War Crimes

takingchances42 said:


Let's look at a recent example. The "attack" by US war planes in Afghanistan on a wedding party.

A bad thing, no doubt about it. But was it a mistake, let alone a crime?

The US planes were fired upon. If a soldier is attacked, then he has the right to return fire. With devastating force if it is available. No one who is not in that position should have the right to pass judgment on that.

But, if the ICC did have jurisdiction... there is a good chance that the US soldiers involved might have been indicted. On criminal grounds. For placing themselves in harm's way, at the direction of their own government, then responding to the attack.

The administration of justice is a fundamentally political process, particularly at the international level. I do believe in truth and justice. I don't believe in asking people to serve their country, then serving them up as victims to the rest of the international community, if it is judged politically expedient to do so.

I see what you mean and yes I agree with that example,also with the rest of your post.
from that viewpoint I think it is good that the US has asked for and gotten a one (or two,not sure) year leeway in joining the ICC.
 
Texan said:


nope darlin..... you got the order wrong.... I posted something completely unrelated to anything you posted then you came back with your attack.

not that anyone cares, but the thread is a short one about Canadians thinking the U.S. is to blame for 9/11....

PARTIALLY to blame due to our Middle East policies.

And if you don't think the CIA Training Bin Laden had something to do with it, you're out of your mind.
 
Evidence will come forward soon that Bin Laden is dead, will take a couple more months.

Several neighbors were trained by the CIA and not one of them has attacked a building or any "innocent" people.
 
Pagliacci said:


I see what you mean and yes I agree with that example,also with the rest of your post.
from that viewpoint I think it is good that the US has asked for and gotten a one (or two,not sure) year leeway in joining the ICC.

The rules for bringing evidence and building a case are much different from ours, much easier with much less burden of proof. This means that anyone can bring a case against anyone. There's little "due process" protection either. The ICC doesn't have our constitutional protection of "innocent until proven guilty either". Because the processes are so loose, it can be easily used as a political tool (which, I might add, is how courts are often used in many other parts of the world).

Recently, one of the European governments tried to hold Henry Kissinger for "war crimes". Several people on lit had told me that he should have been detained and tried for his crimes. The people that represent the ICC want to hold Henry Kissinger, and yet they smile and send Robert Mugabe home with flowers and good cheer. Mugabe is starving and killing his political opposition now and arresting white farmers for the crime of being white. He's also screwed his nation so that they've gone from a net exporter of food to a country that needs 200,000 tonnes of grain to prevent widespread starvation. (he's taken the food, given it to supports and is still starving his opponents).

At the summit last week in Johannesburg, Mugabe was praised and recieved rousing cheers, Colin Powell was hazed. If we were part of the ICC, the "world" might have detained Mr. Powell for his positions on conflict. The UK recognizes Mugabe's tyranny, but they are almost as despised as the USA is.

We cannot be dragged into this thing.
 
Spinaroonie said:


PARTIALLY to blame due to our Middle East policies.

And if you don't think the CIA Training Bin Laden had something to do with it, you're out of your mind.
The Middle East has been fucked up for a long time., and will continue to be fucked up for the rest of my life and yours. Our policys have nothing to do with the hatred that comes from these fundamentialists towards America and the West in general.Perhaps, since you seem to have all the answers pertaining to Americas foreign policy failures, you should apply for Colin Powells job. As rumor has it, that, hes resigning if Bush is reelected.
 
Santino51 said:


What are we doing in Afghanistan??? It's almost 9/11 again, does that jog your memory??

And it's still not over...

al Qaida is alive and kicking...

So Afghanistan was really a waste of time...oh sorry, no it wasn't, women got their rights back again, I think...

ppman
 
p_p_man said:


And it's still not over...

al Qaida is alive and kicking...

So Afghanistan was really a waste of time...oh sorry, no it wasn't, women got their rights back again, I think...

ppman


Your right, it's not over and the al qaeda is still alive and kicking. That is why we must continue to fight. We have to find and destroy this fanatics wherever they live. Unfortunately, this will take a long time and brave men will die to protect us and you.

God Bless America --
 
Back
Top