White Guilt




Slavery is the best thing that ever happened to current African-Americans.

Just think— if it weren't for slave trade, today they could be living in Rwanda or Nigeria or the Sudan.


 



Slavery is the best thing that ever happened to current African-Americans.

Just think— if it weren't for slave trade, today they could be living in Rwanda or Nigeria or the Sudan.



And of course your...time machine and your...research in alternate dimensions where you could see how each outcome worked out...told you this?

What about the guys who starved to death on the way over or were dumped as shark bait? Did you work that into your assessment?
 
And of course your...time machine and your...research in alternate dimensions where you could see how each outcome worked out...told you this?

What about the guys who starved to death on the way over or were dumped as shark bait? Did you work that into your assessment?



"Slavery is the best thing that ever happened to current African-Americans."



 



"Slavery is the best thing that ever happened to current African-Americans."




That's like saying that modern Jews benefitted from a strengthening of their faith from the Holocaust.

It's also complete bullshit.
 
I remember (not when first released) the Jimmy Stewart movie when the use of the word "panties" was wicked.:)

Can't remember the movie but I know I would have hit it.:cool:

I shouldn't laugh.

...but I did.

Great, now I have perv guilt.
 
No, but you have plenty of other isms, like anti-Semitism. There are Russian Russians, and then other Russians who have a different race, cultural or religious background and they are discriminated against.

And let's not forget about how gays are being treated there.

Your statement has no relation to the discussion but okay. Russia has many faults just as America. The point is I do not try to force (instead of white let us say Russian) guilt upon this Russian generation for the sins of the past.

During communist Soviet Union and Russian colonization Russia killed many politicians, artists, poets and great thinkers of the cultures they invaded. This was done in an attempt to stamp out their cultures for easier assimilation. Remind me of the Borg in Star Trek. In my native country of Kazakhstan they butchered us by the thousands and made us learn Russian. They tried to stamp out our cultural identity. So in this I am not much different that the American Indian as traditionally my birthright is a nomadic horse culture. Kazakh means Free or Independent. Stan means Land. So Kazakhstan means land of free which suited nomads. So I think my birth home is not much different than American Indians. But no use crying about what was and better to work for what can be.

Before Americans criticizes Russia on gay issues maybe they get their issues regarding gays under control. America casting stones is hypocritical is it not? Do not get me wrong I love America but America loves to point fingers and in much cases are guilty of same. To my mind President Bush and those that allowed waterboarding should be brought before the Hague Court for violations of the Geneva Convention but it will not happen because America is to powerful. Only small countries are held to the standard that the American Government promotes as they surely do not follow their own beliefs when it is not convenient. But this is off topic too. I think you just looking for fight. Tag your it.
 
Your statement has no relation to the discussion but okay. Russia has many faults just as America. The point is I do not try to force (instead of white let us say Russian) guilt upon this Russian generation for the sins of the past.

During communist Soviet Union and Russian colonization Russia killed many politicians, artists, poets and great thinkers of the cultures they invaded. This was done in an attempt to stamp out their cultures for easier assimilation. Remind me of the Borg in Star Trek. In my native country of Kazakhstan they butchered us by the thousands and made us learn Russian. They tried to stamp out our cultural identity. So in this I am not much different that the American Indian as traditionally my birthright is a nomadic horse culture. Kazakh means Free or Independent. Stan means Land. So Kazakhstan means land of free which suited nomads. So I think my birth home is not much different than American Indians. But no use crying about what was and better to work for what can be.

Before Americans criticizes Russia on gay issues maybe they get their issues regarding gays under control. America casting stones is hypocritical is it not? Do not get me wrong I love America but America loves to point fingers and in much cases are guilty of same. To my mind President Bush and those that allowed waterboarding should be brought before the Hague Court for violations of the Geneva Convention but it will not happen because America is to powerful. Only small countries are held to the standard that the American Government promotes as they surely do not follow their own beliefs when it is not convenient. But this is off topic too. I think you just looking for fight. Tag your it.

I'm not forcing guilt on anybody. I am experiencing it in a specific context. I'm not advocating guilt or reparations, I'm saying that I'm lucky partly and favored in other ways. As a woman I'm not favored. As a chronic pain sufferer I'm not favored. My son has Asperger's and he's not favored. This is one area where it did go our way. I see the difference between those areas where I am favored and where I am not.

This also isn't "America" casting stones, it's "Americans" - I'm critical of both nations in their treatment of gay citizens.
 
I see lunch inspired you. Well put.:cool:

Microsoft Word program I use when I need to be wordy and understood.

