Thoughts on suicide

BustyTheClown said:
What do you think?

I think you come up with the most serious, intellectually challenging, difficult-to-answer questions in Lit. But I'll give this one a shot.

People who commit suicide find no exit from the life they live. Sometimes they can't see the way out, sometimes there is no way out. Sometimes the trigger is very blunt (such as was the case with a friend who killed himself because he had run away from an abusive home and had no place to live) and sometimes the trigger is very minute (a classmate committed suicide because his girlfriend broke up with him; the "straw that broke the camel's back", so to speak).

In some cases (and this is EXTREMELY rare) the world is a better place when a person commits suicide. Take, for example, the four airliners that were destroyed on September 11. Many saw it as 3000 innocent lives lost; I saw it not only as that, but also 15 less terrorists in the world.

My point is that I can see both sides of this coin. There are repercussions for every action that a person makes in this world. Watch the movie "It's a Wonderful Life". Rewind. Watch it again. Think about it.
 
OK let me throw this into the mix. There are a lot of manic depressive or bipolar people in the world. Unfortunately they are misdiagnosed for years because most medical professionals do not want to give a person that diagnosis until their late 20's. It is estimated that half of all manic depressives commit suicide before they are properly diagnosed and put on mood stabilizers.

These people have a chemical inbalance in their brains that they can no more control than a diabetic or anyone with any other disease can control. Are we going to call these people cowards because, after what is usually years of suffering, a chemical imbalance tells them to take their lives.

There is no way to tell what another human being is going through or what may or may not be wrong with them. People that commit suicide out of hopelessness and despair have my sympathy and compassion as do those they leave behind.
 
I don't think suicide is as much a cowardly act as it is a stupid one. Maybe I am stupid for thinking that but thats how I feel about it. Nothing in life is bad enough to kill yourself over... being abused, molested, homeless, the death of a loved one, breaking up with your S/O, alcohol/drug abuse, being crippled... are not reasons to end your life. I see those as reasons to keep on living, getting over things like those are what makes us human. Even mental problems can be overcome, but in the most part people are afraid to admit their weakness and pain thinking if they kill themselves they wont have to face people knowing what they were going through. My opinion may be crude but it is my opinion.
 
I think that you all have missed an important point. While all the talk of deppresion, etc. is certainly true. The fact of the matter is is that many suicide are acutally "murder by proxy" issues.

It is a method that they use to transfer their pain, guilt, anger to those that they feel have wronged them. It is a way that the person, in their weakness, can obtain revenge.

There are also 'control' and 'attention' issues associated with suicides. Particularly with those that make less than 'best effort' attempts.

The issues and reasons are complex, but it has always amazed me how petty most of the reasons were in the end.

Ishmael
 
Mental illness can be overcome yes. But have you ever tried to get help for a mental illness in the US. If you have insurance the hospital will keep you as long as the insurance will pay. If the insurance runs out and you are still suicidal and they have not found the right meds you are still released. Then you had better have an awesome perscription plan even if you are stable on meds when you are released. The average psych drugs for a manic depressive usually run from $200 to $500 a month.

If you don't have insurance but you know you are suicidal and need help you can call a hotline. But until you attempt suicide you will not be hospitalized unless of course you hurt someone else. If you attempt suicide or hurt someone else you will be taken to an emergency facility. Someone that takes enough of an overdose to wind up in a Cardiac Care Unit for 3 days will generally be released after the mandatory 3 day stay. This is especially true if it is near the weekend since they have so many incoming patients then. When released they will get to go to a doctor once every 6 weeks who will talk to them for 15 minutes and write a perscription. Even if they need therapy they are only allowed 3 half hour sessions per outpatient stay!! So unless they attempt suicide or hurt someone again there is no therapy.

Everyone is quick to say go get help. They have options. They can work through this. Have you ever tried getting that help yourself or for someone else that needed it? For a private hospital if you do not have insurance most take a $50,000 check up front or you have to sign a lean on your home stating you will forfeit it if the bill is not paid. A one month stay in a private facility can run around $150,000.

Everyone is so quick to judge. To say there are options and just get help. The problem is that help is not available to everyone. Now it is worse since most insurance plans will only cover 50% of mental health expenses if they cover them at all. Those plans usually have a $100,000 to $150,000 cap on them. How many people do you know that have $75,000 laying around and can pay a couple of hundred for medication a month?
 
