annaswirls
Pointy?
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2003
- Posts
- 7,204
Cool! I just wanted to be sure. There are as many different feelings about comments and reviews as there are poets, and I did not want to inadvertently step on your poetic tootsies.
I agree 100% with your theory on be yourself, seek your own approval, and so on, and most of the reason I write is for myself, figuring things out. However, there is also a part of me that wants to communicate effectively. I do not necessarily want to "please" people with my writing. I want to know if the mic is on, you know? If the sound is coming through.
Musicians may play from their heart, be true to themselves, but they also do a "test 1,2" before they try to get their message across.
Again, it, to me, is a matter of communication. If people were not interested in getting a message across, of having some sort of interaction (not necessarily
pleasing" other people, but creating something that can be shared...then they would not be posting in a public forum, yes? I suppose you could think of it this way. Would we be typing our poems, in English, on a message board where everyone read Spanish only? Would we think about getting a translator so that we could communicate with our neighbors? Consider learning Spanish?
Not a matter of being good enough according to other people's criteria, but does it do what I wanted it to do?
We have mirrors. We tell people if their fly is down. Sometimes in order to really see ourselves, we need to ask someone for their opinion.
At any rate, I am babbling. I just wanted to be sure, sometimes it is hard for me to read between the lines, or even read the actual lines
okay bed. Thanks for taking the time to satisfy my curiousity
~Anna
I agree 100% with your theory on be yourself, seek your own approval, and so on, and most of the reason I write is for myself, figuring things out. However, there is also a part of me that wants to communicate effectively. I do not necessarily want to "please" people with my writing. I want to know if the mic is on, you know? If the sound is coming through.
Musicians may play from their heart, be true to themselves, but they also do a "test 1,2" before they try to get their message across.
Again, it, to me, is a matter of communication. If people were not interested in getting a message across, of having some sort of interaction (not necessarily
pleasing" other people, but creating something that can be shared...then they would not be posting in a public forum, yes? I suppose you could think of it this way. Would we be typing our poems, in English, on a message board where everyone read Spanish only? Would we think about getting a translator so that we could communicate with our neighbors? Consider learning Spanish?
Not a matter of being good enough according to other people's criteria, but does it do what I wanted it to do?
We have mirrors. We tell people if their fly is down. Sometimes in order to really see ourselves, we need to ask someone for their opinion.
At any rate, I am babbling. I just wanted to be sure, sometimes it is hard for me to read between the lines, or even read the actual lines
okay bed. Thanks for taking the time to satisfy my curiousity
~Anna
heh, forgot about that one. That was a good day too. I think it was a precursor to the big light today; there is a tie between them.
Uh, you know, this is a lifelong condition, pervading all corners and pursuits and stuff, of which Lit is just one small corner. Part of what came out of that day's gathering, was imagining I could go way back and advise a me at the earliest age I could possibly digest it. I would sit that kid down and say, "now listen because this is very important. As you go through life, you must realize that there is not one single person who is under any obligation, to like you or love you. Nobody. And as you begin to develop loves and talents, and hope to produce, not everyone will like it, someone somewhere will be able to find something wrong with it, and with you, according to what light/perspective they are working from at that time in their life. So you have to do that. Yourself. You have to enjoy full approval of yourself and all that you do. Because the moment you begin to depend on acceptance from others, you're dancing to their tune. Then you're dancing to someone else's, then another's, and not by your own choosing. You become little more than a puppet. You cut those strings, and that allows full liberties on both sides. Liberty for them to express their honest opinion no matter how adorable or cruel it is, and it leaves you the freedom to consider it or ignore it as seems best to you or what you know of yourself at that time." And so on.
But I never learned that. Nobody counseled me or if they did I didn't listen. I'm trying to understand it now, a bit late, yes, but trying.
So to try and apply it as it pertains to Lit and poems and reviews and whatnot, I relinquish any expectations. Meaning, if you honestly read something that for some reason tickles your fancy enough to mention it, it is always appreciated. Of course it is. If you feel you really want to say something sucks, you should say it sucks, and not worry about hurting my feelings. Even though you might. I mean, you have plenty other things to do, and who am I expect a soft-touch treatment, unless you chose to out of the natural depths of your very good heart. I mean, as they say, everybody writes sucky poems. So... not the end of the world (at least not yet. 2012, is supposedly the year the world ends).
the voting? I've turned those off. It never really felt right, couldn't say exactly why. And the comments, they were helpful at the beginning, and what was commented on really helped. A few days ago, I entered the Coin-Toss Period. Heads, On, tails, Off. Do another coin toss round a couple days later. And that's no more than an exercise to attempt cutting the strings of getting too reliant on those/that.
So, I advocate the greatest amounts of comfort for as many of the varied individuals and their styles and ways as possible.