Ask the physics student

Why should I ask a student these qestions when I can just as easily ask a graduate instead?

funny!


having said that, for an undergrad you have a pretty solid grip on your area of study. most undergrads don't tend to actually know much about what they're supposed to be learning about.
 
Respectfully, Miss Dolf: I think his answers are fine and I don't see anyone complaining about them stepping up to do better. :)


one doesn't have to be a fireman to notice that the guy supposed to be putting out the fire is spraying water on the wrong house. and you don't have to be a physics professor to feel that the answers you might be getting out of your lecturer aren't addressing your question.

i don't have a problem with the way he's answering questions either but that doesn't mean someone else might not feel differently.

the polarity in this thread mildly amuses me. half worshipful fawning, half outright hostility. young intelligent males are so rare on this board, i suppose that accounts for some of it.
 
Do you believe that the "end" of a black hole is the "big bang" of another universe, thus the universe is in a constant state of perfect "recycling" of itself, speaking of the truth in the conservation of matter?

If not, what do you believe is at the "end" of a black hole?

Except the matter doesn't actually go anywhere except the ultra dense mass at the center. So that kinda shit's on the whole black hole being a new universe bit. If they were big banging into a new universe they would loose their mass near instantly and create an relatively teeny tiny universe. For all their power they simply don't have the juice or mass to create a whole new universe. Not even the super massive black holes at the center of galaxies.
 
Last edited:
Theyre looking for God.


That's just how they packaged and sold it to the REPOHZ...they knew if it was presented simply for the pursuit of knowledge the REPOHZ would never give them funding so they had to throw some GAWWWD ALLMIGTAHHHHHH!!! at them to get their Jesus boners all hard over opening their wallets.
 
That's just how they packaged and sold it to the REPOHZ...they knew if it was presented simply for the pursuit of knowledge the REPOHZ would never give them funding so they had to throw some GAWWWD ALLMIGTAHHHHHH!!! at them to get their Jesus boners all hard over opening their wallets.

I'm thinking you might have something with this post..but then..maybe not. Whatever, any way to explain around that god damned God thing works for me.
 
he doesn't give very good answers.

They're good if you don't mind independently researching the terms and ideas he uses.

They're not good in the sense of trying to teach someone how to sharpen a pencil if they don't even know what a pencil is.

It's to be expected considering the fact that he's still in the early stages of learning these things for himself, much less teaching them to others.



Thank you.

having said that, for an undergrad you have a pretty solid grip on your area of study. most undergrads don't tend to actually know much about what they're supposed to be learning about.

You're not talking to me, are you?


one doesn't have to be a fireman to notice that the guy supposed to be putting out the fire is spraying water on the wrong house. and you don't have to be a physics professor to feel that the answers you might be getting out of your lecturer aren't addressing your question.

This.
 
Last edited:
John Doe said:
You're not talking to me, are you?

yeah, i was saying for an undergrad OP seems to have a good grip on what he's learning. then again, undergrads are pretty good at faking it...heh.


you, i already know are well read.
 
yeah, i was saying for an undergrad OP seems to have a good grip on what he's learning. then again, undergrads are pretty good at faking it...heh.


you, i already know are well read.

The internet makes every undergrad a PHD. A room without wifi returns them to 101.
 
yeah, i was saying for an undergrad OP seems to have a good grip on what he's learning. then again, undergrads are pretty good at faking it...heh.


you, i already know are well read.

:) :rose:
 
Bullshit to the God hunt.

They call the Boson Particle the God Particle....or did. I mean a rose smells just as sweet regardless of whether you call it GOD, BOSON, or HILLARY. The Quest is the search for the impulse.

Feynman warned of it. How do you account for the switch from OFF to ON?
 

Want to take a crack at climate sensitivity?




It may be possible to calculate how CO2 behaves in laboratory conditions and hence to calculate a theoretical warming in relation to increasing CO2 levels in laboratory conditions. But that is not the real world.

In the real world, increased concentrations of CO2 would theoretically block a certain proportion of incoming solar insolation so that less solar radiance is absorbed by the ground and oceans, and it would also increase the rate of out going radiation at TOA. Both of these are potentially cooling factors. Thus the first issue is whether in real world conditions the theoretical laboratory ‘heat trapping’ effect of CO2 exceeds the ‘cooling’ effects of CO2 blocking incoming solar irradiance and increasing radiation at TOA and if so, by how much? The second issue is far more complex, namely the inter-relationship with other gases in the atmosphere, whether it is swamped by the hydrological cycle, and what effect it may have on the rate of convection at various altitudes and/or whether convection effectively outstrips any ‘heat trapping’ effect of CO2 carrying the warmer air away and upwards to the upper atmosphere where the ‘heat’ is radiated to space. None of those issues can be assessed in the laboratory, and can only be considered in real world conditions by way of empirical observational data.

