A Mandate

That's not exactly all true.

If you draw any other type of monies and exceed some asinine minimum, you can't draw shit.:cool:

Yeah.... Granted, there are relatively few who fall into this category, but i would, ergo I'd rather do other stuff with my not-really-MY-money that I'm paying to SS.

On a BlackBerry...thumbs about to fall off.
 
As far as how the processes within the program work, I will be in your debt forever if you could explain in in 25,000 words or less.:cool:

Ha ha...I just meant that I'm aware that there's no SS account in my name somewhere and that it's essentially a give-a-penny-take-a-penny insurance program. I still think it blows.
 
I'm aware of this. I think that for many - the majority of Americans - SS is a necessary system that must be in place. I'm not suggesting that it should cease to exist (though I think it will eventually become bankrupt). I'm also not suggesting that workers (myself included) should stop funding the program; I do support moving a portion of the money I pay into a more secure (different) program.

I like your posts. One of the reasons that SS is increasingly at risk is the vast increase in the number of people considered disabled over the past few years. Outside the wars, what is the cause for this vast increase in the number of non-retirement age recipiants? Have the standards changed or are lawyers getting better at "gaming" the system for their and their clients benefit?

I also recognize that there are many people who are truly disabled but who had jobs (and would prefer to have jobs) but that now that jobs are dissappearing, they turn to social security. But there are seem to be (I haven't searched for empirical evidence) many more people who are perfectly able to work who are using SS as an alternative to productive work (and draining away the resources that would otherwise be used for baby boomers).

Is this right? wrong? what are your thoughts? How many more people can we afford to add to SS payments and keep it viable?

It also puzzles me that the SS is getting more demand than ever and is clearly at risk and the President is pulling a gimmic and reducing some of it's revenue through this temporary cut in the payroll tax. Isn't that extremely irresponsible?
 
Last edited:
The Republicans oppose a government mandate to the individual requiring the purchase of health insurance. I oppose that as well, but this thread isn't about health care policy (which is a simple matter of opening Medicare to all and means testing the premiums to be paid (but I digress)).

BUT - today I heard Newt talking about letting We the People put part of our Social Security payments into a private account that we could manage ourselves.

NOW THEREFORE - wouldn't that be an individual mandate to purchase a retirement plan?


Post exceeding 100 words will be deleted.
Cut and Pastes will be deleted.

As opposed to the individual mandate to be involved in a government retirement plan?


:confused:
 
No, Newt's plan WOULD be a mandate, and he's on record as opposing government mandates viz-a-viz health insurance.

What's the difference?

Newt's plan would be to let you control part of your federally mandated plan.

Also, he was for the HC mandate before he was against it.

So why would you use him for anything?

I wouldn't...
 
Newt's plan would be to let you control part of your federally mandated plan.

Also, he was for the HC mandate before he was against it.

So why would you use him for anything?

I wouldn't...

The thread started because I heard him blabbering on C-Span this morning and noted the contradictory positions.
 
The thread started because I heard him blabbering on C-Span this morning and noted the contradictory positions.

JUST NOW!!!!



:eek:



:D

"If a mandate was the solution, we can try that to solve homelessness by mandating everybody to buy a house."
Famous "Activist" Constitutional Law Professor Barack Hussein Obama, 2008
 
No, Newt's plan WOULD be a mandate, and he's on record as opposing government mandates viz-a-viz health insurance.

What's the difference?
A mandate is the government telling you what to do with your money.

Taxes are the government confiscating your money.
 
Back
Top