Primalex
Literotica Guru
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2007
- Posts
- 6,182
I didn't either until I had my daughter. She is diagnosed with ADHD and severe learning disabilities. I fought for years to keep her off meds. Her 3rd grade teacher finally sat me down a few years ago and said I was hurting her by keeping her off meds. She asked me if she had been diagnosed with diabetes world I deny her insulin? So I tried her on meds and she's a much happier child who can actually learn and enjoy school now. If she misses a dose of her Adderall she tells me she can't concentrate or think, she says on the meds she feels normal. That's all the proof I need.
Children without ADHD concentrate and work better with Adderall, too.
You found a solution to a problem. But this doesn't mean that you can conclude from the solution to the problem or even validate that the problem existed.
Let's change the illness.
Your daughter wakes up every day with a headache.
Your daughter takes every morning a pain reliever and everything is fine.
Everyone would immediately say:"Oh, you are fixing symptoms here!"
But when pharmacy comes up and says:"Oh, daily headache? THAT is the Chronic Painful Head Disorder, CPHD! No problem, take this pill and you will feel better."
Now everyone is quiet, although nothing changed at all, they just turned the symptom into the cause.
And this system is so successful, because everyone wins!
The doctor wins, he can solve your problem, quite easily, just has to whip out his prescription pad.
The pharmacy totally wins, they have a life-long customer.
The teacher wins, he has no trouble anymore.
You win, you feel better, because your daughter will acknowledge that she feels much better now without the headache.
Your daughter wins, because, yes, she does feel much better, since taking the pills and hey, without the headaches, she does much better in school.
Everyone wins.
Nobody needs to care now that the headache is caused by the worn-out mattress.
And when your daughter finally reaches adulthood and moves out and sleeps in a bed with a better mattress, she still takes the pain relievers. After all, she has CPHD and sometimes she tries to go without them, but the headache returns then immediately, even when sleeping in the new bed. This proves the diagnosis to be correct, doesn't it?
(Parents actually win twice with the ADHD diagnosis - they get a solution and absolution at the same time. How could a totally fucked up environment and upbringing be the reason?)
I really don't want to belittle your problems and I don't think you are doing anything wrong per se. But when there is not a single scientific study that compares the brain scans of ADHD children with normal children as control group, I'm getting rather wary.
Last edited:
Just my experience with a child with this diagnosis. YMMV

If a typical person took the dose of Adderall my daughter takes it would have the same effect on them as speed. When she takes it, we see the opposite. She calms down and is much more relaxed. The same is true if she takes something that would slow us down. Benadryl for example makes most people tired and relaxed. I made the mistake of giving her Benadryl once and she was jumping off the walls. She was so hyperactive and her thoughts were racing so much she cried and asked me to never give it to her again. Their brains do not work the same way as "typical" brains.