A Genuine First Amendment Issue

Thanks for the big laugh!!! We certainly would not want to do anything that would embarrass America in front of any diplomat from Europe!!! Trump is setting a great example for everyone on that score.

But like you say, there are no standards for behavior for this president...

If a Democratic president behaved the way this one does, you know how these righties would act. Their double-standards are amazing!

One of them created a thread stating "Now we have a CLASSY WH couple". I'm like, what the hell makes them so classy? Because they don't have DARK skin? Is that their definition of classy? :rolleyes:
 
Thanks for the big laugh!!! We certainly would not want to do anything that would embarrass America in front of any diplomat from Europe!!! Trump is setting a great example for everyone on that score.

But like you say, there are no standards for behavior for this president...

If only the Press Pool thought the same way you do...

You ever stop and think if it's possible the MSM is acting more like the National Enquirer than an actual news source?
 
You can bullshit yourself into that line of crap, but nobody who has observed the trend of your statements is buying it.

Then they need a basic civics course and an encyclopedia as bad as you do.

You'd be very hard pressed to find anything I've posted that's inconsistent with the liberal political philosophy.

Regarding your other statements on the equivalency among recent presidents, Trump is exceptionally divorced from telling the truth.

Not really....and it doesn't change the fact that the rest of them were at the end of the day, especially on the important things, totally full of shit, just like trump.
 
If only the Press Pool thought the same way you do...

You ever stop and think if it's possible the MSM is acting more like the National Enquirer than an actual news source?

Why in hell would I think that most news outlets would behave like the yellow journalism outlet National Enquirer, who are in Trump's back pocket?

Are you from Mars? Tell the truth, now...
 
Last edited:
Then they need a basic civics course and an encyclopedia as bad as you do.

You'd be very hard pressed to find anything I've posted that's inconsistent with the liberal political philosophy.

Not really....and it doesn't change the fact that the rest of them were at the end of the day, especially on the important things, totally full of shit, just like trump.

How you fancy your political philosophy means nothing in the context of your constant attacks on anyone who criticizes the constant pathological lying of the current president. You also try to hide your obvious partisanship behind the Holden Caufield-esque argument that "all the recent presidents were fucked up".

Like I said, early childhood development science emphasizes that one of the first concepts that needs to be taught in schools is making valid relative assessments, like which glass has more water in it and which behaviors are more destructive. I see now why your user name includes the word "boy".
 
Although Trump supports, and calls for, laws that would clearly violate the first amendment, this action doesn't. It does clearly go against the spirit, but that's different.


Good, give her time to learn her manners, obey instructions, and maintain the proper decorum in the White House.
:rolleyes:
You obviously haven't seen the video that clearly exposes the lies (as usual) of Trump and Sanders.

It's very clear that Collins was not the only reporter who hadn't left the room and was still asking questions.
Yet CNN was the only network barred from the later event.

Additionally, she was representing all the TV networks with the questions she was asking.
Apparently Fox had no issues with her questions, since they came to her defense.
 
Last edited:
Not really....and it doesn't change the fact that the rest of them were at the end of the day, especially on the important things, totally full of shit, just like trump.
:rolleyes:
No president in recent history has lied as often or as blatantly as Trump.

A couple recent examples:
Even the White House releases lie. The White House transcript of the Helsinki press briefing left out Putin saying he preferred Trump.
OK, maybe that's just trying to rewrite history, another hobby of Trump's.

Trump did lie in England when he said he predicted at Turnberry that the UK would vote in favor of brexit
Apparently he hoped no one would remember he arrived in Scotland the day after the vote.
attachment.php


Not to mention that he was too ignorant to know that if, in fact, they were going wild, it was because Scotland voted overwhelmingly to stay in the EU.

But that didn't stop Grisham, who was the communications spokesperson for the trip from doubling down on the lie when it was pointed out. :rolleyes:
attachment.php
 
:rolleyes:
No president in recent history has lied as often or as blatantly as Trump.

A couple recent examples:
Even the White House releases lie. The White House transcript of the Helsinki press briefing left out Putin saying he preferred Trump.
OK, maybe that's just trying to rewrite history, another hobby of Trump's.

Trump did lie in England when he said he predicted at Turnberry that the UK would vote in favor of brexit
Apparently he hoped no one would remember he arrived in Scotland the day after the vote.
attachment.php


Not to mention that he was too ignorant to know that if, in fact, they were going wild, it was because Scotland voted overwhelmingly to stay in the EU.

