bailadora
We create the dreams.
- Joined
- Oct 16, 2007
- Posts
- 3,855
I've been away from Lit for a few days. Wow - some great posts here - thanks to everyone who has shared their thoughts.
TigerClaw, interesting that you bring up evolution as this is exactly the same point my husband made when I told him I'd started this thread. I can see your point that certain attributes were equated with health, thus those individuals who had them were the best candidates to procreate with. But...I think the current "ideal" is more off kilter than we might think. I decided to do some research on the topic because I was curious if it was just my own sensitivity to certain things that might be coloring my perspective. Some food for thought:
The Association of Model Agents (AMA) says that female models should be around 34-24-34 inches (86-61-86 cm) and at least 5 ft 8 in (1.73 m) tall. Currently, the height required to do fashion shows has increased. During the last fashion shows in Europe, the average height was 1.79 m (5 ft 10 in), the average weight was 50 kg (110 lb), with bust between 85 to 90 cm (33.5 to 35.4 inches), waist under 62 cm (24.4 inches), and hips under 90 cm (35.4 inches), to fit the 34/36 size of haute Couture prototypes. Average dimensions for a male model are a height of 180-188 cm (5 ft 11 in- 6'2") and a weight of 64-75 kg (140-165 lb). Male models are also toned and fit. Organizers of a fashion show in Madrid in September 2006 turned away models who were judged to be underweight by medical personnel who were on hand. In February 2007, six months after her sister, Luisel Ramos, also a model, died, Uruguayan model Eliana Ramos became the third international model to die of malnutrition in six months (The second victim was Ana Carolina Reston). Luisel Ramos died of heart failure caused by anorexia nervosa. Source: Wikipedia
I did the math and if the above averages are true - then your average female model has a BMI of less than 18%, which is underweight by medical standards. How is this healthy when these women are literally dying to be thin? The men's statistics seemed to be more in line, but then I read the following:
Similarly, all boys see is a body ideal that for most men is impossible to achieve without illegal anabolic steroids. There is a physiological limit to how much muscle a man can attain naturally, given his height, frame, and body fat percentage. Unfortunately, however, the action figure heroes on toy store shelves and male fitness models on magazine covers and ads suggest otherwise. Source - Student Nutrition and Action Council at UCLA
I don't know - it's all a tangled mess. I realize and agree that we are all ultimately responsible for our personal health. OTOH: I also believe in corporate responsibility and I think the fashion industry and the associated media needs to acknowledge and correct their role in setting an unhealthy standard.
The Male and Female form also has a "ratio" that is acceptable to the human eye. The correct ratio was a visual representation of health. In early civilizations health was very important of course.
Evolution has made us want certain things in the opposite sex. Marketing has taken these aspects and as with everything else bring it to the extreme. The more modern the society the more whacked the sense of beauty. There have been studies showing this. One note, although the modern societies have skewed the sense of beauty it is not as far off as we would think.
What beauty shows, magazines want us to believe is attractive to Modern Man is not what Modern Man is attracted too. Yes, we admire the beauty but in the back of our minds might be, less/more butt, less/more chest, better proportion, etc.
TigerClaw, interesting that you bring up evolution as this is exactly the same point my husband made when I told him I'd started this thread. I can see your point that certain attributes were equated with health, thus those individuals who had them were the best candidates to procreate with. But...I think the current "ideal" is more off kilter than we might think. I decided to do some research on the topic because I was curious if it was just my own sensitivity to certain things that might be coloring my perspective. Some food for thought:
The Association of Model Agents (AMA) says that female models should be around 34-24-34 inches (86-61-86 cm) and at least 5 ft 8 in (1.73 m) tall. Currently, the height required to do fashion shows has increased. During the last fashion shows in Europe, the average height was 1.79 m (5 ft 10 in), the average weight was 50 kg (110 lb), with bust between 85 to 90 cm (33.5 to 35.4 inches), waist under 62 cm (24.4 inches), and hips under 90 cm (35.4 inches), to fit the 34/36 size of haute Couture prototypes. Average dimensions for a male model are a height of 180-188 cm (5 ft 11 in- 6'2") and a weight of 64-75 kg (140-165 lb). Male models are also toned and fit. Organizers of a fashion show in Madrid in September 2006 turned away models who were judged to be underweight by medical personnel who were on hand. In February 2007, six months after her sister, Luisel Ramos, also a model, died, Uruguayan model Eliana Ramos became the third international model to die of malnutrition in six months (The second victim was Ana Carolina Reston). Luisel Ramos died of heart failure caused by anorexia nervosa. Source: Wikipedia
I did the math and if the above averages are true - then your average female model has a BMI of less than 18%, which is underweight by medical standards. How is this healthy when these women are literally dying to be thin? The men's statistics seemed to be more in line, but then I read the following:
Similarly, all boys see is a body ideal that for most men is impossible to achieve without illegal anabolic steroids. There is a physiological limit to how much muscle a man can attain naturally, given his height, frame, and body fat percentage. Unfortunately, however, the action figure heroes on toy store shelves and male fitness models on magazine covers and ads suggest otherwise. Source - Student Nutrition and Action Council at UCLA
I don't know - it's all a tangled mess. I realize and agree that we are all ultimately responsible for our personal health. OTOH: I also believe in corporate responsibility and I think the fashion industry and the associated media needs to acknowledge and correct their role in setting an unhealthy standard.