Pagliacci
Crane Style
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2002
- Posts
- 2,189
takingchances42 said:
Let's look at a recent example. The "attack" by US war planes in Afghanistan on a wedding party.
A bad thing, no doubt about it. But was it a mistake, let alone a crime?
The US planes were fired upon. If a soldier is attacked, then he has the right to return fire. With devastating force if it is available. No one who is not in that position should have the right to pass judgment on that.
But, if the ICC did have jurisdiction... there is a good chance that the US soldiers involved might have been indicted. On criminal grounds. For placing themselves in harm's way, at the direction of their own government, then responding to the attack.
The administration of justice is a fundamentally political process, particularly at the international level. I do believe in truth and justice. I don't believe in asking people to serve their country, then serving them up as victims to the rest of the international community, if it is judged politically expedient to do so.
I see what you mean and yes I agree with that example,also with the rest of your post.
from that viewpoint I think it is good that the US has asked for and gotten a one (or two,not sure) year leeway in joining the ICC.