But that didn't stop Grisham, who was the communications spokesperson for the trip from doubling down on the lie when it was pointed out. :rolleyes:
attachment.php

YAWN!
 
How you fancy your political philosophy means nothing in the context of your constant attacks on anyone who criticizes the constant pathological lying of the current president.

Not anyone...the hystericals like yourself and carnal fart who try to make him out to be some autocratic Caligula-esque Hitler incarnate over every tiny thing the guys does.

There are plenty of valid criticisms of Trump, I've engaged in a good deal of it myself.

His being an autocratic Nazi just isn't one of them.

You also try to hide your obvious partisanship behind the Holden Caufield-esque argument that "all the recent presidents were fucked up".

What partisanship? Do you even know what that word means??

I don't support any parties. :)

Like I said, early childhood development science emphasizes that one of the first concepts that needs to be taught in schools is making valid relative assessments, like which glass has more water in it and which behaviors are more destructive. I see now why your user name includes the word "boy".

And relatively speaking what exact has Trump done that is as world ending, sky falling horrible as you and the other hysterical types try to make him out to be?

He casually lies and regularly says shit that is super offensive to leftist and occasionally offensive to pretty much everyone.....that's seriously all you've got.

That's the WORST he's dished out in comparison to other presidents.

He hasn't started any wars or military shit storms yet....like pretty much every other POTUS in living memory. He hasn't dropped anywhere near as many bombs on innocent brown folks or US citizens as Obama did or blatantly violated 4A like both Bush and O did with the PATRIOT act, not yet anyhow.

He hasn't been caught doing bidnizz for/with the cartels like Reagan and Obama.


I can go on but it's unnecessary, point is made. Trump is a twat, but he hasn't done a LOT of heinous shit we've let a lot of other POTUS's slide on. Yet every time he farts in some other country you and the hysterical brigade freak out about his blatant declaration of bio-chemical warfare upon our allies and THAT how he's like totally Hitler incarnate starting WWIII!!!! The guy can't smile and say "Good morning!" without you and yours behaving like he's coming to make you dig your own mass graves or something.

And of course anyone who doesn't buy every word of your hyperbole is a Republican partisan, white supermacist and Trump loyalist. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:
No president in recent history has lied as often or as blatantly as Trump.

So what?

Doesn't change the fact that the others did it enough effectively there isn't any real world difference.

All that hope and change has done WONDERS hasn't it?? LOL

Hope and Change!! It wasn't a damn bit different than MAGA....total fucking lie sold to the derps.


Mostly because POTUS isn't the god king the US electorate thinks he is, our congress is basically filled with lifetime service incumbents that are just worthless as tape worms and just as hard to get rid of.
 
The job requirements for President are defined in the US Constitution. - Anyone who is at least 35 years old, is a natural born citizen, and has lived in the United States for at least 14 years - can con his or her way into the White House.

There is no constitutional requirement the President be a nice guy - a convicted felon can run for President.

There is also no law that requires a White House Press Corps. Members of the Press are there by invitation.

Shill on, partisans. :party 0n:
 
Not anyone...the hystericals like yourself and carnal fart who try to make him out to be some autocratic Caligula-esque Hitler incarnate over every tiny thing the guys does.

There are plenty of valid criticisms of Trump, I've engaged in a good deal of it myself.

His being an autocratic Nazi just isn't one of them.


What partisanship? Do you even know what that word means??

I don't support any parties. :)



And relatively speaking what exact has Trump done that is as world ending, sky falling horrible as you and the other hysterical types try to make him out to be?

He casually lies and regularly says shit that is super offensive to leftist and occasionally offensive to pretty much everyone.....that's seriously all you've got.

That's the WORST he's dished out in comparison to other presidents.

He hasn't started any wars or military shit storms yet....like pretty much every other POTUS in living memory. He hasn't dropped anywhere near as many bombs on innocent brown folks or US citizens as Obama did or blatantly violated 4A like both Bush and O did with the PATRIOT act, not yet anyhow.

He hasn't been caught doing bidnizz for/with the cartels like Reagan and Obama.


