before hominids were able to verbalise about them.

Once that limit has been reached, any further inquiry would be the equivalent of spinning our wheels.
So what-- we should stop now, just in case we reach that limit? That's dumb.
 
After reading this thread I think we should all calm down and admit that there is more than one kind of knowledge available to humanity.

Obviously, in our modern technological society Kuhn and Popper-style rational scientific inquiry based upon the transparent exchange of data and method and the falsifiable proposition (hypothesis formation) is our dominant means of achieving "knowledge" today.

But the modern scientific method as developed since The Enlightenment is actually only relevant to a very narrow sphere of inquiry into physically verifiable existence. Only because we are living in a highly technological, consumer-based society encased and supported by our manufactured environments and devices do we imagine that science is the primary way to know anything.

For time immemorial the human species lived as hunter gatherers in direct naked contact with full force of mysterious nature. For our ancestors the myriad ways of knowing often had little to do with rational inquiry into and modeling of nature. They relied heavily upon genetic memory, traditional knowledge, dreamtime experiences, various shamanistic techniques of consciousness altering, intuition and always a mental cosmic map of reality superimposed upon the environment around them which allowed them to see the numinous nature of the world long lost to us as we attempt (but must ultimately always fail) to be objective.

Perhaps being able to literally see the numinous or experience dreams as problem solving isn't going to provide engineers clues to how to build a better Ford, but when big science is stretched to its very limits as it is today in cosmology then at some point the realm of the transcendental and mythopoeic are crossed over into and empiricism loses its validity.

All human beings are hardwired to function best within a holistic cosmological mythology. And by myth, I don't mean a "lie" but a self-consistent working (and therefore useful) model of reality, and not just the physical empirical reality we can see and touch, but the spiritual as well.

All human mythological traditions, by definition, must answer these most primal human questions:

Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do? How should we do it? And finally whence did we come and where are we going?

Ask any clever adult hominid being from the last 700,000 years of our history these questions and he or she will have a cogent working knowledge of these essential issues and provide you with an answer. Yet scientific materialism as a working way of knowledge has only existed for about the last 350 years. And even today, modern science can only in the most vague and unsatisfying ways answer the primal need of humanity to know who, why, what, how, whence and where of existence.
 
Last edited:
I invite anyone who is part of this discussion to consider their personal beliefs/philosophies, by assuming that space and time are illusions, conditions of consciousness. Then report back here and reiterate your philosophy as it appears when viewed through that prism. I believe if you do this, there is only one possible conclusion.

I'm convinced that space and time are not illusions and are not conditions of consciousness.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that idea goes back to George Berkeley, Bishop of Cloyne. He held that nothing exists except in the mind of perceivers and that without a perceiver, nothing exists.

"Esse est percipi" ("to be is to be perceived").

It smacks of that old chestnut "If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it...does it make a sound?"

Only philosophers with way too much time on their hands argue over that one. As for space and time being mere illusions, I'll fall back on my favorite physicist, Richard Feynman...twice...

"Philosophers say a great deal about what is absolutely necessary for science, and it is always, so far as one can see, rather naive, and probably wrong."

...and...

"The first principle is that you must not fool yourself - and you are the easiest person to fool."
 
Last edited:
lustatopia, I'll give you my favorite answer...yes and no.

Or, if it works, I both agree and disagree. Of course modern science only deals with what is physically verifiable. If it isn't verifiable, it is outside of science. If your pet theory doesn't hold up to verification, it's wrong. Or as (again) Richard Feynman said...

"It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

I do have a problem with concepts such as genetic memory, various shamanistic techniques of consciousness altering, intuition and cosmic maps as realistic methods of dealing with the reality of day to day life. I think those methods are of little value today and were of even less value to our ancestors, going all the way back to "Lucy".

On the other hand, traditional knowledge, passed down from generation to generation, such as how to light a fire, make a stone tool, kill an animal without getting yourself killed, what plants were edible versus the ones that made you sick...those bits of knowledge were indispensable. They were also acquired by the good old (scientific) method of trial and error, which has a basis in reality.

Shamans who swallowed hallucinogenic mushrooms (or whatever) and went in search of cave bears to learn their wisdom got eliminated from the gene pool. That's why they swallowed hallucinogenic mushrooms (or whatever) and stayed in the safety of the clan and pretended to be acquiring the wisdom of cave bears. They weren't stupid, that is, the ones who contributed to the gene pool. By the same token, the clan members probably watched the show, and not being stupid, quietly murmured, "Fucking hell...do we have to put up with this crappola...again?"
 
Last edited:
Stephen, perhaps you should begin by telling us all what you really believe. You know cut the space/time pseudo-science jargon Buzz Lightyear crap and speak to the human identity...

Who do you think are we?

Why do you think we are we here?

What should we do?

How should we do it?

Whence did we come from?

And Where are we going?

These are the basic human existential questions pondered since before we were even homo sapiens and comprehensively answered by every great human mythological tradition on the planet.

