The Official Authors' Hangout Winter Holidays 2025 Support Thread

As long as you're happy with it, that's what matters! I thought that mine was pretty good, but the score keeps dropping. It's sitting at 4.35/51 right now. Like, it wasn't a perfect story, but I thought it was at least a 4.5l I want to tell myself that it's because I shouldn't have submitted it in the romance catagory, and that it would have done better if I'd just submitted it as a non-erotic like all the other times I've submitted stories without sex, but still. It does wound the pride.
I know it's easier to say than do, but think of it this way: two people giving it a one because they're twats is enough to be the difference between 4.35 and 4.49 with that number of votes. If you're happy with it, be happy with it. Don't let either the 1s or the 5s affect how you feel about it.
 
Well, maybe you just got a few bombs that will be swept away later.
That's what I'm hoping for. I don't expect it to win, but it would be nice have an "A" average (I figure a 4.5 is basically an A-).
In other news, my NCR story "Does she know its Christmas" is finally in full draft stage at about 26.5 thousand words, a real door-stopper compared to my other stuff. I'm gonna sleep, then edit and submit it tomorrow. Not expecting a miracle, but maybe it'll do well.
Congrats! I'm working on one last competition piece that's a follow-up on last year's piece. Calling it "Sammi Elf Sweetens Her Sugarplum" and it's about a Christmas elf getting buttfucked by her human boyfriend. A true holiday classic, if you can't tell.
I know it's easier to say than do, but think of it this way: two people giving it a one because they're twats is enough to be the difference between 4.35 and 4.49 with that number of votes. If you're happy with it, be happy with it. Don't let either the 1s or the 5s affect how you feel about it.
I know, I know. I just ... I know. I am happy with it. I am. At least it's not a surprise hit (relatively speaking) that makes me think "damn, maybe I should have quiried that to magazines" like this one was. One day I'd like to make money off of writing, but for now I'm just happy that people are reading my stories and occasionally telling me that they liked them afterward. There's a reason my forum quote is what it is, after all.
 
That's what I'm hoping for. I don't expect it to win, but it would be nice have an "A" average (I figure a 4.5 is basically an A-).

Congrats! I'm working on one last competition piece that's a follow-up on last year's piece. Calling it "Sammi Elf Sweetens Her Sugarplum" and it's about a Christmas elf getting buttfucked by her human boyfriend. A true holiday classic, if you can't tell.

I know, I know. I just ... I know. I am happy with it. I am. At least it's not a surprise hit (relatively speaking) that makes me think "damn, maybe I should have quiried that to magazines" like this one was. One day I'd like to make money off of writing, but for now I'm just happy that people are reading my stories and occasionally telling me that they liked them afterward. There's a reason my forum quote is what it is, after all.
When looking at scores here, all aspects of writing are squashed together into a simple, single number. Thus, you can’t tell if your score is based on the quality of your writing.or the content of your writing. Then throw in choice of category, where great content can be scored lower because your story didn’t match reader expectations.

The one score that matters the most happens after your final read through, and your finger is hovering over the submit button.
 
Sigh, another day waking up, another single low score coming in overnight that lowers my score. It almost feels bot-like but if it is, I think they're doing it "smart" and will avoid sweeps. I should honestly just stop checking.
As it stands mine probably won't get enough to qualify. Its a shame but I've received 5 new followers since I posted it. So not a total loss.
 
As it stands mine probably won't get enough to qualify. Its a shame but I've received 5 new followers since I posted it. So not a total loss.
I love that you got new followers. I feel like that's going to be the major benefit here for me, too.

I really really hate the one-bombers.

Why are people such assholes?
The smaller the stakes the bigger the egos.
I wonder if some of this has to do with the fact that when the stakes are smaller, people feel less bad about manipulating the outcomes. Like they can allow themselves a little bit of fudge factor without it affecting their ego/feelings about themselves at all.

