50,000

Then speak as an individual and not as an authority on average.

Individuals do care, you're dragging an entire group down to the lowest common denominator by characterizing them all the same. You're accomplishing very little but spreading more despair.

You're also invalidating any spontaneous American contribution from individuals, which I find to be counterproductive to any purpose that serves doing something to help someone else in distress.

Why run down people who are making donations of their own accord in order to appear to be some sort of authority? Do you want to be Mayor of "WhyHaitiIsFuckedville?"
I do speak as an individual. But, as an individual, I recognize that $50 per Haitian won't amount to much, compared to what they face.

That's not "spreading despair" — that's acknowledging reality.

It might seem like "spreading despair" if you live in a world where anything that goes wrong can magically be fixed, but that's the sort of state of mind we normally ascribe to children.
 
I am not going to recall how much I donated or how much everyone else donated either. Nor am I going to ask. I am going to remember that there were donations. The numbers are there. I'm not memorizing them or quizzing someone on them.
The argument could be made--strongly--that throwing money at something and calling it a day is the least engaged of all responses. We gave $100. It took about three minutes online. Texting takes even less time--a couple of seconds.

If you're keeping score by the amount of money people are giving in the aggregate, then you're right, we've all done a lot. If you're keeping score by the amount of real estate the tragedy appears to be taking up in people's actual lives and minds--especially as compared to other such tragedies--it gives the impression of being very small.
 
Last edited:
The argument could be made--strongly--that throwing money at something and calling it a day is the least engaged of all responses. We gave $100. It took about three minutes online. Texting takes even less time--a couple of seconds.

If you're keeping score by the amount of money people are giving in the aggregate, then you're right, we've all done a lot. If you're keeping score by the amount of real estate the tragedy appears to be taking up in people's lives and minds, it gives the impression of being very small.

The least engaged of all responses is doing nothing. The strength of that argument makes no sense to me other than in some philosophical way that measures distress against cash. As if thinking and feeling really bad is somehow of more worth than action of transferring money to a charity organization. But the fact is - distress is relieved by cash in a disaster sense by providing medical care, water and blankets, and people to deliver them. Same way that raising children can't be done by doing nothing. Yes, child support might be less engaged, but that support is still...support. It helps.

I don't see how giving no money is of any use at all, and I don't see how talking about it in the same way you might talk about a movie - how much it affected you personally - is all that productive either. It's not about me. People can watch the news to see how it affected others.

I respond by making a donation, which I consider to be engaged as much as I can be engaged at a moment. I can't go to Haiti and do anything myself. I couldn't go to New Orleans when my own family was affected. I can however, at least make some effort to pay for someone's salary and the materials for those whose job it is to do such a thing - the Red Cross. They asked, I sent. But I worked to make the money, that work and time is transferred to them. It does represent some actual effort someone made at some point, enough for someone to pay you for it.

If you want to tell the Red Cross that their efforts are in vain because it's source is in money, good luck with that. I'll have to listen when they tell me that every bit helps. They should know. And I don't see who can determine the "real" value of that other than the Red Cross, who as far as I can tell, doesn't turn down pennies.

We can't "think" this well or talk this well. But by making a donation to the people whose job it is to handle things like this, who say "thank you, you make a difference" when you do...I will have to take their word for it.

The people who believe otherwise...I don't see why thought versus action makes someone more engaged in a real sense. Money is energy. A donation is a transfer of energy to help solve a problem, directed toward people whose job it is to solve that problem.

Are you "unengaged" if you pay someone to perform a service for another person?

The "keeping score" thing is not the point. The "do what you can and have someone else keep score" is my point.

But I see no sense to "Nothing matters, you feed someone for a day and the suffering continues." Try raising kids that way. Each meal, each bottle of water, each moment, small things...they matter, they count. You can't decide ahead of time that the energy you're going to dedicate must be meaningless. Hopefully it translates into moments that make differences in people's lives. You're facilitating change.

Sitting on your ass and bitching about how the world sucks is facilitating no change, no positive effects at all.
 
Last edited:
The least engaged of all responses is doing nothing. The strength of that argument makes no sense to me other than in some philosophical way that measures distress against cash. As if thinking and feeling really bad is somehow of more worth than action of transferring money to a charity organization. But the fact is - distress is relieved by cash in a disaster sense by providing medical care, water and blankets, and people to deliver them. Same way that raising children can't be done by doing nothing. Yes, child support might be less engaged, but that support is still...support. It helps.

I don't see how giving no money is of any use at all, and I don't see how talking about it in the same way you might talk about a movie - how much it affected you personally - is all that productive either. It's not about me. People can watch the news to see how it affected others.

I respond by making a donation, which I consider to be engaged as much as I can be engaged at a moment. I can't go to Haiti and do anything myself. I couldn't go to New Orleans when my own family was affected. I can however, at least make some effort to pay for someone's salary and the materials for those whose job it is to do such a thing - the Red Cross. They asked, I sent. But I worked to make the money, that work and time is transferred to them. It does represent some actual effort someone made at some point, enough for someone to pay you for it.