My point is that the empirical scientific method - which I highly respect as a research worker myself - actually can not satisfactorily answer a single one of these most basic of all human questions.

True, science has pushed back the frontiers of human ignorance. For instance, evolution satisfactorily answers "where do we come from" to, say, back about 500 million years ago or more, but where the fuck does evolution come from? Science can say nothing very serious about that frontier. Yet there are ways to imagine beyond the frontiers of empiricism, that much is self-evident.

My assertion here is that there exists many ways of seeing and forms of knowledge well beyond the realm we all now gratefully concede to the empirical scientific method.

As an aside, it's interesting that you mentioned the uselessness of hallucinogenic mushrooms or the shamanic tradition since one theory of linguistics is that it was the synesthesia experience that first allowed early hominids to make the psychological connexion between sound and objects and events which resulted in the evolution of syntax (verbs and nouns) and music and onward to poetry and visual representation in cave paintings and carvings...ultimately resulting in our modern consciousness and scientific gestalt which is so far removed from its ancient origins we're totally unaware of its evolution.

Or do you imagine that we sprang fully formed from the head Zeus? That our kind of modern conscious awareness extends back into the last ice age? Shamans were just modern day snake oil salesmen?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology)
 
Last edited:
Stephen, perhaps you should begin by telling us all what you really believe. You know cut the space/time pseudo-science jargon Buzz Lightyear crap and speak to the human identity...

Who do you think are we?

Why do you think we are we here?

What should we do?

How should we do it?

Whence did we come from?

And Where are we going?

These are the basic human existential questions pondered since before we were even homo sapiens and comprehensively answered by every great human mythological tradition on the planet.

My point is that the empirical scientific method - which I highly respect as a research worker myself - actually can not satisfactorily answer a single one of these most basic of all human questions.

True, science has pushed back the frontiers of human ignorance. For instance, evolution satisfactorily answers "where do we come from" to, say, back about 500 million years ago or more, but where the fuck does evolution come from? Science can say nothing very serious about that frontier. Yet there are ways to imagine beyond the frontiers of empiricism, that much is self-evident.

My assertion here is that there exists many ways of seeing and forms of knowledge well beyond the realm we all now gratefully concede to the empirical scientific method.

As an aside, it's interesting that you mentioned the uselessness of hallucinogenic mushrooms or the shamanic tradition since one theory of linguistics is that it was the synesthesia experience that first allowed early hominids to make the psychological connexion between sound and objects and events which resulted in the evolution of syntax (verbs and nouns) and music and onward to poetry and visual representation in cave paintings and carvings...ultimately resulting in our modern consciousness and scientific gestalt which is so far removed from its ancient origins we're totally unaware of its evolution.

Or do you imagine that we sprang fully formed from the head Zeus? That our kind of modern conscious awareness extends back into the last ice age? Shamans were just modern day snake oil salesmen?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology)

Wow!!

Okay...here's what I believe, based on nothing more than my intuition. (Bad start...)

I think we are H. sapiens sapiens and we are here because we evolved from H. sapiens. (Which H. sapiens...I don't have a clue...)

What should we do? Leave a planet that just might support H. sapiens sapiens sapiens, and that would involve not further fucking up what we've already fucked up.

We already know where we came from and it's not ours to posit where we're going. Evolution acts on species, not individual (false) prophets.

Where does evolution come from? It comes from random mutations in the genetic makeup of a species (almost always in isolated groups of a species), that confers some advantage in said species ability to survive and reproduce in the face of environmental change. Unfortunately, most genetic mutations lead to disaster.

While there are all kinds of ways to imagine beyond the frontiers of empiricism, there is only one way that gets you anywhere that is useful to go. And that is observe, hypothesize, test and reason, which...damn...is empiricism. All else leads to faith, dogma and "How dare you question the "Divinely Established Truth", which is the stock in trade of religion, astrology and Deepak Chopra.

I have a sister-in-law who keeps trying to tell me that all belief systems are of equal value. The only way I can see that as being true is to accept that all belief systems have no value. When she insists that astrology has as much to say (of value) about human psychology as mainstream psychology, I cringe. She insists that the position of the planets, with respect to the Zodiac, at the moment of ones birth has an everlasting effect on someone's nature and I'm absurd to think otherwise. When I tell her that the Zodiac has thirteen constellations and not the twelve of astrology, she goes ballistic and tells me that "You're just confusing the issue!"

When I insist on empirical evidence, she just howls, "Of course you want empirical evidence! You're a Taurus! And that proves my point!"

There are forms of knowledge well beyond the scientific method. They're called faiths and they exist because they are based on the assertion that what someone in power said is what you will believe...or else.

It worked for almost all of human history. Then Galileo pointed his telescope to the sky and found that it ain't necessarily so. The powers that were successfully shut him up but the cat was out of the bag. Observation now trumped dogma. ( My sis in law still hasn't figured it out.)