And some of it is my fault - I don't have enough reach to get hundreds of ratings, so my average is far more affected by even 3's and 4's than it otherwise would be. And if it just seemed like people legitimately enjoying but not LOVING my work, that would be one thing. I'm used to that. I don't have a lot of red H's and my poetry is barely read by anyone (I just love writing it). But it's just the timing that seems too much to be coincidental. Like, did the ones who like but not love (or those who hate) just happen to only start coming out now and all at once/all in a row? And all overnight (for me) like clockwork? I stopped having a mix of ratings and that just seems odd. I don't expect to win anything, but I'd love my score to stay real.

I've also noticed that *everyone* who has "Winter Contest 2025" as a tag seems to follow the same pattern. All of our relative positions are the same, but the scores are all dropping at the same general rate. But just "Christmas"? Not seeing the same effect. Flying under the radar, perhaps, or maybe just not being found by people who dislike contests so much.
 
I've heard the tag thing before, yeah. My entry tends to go up during the day and down overnight, but who knows if that's real or meaningful. There do tend to be lots of sweeps closer to the end of the contests; I've seen stories with hundreds of ratings, written by authors with thousands of followers who get hundreds or thousands of ratings on everything, go up a full quarter of a point in the final day, becoming the highest-rated work in their catalogue just in time for the deadline. Then after the contest closes and some time passes, they'll sink back down to something more like the rest of their work. So I don't put much stock in contest results or the ratings your work has until a few months after the contest closes.
 
I've also noticed that *everyone* who has "Winter Contest 2025" as a tag seems to follow the same pattern. All of our relative positions are the same, but the scores are all dropping at the same general rate. But just "Christmas"? Not seeing the same effect. Flying under the radar, perhaps, or maybe just not being found by people who dislike contests so much.
I don't know if it is the tag itself or everyone in the contest, but the contests definitely bring it out.

I swore during the Nude Day event that I would never enter another contest because of the one-bombers.

They also get brought to by making the all-time leader board (the one that requires 100 votes). I'm realizing, that for me at least who does not have thousands of votes, my stories will do better rating if the are at 4.82 at 99 votes than 4.92. It'r frustrating. The 4.80-4.84 stories slide under the radar and never get hit that hard. But the ones that have the audacity to have a 4.88 or something get bombed back into the 4.7's. I assume they will eventually recover, but the votes come so slowly and it literally a hundred votes (all 5's) to balance out three 1's at that rating.
 
They also get brought to by making the all-time leader board (the one that requires 100 votes). I'm realizing, that for me at least who does not have thousands of votes, my stories will do better rating if the are at 4.82 at 99 votes than 4.92. It'r frustrating. The 4.80-4.84 stories slide under the radar and never get hit that hard. But the ones that have the audacity to have a 4.88 or something get bombed back into the 4.7's.
I have the exact same experience. As soon as my stories hit that 100 vote mark they drop very noticeably in score. 4.85-9's go down to low 4.8's, or even into the 4.7's. Its made me want to only submit my contest entries at the last minute so they don't get enough votes to risk that.
 
I don't know if it is the tag itself or everyone in the contest, but the contests definitely bring it out.

I swore during the Nude Day event that I would never enter another contest because of the one-bombers.

They also get brought to by making the all-time leader board (the one that requires 100 votes). I'm realizing, that for me at least who does not have thousands of votes, my stories will do better rating if the are at 4.82 at 99 votes than 4.92. It'r frustrating. The 4.80-4.84 stories slide under the radar and never get hit that hard. But the ones that have the audacity to have a 4.88 or something get bombed back into the 4.7's. I assume they will eventually recover, but the votes come so slowly and it literally a hundred votes (all 5's) to balance out three 1's at that rating.

One mustn't fly to close to the sun, unfortunately.
 
Story is submitted. Not quite a week before the deadline like my most optimistic projections or my Halloween story, but I think I did pretty well given how dependent on last minute panic I've been in prior years, and just how long this one is compared to my other stories (I don't know how everyone else does it).
 
I just outlined my story. Hoping for a short one. I don't expect to place at all, but I want to have something entered. I just hope I finish in time!
 
