Title IX?

KillerMuffin

Seraphically Disinclined
Joined
Jul 29, 2000
Posts
25,603
Link: http://slate.msn.com/?id=2071832

Cut'n Paste stuff:

Hardly Sporting
Don't gut Title IX until you know what it does.
By Lynn Sanders
Posted Tuesday, October 1, 2002, at 1:09 PM PT


The girls' field-hockey team in Charles McGrath's town has a new hazing ritual featuring forced simulated oral sex with bananas. Rooting around for the cause of this particular element of the decline of Western civilization, McGrath—writing recently in New York Times Magazine—came up with a sure-fire suspect: Title IX. In his story, McGrath misleadingly described Title IX as "the landmark 1972 law that required universities and colleges to grant equal financing and resources to male and female athletics."


Like almost everyone else, McGrath is wrong about Title IX, because the law isn't limited to gender equity in sports. To be sure, something approaching hysteria about the impact it would have on sports did start almost immediately after Nixon signed the law in 1972, with members of Congress getting their tightie-whities in a bunch about what would happen to football if school athletic budgets had to be shared with girls. But it wasn't until 1975 that the then-Department of Health, Education, and Welfare issued regulations clarifying that Title IX would also prohibit sex discrimination in athletics. Parity in sports was an afterthought. So, before conservatives call for Title IX's demise and liberals prepare to ward off their attacks, we need to get a grip on what the law does and doesn't do.

Title IX outlawed sex discrimination in all areas of education. The statute reads: "No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance." In non-legalese, this means schools can't discriminate on the basis of sex in student admissions, scholarships, recruitment, courses, or any aspect of employment, as well as in providing opportunities for boys and girls to participate in sports.

Since Title IX became law in 1972, girls cannot be discouraged from taking science classes or prevented from joining the math club. Boys may sign up for cooking classes. Law schools and medical schools were forced to stop using quotas limiting the number of women students and could no longer refuse to admit women by claiming they'd get pregnant and waste their education—routine practices before the law's implementation. Title IX litigation has addressed fairness in testing and scholarships, employment discrimination against teachers, bias against pregnant students, and sexual harassment in elementary schools.

<snip> I suggest a click to read the rest. It's an interesting editorial.




What do you think? Is it discrimination? Does it make things fair? Right or Wrong? Why do you think what you do about Title IX?
 
I support Title IX. I think it's safe, nobody is going to mess with what white women want in this country :cool:
 
Last edited:
I have no problems with Title IX in intent or purpose. I have a few minor qualms with some of the accounting that the rules created.

The "biggie" out of the entire thing for me (and it's pretty darn minor in the overall realm of things) is that all money decisions are based entirely on student population figures.

Just to pick on sports programs, If 54% of a school's students are female then the "women's sports" programs are supposed to get 54% of all athletic department funds under the existing rules.

Why isn't the funding distributed based on the percentage of students that are actually interested in PARTICIPATING in those programs instead of just the number of warm bodies in the student population? How does the cost of equipping the actual athletes come into play? (Answer: it doesn't.)

Why aren't the schools required to develop a massive list of all of the possible athletic programs and survey every single freshman for their INTEREST and base funding on the interest level within their student population? That seems to be a more equitable system that would actually provide the "equeal opportunity" Title IX was intended to produce.
 
I have no problem with Title IX or its intent. I do have a problem with male athletic programs being cut at post high school institution. Unfortunately the statistics are not good for the guys. When high school is added the male programs actually increased, but look at all sides of the equation.
 
hmmm...

I wonder if this would all matter if the U.S. wasn't such a sports driven society. Because in a way, would there be any reason to strive for equality in sports if it wasn't so prominent?
 
Back
Top