Thoughts on abortion?

Under what circumstances should abortion be regulated?

  • Always -- a woman should never have the right to have an abortion.

    Votes: 4 9.8%
  • In most cases -- abortion should be allowed only when the mother's or fetus' life is in danger (and

    Votes: 7 17.1%
  • Never. A woman should always have the right to control her own body, no matter what.

    Votes: 30 73.2%
  • Unsure/undecided

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    41
JazzManJim said:
OH hell. Get the flame-guns ready, folks.

I'm one of those folks who believes that life begins at conception - that once there's a fetus it's a developmental human being and it has the same right to live and protection from being killed as everyone else does. So I'm opposed to abortion except in cases where someone else is going to die. Then it's a choice between one life and another and only one of them could possibly survive.

Well, Jim and I agree for the most part. I've never understood the distinction between a fetus and a baby. I know it's just me. Blame the catholic upbringing I suppose. Since we all know how I feel about ending any life(Including convicted killers) I have to go with my gut and say that potential people deserve as much consideration as those who lived their life poorly.

And yet, I have to be pro-choice, this is one situation where my head beats my heart. A vancouver doctor who performed abortions summed up what I felt perfectly when he said(and I'm paraphrasing slightly) "Abortions have always happened and, despite the best efforts of some people, most likely will always happen. I've always felt that my responsibility as a doctor was to ensure that this procedure be as safe as it can be. Without doing excess damage to the woman or the fetus"

So, what's better; Legalized, safe abortions or back alley abortions?

Secondly, I have no idea what carrying a child entails so it's hard for me to say "Just put the baby up for adoption". It's not my body that would be put through the obvious strain of carrying a child to term.

So what can I do? Rally like King Canute against the inevitable? Or accept it and try to win people over to my way of thinking without legislation or trying to make abortions harder to get.

As E said when we discussed this question a long, long time ago " I understand where you're coming from, so, next time you get pregnant I will completely support your decision to carry the child to term."

Wiseass.

:)
 
I believe that women have the right to make their own decision on whether or not to have a baby. Regulating abortion won't help any since there is an exception to every rule. (i.e.- abortions should ONLY be allowed when...) and I am firmly against the extreme pro-life people who don't believe abortion should be allowed under any circumstances. Forcing a woman to have a baby is heinous.

I have not been in any position to make a choice and can't honestly say what I would have done had I become pregnant earlier in life. But, it is wonderful to know that I would have been able to make a CHOICE.

Jellybean
 
Weevil said:


Well, Jim and I agree for the most part. I've never understood the distinction between a fetus and a baby. I know it's just me. Blame the catholic upbringing I suppose. Since we all know how I feel about ending any life(Including convicted killers) I have to go with my gut and say that potential people deserve as much consideration as those who lived their life poorly.

And yet, I have to be pro-choice, this is one situation where my head beats my heart. A vancouver doctor who performed abortions summed up what I felt perfectly when he said(and I'm paraphrasing slightly) "Abortions have always happened and, despite the best efforts of some people, most likely will always happen. I've always felt that my responsibility as a doctor was to ensure that this procedure be as safe as it can be. Without doing excess damage to the woman or the fetus"

Having read what you said, and on the strengths of the two paragraphs I quoted up there, let me play Devil's Advocate. :)

What you could as easily say in the second paragraph would go something like, "People are always going to kill other people. We might as well make it as safe to do so as we can. I might as well make sure that a person can kill another person without risking excess damage to themselves".

I know, it doesn't make sense. And it probably made folks mad. That's the wall against which I've run in my thoughts on this. I do believe that a fetus is a human being. I believe that we have enough scientific evidence to say that. I've read lots of studies and gone over scads of research to get there. Now, since I believe that, I can't condone killing that person. The doctor's argument doesn't hold water with me, because I can just as easily read it the way I said it.

But, again, that's me.
 
murderer in the house..

I really don't see it that way. I had an abortion almost ten years ago. It was an informed, educated and very rational decision. Was it a difficult one? You bet your ass, but I knew my decision from very shortly after I found out I was pregnant.

I in no way mean to trivialize this situation. It was difficult and scary. It was also the right choice. I do not regret my decision.

Edited to add: as far as 'there are so many people who want babies who are unable...' Well, I've worked in group homes, foster care, et al...I've encountered thousands of children who would give up anything for a family.

Actually, they had families at one point in their lives. Their families raped them, prostituted them, neglected them, locked them in basements and didn't feed them, burned them and shot their spouses in front of them. What a life!

There are so many other issues here besides when life begins...don't even get me started on the crack addicted mother and her unborn child...
 