If you want to tell the Red Cross that their efforts are in vain because it's source is in money, good luck with that. I'll have to listen when they tell me that every bit helps. They should know. And I don't see who can determine the "real" value of that other than the Red Cross, who as far as I can tell, doesn't turn down pennies.

We can't "think" this well or talk this well. But by making a donation to the people whose job it is to handle things like this, who say "thank you, you make a difference" when you do...I will have to take their word for it.

The people who believe otherwise...I don't see why thought versus action makes someone more engaged in a real sense. Money is energy. A donation is a transfer of energy to help solve a problem, directed toward people whose job it is to solve that problem.

Are you "unengaged" if you pay someone to perform a service for another person?

The "keeping score" thing is not the point. The "do what you can and have someone else keep score" is my point.

But I see no sense to "Nothing matters, you feed someone for a day and the suffering continues." Try raising kids that way. Each meal, each bottle of water, each moment, small things...they matter, they count. You can't decide ahead of time that the energy you're going to dedicate must be meaningless. Hopefully it translates into moments that make differences in people's lives. You're facilitating change.

Sitting on your ass and bitching about how the world sucks is facilitating no change, no positive effects at all.
It's possible you've misread my OP. I'm not bitching about anyone, or judging one response against another. I'm noticing that in this case, for some reason, no one seems to be talking about 50,000 dead in Haiti. I'm not proposing 'talking about' as a superior response to anything else. I'm finding it odd how little of the national discourse seems to be about this, as compared to similar tragedies (during which, presumably, donations were also being made in large amounts). I don't have TV, so I wondered if perhaps it was being played down in a way that was signaling a smaller story than (I feel) it is.

That's all. You're fighting a beef that I don't have...
 
It's possible you've misread my OP. I'm not bitching about anyone, or judging one response against another. I'm noticing that in this case, for some reason, no one seems to be talking about 50,000 dead in Haiti. I'm not proposing 'talking about' as a superior response to anything else. I'm finding it odd how little of the national discourse seems to be about this, as compared to similar tragedies (during which, presumably, donations were also being made in large amounts). I don't have TV, so I wondered if perhaps it was being played down in a way that was signaling a smaller story than (I feel) it is.

That's all. You're fighting a beef that I don't have...

Okay, I'm just furthering Byron's and your discussion about how giving money is unengaged. I disagree with that way of thinking.

If you're not really monitoring media, then I guess you won't see it. My point is that the "conversation" is taking place and I see it all over the place, and I work at home. I don't think I've left the house since the hurricane but I've seen it everywhere. You can certainly find it if you look. Or if you...say...post it on a forum and people start talking to you. Just like other conversations, you gotta be there for it.

I think the way people have communicated has changed a great deal over the past several years, so you'll find a rich text medium where the "hang around the water cooler" thing has changed to following Twitter and checking in with friends' blogs.

If you're not connected to that, that's where it's certainly happening.
 
We aren't "throwing" stuff.

We're just friends, here, talking about things.

"America" is oblivious to our discussions.

I'm glad we're talking. And I'm glad you're alive so that we can talk. But your calculated, quasi-cynical, pseudo-practical, Steven Wright style-hipsterized, internet-powered indifference towards tragedy (that only exists because it's all conveniently outside of your direct world) isn't really impressing anyone. Or if it's supposed to impress someone, then, like the go-nowhere ongoing political discussions and fighting here, it's lost on this site.

Okay, I'm just furthering Byron's and your discussion about how giving money is unengaged. I disagree with that way of thinking.

If you're not really monitoring media, then I guess you won't see it. My point is that the "conversation" is taking place and I see it all over the place, and I work at home. I don't think I've left the house since the hurricane but I've seen it everywhere. You can certainly find it if you look. Or if you...say...post it on a forum and people start talking to you. Just like other conversations, you gotta be there for it.

I think the way people have communicated has changed a great deal over the past several years, so you'll find a rich text medium where the "hang around the water cooler" thing has changed to following Twitter and checking in with friends' blogs.

If you're not connected to that, that's where it's certainly happening.

Once again, I'm happy that you're here, Reci.
 
To the OP, I agree, not many people I know are talking about it. One of the guys that works for me only asked when I thought US Soldiers were going to start being killed by the people they are there to help.

I told them I didn't think that would happen considering we are they and only helping, not taking over their government. But in the end, I guess it's one in the same.

You live in LA, nobody talks about anything but themselves,....
 
Once again, I'm happy that you're here, Reci.

I'm happy to be here. And people with hearts on their shoulders ganking each other in Halo to raise money for Haiti...is not something I would have thought of myself.

Yup, all those horrible gamers who have no respect for human life, desensitized to everything...

Awwwww.
 
Nobody I know is talking about the Haiti earthquake. It's a massive and soul-sapping disaster. That may be partially why--too big to comprehend or talk about--but I don't even sense that pall that sometimes accompanies such things (at least when they happen at "home," even if the scale is smaller).