I can go on but it's unnecessary, point is made. Trump is a twat, but he hasn't done a LOT of heinous shit we've let a lot of other POTUS's slide on. Yet every time he farts in some other country you and the hysterical brigade freak out about his blatant declaration of bio-chemical warfare upon our allies and THAT how he's like totally Hitler incarnate starting WWIII!!!! The guy can't smile and say "Good morning!" without you and yours behaving like he's coming to make you dig your own mass graves or something.

And of course anyone who doesn't buy every word of your hyperbole is a Republican partisan, white supermacist and Trump loyalist. :rolleyes:


1) I said nothing about Nazis. That's your straw man. I spoke of an unusual situation where a president has an extremely remote relationship with facts that are necessary to use as the basis for policy decisions.

2) If you think it is no big deal for a president to lie as much as this one, you have no ethical foundation.

3) Trumps actions are having real consequences: pissing off our allies, emboldening dictators who are killing their own people and carrying out wars of aggression, gutting environmental regulations, totally ignoring any action on climate change because he does not accept facts, inflaming conflict within our country, engaging in trade wars, compensating for his trade wars by giving out subsidies to a constituency he wishes to keep in his base, running up the deficit, favoring politically supportive religions over other religions, mischaracterizing certain ethnic groups, allowing himself and others to skim profits and inappropriate benefits from public service, and trashing consumer protection regulations.

If you can't see the significant difference between this corrupt idiot's actions and those of his predecessors, you are either extremely unperceptive or you indeed have a partisan agenda. Saying you are not partisan because you don't support either of the major parties is the same as Trump basing his decisions on lies. All that crap you said about supporting environmental regulation and open markets as a "liberal" ideologue is undermined by your lack of ethics and denial of reality.
 
Branzburg v. Hayes

"We do not question the significance of free speech, press, or assembly to the country's welfare. Nor is it suggested that news gathering does not quality for First Amendment protection; without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press could be eviscerated."

and it goes on to say about the specific case at hand:

"But these cases involve no intrusions upon speech or assembly, no prior restraint or restriction on what the press may publish, and no express or implied command that the press publish what it prefers to withhold. No exaction or tax for the privilege of publishing, and no penalty, civil or criminal, related to the content of published material is at issue here. The use of confidential sources by the press is not forbidden or restricted; reporters remain free to seek news from any source by means within the law. No attempt is made to require the press to publish its sources of information or indiscriminately to disclose them on request."

But clearly the seeking of news is protected. We just have not had an asshat like Tricky Trumpy around to test it again in the SCOTUS.

I don't see it as a First Amendment issue. The White House has not prevented or attempted to prevent the reporter from reporting or investigating any information that comes their way. The First Amendment in my view does not compel ANY administration to provide information or access, only the right to investigate and report news that comes their way. I feel that access to The White House is a privilege and not a right for the press.

Does anyone know when they started to have a full time press corp. stationed at The White House?

The SCOTUS does

You blithering idiot. Do you even have the slightest idea what legal principle Branzburg v. Hayes stands for? Pay the fuck attention:
408 U.S. 665

Syllabus

"The First Amendment does not relieve a newspaper reporter of the obligation that all citizens have to respond to a grand jury subpoena and answer questions relevant to a criminal investigation, and therefore the Amendment does not afford him a constitutional testimonial privilege for an agreement he makes to conceal facts relevant to a grand jury's investigation of a crime or to conceal the criminal conduct of his source or evidence thereof." Pp. 408 U. S. 679-709.

https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/408/665/

You're blubbering on about the First Amendment protecting news gathering and you pick a landmark case where the Supreme Court is clearly articulating a First Amendment protection the press DOESN'T HAVE -- namely the Constitutionally protected right to refuse to identify confidential sources when compelled to do so by a grand jury in a criminal investigation.

Why?

As Justice White wrote for the majority:

"The administration of a constitutional newsman's privilege would present practical and conceptual difficulties of a high order. Sooner or later, it would be necessary to define those categories of newsmen who qualified for the privilege, a questionable procedure in light of the traditional doctrine that liberty of the press is the right of the lonely pamphleteer who uses carbon paper or a mimeograph just as much as of the large metropolitan publisher who utilizes the latest photocomposition methods. Freedom of the press is a "fundamental personal right" which "is not confined to newspapers and periodicals. It necessarily embraces pamphlets and leaflets. . . . The press in its historic connotation comprehends every sort of publication which affords a vehicle of information and opinion."

