A Genuine First Amendment Issue

Bad form, but not a First Amendment issue, as several others have pointed out.

"In 2008, President Barack Obama booted three reporters from conservative newspapers off his campaign plane.

The campaign claimed there were only a limited number of seats on the plane for reporters, who would follow the then-candidate on the last four days of his presidential campaign.

Obama's camp didn't allow The Washington Times, the New York Post or the Dallas Morning News on the plane but allowed non-political media outlets such as Glamour and Ebony magazines to stay.

The three barred media outlets called foul play, but Obama's campaign responded by saying they allowed other media outlets, such as Fox News and The Wall Street Journal to stay, even though they'd been critical of Obama.

Friday's media ban was the first during Trump's official presidency. Given his current beef with the media, it likely won't be the last ban."


https://www.abc10.com/article/news/...ia-outlets-from-the-white-house/103-414543179

Various Presidents have had various beefs with specific outlets and individual reporters over the years. The easiest way to deal with it is the soft ban (just never consent to an interview with the outlet, never call the reporter). The link above also has a section and cross links the "rules of conduct" that journalists agree to to be part of the permanent press pool.
 
All evidence to the contrary of your every assertion notwithstanding.

To the specific issue: Tricky made this the issues when he tweeted on it. A question he does not like does not rise to the level of hatred and bitterness.

It was not CNN that engaged in lying to the electorate before the election.

LOON A T ICK
 
It wasn't a first amendment issue when Obama did it to an entire news organization, nor is this an example of a first amendment issue.
_________________________________________________________________

He didn't. He ATTEMPTED TO (see link from Judicial Watch below). While I don't agree with even an attempt to do so, there is a big difference between the two. Please be accurate if you are going to make a claim like that. Inaccuracies in such things lead to a persons credibility being suspect.

https://www.judicialwatch.org/press-room/press-releases/documents-show-obama-white-house-attacked-excluded-fox-news-channel/


_________________________________________________________________

Nothing in the first amendment requires anyone whether they be a public official or a private citizen to talk with a reporter or allow them individually or collectively access.

_________________________________________________________________

While there isn't any thing in the First Amendment to cover this particular situation, you would be comfortable with the situation if Obama had managed to kick Fox News out? And if not why not? They are both primarily the same. A double standard maybe?
You would support allowing a president (anyone of them) to pick and choose which news outlets can and can not cover stories from the white house? Remember if it's good for the goose it's good for the goosee.

________________________________________________________________
It was not a First Amendment issue when White House press pool begrudgingly admitted that Obama was in their view the least accessible president in their lifetimes.

Assuming that they were aware that they were going to get caught and the chilling effect that it would have spying on sharyl attkisson by the Obama Administration was in fact a First Amendment issue. As was the Obama Administration actually suing reporters in order to try to get their sources.
_________________________________________________________________

And of course you have a cite or link to support these assertions? And you're going to share it with us to rub it in our faces, right? Or are you going to pull the 'ol Ish dodge of 'I'm not doing your research for you'?
_________________________________________________________________

Try again. This time with some basic knowledge about what the First Amendment entails with relation to the press..

My only bias is to repudiate your (and anyone else's) ignorance of Constitutional law. It's damn near a full time job on this forum.

Damn near? Who do you think you're fooling? Most of the idjits here on the GB can't remember which way to correctly put on their underwear. They can't even be expected to understand complex issues like breakfast is the most important meal of the day, let alone grasp complex legal theory involving established principles they've heard every day of their entire lives.

Damn near a full time job my left eyeball. It takes a fully staffed government battalion of bureaucrats just to handle the daily overflow of ignorant GB tripe and you know it.

Testy, testy! Ya'll are getting a bit testy aren't you? Mayhaps the reason is for the last couple of years you've been trying to defend the indefensible? Or is it that your egos are starting to show through?

The question I have for you is this: If it's so damned frustrating talking to the ignorant uneducated masses here, why are you here? Why are you not on a forum more suited to your towering intellect? After all if you are so well versed in constitutional law, so much more intelligent then those here you're wasting your time and talents trying to teach mice to knit.

Or is it that you like thinking of yourself as a big fish in a little pond and are afraid to seek out those who are experts and much more learned in that field then you? Those who you can't put down as idjits and allow your over blown ego to ooze out in your posts?

So which is it? Or is it all of the above?


