Who Should Decide?

I just read the news too Carrie. I feel sad about it. I hope they're able to get the stay.


Judge Orders Teen to Have Cancer Treatment
By SONJA BARISIC, AP

NORFOLK, Virginia (July 22) - A judge ruled Friday that a 16-year-old boy fighting to use alternative treatment for his cancer must report to a hospital by Tuesday and accept treatment that doctors deem necessary, the family's attorney said.

In legal cases regarding refusal of treatment for children, courts consider the child's age and maturity, the family's reasoning and whether the treatment has been shown to work, bioethics expert Arthur Caplan said.

The judge also found Starchild Abraham Cherrix's parents were neglectful for allowing him to pursue alternative treatment of a sugar-free, organic diet and herbal supplements supervised by a clinic in Mexico, lawyer John Stepanovich said.

Jay and Rose Cherrix of Chincoteague on Virginia's Eastern Shore must continue to share custody of their son with the Accomack County Department of Social Services, as the judge had previously ordered, Stepanovich said.

The parents were devastated by the new order and planned to appeal, the lawyer said.

Stepanovich said he will ask a higher court on Monday to stay enforcement of the order, which requires the parents to take Abraham to Children's Hospital of the King's Daughters in Norfolk and to give the oncologist their written legal consent to treat their son for Hodgkin's disease.

"I want to caution all parents of Virginia: Look out, because Social Services may be pounding on your door next when they disagree with the decision you've made about the health care of your child," Stepanovich said.

Phone calls to the Cherrix home went unanswered.

The lawyer declined to release the ruling, saying juvenile court Judge Jesse E. Demps has sealed much of the case.

Social Services officials have declined to comment, citing privacy laws. After three months of chemotherapy last year made him nauseated and weak, Abraham rejected doctors' recommendations to go through a second round when he learned early this year that his Hodgkin's disease, a cancer of the lymph nodes, was active again.

A social worker then asked a judge to require the teen to continue conventional treatment. In May, the judge issued a temporary order finding Abraham's parents neglectful and awarding partial custody to the county, with Abraham continuing to live at home with his four siblings.


07-22-06 02:01 EDT


Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP news report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press.
 
...requires the parents to take Abraham to Children's Hospital of the King's Daughters in Norfolk and to give the oncologist their written legal consent to treat their son for Hodgkin's disease.

This is absolutely outrageous interference with parents' rights to determine what is best for their own child.

I hope the appeal is successful.

My heart goes to this young man and his family.
 
One of the hardest things about this job is the frustration. The frustration that parents have because they can't do anything against this awful disease that is hurting their children. The frustration that the kids have because they don't understand why this is happening to them.
Though there is always one who understands more than we think. I had one 4 yr old who had a brain tumor. I was visiting one day and her parents were trying to keep from crying around her,holding back their tears. She looked up at them while I was taking her vitals and said "Mommy,Daddy, Please don't cry..when I'm in Jesus' arms,my head won't hurt anymore!" I had to leave the room with tears of my own on my cheeks. :rolleyes:
 
Judge Lifts Order for Cancer Treatment
By SONJA BARISIC, Associated Press Writer
1 hour ago

ACCOMAC, Va. - A judge ruled Tuesday that a 16-year-old cancer patient who has refused conventional medical treatment does not have to report to a hospital as previously ordered and scheduled a trial to settle the dispute.

http://www.comcast.net/news/national/index.jsp?cat=DOMESTIC&fn=/2006/07/25/441552.html

Finally, they catch a break.

I am a parent of a 17-year-old. As much as I would be saddened by the alternative, I have to say, if faced with a similar situation, I would stand behind her 100%.
 
I was glad to hear this. I see chemo work for some people but obviously Abraham felt it wasn't for him and he should have a choice about whether to do it or not. I think he is old enough and informed enough to make that choice.
 
i was reading this thread and i feel very torn on a number of things ..i will comment later as i need a cup of coffee..lol
 
carrie-on said:
I was glad to hear this. I see chemo work for some people but obviously Abraham felt it wasn't for him and he should have a choice about whether to do it or not. I think he is old enough and informed enough to make that choice.

We raise our children to make informed, responsibile choices with their lives, and I think Abraham has done that.

We all know there is no fail proof treatment. Even though one patient may have a favorable outcome, there is no guarantee that the next patient will have the same result.

I wish him and his family all the best.
 
Here's an update that I just ran across.

ACCOMAC, Va. - A 16-year-old cancer patient 's legal fight ended in victory Wednesday when his family's attorneys and social services officials reached an agreement that would allow him to forgo chemotherapy.

At the start of what was scheduled to be a two-day hearing, Accomack County Circuit Judge Glen A. Tyler announced that both sides had reached a consent decree, which Tyler approved.

http://www.comcast.net/news/national/index.jsp?cat=DOMESTIC&fn=/2006/08/16/456708.html
 
Back
Top