What Tags Do You Prioritize?

Zeebop

Virgin
Joined
Jun 26, 2025
Posts
4
Given that there are a limited number of tags a given story/chapter can have, and a lot of potential content that can be included, how do you prioritize which tags to place on a given story/chapter? Like, would you emphasize the most common elements (e.g. blowjobs, oral sex, etc.), or the weirdest specific acts (e.g. snowballing, piss drinking, etc.) even if they don't feature extensively, or specific niche interests (i.e., should a fantasy story that include tags for common fantasy races like elves, orcs, hobbits, etc.)?

I don't think there's a right or wrong answer, but I'm curious what folks gravitate towards in tagging their own stories.
 
I prioritize the elements that are essential to my own enjoyment. It's a mix of common and niche. I want to attract like minded people. I don't think about warning people with tags. But I think my list serves that purpose too.
 
I find tags to be a little funny, because I see them as having kind of a double purpose. One is to tell readers what sort of genre/content your story has. The other is for the sex. And I think a decent erotica story can serve double-duty as a solid character-driven read and, you know, hot.

So on the one hand I'll include things like ghosts/possession/haunted house (i.e. for my Halloween story in particular). But then on the other I know people are looking for certain types of... ahem... payoffs, so maybe I'll include tags oriented that way. And I feel a bit like a pop-up ad shouting Hey step right up this story has blowjobs!!

(And I'm seeing now that I didn't include many of the latter variety tags in said Halloween story, which could perhaps have contributed to its relatively low engagement numbers. Maybe.)
 
As I wrote T/I stories I add a tag if there are bisexuality, gay, domination or BDSM. These with the normat family member tags.
Edit: I forgot crossdressing and feminization which are just emerging in my series.
 
My thoughts on tags:

1. use all 10 of them
2. Make sure they accurately describe your story
3. use common, popular tags that readers are actually going to search for
4. Use titillating words when you can
5. Focus on what is most erotically appealing in your story in choosing a tag
6. Don't waste tags on esoteric terms that you might think make your story unique but that no potential reader will actually ever search for or care about
7. Before choosing tags, go to the tag page and search for the most commonly used tags in the right category
8. Find similar, popular stories you like and check out their tags. If you use similar tags there's a greater chance your story will show up on those stories' similar stories lists.
 
I have a particular formula for my stories,* but that's because I write niche, and I want people within that niche when they're searching for stories to find mine.

I think including the very very popular ones, like most sex acts, isn't all too helpful for searching. I don't know how many people are searching for tags just for "cowgirl," or "missionary," or "doggystyle." But the tags serve dual purpose: helping people find your stories, and advertising what elements are in your story. So I'm not adverse to including sex act tags if I run out of the more helpful tags for people searching. They can also serve as content warnings, so I think any story that has noncon in it should have at least one tag so the few people who do check tags before reading a story (insert gripe about how tags should be visible without having to click anything once you're in a story here) to let them know (though author's note is better, since that will always show up at the start if you put it there).

I agree with most of @SimonDoom's points. I'd add if you're writing more niche, kink, or fetish content in a story, as long as it features semi-prominently, that's an absolute must on your tag list, even if they aren't common tags. But do some due diligence in searching for variations on those tags to see which ones have the most use, so you have a higher likelihood of people finding them.

* Anthro/monster girl/monster, broad group of main non-human characters (furry, scalie, avian), species (gecko, cuttlefish, maned wolf, jerboa), then the rest is the other major kinks (consentacles, d/s, femdom, size difference, breeding), and if I run out, then I'll include the sex acts that are most prevalent and most likely to catch reader attention, since those ones I view more as for people who are looking through story lists, not people who are searching for those tags specifically.
 
I agree with most of @SimonDoom's points. I'd add if you're writing more niche, kink, or fetish content in a story, as long as it features semi-prominently, that's an absolute must on your tag list, even if they aren't common tags. But do some due diligence in searching for variations on those tags to see which ones have the most use, so you have a higher likelihood of people finding them.