Comshaw
 
Branzburg v. Hayes

"We do not question the significance of free speech, press, or assembly to the country's welfare. Nor is it suggested that news gathering does not quality for First Amendment protection; without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press could be eviscerated."

and it goes on to say about the specific case at hand:

"But these cases involve no intrusions upon speech or assembly, no prior restraint or restriction on what the press may publish, and no express or implied command that the press publish what it prefers to withhold. No exaction or tax for the privilege of publishing, and no penalty, civil or criminal, related to the content of published material is at issue here. The use of confidential sources by the press is not forbidden or restricted; reporters remain free to seek news from any source by means within the law. No attempt is made to require the press to publish its sources of information or indiscriminately to disclose them on request."

But clearly the seeking of news is protected. We just have not had an asshat like Tricky Trumpy around to test it again in the SCOTUS.
 
“The Obama administration seems to have lied about its attempt to exclude Fox News Channel from access to an interview with the ‘pay czar.’ These documents show there is a pervasive anti-Fox bias in the Obama White House,” said Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton. “The juvenile Mafioso-talk in these emails has no place in any White House. For the Obama administration to purposely exclude a major news organization from access to information has troubling First Amendment implications.”
 
Good, give her time to learn her manners, obey instructions, and maintain the proper decorum in the White House.

Lmao, what a putz! Maybe your president should lead by setting an example instead of spouting lies and slander. As a republitard you probably overlook it but it needed to be said.
 

Testy, testy! Ya'll are getting a bit testy aren't you? Mayhaps the reason is for the last couple of years you've been trying to defend the indefensible? Or is it that your egos are starting to show through?

The question I have for you is this: If it's so damned frustrating talking to the ignorant uneducated masses here, why are you here? Why are you not on a forum more suited to your towering intellect? After all if you are so well versed in constitutional law, so much more intelligent then those here you're wasting your time and talents trying to teach mice to knit.

Or is it that you like thinking of yourself as a big fish in a little pond and are afraid to seek out those who are experts and much more learned in that field then you? Those who you can't put down as idjits and allow your over blown ego to ooze out in your posts?

So which is it? Or is it all of the above?


Comshaw


The worse Dump becomes, the testier his condescending self gets. It's as if he has become frustrated despite all the signs on the wall regarding his beloved president.


My God, I think it's beyond Dump. It's as if resigning to seeing the truth behind this malevolent "leader" means surrendering to the SJWs that he and his ilk oh so greatly despise with such malice.

#TheAnxiety

If he really wants to debate with people with similar political beliefs, he can simply hop on to Free Rep-blic, a site full of Republicans congregating with the same ideas. But that's just too easy! Nah, him and his boys simply wish to bitch to the "leftists" and stick it to them.
 
“The Obama administration seems to have lied about its attempt to exclude Fox News Channel from access to an interview with the ‘pay czar.’ These documents show there is a pervasive anti-Fox bias in the Obama White House,” said Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton. “The juvenile Mafioso-talk in these emails has no place in any White House. For the Obama administration to purposely exclude a major news organization from access to information has troubling First Amendment implications.”

*chuckle*

https://www.washingtonpost.com/life...4e693b38637_story.html?utm_term=.376f77fd5ab0

I do not remember the outrage when the Obama administration was going after the press...

If you want to fault President Trump for anything, it is once again, seizing upon Obama's precedents (you know, phone and pen, I cannot be a dictator, but I can act like one).
 
CNN reporter calls for banning phrase 'Fake News' after Capital Gazette shooting.

The CNN reporter the OP is referring to is Kaitlan Collins.

After a man with an alleged personal "vendetta" against the newspaper opened fire with a shotgun at the Capital Gazette, killing five people, a CNN White House reporter suggested the use of the term "fake news" had something to do with the heinous crime.

Collins' attempt to shift the blame to "the war on the media," has been echoed by several others on the Left, who point to one person in particular as the true culprit: Donald Trump.

The response to Collins' call for the banning of the term "fake news" was met with a variety of responses online, many of which pointed to the failure of the media for the proliferation of the phrase.
https://www.dailywire.com/news/32480/cnn-reporter-calls-banning-phrase-fake-news-after-james-barrett
 
*chuckle*

https://www.washingtonpost.com/life...4e693b38637_story.html?utm_term=.376f77fd5ab0

I do not remember the outrage when the Obama administration was going after the press...

