Ask the physics student

It is the equivalent of the Sports Speak in the locker rooms before and after events.

We have to play our game.
We have to do the little things right.

:rolleyes:

Fuck. Whatever. If you don't know you don't know.

Still, engineers know how to deal with that shit.
 
"I don't know."

I firmly believe admitting ignorance can be a solid foundation for further inquiry, since it can force us to question our assumptions. But just saying "I don't know" is a cheap answer here to what was a sincere question. Sometimes you can honor a question just by framing it.
 
I like this thread and have learned a lot. Probably will take me until you finish your masters to come up with a worthwhile question for you though. :)
 
I like this thread and have learned a lot. Probably will take me until you finish your masters to come up with a worthwhile question for you though. :)

Thanks! At some point I'll have more to say about my confusing answers, but I'm glad to hear even a few people are enjoying the thread.


Sweet .gif. IMO Daniel Craig gives Sean Connery a run for his money as Bond.

The spiral of a bore imparts a spin to an exiting bullet. A spinning bullet is more aerodynamically stable in flight (a ballistic trajectory), which produces more accurate shots. Think of a football -- American football -- spinning about the axis of its flight versus a tumbling football.
 
What's the difference between Max Factor and Quantum Theorist?









Max Factor has models that work
 
How does an implosion of a dying star become an explosion?

Holy moly, a detailed answer to your question is above my pay grade; stellar dynamics are perhaps surprisingly intricate and still very much an active area of research. But I can still offer a hazy explanation for the process which generates a supernova explosion from core collapse.

When a star collapses under its own gravitational potential it is doing so as it exhausts the fuel of its fusion processes which counterbalance that gravitational potential. As a star then collapses its interior, under the core collapse model, it will achieve a critical energy-density state in which the star will experience runaway fusion, especially helium fusion. There are various stellar processes in which a significant portion of the star's mass will be converted into neutrinos (light, chargeless particles which rarely interact with matter) which are then captured at the outer layers of the star. This neutrino capture continues, forming a shock wave as the neutrinos collect into a backlog, until another critical state forms when sufficient energy has been collected via neutrino capture, and the outer layers of the star are expelled in a violent explosion.
 
Last edited:
Do you believe that the "end" of a black hole is the "big bang" of another universe, thus the universe is in a constant state of perfect "recycling" of itself, speaking of the truth in the conservation of matter?

If not, what do you believe is at the "end" of a black hole?

Yes and No.

Black holes serve to compact the matter of this universe to a singular point, so that there can be the 'next' Big Bang for this universe as it recycles itself. Not some 'other' universe.
 
I think it's safe to say for the time being there exists only speculation and informed hypothesizing on what pertains within the interior of an event horizon in general, and at the singularity in particular of a black hole. The conditions which obtain within a black hole's event horizon are extreme in the sense of both being highly energetic and confined across scales of distance, which implies both pillars of theoretical physics -- quantum physics which obtains across small scales, and general relativity which obtains at large energies and cosmological scales -- are necessary to properly model a black hole's interior. So until a proper quantum gravity theory has been formulated, and our confidence in this theory is appreciated, we'll necessarily have a wanting understanding of black holes.

My suspicion is, once we're able to model black hole physics with quantum gravity, we'll find there are processes which intervene and prevent matter from collapsing into singularities. That at the heart of black holes exists a novel state of matter similar to "quark-gluon plasmas." But I won't burden you with plasmas unless you're desiring it.

I realize in some sense this must be an unsatisfying answer. But I can also tell you the baby universe conjecture you're asking about is generally considered a toy model. It might be valid, but there's nothing necessarily in the physics which would lead us to believe it's true. A related issue you might be interested in is the black hole information paradox, which pertains in a sense to the conservation of information in the universe. It was supposed information thought to be destroyed by black holes could instead "leak" into other universes, thereby being conserved.

Hm. I have to disagree with that. After all, scientists state that the "beginning" of our universe was a singular(ity) point of infinitely compressed matter that suddenly expanded, leading now into what we now see as our observable universe.

If the matter at the "end" of a black hole is infinitely compressed, that sounds, to me at least, like it matches REALLY well with that theory.

After all, it's said that entropy will ultimately be the downfall of this universe, but Nature has a way of seeming to find a way to constantly renew Herself. I think this is the way the universe does it.

By compressing -some- matter so tightly that it becomes a singularity, it can then create another universe on the other side so that something always exists. Nature Abhors a Vacuum.
 
Last edited:
Ah, Al and Beth were married, not Sam.


That was a very good show.
 
What shows do you equate? I apparently need to update my tv watching.
I don't watch them all but shows that are considered to be among the very best and currently still airing are:

Breaking Bad
Walking Dead
Mad Men
House of Cards
Game of Thrones
Under the Dome
Parks and Rec
Hannibal
Dr. Who
Duck Dynasty

Those are ones I'm aware of. Many shows that I don't know at all are popular and critical hits.
They're all over the place channel-wise, too. From premium to basic cable to network.
 
My son saw something where he thinks that if the sun just disappeared we'd be able to live for a few years on residual foodstuffs, but I think that's kinda bullshit.

If the sun didn't go nova or nothin', but just ceased to be (a wizard did it) what happens? No gravity well means no orbit, right?

Do we collapse in on the vacuum or spin out into space with our residual foodstuffs?
 
Back
Top