"As an aside, it's interesting that you mentioned the uselessness of hallucinogenic mushrooms or the shamanic tradition since one theory of linguistics is that it was the synesthesia experience that first allowed early hominids to make the psychological connexion between sound and objects and events which resulted in the evolution of syntax (verbs and nouns) and music and onward to poetry and visual representation in cave paintings and carvings...ultimately resulting in our modern consciousness and scientific gestalt which is so far removed from its ancient origins we're totally unaware of its evolution."

Tell it to my sis in law. She might understand. As for those carvings, like the ones of fat and pregnant women, I could say that they are simply graffiti, as in some asshole's taunt to some other guy that '"I fucked your mother!" I doubt it but go ahead and try to prove me wrong. The cave paintings of animals being brought down by hunters just might be the wishful thinking of the hunter's family when the hunter got gored and killed by an oryx. Maybe yes and maybe no. Who the hell knows what was going on in the minds of those cave painters? For all we know, they could have been as grounded in reality as my sis in law, the astrologer. Which is to say, not at all.

My guess is that cave paintings of people killing animals is typical hunter bravado. I seriously doubt that it has anything to do with "the synesthesia experience that first allowed early hominids to make the psychological connexion between sound and objects and events which resulted in the evolution of syntax (verbs and nouns) and music and onward to poetry and visual representation in cave paintings and carvings...ultimately resulting in our modern consciousness and scientific gestalt which is so far removed from its ancient origins we're totally unaware of its evolution."

lustatopia, when you make statements like that, you make me think that Deepak Chopra and my sis in law are in good company.

Shamans were not modern day snake oil salesman. They were ancestral snake oil salesmen. And like Deepak Chopra, they relied on flowery, almost tangible horse shit to disguise the fact that instead of being prophets, they were snake oil salesmen.
 
Last edited:
I don’t think I’ll go into the content of your beliefs, Stephen, but this is what I wonder: Do you ever notice they’re 100% perfectly in consensus with the mainstream authoritative views of your time? Does that, and the zealotry with which you hold them, ever make you suspicious? Like, "wait a minute, if this were the middle ages, would I be a Galileo or a guy with a pitchfork?"

Just curious. ;)
 
I don’t think I’ll go into the content of your beliefs, Stephen, but this is what I wonder: Do you ever notice they’re 100% perfectly in consensus with the mainstream authoritative views of your time? Does that, and the zealotry with which you hold them, ever make you suspicious? Like, "wait a minute, if this were the middle ages, would I be a Galileo or a guy with a pitchfork?"

Just curious. ;)

You have got to be kidding.
 
You have got to be kidding.

Not really. I’m always interested precisely in things people hold to be “obviously true” and why, and I’m always bothered by people who don’t deviate from the consensus in any way. You know, the ones who read only the books you’re supposed to read, hold only the opinions anyone with common sense would have to accept, ask only the questions implied in the offered answers, and so on. That’s not to say I like crackpots because I don’t, but I do like a sense of irony and the ability to imagine things differently.

I really don’t know Stephen enough to say if he’s one of them, so let there be no insult implied. What I did read from his post, however, was a puzzling refusal or inability to as much as acknowledge different levels and angles of description.

Like, a man and a woman meet and have sex. Physicist: Atoms interacting. Biologist: Hormonal activity and physiological changes. Psychologist: she’s looking for a daddy and he’s dealing with a mid-age crisis. Astrologer: her Venus is transiting over his Mars. Poet: here alone there’s an infinity of descriptions. The ‘best’ one? The one that’s most suitable to a task at hand.

If you agree with this pretty non-outrageous point, there’s no reason to scoff at myth as silly crap.
 
Not really. I’m always interested precisely in things people hold to be “obviously true” and why, and I’m always bothered by people who don’t deviate from the consensus in any way. You know, the ones who read only the books you’re supposed to read, hold only the opinions anyone with common sense would have to accept, ask only the questions implied in the offered answers, and so on. That’s not to say I like crackpots because I don’t, but I do like a sense of irony and the ability to imagine things differently.
Do you really think stephen's SIL is some kind of philosophical rebel because she's sucked down every nutty magical thought system she's run across-- and neglected empiricism entirely?

Where are you living that that's so unusual? I want to visit there. I'll tell you though, Irony is not inher vocabulary. You're romancing willful ignorance.

I really don’t know Stephen enough to say if he’s one of them, so let there be no insult implied.
You didn't only imply the insult, you were quite specific with the insult.

What I did read from his post, however, was a puzzling refusal or inability to as much as acknowledge different levels and angles of description.
You should probably re-read it then.
If you agree with this pretty non-outrageous point, there’s no reason to scoff at myth as silly crap.
it would be nice if myth were used for descriptive purposes."her venus transiting his mars" is very sweet. But that's not what an Astrologer actually says, and you know that quite well.

The myths get used for the wrong purpose far too often. His SIL isn't describing things, she's explaining things by means of a tool that is useless for explanation. Like cutting fabric with a pair of pliers.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top