Among the other "protections" the press does not have:

"The prevailing view is that the press is not free to publish with impunity everything and anything it desires to publish. Although it may deter or regulate what is said or published, the press may not circulate knowing or reckless falsehoods damaging to private reputation without subjecting itself to liability for damages, including punitive damages, or even criminal prosecution."

"A newspaper or a journalist may also be punished for contempt of court, in appropriate circumstances."

"It has generally been held that the First Amendment does not guarantee the press a constitutional right of special access to information not available to the public generally."

"Despite the fact that news gathering may be hampered, the press is regularly excluded from grand jury proceedings, our own conferences, the meetings of other official bodies gathered in executive session, and the meetings of private organizations. Newsmen have no constitutional right of access to the scenes of crime or disaster when the general public is excluded, and they may be prohibited from attending or publishing information about trials if such restrictions re necessary to assure a defendant a fair trial before an impartial tribunal."

Nice going, numbnuts. Cite a Supreme Court case the overall thrust of which undercuts the very point you're trying to make. :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::D:D
 
You're completely detached from reality if you think "there isn't any real world difference".

Then point it out....how have DJT's lies been worse than any others??


1) I said nothing about Nazis.

Maybe not but the pack you run with regularly does along with other hysterical bullshit like "autocrat" "dictator" and fascist.

2) If you think it is no big deal for a president to lie as much as this one, you have no ethical foundation.

But it's totally ok for presidents to lie 30% less.....:rolleyes:

Lying is either ok or it's not.

3) Trumps actions are having real consequences:

Never said they weren't....just that they aren't any less real than other POTUS's doing fucked up shit.

pissing off our allies,

What allies?? LOL we don't have any.

emboldening dictators who are killing their own people and carrying out wars of aggression,

I hate to tell you this but that's been going on since at least the early 70's.

That like everything else you listed isn't new and didn't start on 20JAN2017.

If you can't see the significant difference between this corrupt idiot's actions and those of his predecessors, you are either extremely unperceptive or you indeed have a partisan agenda.

Says the (D) partisan who can't tell me exactly why it's different from when your precious (D) does it. :rolleyes:

Saying you are not partisan because you don't support either of the major parties is the same as Trump basing his decisions on lies.

Uhhh no, you need to look up the definition of partisan, you clearly don't know what it means.

All that crap you said about supporting environmental regulation and open markets as a "liberal" ideologue is undermined by your lack of ethics and denial of reality.

How am I denying reality or lacking in ethics by not buying into a bunch of hysteria over Trump?

Further more how does that undermine my supporting environmental regulations and open markets? :confused:

You sound JUST like the teahaddist who couldn't convince me Obama was a Kenyan Communist coming to kill grandma in the night with his death panels.
 
Maybe not but the pack you run with regularly does along with other hysterical bullshit like "autocrat" "dictator" and fascist.

Dismissing my actual points by associating me with a pack is chickenshit.

You are extremely petty.
 
Well, for one, by the sheer number of them.

Ugh I hate defending giant balloon baby guy but really most of his lies are just self promotion and bragging. He's always been that way long long before he was even very well known. His whole business was based on his ability to build himself up into something he wasn't. He's actually pretty good at it or at least was before Google made it really easy to see he was full of shit. But habits die hard especially for geezers like him.
 
Ugh I hate defending giant balloon baby guy but really most of his lies are just self promotion and bragging.
Well, only because he talks about himself so much.
But when he does talk about the normal things presidents talk about, when he's actually saying something intelligible (as opposed to his typical repetitive rambling) he lies just as much there.

So to say it's mostly self promotion isn't saying much.
 
So let's cut to the chase.



Is the reporter in question in jail?
Is the reporter in question prohibited from publishing?
Has the reporter in question had her credentials diminished, or enhanced?


Is it a good thing to go from reporting on the story to being the story? Is this a Dan Rather moment? Turning a simple bloody nose into a war injury?
 
You blithering idiot. Do you even have the slightest idea what legal principle Branzburg v. Hayes stands for? Pay the fuck attention:


You're blubbering on about the First Amendment protecting news gathering and you pick a landmark case where the Supreme Court is clearly articulating a First Amendment protection the press DOESN'T HAVE -- namely the Constitutionally protected right to refuse to identify confidential sources when compelled to do so by a grand jury in a criminal investigation.

Why?