Ishmael:

We are not necessarily discussing those who tried to commit suicide and didn't, we are discussing those who did.

Perhaps, murder by proxy....transference of negative feelings....depression or other clinical disorder would all tie into that. The reasons may seem "petty", but don't feel "petty" to the person who is struggling.

For those who can't understand why someone would consider suicide, good for you. It is apparent that you don't suffer from mental health issues. I am sincere in this statement.

For those who do suffer wiht these issues, offering my empathy. Seek or continue treatment and support from friends.
 
MissTaken said:
Ishmael:

We are not necessarily discussing those who tried to commit suicide and didn't, we are discussing those who did.

Understood, but attempts are generally precursors. Correct me if I'm wrong, and I know you will :D , but I once read that 'attempts' lead to other attempts and that if that person does happen to be successful it was usually by mistake.

MissTaken said:
Perhaps, murder by proxy....transference of negative feelings....depression or other clinical disorder would all tie into that. The reasons may seem "petty", but don't feel "petty" to the person who is struggling.

100% agreement here, if their mental faculties were such that they could analyze the pettiness of the act, they would have never attempted it.

Ishmael
 
OK, my thought on this subject.

I think that those who commit suicide are in dire need of mental help and just plain haven't been able to voice that need. I also, however, get angry with those who do it for making their loved ones find them in that fashion.

My sister's husband killed himself a couple years back. They were seperated and in proces sof divorcing. He was trying to get her back. She wasn't gonna have it. He called her one night at about 1130 and told her all the papers she needed were on the table. Then with her still on the phone, he p[ulled the trigger and blew a hole in his chest witha shotgun.

His parents were the first ones to find him, laying in a pool of blood in his front yard, still breathing slightly, but pretty much too far gone. By the time the first responders got there, it was too late.

He left behind 3 children who are still very confused over it.

Was it selfish? Yes, in a way I think it was. Was it cowardly? Possibly. I think it was his final cry for attention to get my sister back. He blew it by being a jerk for too many years. His reason behind his behavior was alcohol/drug addiction and depression. He wasn't a good husband. He wasn't a very god father. He was a prick, but he was still part of the family. Did it hurt when I heard? Yeah, it did. Do I miss him? No. I don't miss the man he'd become.

I do, however, ache for my sister's children who miss their dad so much. I ache for 2 little boys and a little girl growing up and him not being a part of their lives.

I don't know if these things answer any questions, but I do know one thing. Selfish or not, corawrdly or not, whatever hurt is inside a person to make them do it...is nothing compared to the hurt of those they leave behind when they sucede.
 
consider this...

Ishmael said:


Understood, but attempts are generally precursors. Correct me if I'm wrong, and I know you will :D , but I once read that 'attempts' lead to other attempts and that if that person does happen to be successful it was usually by mistake.



100% agreement here, if their mental faculties were such that they could analyze the pettiness of the act, they would have never attempted it.

Ishmael
perhaps the repeated attempts are hopes for mistakes. often people die in what is not even an attempt, but a "game" they play with themselves in which they see how close they can come.
 
Re: One person at a tim

LukkyKnight said:
Once, a long time ago now, I reached out to a person teetering on the edge of taking their own life. I didn't realize the immediacy of the danger, frankly, I didn't see the gun, or know it was loaded... I am glad instinct told me to stay until I sensed a turn-around.


I don't hear from my friend much anymore, but the light still burns, it did not go out, and others benefit from the continuation of that presence.

I did not see this last night. I had no idea it was here. I seem to recall you telling me about this. I have wondered since then if the person mentioned wishes they had not of taken your outstretched hand? *shrug* Some people live in darkness above the earth as well as below it. I hope that you never find that darkness. :rose:
 
Wishes, Sempre?

At any given time each of us has thoughts of what might have been, and may even wish things had gone differently. When we are low, we wish for endings.

Each life is a gift, too precious to let go of. It is a long chain, stretching back beyond the mists of history. Each life in the here and now touches others. Who can say what might have gone differently had I not done what I did?

Perhaps a child might not have been born to bring hope and joy to his parents and their friends and family...

Perhaps the light that was not allowed to go out has lent strength to others, helping in ways they could not imagine would happen...

Perhaps the best is yet to come...



Is it callous not to grant a wish to give up? Perhaps so. If so, I am a hard man, for I'd do it again, and again. The world is the people, and I act to preserve them when and as I can.
 
Back
Top