If you want to fault President Trump for anything, it is once again, seizing upon Obama's precedents (you know, phone and pen, I cannot be a dictator, but I can act like one).

Obama or any POTUS would be wrong in doing the same thing. Unlike you I do not need a demagogue nor will I recognize or prefer an autocrat.

So why don't you just say you agree?
 
I don't see it as a First Amendment issue. The White House has not prevented or attempted to prevent the reporter from reporting or investigating any information that comes their way. The First Amendment in my view does not compel ANY administration to provide information or access, only the right to investigate and report news that comes their way. I feel that access to The White House is a privilege and not a right for the press.

Does anyone know when they started to have a full time press corp. stationed at The White House?
 
I don't see it as a First Amendment issue. The White House has not prevented or attempted to prevent the reporter from reporting or investigating any information that comes their way. The First Amendment in my view does not compel ANY administration to provide information or access, only the right to investigate and report news that comes their way. I feel that access to The White House is a privilege and not a right for the press.

Does anyone know when they started to have a full time press corp. stationed at The White House?

The SCOTUS does
 
Testy, testy! Ya'll are getting a bit testy aren't you? Mayhaps the reason is for the last couple of years you've been trying to defend the indefensible? Or is it that your egos are starting to show through?

It's the never ending partisan hypocrisy from the (D)'s who think their shit not only never has stank but never will.

Even when they do the exact same shit they condemn (R)'s for it's nothing but roses!

:rolleyes:
 
The SCOTUS does

I don't know this to be true. It is a very narrow view of the First Amendment. The press has the right to report what they view as the news but I know of no ruling that gives them undeniable access to The White House.
 
I don't know this to be true. It is a very narrow view of the First Amendment. The press has the right to report what they view as the news but I know of no ruling that gives them undeniable access to The White House.

Ain't that the truth.
 
"Shit" is a matter of degree

It's the never ending partisan hypocrisy from the (D)'s who think their shit not only never has stank but never will.

Even when they do the exact same shit they condemn (R)'s for it's nothing but roses!

:rolleyes:

No president in my lifetime has ever pulled so much "shit" on a daily basis as Trump.


You are simply too partisan to recognize the obvious, however.
 
No president in my lifetime has ever pulled so much "shit" on a daily basis as Trump.


You are simply too partisan to recognize the obvious, however.

Speaking of partisan...

The operative thing here is that short of Nixon and Reagan, no President has ever enjoyed as hostile a press as this one who on a daily basis look for molehills to turn into mountains. It's funny how people died in Fast&Furious and Benghazi, but our press, enthralled with their "black" president could find zero evidence of scandal even though people died, but every single day they can find another Trump scandal where no one has died. Even Mrs. Clinton got not just a pass on scandal for her offline electronics antics but a stolid defense that rose to the level of the defenses of her husband's sexual peccadilloes. It is with a bit of whiplash how quickly we went from it's his private life and between him and her only to it's proof that he is not of presidential "gravitas."
 
No president in my lifetime has ever pulled so much "shit" on a daily basis as Trump.

You must not have paid ANY attention to the last 3 assholes who have held his job/title/office.

Not the slightest shred of attention or critical thought given to the things they actually did.

You are simply too partisan to recognize the obvious, however.

I'm a liberal ideologue, not a republican partisan, get a clue....or a middle school civics class and a dictionary.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of partisan...

The operative thing here is that short of Nixon and Reagan, no President has ever enjoyed as hostile a press as this one who on a daily basis look for molehills to turn into mountains. It's funny how people died in Fast&Furious and Benghazi, but our press, enthralled with their "black" president could find zero evidence of scandal even though people died, but every single day they can find another Trump scandal where no one has died. Even Mrs. Clinton got not just a pass on scandal for her offline electronics antics but a stolid defense that rose to the level of the defenses of her husband's sexual peccadilloes. It is with a bit of whiplash how quickly we went from it's his private life and between him and her only to it's proof that he is not of presidential "gravitas."

He was a Democrat though!! That makes it progress!!!

Clinton even got caught red handed subverting democracy....NO PROBLEM.

Trump tells an unruly CNN employee to fuck off? OMG...the fucking sky is falling!!!:rolleyes:
 
Good, give her time to learn her manners, obey instructions, and maintain the proper decorum in the White House.

This is a typo? You meant "him" correct?

Because Trump doesn't have any manners, doesn't obey instruction and does not maintain proper decorum in the White House.
 
Back
Top