Last edited:
SweetBrat73 said:
There is always adoption too. There are so many ppl out there that want babies and can't have them. If you can abort...why can't you give it up to a couple that will love it and give it what you can't???
Brat


There are people out there who want to adopt perfect, healthy, white babies. Anything else stands a strong chance of living in the child welfare system for most of its life.

All I was saying in my post was that birth control isn't perfect. Not by a long shot. Condoms break with frightening regularity, pills stop working, an IUD comes out (and by the way, an IUD does nothing to prevent conception, it simply prevents the fetus from attaching to the uterine wall, so you could get pregnant every single month and your body would just spontaneously abort the fetus before it attached), spermicide causes bad reactions so a sponge and a diaphragm are out... see the problem?

I said it in my first post. Abortion never should have been something that was introduced to politics. It's too personal a decision for that.

I love my two children. I could never explain what they mean to me or what it felt like for them to grow inside me. I believe they were people as soon as I felt 'em moving around in there. I loved them long before I held them the first time. And if one of them gets pregnant someday far in the future and decides to have an abortion, I'll support them and love them and hold them all the way through it.
 
BustyTheClown said:

One of you -- can't remember who -- said that there was probably no one out there who was pro-abortion... I might count myself in that category, as well.

Twas I that said it, and I knew that it might cause some confusion. Let me see if I can state it better. When I said that I don't know anybody that is truly PRO-abortion, I meant in the sense that that nobody is going to be out there campaigning for MORE abortions. I am COMPLETELY opposed to the governmental regulating or banning of abortions, but I would hope that all the alternatives are considered in each case. Once an educated decision is made, I would support it unreservedly.
 
CelestialBody said:
Quick question, are those who are opposed to abortion based on the belief that it is murder also opposed to the death penalty?

No. There's one critical difference for me in that regard. The criminal sentenced to death has committed a heinous crime. The child is completely innocent.
 
JazzManJim said:


Having read what you said, and on the strengths of the two paragraphs I quoted up there, let me play Devil's Advocate. :)

What you could as easily say in the second paragraph would go something like, "People are always going to kill other people. We might as well make it as safe to do so as we can. I might as well make sure that a person can kill another person without risking excess damage to themselves".

Well, Jim, let me flip your example around on you; We've banned murder, haven't we? Do people still murder? Sure do.

So what would you say is the more reasonable way of preventing as many murders that we can?

A slow, long and educational process?

Or passing a law that says "no more killing"

Rome wasn't built in a day.
 
JazzManJim said:


No. There's one critical difference for me in that regard. The criminal sentenced to death has committed a heinous crime. The child is completely innocent.

So, you're not opposed to killing, you just want to pick and choose who you kill?


(I don't think abortion is killing, for the record)
 
alexandraaah said:


So, you're not opposed to killing, you just want to pick and choose who you kill?


(I don't think abortion is killing, for the record)

I know you don't, and that's why there's always going to be a large and unsurpassable gulf between those who think abortions should be allowed and those who don't.

Until there's some conclusive scientific evidence fixing the point at which human life begins, it's always going to be there. Even after, it may not solve it completely, but it'll seal things for the vast majority, IMO.

As far as the death penalty goes, I believe that there are crimes a person may commit that obligates a society to claim that life as forfeit. I also believe that sometimes it's necessary to kill, but that necessity should only occur in the most extreme or unavoidable circumstances. I believe that only rarely do baby humans cause those circumstances.

But, like I said at the beginning of this post, if you don't believe that a fetus is a human being, then you're not going to buy my opinion.
 
Weevil said:


Well, Jim, let me flip your example around on you; We've banned murder, haven't we? Do people still murder? Sure do.

So what would you say is the more reasonable way of preventing as many murders that we can?

A slow, long and educational process?

Or passing a law that says "no more killing"

I don't believe it's an "either-or" proposition.

But, according to the Guttmacher Institute (a special research affiliate of Planned Parenthood) the number of abortions have increased from a bit over 774,000 in 1973 to nearly 1,366, 000 in 1996. That number dipped below 1,500,000 in 10 of the 26 years and reached a high of over 1,600,000 in 1990.

That's not prevention. I'm not saying it's encouragement either, but it's certainly clear that allowing abortions doesn't discourage them.

I think that vigorous education is called for, but that doesn't change my stance on the issue itself.
 
JazzManJim said:


I don't believe it's an "either-or" proposition.

But, according to the Guttmacher Institute (a special research affiliate of Planned Parenthood) the number of abortions have increased from a bit over 774,000 in 1973 to nearly 1,366, 000 in 1996. That number dipped below 1,500,000 in 10 of the 26 years and reached a high of over 1,600,000 in 1990.

That's not prevention. I'm not saying it's encouragement either, but it's certainly clear that allowing abortions doesn't discourage them.