How is it playing on TV? Top story? "In other news...?"

Is it going to be another Katrina, where if I ask someone a year from now what the date and death toll was, they'll get that dumb punched-between-the-eyes look?

you must live under a rock, thats all Im hearing about!Its everywhere. news, NFL, front page of the paper, sheesh, where do you live?
 
Sonny L - our tv coverage is ongoing and detailed here in the UK. Other 'life' goes on, side by side, but that doesn't mean we don't think, talk, and act on what we're being shown.

I'm just an observer.

I don't contribute, nor do I subtract.

Pride is not a factor.

I appreciate what you and what other people do (Americans have already texted more money toward relief than Brown has promised), but what is terrible to me is that people believe that throwing money and aid at Haiti is going to somehow prevent the calamity that's just starting.

Obama has promised what... $100 million? Divide that amongst 2 million people, and that's $50 per person. "Oh, sorry your world was destroyed, but we're the US, and here's some rice and water to last you about a week. After that, we'll be more interested in the Super Bowl."
you do subtract. when you make sweeping statements like 'americans don't care' then you do so many people a grave injustice with your words.

how big is the US compared to Britain? I can't see the point of such ridiculous statements as you've made here. It's like a political 'distract the audience' tool. Stupid. And beneath you. Throwing money isn't about to prevent the calamity - but it might help bring about a swifter end to its course. People can only do what they can do - donations made now will not help prevent the rioting of a desperate, frustrated, shocked population waiting for physical aid that's taking more time then they have to reach them. But it will help in the longer run of things. Your posts feel as if there are only the US and Britain making contributions - they are flooding in from all across the globe because people DO care about other people in distress. Aid has to be coordinated. And that takes time. My thoughts are with those people trapped in an inhuman situation struggling to keep whatever remains of their families alive, and also for those trying to help with insufficient means and having to watch the death toll climb, and climb, and climb ...

express your cynicism as you wish, but please don't make such sweeping statements about the feelings of others wherever they live. It does you a disservice.
 
Where were your bleedin' hearts when Haiti really needed you?




They easily had as many dying skinnies as Somalia...
 
Last edited:
Where were your bleedin' hearts when Haiti really needed you?




They easily had as many dying skinnies as Somalia...

1: we cannot act on things we don't know about.
2: fuck off with the 'bleedin' hearts derogatory-ness. people can care without it being over the top, false, or a cynical display of faux grief for some imaginary kudos on a porn website. grow up.
 
Nobody I know is talking about the Haiti earthquake. It's a massive and soul-sapping disaster. That may be partially why--too big to comprehend or talk about--but I don't even sense that pall that sometimes accompanies such things (at least when they happen at "home," even if the scale is smaller).

How is it playing on TV? Top story? "In other news...?"

Is it going to be another Katrina, where if I ask someone a year from now what the date and death toll was, they'll get that dumb punched-between-the-eyes look?

We gathered donations at work. Several local charity groups have joined together and set up a relief station at a local warehouse. Accepting food, clothing, camping gear, etc..

Not much in the way of discussing the Haiti earthquake here. Simply sad looks and acceptance of Haitis sad state of affairs. Seeing it on the news and googling articles have greatly saddened some people I know.

As for me, I feel extremely fortunate and blessed not to be in Haiti.
 
1: we cannot act on things we don't know about.
2: fuck off with the 'bleedin' hearts derogatory-ness. people can care without it being over the top, false, or a cynical display of faux grief for some imaginary kudos on a porn website. grow up.


It's a false display motived by television.

It's the abandonment or reason.

"Every picture tells a story don't it!"

Same thing went down in Somalia, but once we took a few casualties the demand for action turned into, "What the fuck are we doing there?"

Black Hawk Down

Another picture, another day, another story...

:mad: :mad: :mad:

It'll be the same with Haiti.
It will take longer to build than N'Awlins,
But quicker to lose sympathy because the devil doesn't do a proper Mardi Gras...
 
Last edited:
See!???




Everybody gets a chance to put on their feel-good, I gave, I care badge for a week...

Not 5% of you know what life is like right now in Indonesia.

Where we USED to care for 15 minutes.
 
It's a false display motived by television.

It's the abandonment or reason.

"Every picture tells a story don't it!"

Same thing went down in Somalia, but once we took a few casualties the demand for action turned into, "What the fuck are we doing there?"

Black Hawk Down

Another picture, another day, another story...

:mad: :mad: :mad:

It'll be the same with Haiti.
It will take longer to build than N'Awlins,
But quicker to lose sympathy because the devil doesn't do a proper Mardi Gras...

i disagree with you 100% when it comes to individuals and their personal feelings on this. people DO care. some don't, as you've shown. politicians and the media will use, as always. to offer aid to fellow humans in distress is as natural as breathing for most of us. At what level will always depend on what else happens in our lives to eclipse its priority, but that's not the same as not caring at all. To try to help is better than to sit back and slate others for trying.
 
Back
Top