AG31
Literotica Guru
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2021
- Posts
- 5,478
I became curious about what Michael Connelly (Harry Bosch fame) was doing with his style. It was engaging and compelling. But he was ignoring all kinds of advice we hear for writers. He showed an extreme avoidance of show, don't tell. There is virtually no point at which he describes how a person is feeling. In the rare instances where he goes there, it sounds like a newspaper report. He visits a comatose colleague in the hospital because "he wanted to go and show his support even if she didn't know he was there." He's going to invite his SO to join him on an investigative hike, "Plus he would enjoy her company." Those are actually the only references to emotion I can remember in the first 75 pages.
Vary your sentence structure. Almost all of his sentences are plain declarative, occasionally introduced by an "As..." phrase.
He mostly avoids dialogue tags altogether, usually 2 to 4 per page. That's not exactly ignoring good advice, but I've yet to see him use anything but "asked" and "said." Variety, variety, variety. Isn't that what we're supposed to strive for?
The result of this dry, low key approach is to make me think of those true crime shows, where the narrator speaks almost in a monotone. I call on the ancient among us to remember Dragnet. "Just the facts, ma'am."
So how does all this result in a distinctive, attractive style, instead of an amateurish, klunky story it would be hard to get published.
One thing, of course, is the story itself, the action. It's a good story, and every sentence moves it ahead. But why doesn't this succeed only in spite of the writing style? It has something to do with intentionality, I think, but I can't go further than that.
Can you articulate what moves a book like this into the realm of a really good read?
Can you think of other kinds of ignoring the best advice and coming up with a gem?
Vary your sentence structure. Almost all of his sentences are plain declarative, occasionally introduced by an "As..." phrase.
He mostly avoids dialogue tags altogether, usually 2 to 4 per page. That's not exactly ignoring good advice, but I've yet to see him use anything but "asked" and "said." Variety, variety, variety. Isn't that what we're supposed to strive for?
The result of this dry, low key approach is to make me think of those true crime shows, where the narrator speaks almost in a monotone. I call on the ancient among us to remember Dragnet. "Just the facts, ma'am."
So how does all this result in a distinctive, attractive style, instead of an amateurish, klunky story it would be hard to get published.
One thing, of course, is the story itself, the action. It's a good story, and every sentence moves it ahead. But why doesn't this succeed only in spite of the writing style? It has something to do with intentionality, I think, but I can't go further than that.
Can you articulate what moves a book like this into the realm of a really good read?
Can you think of other kinds of ignoring the best advice and coming up with a gem?