I think that vigorous education is called for, but that doesn't change my stance on the issue itself.

See, I do think it's an either/or issue. I don't think there will ever be another time when a secular western government will have the authority to ban abortion.

And as to the numbers, I think that's because idiots like Pat Robertson are so caught up in playing the boogeyman and talking about "banning" abortion that they aren't focusing their efforts in the right area.

But, Bill, Ireland's abortion numbers are shooting through the roof, despite it being illegal. So, making it legal with out education doesn't work? Well neither does making it illegal without education.
 
Weevil said:
So, making it legal with out education doesn't work? Well neither does making it illegal without education.

So we're agreed that education is critical. Let's do that. But it still leaves the initial debate raging on.

Like I said, I doubt seriously that it's going to be solved in a lot of folks' mind until there's a conclusive finding on the beginning point of life.
 
JazzManJim said:


I don't believe it's an "either-or" proposition.

But, according to the Guttmacher Institute (a special research affiliate of Planned Parenthood) the number of abortions have increased from a bit over 774,000 in 1973 to nearly 1,366, 000 in 1996. That number dipped below 1,500,000 in 10 of the 26 years and reached a high of over 1,600,000 in 1990.

That's not prevention. I'm not saying it's encouragement either, but it's certainly clear that allowing abortions doesn't discourage them.

I think that vigorous education is called for, but that doesn't change my stance on the issue itself.

Jim hun, you also have to take into account that abortions became legal in 1973 with Roe v Wade. Of course numbers are going to rise, just from the basic fact that they became more trackable then, that physicians could do them without being prosecuted, etc. They weren't just guesstimating numbers of those back alley and 'secret clinic' butcher scenes. These kind of stats are always hard to quantify.

I think it was HBO, that made a movie a few years back now called If These Walls Could Talk. It portrayed the lives of 3 women, at different political times in the abortion debate. It delved into the background of how they found themselves pregnant, what their options were, what they went through, and the final outcome. I thought it was a pretty damn good movie.

I think I'd have to chip in my vote with the majority that's responded here. I am not "pro-abortion". I would be happy as all get-out if another one never had to be performed again. BUT, I don't think the government should be regulating it. Especially not when it's driven by mostly religious reasons.

As far as the prevention issue...there are still hundreds of thousands of people out there who's health insurance plans DON'T cover contraception as part of the medication plan (of course most of them jumped on the bandwagon the moment Viagra hit the market...hrm). I think this is abhorrent. There are so many boiling issues that contribute to the number of unwanted pregnancies. This is one of those things that I truly believe if both sides (meaning 'pro life' vs 'pro choice') would combine their money, effort, and voice to good PREVENTION EDUCATION...we would have much less of an 'abortion issue' to deal with.

Yeah yeah, I know it's a pipe dream, but I still have it.

I have to admit, I thought I'd find flameage here, especially this topic. I like the civil conversation that's going on here :)

*hugs*
mae
 
pagancowgirl said:

(and by the way, an IUD does nothing to prevent conception, it simply prevents the fetus from attaching to the uterine wall, so you could get pregnant every single month and your body would just spontaneously abort the fetus before it attached), spermicide causes bad reactions so a sponge and a diaphragm are out... see the problem?

I know this is a lil off the subject...but this part tickled a bit in my brain and I wanted to respond, on a 'sharing education' level. I got this information at the ARHP (Association of Reproductive Health Professionals) national conference last December...that research (I looked for the actual article on it I got, but didn't find it in my various chaotic piles around my house!) supports the notion that IUD's don't work by preventing implantation of an already conceived zygote in the uterine wall. That there is actually a reaction that occurs in the woman's body that prevents conception. I had learned in my old sex-ed classes and then in my healthcare schooling the information PCG shared above. I was suprised to hear the shift of thinking...it makes me think sometimes, and realize how much of health care that we don't really understand why it works, yet we prescribe/do it anyway? Bodies are such complex things!

My whole intent on sharing that tidbit is with the idea that some people reading might now personally be able to look at it as a possible non-hormonal (if you get the copper IUD) contraception option. I know several women who feel as Jim does, that life begins at conception, and had ruled out the IUD as an option because of that. And remember, IUD's should only be used in a monogamous relationship...as it doesn't prevent against STD transmission, and can increase the risk of PID and the like if you do engage in more "high risk" behaviours regarding intercourse and partners!

*This Public Health Lit Annoucement has been brought to you by the Mae Clinic! Not to be confused with the internationally famous Mayo Clinic....hehe*

Bah, I feel like I'm back at work again or something! :)

*hugs*
mae
 
CelestialBody said:
By the way, your high in 1990? that implies that a new high has not been set every year, the number of abortions are falling. Between 1990 and 2000, in the state of Michigan alone, the number fell from 36,183 to 26,807.