* Anthro/monster girl/monster, broad group of main non-human characters (furry, scalie, avian), species (gecko, cuttlefish, maned wolf, jerboa), then the rest is the other major kinks (consentacles, d/s, femdom, size difference, breeding), and if I run out, then I'll include the sex acts that are most prevalent and most likely to catch reader attention, since those ones I view more as for people who are looking through story lists, not people who are searching for those tags specifically.

I completely agree with using unusual tags that specifically target the special kink of a story with an unusual kink. In a niche story, you're not looking for a big readership; you're looking for the right readership that's looking for the niche.

But sometimes people insert tags that are particular to some feature of a story without considering whether the tag has anything kinky about it or is ever likely to be the subject of a search. Like using "Des Moines" as a tag just because the story is set in Des Moines. I have seen tags like that. That, to me, seems like a waste of a tag.
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there. I mean, what possible use can they have in a normal story? What do you do, add "boy", "girl", "have sex", "his place"? If there's something kinky in it, do you have to tag "weeing" if the story name is "Sabrina Wees in Hortense's Mouth"?

I can't imagine looking for stories based on tags, but just for a moment suppose I was really, really keen on hand jobs or hand-jobs or handjobs and wanted to find . . . so I look for the tag "handjob" and don't find the ones tagged "handjobs" or . . .

Footnote. Not quite sure what a hand(-)job is, term used for illustrative purposes only.
 
I completely agree with using unusual tags that specifically target the special kink of a story with an unusual kink. In a niche story, you're not looking for a big readership; you're looking for the right readership that's looking for the niche.

But sometimes people insert tags that are particular to some feature of a story without considering whether the tag has anything kinky about it or is ever likely to be the subject of a search. Like using "Des Moines" as a tag just because the story is set in Des Moines. I have seen tags like that. That, to me, seems like a waste of a tag.
To be fair, I'm not putting in "tamandua" on the off chance someone is looking for a tamandua story, but hey, if someone is... I got you, boo 😁 That's more for the people who do look at tags and, given a lot of them are probably anthro readers, want to know what they're getting. But for the most part, these more niche groups tend to find stories through search, because just going through non-human is a slog, and most of them aren't the specific type of non-human you want; same for SF&F, it's such a wide bucket that you're honestly better off doing tag searches than checking out the whole list of stories in some cases.

Place names and people names are the ones that confound me the most. Like "Rachel" as a tag. Who's looking up first names, or cares? "Man, I really need a story that has a Bobby in it right now..." Or who's really looking for stories set in "Toledo"?

Some people also do shitpost tags, which, I guess if you have a big enough audience or don't care (seems to be the two use cases most common, that, and AO3 people), that's fine as long as you have enough other tags for people to find.
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there. I mean, what possible use can they have in a normal story? What do you do, add "boy", "girl", "have sex", "his place"? If there's something kinky in it, do you have to tag "weeing" if the story name is "Sabrina Wees in Hortense's Mouth"?

I can't imagine looking for stories based on tags, but just for a moment suppose I was really, really keen on hand jobs or hand-jobs or handjobs and wanted to find . . . so I look for the tag "handjob" and don't find the ones tagged "handjobs" or . . .
I had a very long response to this, but it was shocked and hurt, and a bit ungenerous toward you if I'm being honest, so instead, I'm writing this.

I have a hard time believing you can't see the benefit of tags to non-cisthet people or those of us with non-traditional kinks and fetishes, and that you truly would advocate for getting rid of tags which would hinder people like me, who likes queer content and has inclinations toward stories that are seen as deviant by a lot of people, from finding the content I want to find. I am similarly doubtful that you are incapable of seeing how this is helpful to those who have trouble finding the stories we like by wading through a sea of things we aren't interested in, or that you would advocate for disenfranchisement of us queer and/or fetishistic folk because tags aren't useful for vanilla cishet stories.

