Ask the physics student

Might be the wrong place for this, but a serious question:

What makes gravity?

I mean, I know what it is, but I never understood why.

Here's the way I explained it to a friend. In physics you have several formulations of dynamics, which describe the behavior of systems: Newtonian, Hamiltonian, and Lagrangian. Each of the formulations are functionally equivalent but depending on need, either may be more convenient to postulate for a given system. In Newtonian dynamics a system will remain at rest or constant relative motion unless acted upon by an outside force. This is equivalent to stating a conservation law, for instance the conservation of momentum. In Hamiltonian or especially Lagrangian dynamics this is stated at a least action principle. Which is to say, if a system is transformed from one state to another (or an object travels from one location to another) the time of transformation or of travel is minimized -- the action (a quantity of kinetic and potential energy) is made an extremal (min or max) value.

So how does this pertain to gravity? Newtonian conservation can be read as straight line motion unless acted upon by an outside force. Gravity is straight line motion in curved spacetime. The distribution and behavior of mass-energy determines the geometry of spacetime. Think of it as altering the distances between points. In high school Euclidean geometry the distances are given by the Pythagorean theorem. In Einsteinian physics this theorem is generalized for curved spacetimes. This is how one can say gravity is geometry. How you arrive at the equivalence principle between gravity and acceleration.
 
What's stronger...the Leidenfrost Effect, the Heisenberg Principle, the Peter Principle, the Durbin Amendment, Kirlian photography, the Pythagorean Theorem, Godwin's Law, Murphy's Law, Miranda Rights, Rule 34, Rule 63, Jacob's Ladder, Occam's Razor, Craig's List or Damocles' sword?

In my life it's usually Murphy's Law which prevails. Therefore it's the strongest.
 
How come we can put a man on the moon but can't put metal in a microwave?

Economic incentives. Though in the case of your kitchen appliance, there is a physics excuse for the rule. The metal is acting as an antenna for microwave energy, and generating an electrical current.
 
I wish to complete work without adding in the inconvenient bit about movement.

Please help.

What needs to be done is for 12 barn stalls to be mucked and for a load of hay to be thrown into the loft. I could really use some physics.
 
What made you want to major in physics?

I love the great, immortal cosmological questions. What is time or space? What is causation and how deep a role does it play in our universe? How is it there's something rather than nothing? These are the questions which drive me, and lead me to theoretical physics in general and quantum gravity in particular.
 
Here's the way I explained it to a friend. In physics you have several formulations of dynamics, which describe the behavior of systems: Newtonian, Hamiltonian, and Lagrangian. Each of the formulations are functionally equivalent but depending on need, either may be more convenient to postulate for a given system. In Newtonian dynamics a system will remain at rest or constant relative motion unless acted upon by an outside force. This is equivalent to stating a conservation law, for instance the conservation of momentum. In Hamiltonian or especially Lagrangian dynamics this is stated at a least action principle. Which is to say, if a system is transformed from one state to another (or an object travels from one location to another) the time of transformation or of travel is minimized -- the action (a quantity of kinetic and potential energy) is made an extremal (min or max) value.

So how does this pertain to gravity? Newtonian conservation can be read as straight line motion unless acted upon by an outside force. Gravity is straight line motion in curved spacetime. The distribution and behavior of mass-energy determines the geometry of spacetime. Think of it as altering the distances between points. In high school Euclidean geometry the distances are given by the Pythagorean theorem. In Einsteinian physics this theorem is generalized for curved spacetimes. This is how one can say gravity is geometry. How you arrive at the equivalence principle between gravity and acceleration.

attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Combination student loans and grants. My understanding is, graduate studies done properly, grants become proportionally more significant.

No high speed I'm asking how will you pay for the loans....you have to give that money back.

What are you going to do for money after school??
 
Why are quantum physicists so poor at sex?















A: Because when they find the position, they can't find the momentum, and when they have the momentum, they can't find the position.
 
No high speed I'm asking how will you pay for the loans....you have to give that money back.

What are you going to do for money after school??

Blood, sweat and tears. Though mostly tears.

Ideally I'd make my career in research at the university setting, although I see some form of professorship or lectureship in my future.
 
Why are quantum physicists so poor at sex?















A: Because when they find the position, they can't find the momentum, and when they have the momentum, they can't find the position.

I knew I liked you for a reason. :)
 
I wish to complete work without adding in the inconvenient bit about movement.

Please help.

What needs to be done is for 12 barn stalls to be mucked and for a load of hay to be thrown into the loft. I could really use some physics.

Sounds like what you need is not a physicist, but a day laborer. :)
 
Blood, sweat and tears. Though mostly tears.

Ideally I'd make my career in research at the university setting, although I see some form of professorship or lectureship in my future.

Right on :cool:
 
Are you going to the Irish Fair? Boiled in Lead, a good local band is playing Friday evening. Bus tickets are free.

I will be there, Wings will you be too?

That looks like a blast! I'm being taken out to celebrate my new job so I can't pass up a fancy meal. ;)


ETA: just sent the link to my peeps so I might go after! I'll let you know.
 
Last edited:
I like your style. Don't ever let the RWCJ or LWCJ get you down (not that I expect you would).

Thanks....keep on rockin in the free world. :cool:
http://images.wikia.com/uncyclopedia/images/0/0e/Windmill_headbanging.gif

Why is it so important to find the god damn particle?

What's it worth to answer some of humanities biggest questions? Perhaps pose new questions we never thought of before?

At any rate I think most outside the loony religious sects of society consider knowledge and understanding of the world we live in a worthwhile pursuit, to what monetary extent is another matter entirely.
 
Back
Top