I have no problem with that, and this dovetails much into what Mae said earlier. It's true that abortions prior to Roe v Wade were harder to track, but they were tracked by the US Bureau of Vital Statistics. I happened across some stuff in my readings in the past that placed the number of abortions in 1972 somewhere around 100,000 according to a study done at Creighton University.

That's a hell of an increase. Even accounting for underreporting, that's a lot.

All I've been saying is that to say that removing the law against abortions caused less of them is inaccurate. I'm still very much in favor of reproductive education, birth control, teaching abstinence along with everything else. I just see the number you quoted and it staggers me.
 
Again, wow. I too am still impressed by the civility being shown here... I hope it stays this way -- this is truly engaging.

Just to toss a couple things into the mix, as I am still young and not up to date with the more detailed analyses here, lol... I agree, Jim, that the abortion debate won't even begin to calm down until the whole question of "When does personhood begin?" thing dies down. I just want to clarify one thing, though -- I know that fetuses are human beings, like you've said. But I'd like to make the distinction between humang beings and people. It doesn't seem important at first, but think about it -- do you consider a fetus a person in the way you consider the fetus' mother, for example? Is the fetus a fully functioning member of society with moral rights? I won't answer these questions (mostly because they can't really be answered without dissention), I'll just throw them out there for you to chew on.

I'm sorry, I'm an assmaster -- I've forgotten who said about not really knowing about abortion until you feel the presence of a baby in your body... I totally heard you on that. I think I'm a bit of a hypocrite sometimes -- which irks me, but I'm young and still learning -- in that I say that men have no right to tell women what to do with their bodies... but I guess the same could go for women who've never been pregnant? I kicked myself in the ass when I read what you wrote. Thank you for that -- I totally dig where you're coming from, even if I can't identify.

Also, I wanted to comment on the whole adoption thing... I am adopted, so I know what the whole people wanting to adopt babies thing is like. I was adopted at almost 3 years old, so it's not bad, but I've met some kids that were in their mid- to late-teens in foster homes... and boy were they fucked up. I feel such empathy for those kids because they just aren't wanted by adoptive couples. It enrages me that people go off about how wonderful a couple are for waiting five "agonizing" years to adopt a gorgeous little white baby girl when there were plenty of other children of all ages, races, etc., readily available and eager to get a family from the get-go. People can be so two-faced sometimes. :(
 
life

The essential question here is when does human life begin? And as I see it, there are two possible answers. The first is at fertilization. At that moment we have a distinct living being which, is unique and at the most basic, genetic level, inarguably homo sapien.

Alternatively, we can argue that being a unique homo sapien being doesn't make one human. And that, of course, leads inevitably to all the great horrors of history.

We can say that one must be viable - whatever that means - and that opens the door to both infanticide and involuntary euthanasia. And of course there are the blacks/jews/irish/american infidels/"insert your least favorite minority here". They may be homo sapien, you can't argue with the science, but they're obviously not human.

Science tells us that we're all homo sapiens from the moment of conception. I believe all homo sapiens are human. Any of you may believe differently. But, when you answer that question, what makes us human?, think on your faults and ask yourself if you make the grade.
 
Weird Harold said:
Regulation (legislation) of abortions falls into the class of "NUNYA" as in "nunya damn bidness." It is not something that government has any business legislating.

BTW, this does not say that abortion is either good or bad -- only that legislating it is an intrusion into a private decision between the patient and her doctor where government has no business prying.

I agree 100%. Abortion is, to a large degree, a moral & individual choice. There are many doctors who believe abortion is a viable alternative; there are many others who don't. Whether you consider the fetus to be a person, with the rights that people have, is a personal decision that you and you alone make. For some, this decision has religious basis. For other's it does not. Either way, the government has no right to make that decision for you.

For the record, I think that adults should have the right to not wear seat belts or helmets, if they so choose. I also think adults should have the right to smoke tobacco or marijuana (even though I do neither), to drink, to eat fatty foods, to not exercise. So long as you don't infringe on my liberty, knock yourself out. Yes, all these things have potentially harmful effects. Yes, abortions harm not only the fetus but the mother. But part of being truly free & independent is making our own choices and taking responsibility for those choices. I don't think that a government "mothering" us makes us more enlightened. In fact, I think a government that enforces morality is an evil, evil thing.
 
Tough Q. I would never leave a girl in a possition where she'd have to make that choice but... Damn it to hell she still has the right to chose it if somebody else dumps her there...

I don't think abortion is nice or good or something you should do but sigh it needs to be available, confidential and preferably no Q. asked... simply because of the situations where it really is necisary...

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Back
Top