I don't wish to lambast you as a person. I think this is more a case of a position that was poorly thought out, and not indicative of who you are, which is kind, intelligent, tolerant, and a fun person that I really like and whose opinions I usually value quite highly.

So, as your friend, I would invite you to give this a little more thought, or explain it better, because in my opinion it does not come off well.

You know, perhaps I'm misinterpreting it, which is certainly possible, it's something that happens a lot to me, and maybe I look like a butthurt lunatic snowflake to everyone for saying this, which in most cases means I would keep my snout shut because I dislike causing trouble, or being a hassle, or bringing down the mood, or making myself look like a genuine idiot, or any confrontation really, I'm very confrontation averse. But I feel this is important, and I don't want to remain quiet on the off-chance that I'm not the only one. And if I am the only one... I'm really sorry for being an oversensitive lunatic, everyone, and feel free to totally disregard and roll your eyes at the dumb bird.
 
Last edited:
I put all the tags in the beginning of the story text as well as in the tags section--usually more in fact, because there is no limit that way. The Plow has 25 tags in the body of the story. I would be interested to know though who actually stumbles on my stories based on the tags versus the body text.

As for what goes specifically in the tags section, I try to hone in on the ten broadest themes without getting super granular with them either. In a few cases I have put several similar tags together if it's a major kink that features prominently in the story (ahem) and I want the reader to have the highest probability of finding it if they type one of those variations. Scale Servicing lists "foot fetish," "foot worship," and "footjob" as tags.

Though, I have no actual data to back up whether this approach makes sense or helps interested readers find the piece. It's just an intuitive guess as to what is likely to work best. I have never had any feedback telling me they wish I did something differently with the tags so take that for what it's worth. 😅
 
I'm gonna say what I always do to this:

Weird tags are searched, too. My audience is unlikely to be the people who search the common/popular tags. My audience is the people who will search "trouble giving up control" and "marionette" and "ethical failure."

That's not to say people who like the popular tags wouldn't also enjoy my writing, just that they are less likely to and I don't want to waste their time just because my story happens to have a blowjob in it, but isn't about blowjobs.

I prioritize the tags that I think someone might search for if they were looking for that story of mine. I don't even look at the popular tags list because it's useless to me.
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there. I mean, what possible use can they have in a normal story? What do you do, add "boy", "girl", "have sex", "his place"? If there's something kinky in it, do you have to tag "weeing" if the story name is "Sabrina Wees in Hortense's Mouth"?

I can't imagine looking for stories based on tags, but just for a moment suppose I was really, really keen on hand jobs or hand-jobs or handjobs and wanted to find . . . so I look for the tag "handjob" and don't find the ones tagged "handjobs" or . . .

Footnote. Not quite sure what a hand(-)job is, term used for illustrative purposes only.

If I am in a certain "mood" (grouchy old man) I have been known to pass on stories with no tags present. I don't like reading, investing my time, becoming involved, then come across a squick that makes me want to bail out of the story.

Fortunately for me, I'm not often in the mood. But I do appreciate a well tagged story. (y)

Also, I do search for potential stories to read by using tags. :)
 
If I am in a certain "mood" (grouchy old man) I have been known to pass on stories with no tags present. I don't like reading, investing my time, becoming involved, then come across a squick that makes me want to bail out of the story.

Fortunately for me, I'm not often in the mood. But I do appreciate a well tagged story. (y)

Also, I do search for potential stories to read by using tags. :)
Same on the tags not being present.

For me it's more about "If you can't be bothered, I'm not gonna waste my time when there are so many other options to choose from that I *know* involves one of my kinks.
 
Agreeing with a lot of the previous posters, I also think tags have a warning function. If your story has, oh, anal sex, be sure to have the "anal" tag, because some people can't stand that and will want to nope out of it. Why disgust some poor reader who found your story in Romance, but is horrified by the thought of touching someone's asshole?
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there. I mean, what possible use can they have in a normal story?
Wow.