The problem with making an assessment based upon observational data is that it is a hapless task since the data sets are either too short and/or have been horribly bastardised by endless adjustments, siting issues, station drop outs and polluted by UHI and/or we do not have accurate data on aerosol emissions and/or upon clouds. Quite simply data sets of sufficiently high quality do not exist, and therefore as a matter of fact no worthwhile assessment can be made..

The nub of the issue is that it is simply impossible to determine a value for climate sensitivity from observation data until absolutely everything is known and understood about natural variation, what its various constituent components are, the forcings of each and every individual component and whether the individual component concerned operates positively or negatively, and the upper and lower bounds of the forcings associated with each and every one of its constituent components.

This is logically and necessarily the position, since until one can look at the data set (thermometer or proxy) and identify the extent of each change in the data set and say with certainty to what extent, if any, that change was (or was not) brought about by natural variation, one cannot extract the signal of climate sensitivity from the noise of natural variation.


”Quantifying climate sensitivity from real world data cannot even be done using present-day data, including satellite data. If you think that one could do better with paleo data, then you’re fooling yourself. This is fine, but there is no need to try to fool others by making extravagant claims.”



We do not know whether at this stage of the Holocene adding more CO2 does anything, or, if it does, whether it warms or cools the atmosphere (or for that matter the oceans). Anyone who claims that they know and/or can properly assess the effect of CO2 in real world conditions is being disengenuous.
 
I've always been under the perception that the Earth, was once a Sun itself, cooling and crusting, with moss, sweat and bacteria forming. I mean what makes some hot and others not. Seems to me, one great explosion created many different symmetrical particles, am I close, in my train of thought?
 
Respectfully, Miss Dolf: I think his answers are fine and I don't see anyone complaining about them stepping up to do better. :)
Who else started a thread saying that they would?
False advertising.

They're good if you don't mind independently researching the terms and ideas he uses.

They're not good in the sense of trying to teach someone how to sharpen a pencil if they don't even know what a pencil is.

It's to be expected considering the fact that he's still in the early stages of learning these things for himself, much less teaching them to others
No, if I asked him to sharpen a pencil his reply was "well there's wood and graphite and plastic and a blade."

No shit, sherlock!
 
I've always been under the perception that the Earth, was once a Sun itself, cooling and crusting, with moss, sweat and bacteria forming. I mean what makes some hot and others not. Seems to me, one great explosion created many different symmetrical particles, am I close, in my train of thought?

Not really, no.

But it's bits of suns. Sort of.
 
Who else started a thread saying that they would?
False advertising.

So you want him to make a qualifier "Ask the physics student and I'll do the best I can to answer. My answers won't be perfect but I'll try my best."?? :confused: I mean, I don't think I'm being too generous to go "Yeah, his answers aren't perfectly detailed, in layman's terms, and backed up with mountains of citations but they're fine." Again, if you think his answers are bad, why don't you answer the questions better, if you can?
 
So you want him to make a qualifier "Ask the physics student and I'll do the best I can to answer. My answers won't be perfect but I'll try my best."?? :confused: I mean, I don't think I'm being too generous to go "Yeah, his answers aren't perfectly detailed, in layman's terms, and backed up with mountains of citations but they're fine." Again, if you think his answers are bad, why don't you answer the questions better, if you can?

Dolfy is simply upset that someone else is garnering attention.
The life of an attention whore is never easy.
 
I've always been under the perception that the Earth, was once a Sun itself, cooling and crusting, with moss, sweat and bacteria forming. I mean what makes some hot and others not. Seems to me, one great explosion created many different symmetrical particles, am I close, in my train of thought?

Is this a joke?
 
So you want him to make a qualifier "Ask the physics student and I'll do the best I can to answer. My answers won't be perfect but I'll try my best."?? :confused: I mean, I don't think I'm being too generous to go "Yeah, his answers aren't perfectly detailed, in layman's terms, and backed up with mountains of citations but they're fine." Again, if you think his answers are bad, why don't you answer the questions better, if you can?
please specify the flaws in the question. if you can.
 
Back
Top