And some of it is my fault - I don't have enough reach to get hundreds of ratings, so my average is far more affected by even 3's and 4's than it otherwise would be. And if it just seemed like people legitimately enjoying but not LOVING my work, that would be one thing. I'm used to that. I don't have a lot of red H's and my poetry is barely read by anyone (I just love writing it). But it's just the timing that seems too much to be coincidental. Like, did the ones who like but not love (or those who hate) just happen to only start coming out now and all at once/all in a row? And all overnight (for me) like clockwork? I stopped having a mix of ratings and that just seems odd. I don't expect to win anything, but I'd love my score to stay real.
Word. And it's not enough to ping something as OBVIOUSLY fake, just enough to bring our scores down. Like, maybe my story really isn't that great, but knowing that there are people who review bomb stories is disheartening. Like, I don't even have that good of a score, nor was I expecting one, but it seems like they target anyone who isn't their favorite author.

I've also noticed that *everyone* who has "Winter Contest 2025" as a tag seems to follow the same pattern. All of our relative positions are the same, but the scores are all dropping at the same general rate. But just "Christmas"? Not seeing the same effect. Flying under the radar, perhaps, or maybe just not being found by people who dislike contests so much.
I'd not noticed that, so I'll have to make sure that I tag it as such in the future. I know that some people like for stories that are part of contests to be tagged with that contest, but if that makes it easier for review bombers to target it, I'm not gonna tag it that way.
 
Very nice to have someone ask that I continue Plugged In as a series, because annoyingly it works better as a series than a standalone.
Congrats!

I've just submitted a sequel to the story I submitted last year, so I'm pretty pumped. Haven't done this much writing in such a short amount of time in a while, so it's nice to know that the creative juices are still flowing! Fingers crossed that I get more forgiveness for my writing with smut scenes than my writing without them.
 
I have written stories for the past three contests, but I do not think I have time to write one for the Winter Holidays.
 
Just out of curiosity, are you guys tracking the ratings, watching your story move up and down the list as the days progress... or just waiting patiently for December 12th? No reason for asking *cough* 😂

p.s. I have absolutely no delusions of winning anything here, just a bit of a nerd. :D
 
Just out of curiosity, are you guys tracking the ratings, watching your story move up and down the list as the days progress... or just waiting patiently for December 12th? No reason for asking *cough* 😂

p.s. I have absolutely no delusions of winning anything here, just a bit of a nerd. :D
I'm not watching anything. Out of curiosity, how do you get that footer in your posts? The one that lists your stories. I can't figure it out.
 
Just out of curiosity, are you guys tracking the ratings, watching your story move up and down the list as the days progress... or just waiting patiently for December 12th? No reason for asking *cough* 😂

p.s. I have absolutely no delusions of winning anything here, just a bit of a nerd. :D
I have not been nearly as bad this time as I was in my other contest I entered, back in June. That time, I had to promise to my wife I wouldn't check more than every fifteen minutes. And unlike my other vow to her, I did not completely uphold this one. I did realize I was conceivably competitive for a prize that time. Eventually, the 1-bombs drove my score down enough I gave up and stopped tracking regularly. It hurt too much. That story was the one I'm emotionally most tied to.

This time I realize I'm not competitive. I really like this story, but I made my FMC too bitchy and my MMC too wussy. I'm overall happy with the reaction, but it's not going to get me another W. I would be watching another story closely, because it does have a chance and I feel very vested in that story. It's be a close friend and I helped. But you can't watch vote by vote on someone else's story. My fingers are still crossed for her.

Out of curiosity, how do you get that footer in your posts? The one that lists your stories. I can't figure it out
Go to your forum preferences (one of your choices if you click on your name in the upper right hand corner of this page)

There is a signature choice to the left. Just type it in there. You also need Show People's Signatures with their Messages clicked in the first page you went to, but if you can see others, I guess you have that clicked.
 
This time I realize I'm not competitive. I really like this story, but I made my FMC too bitchy and my MMC too wussy. I'm overall happy with the reaction, but it's not going to get me another W
That kind of sums up my attitude as well. I wrote the story mostly because being in comps seems to be a good way to get some views on an author's work, to have something published in between larger stories that need a lot of work and won't be published until the new year, and because I thought the premise and plot were challenging to write. So, I'm happy to see someone else get a deserved win, but am having fun watching the ratings move around and maybe learning something about how comps behave in the process.
 
Back
Top