Even if you personally don't find them useful...others do, and they're the easiest thing in the world to ignore. I can't imagine having that level of hate for something which helps others and doesn't affect your life at all.
 
One of the benefits of sex act tags is being able to search for multiples. So if I'm in the mood for a queer anthro blowjob story, it's a lot easier for me to find that than wading through a bunch of anthro stories, or queer stories, or blowjob stories on their own. On their own, I think sex act tags probably aren't used all that much for search purposes, people are probably looking more for specific kink stuff: d/s, mommy, futa, hemipenes, demon, etc. But the extra filtering is useful.
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there.
Seconded. They are an incredible chore to pick whenever I want to post a new story. Even if I had mostly figured out how to do it, mostly by coming to the same conclusions as @SimonDoom has, I still feel like a sleazy SEO hustler each time I have to scour that stupid cloud of popular tags and try to justify the inclusion of some of the larger ones.

It's especially aggravating when you realize that none of it would be necessary if the site had a proper recommendation system that actually looks at the content of the stories and not some arbitrary metadata.
 
I have a hard time believing you can't see the benefit of tags ...
I have two problems with tags: for queer kinky stories, ten tags is often not enough to enable you to attract all the readers who could be lured with a tag reflecting their interest.

For het couply vanilla stories (boy meets girl; spoiler: they fuck), filling up ten tags can be truly difficult, even when two are taken up by Some Event and Some Event 20xx.

Having a list of recognised tags would be really helpful, and merging synonyms together, so people don't have to use both 'blow job' and 'blowjob', etc.
 
I put all the tags in the beginning of the story text as well as in the tags section--usually more in fact, because there is no limit that way. The Plow has 25 tags in the body of the story. I would be interested to know though ...
... how many hit the Back button without reading further?

Me.
 
Oh I hate tags so much. I wish they weren't there.
There's no accounting for taste. IMO the tag system is more useful than categories, as long as authors actually use it. The most basic Erotic Couplings story ever could have the tags MF and Missionary and that's it. Beyond that?

I almost always pick them from the front page of tags, I figure anything that's not there is too obscure, but there are a few exceptions, like "friends to lovers". I try to find room for sex position tags, just in case someone is looking for a specific thing, but it's not a high priority. I try to use tags for basically anything that people could have strong feelings about, either for or against, like creampies or anal, and more esoteric things like blindfold use and impregnation.
I put all the tags in the beginning of the story text as well as in the tags section--usually more in fact, because there is no limit that way. The Plow has 25 tags in the body of the story. I would be interested to know though who actually stumbles on my stories based on the tags versus the body text.
I put them at the start of the story too, but I keep it the same as what I enter in the Tags field. I put them at the start because I've heard people have different abilities/experiences with finding tags. It's possible to see them in the sidebar at the start of the story, but I've seen people say they can only see them at the end, so I put them in the text to help people with whatever that setup is.
 
I never use all ten and I only use very basic ones.

I get they're useful but my opinion is that a lot of people got to the category they want or pick a story by title, tagline or the author. In other words I don't think tags are worth putting much effort into.
 
How much you like tags might vary depending on how many of your stories involve niche interests or kinks. People can and do search for stories with specific tags, so a tag for a narrower interest might draw a lot of those readers to you.

I would certainly tag anything that's a kink, for starters, but I'd also save a couple of spots for things that might not be kinks but might still be subjects of interest. As an example, a story where an orc and a human get pregnant could be tagged "impregnation" (a common kink) and "orc" (less common kink) but also "D&D" (area of interest).

I always aim to use all ten. I sometimes use the top tags list for inspiration, as in seeing if I've missed anything that might be more of a kink than I thought. Still, my goal in picking them is describing the story and its kinks and elements as accurately as possible, even if the accurate tags are less common.
 
Back
Top