As Justice White wrote for the majority:



Among the other "protections" the press does not have:



Nice going, numbnuts. Cite a Supreme Court case the overall thrust of which undercuts the very point you're trying to make. :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::D:D

And you argue all the points not in question. Stay focused. Tricky Trumpy's deflection and mental gymnastics do not become you. I am sure you know that the content of the opinions and even dissenting opinions are used to shape future law. Right counselor?

The key is "We do not question the significance of free speech, press, or assembly to the country's welfare. Nor is it suggested that news gathering does not quality for First Amendment protection; without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press would be eviscerated." Which has been used by lower courts to find on the side of news gathering. It is how proceedings and records have been opened to the media.

In Richmond Newspapers Inc. v. Virginia the court found that the public and media have a First Amendment right to attend criminal judicial proceedings, which reinforces the idea that newsgathering is constitutionally protected. And in Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court, the Court noted that because the right to publish news depends on the ability of the media to gather information, restrictions on the right to gather news diminish the right to publish.. But in this instance we do not have even the issue of a special proceeding.

So it is fair to say and there is an argument to make that the denial of access or diminishment of the right to gather news is a diminishment of First Amendment rights of the person seeking to gather the information. In particular the prevention of news gathering because the POTUS does not want to be asked hard questions by a specific person. In fact, your pointing out the White's opinion for the majority only bolster's my point. She was in fact the "lonely pamphleteer" seeking to attend the news gathering event like all others around her and she was singled out and denied access.

When considering whether a constitutional presumption of access applies to particular proceedings or records, courts apply the “logic and experience test,” also called the “Press-Enterprise test.” The test considers “whether the place and process have historically been open to the press and general public,” and “whether public access plays a significant positive role in the functioning of the particular process in question.” Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court (1986) . Obviously in this case we have an event that is open to the press since all the other members fo the press were welcomed. After all it was a "press conference" ! It is not very difficult to apply logic and experience in this case.

We have never had such an information intensive society and culture in the history of the world and not since Gutenberg has media seen such a revolution. We also have never had such a liar as POTUS which makes truth-seeking by people all the more important and consequential.

So open up your confirmation bias as best you can, or stay a small and petty name-caller, but you cannot deny that the prevention of news gathering by a POTUS, any POTUS, particularly when they single out one person from attending an open news gathering event, is a genuine First Amendment issue.
 
And you argue all the points not in question. Stay focused. Tricky Trumpy's deflection and mental gymnastics do not become you. I am sure you know that the content of the opinions and even dissenting opinions are used to shape future law. Right counselor?

The key is "We do not question the significance of free speech, press, or assembly to the country's welfare. Nor is it suggested that news gathering does not quality for First Amendment protection; without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press would be eviscerated." Which has been used by lower courts to find on the side of news gathering. It is how proceedings and records have been opened to the media.

In Richmond Newspapers Inc. v. Virginia the court found that the public and media have a First Amendment right to attend criminal judicial proceedings, which reinforces the idea that newsgathering is constitutionally protected. And in Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court, the Court noted that because the right to publish news depends on the ability of the media to gather information, restrictions on the right to gather news diminish the right to publish.. But in this instance we do not have even the issue of a special proceeding.

So it is fair to say and there is an argument to make that the denial of access or diminishment of the right to gather news is a diminishment of First Amendment rights of the person seeking to gather the information. In particular the prevention of news gathering because the POTUS does not want to be asked hard questions by a specific person. In fact, your pointing out the White's opinion for the majority only bolster's my point. She was in fact the "lonely pamphleteer" seeking to attend the news gathering event like all others around her and she was singled out and denied access.

When considering whether a constitutional presumption of access applies to particular proceedings or records, courts apply the “logic and experience test,” also called the “Press-Enterprise test.” The test considers “whether the place and process have historically been open to the press and general public,” and “whether public access plays a significant positive role in the functioning of the particular process in question.” Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court (1986) . Obviously in this case we have an event that is open to the press since all the other members fo the press were welcomed. After all it was a "press conference" ! It is not very difficult to apply logic and experience in this case.

We have never had such an information intensive society and culture in the history of the world and not since Gutenberg has media seen such a revolution. We also have never had such a liar as POTUS which makes truth-seeking by people all the more important and consequential.

So open up your confirmation bias as best you can, or stay a small and petty name-caller, but you cannot deny that the prevention of news gathering by a POTUS, any POTUS, particularly when they single out one person from attending an open news gathering event, is a genuine First Amendment issue.

Steeped in your own confirmation bias, you'll never learn.:rolleyes:
 
Back
Top