A Mother-in-law question

ahooohgah

Experienced
Joined
Apr 17, 2003
Posts
90
My mother-in-law is coming to live near us, or with us, in the near future, due to failing health. Here's the problem, condensed. She is obsessive-compulsive, (we think) and in denial about it. She has gotten some quotes from several professional movers, which nearly caused her early demise. Her kids, my wife and her brother and myself, are fully capable of moving her stuff with a U-Haul, and we are all willing to do just that, until we figure in the OC condition we all labor under. We know from experience that she will not allow anyone to just come in and move her stuff out. She will have to literally oversee and conduct the labor, with many warnings about the value of the stuff. She'll say "that's too heavy, let me help". Just generally be in the way. We will all be taking time away from work to do this, so as a practical matter, we will have to get on with the job and get it done in a timely manner, just like the pro movers would.

Here's what I proposed. I gave her two choices; one, hire the movers, or, two, we would do it, but only if she were to go somewhere else and just stay away while we worked. Of course she was insulted and thought it was absurd, but I thought it was the only way to help and still survive. I still think so.

I am concerend about our collective sanity if we try to do it with her in the house. I do want to be fair, and respectful of my elders, and help where I can and should. But where is that point where it becomes too much to handle? All of us have a fragile relationship with this woman already, and I'm afraid if we don't handle it delicately, it could harm things beyond repair.

What would you do?
 
Exactly what you did. Tell her that either she goes somewhere else and stays until the moving is done, or she hires the movers. Those are her choices.

I am hoping for your sanity and your marriage that she moves somewhere just close to you and not in with you.
 
Missingmeds said:
.... that she moves somewhere just close to you and not in with you.

Yeah, exactly! That's the way it's going to start out. Whether it stays that way or not, time will tell.

I've been working on toughening up my personal boundaries, and that's where the two choices came from. I can only choose my own actions, and I can allow her to choose hers. I used to allow her way too much liberty to control me, thinking I was being respectful, when in fact all it was was having weak boundaries. All that's changing now.
 
I think that you might survive this then. Just stand up for you and yours and don't worry about the rest.
 
Does she have any pets?

If so, you could talk about how they would be safer out of the moving environment. Of course, she would need to go with them and attend to them while things are being packed up and moved. Therefore, she feels needed and her babies would be safe.

Just an idea...

Best of luck to you!
 
ahooohgah said:
Yeah, exactly! That's the way it's going to start out. Whether it stays that way or not, time will tell.

I've been working on toughening up my personal boundaries, and that's where the two choices came from. I can only choose my own actions, and I can allow her to choose hers. I used to allow her way too much liberty to control me, thinking I was being respectful, when in fact all it was was having weak boundaries. All that's changing now.

I agree that you did absolutely the right thing by handing her choices. You have to protect your own sanity and the relationships of those around her. You chose a fair and diplomatic way of doing that.

She is going to fight it, no matter what you propose...simply because they are YOUR boundaries, not hers, and she's not used to anybody rocking the boat. No matter what choices you gave her, she would still balk. Just stick to your guns and be confident that you are doing what you have to do for YOU. And for her, since she will be the one who benefits most in the long run.

Good luck...and hang in there. :rose:

S.
 
ahooohgah said:
My mother-in-law is coming to live near us, or with us, in the near future, due to failing health. Here's the problem, condensed. She is obsessive-compulsive, (we think) and in denial about it. She has gotten some quotes from several professional movers, which nearly caused her early demise. Her kids, my wife and her brother and myself, are fully capable of moving her stuff with a U-Haul, and we are all willing to do just that, until we figure in the OC condition we all labor under. We know from experience that she will not allow anyone to just come in and move her stuff out. She will have to literally oversee and conduct the labor, with many warnings about the value of the stuff. She'll say "that's too heavy, let me help". Just generally be in the way. We will all be taking time away from work to do this, so as a practical matter, we will have to get on with the job and get it done in a timely manner, just like the pro movers would.

Here's what I proposed. I gave her two choices; one, hire the movers, or, two, we would do it, but only if she were to go somewhere else and just stay away while we worked. Of course she was insulted and thought it was absurd, but I thought it was the only way to help and still survive. I still think so.

I am concerend about our collective sanity if we try to do it with her in the house. I do want to be fair, and respectful of my elders, and help where I can and should. But where is that point where it becomes too much to handle? All of us have a fragile relationship with this woman already, and I'm afraid if we don't handle it delicately, it could harm things beyond repair.

What would you do?

I feel for you. It's difficult to deal with people with such conditions - just remember she's ill. I also deal with a close relative with OCD AND who is also narcisistic...bad combo. My startegy is to not get too involved in their everyday decisions...keep your distance (which sounds like you're doing), and not let their actions or words hit home too much.
 
Can't you just slip her a mickey and get everything done while she's passed out?
 
crazybbwgirl said:
Can't you just slip her a mickey and get everything done while she's passed out?

How bout me and you just go and split a mickey now? :)

What's yer pleasure?
 
GeOfLuViAl said:
How bout me and you just go and split a mickey now? :)

What's yer pleasure?


mmmmmm - pot! which I guess isn't really a micky - but it works!
 
That has every resemblance to a thread hijack.....maybe you two ought to go get a room.

My startegy is to not get too involved in their everyday decisions...

I try that on a normal everyday basis, but it won't exactly work here for this One Big Thing. I guess that's why I want to do it right.

sheath, there's more truth in this than you know!
simply because they are YOUR boundaries, not hers, and she's not used to anybody rocking the boat.
Her whole family is totally ignorant of boundaries....so it's up to little old me to teach her what I know about 'em, and it's a rude shock when I stand up to her. She looks like I've slapped her! But that's the way it's going to be, and has been for a few years now. This move, and these two choices I gave her are the first real test of our respective resolve. It's been little things up to this point.
 
Back
Top