I'm not forcing guilt on anybody. I am experiencing it in a specific context. I'm not advocating guilt or reparations, I'm saying that I'm lucky partly and favored in other ways. As a woman I'm not favored. As a chronic pain sufferer I'm not favored. My son has Asperger's and he's not favored. This is one area where it did go our way. I see the difference between those areas where I am favored and where I am not.

This also isn't "America" casting stones, it's "Americans" - I'm critical of both nations in their treatment of gay citizens.

Friend I not saying you force guilt but seems to me that blacks do and Indians.

Regarding gay in Russia. I think the majority of Russian not give a shit to be honest. Gays been serving openly in Russian military long before American military. Russian society is very much (i'm not sure how to express for you)...You know how Communism attempt to make all equal?....it is like that. Russians like sameness. It is not so much as they are hatred against gays as much as they want a version of their normal to prevail. So you can be gay but just do not be provocative. Russia do not want marching in street with men wearing fairy wings and a crown. Do you understand my point? I am not saying this is right I'm just trying to explain the view. So it is not gay hate as much as do not be a spectacle.
 
Before Americans criticizes Russia on gay issues maybe they get their issues regarding gays under control. America casting stones is hypocritical is it not? Do not get me wrong I love America but America loves to point fingers and in much cases are guilty of same. To my mind President Bush and those that allowed waterboarding should be brought before the Hague Court for violations of the Geneva Convention but it will not happen because America is to powerful.

Bush waterboarded gays? What a dick!
 
Bush waterboarded gays? What a dick!

yeah but he didn't know what 'waterboarding' meant, so he just pushed them down a long twisty water slide.

surprisingly, the terrorists spilled all their secrets soon afterwards
 
yeah but he didn't know what 'waterboarding' meant, so he just pushed them down a long twisty water slide.

surprisingly, the terrorists spilled all their secrets soon afterwards

That's what waterboarding is? Shit, sign me up. I love slides.
 
Friend I not saying you force guilt but seems to me that blacks do and Indians.

Regarding gay in Russia. I think the majority of Russian not give a shit to be honest. Gays been serving openly in Russian military long before American military. Russian society is very much (i'm not sure how to express for you)...You know how Communism attempt to make all equal?....it is like that. Russians like sameness. It is not so much as they are hatred against gays as much as they want a version of their normal to prevail. So you can be gay but just do not be provocative. Russia do not want marching in street with men wearing fairy wings and a crown. Do you understand my point? I am not saying this is right I'm just trying to explain the view. So it is not gay hate as much as do not be a spectacle.

Yes, that is the point. "Liking Sameness" is something Americans do well, but one size does not fit all.

I understand your viewpoint, but it's a social convention that serves the majority, not the minority, who cannot be same without pretending to be something they are not for social purposes.

The point to these freedoms is to not have a false standard apply.

Realistically in both countries, the sameness to be applied is a very traditional, but obsolete view of what makes things "go smoothly" but only makes things go smoothly for those that already subscribe to this point of view or force themselves to.

I think you express yourself well and I do understand, that's not the issue. I think you are applying a standard that is comfortable (or workable) for you, but you do not know how much it is destructive and unworkable for other individuals or those with different cultural sentiments.

America likes individuality...to a point. The 50's were a time of (theoretical) peace and happiness for all the white folks, and the only problems happened when those women and minorities got ideas in their heads and ruined it all.

My view of Russian culture is hyper-masculine and Spetznaz prone. Spetznaz train by beating someone (almost and sometimes to) death as part of routine training. I get it, it's cold, it's rough, life isn't easy, suck it up. But that attitude does not apply to, say...what your life should be like if you want to sell cheese at a kiosk.

Mary Roach did a book where she interviewed a number of Russian Cosmonauts. In a social experiment they put many people from many different cultures together and the Japanese women (who are more demure and conservative) could not fend off Russian men when the men came on to them sexually. The woman would politely say "no" and the Russians would keep going. To them, the only acceptable "no" is a punch in the face.

There's a lot of punching involved. Perhaps if the punching were cut back on a bit...

Societies should not only welcome the punchers. So say the historical punchees. If you listen to those with bruised social standing, there are lessons to be learned.
 



"Slavery is the best thing that ever happened to current African-Americans."




"Manifest Destiny was the best thing that ever happened to current Native Americans."

"Rape culture is the best thing that ever happened to current women's feminist movements."

"Megan Kanka's murder is the best thing that ever happened to current sex offender profiling and registration techniques."

"Southeast Asian child prostitution is the best thing that ever happened to current Southeast Asian sex trade abolitionists."
 
Back
Top