Ask the physics student

I appreciate how it must seem there is some reflexivity between a black hole's singularity, and the singularity of the big bang. If Nature provides for some inflationary mechanism at a black hole's singularity, as it seems to have provided in the early moments of our universe, then surely the physical motivation exists for that inflationary mechanism to produce a baby universe from a black hole singularity, expanding into some higher dimensional space perhaps. But I still have my doubts, first because we cannot yet say whether singularities actually exists either at the hearts of black holes, or at the moment prior to the inflationary epoch of our early universe, and second because singularities are mathematically pathological and should indicate some shortcoming with the theory.

There is a neat side discussion about both black holes and cosmology. The event horizon of a black hole scales with its mass in such a way that its density within the event horizon falls as the black hole becomes more massive. Some physicist, I forget who, applied this relationship to cosmological scales, and found that our universe appears strikingly like a sufficiently massive black hole.

I sincerely doubt we'll have the technology/math to figure out what's really going on inside black holes in my lifetime. Damn my fragile mortal shell! :( It makes me want to go full cyborg so I can live long enough to see if we can ever get to FTL travel and study one "up close" (relatively speaking).
 
OK so that was more interesting. So forget about the tax payer.

What is the fundamental incompatibility of quantum physics and general relativity? And why is time an illusion?

Between quantum physics and general relativity theory is a landscape rife with conflict, and properly enumerating those conflicts would be the subject of volumes. If you’re willing to make the investment of time, I have begun reading Physics Meets Philosophy at the Planck Scale, which consists of a collection of essays on the physical and philosophical motivation underlying quantum gravity theories. Quantum physics and general relativity are fundamentally incompatible; either mode contains natural constants and important relationships not respected by the other. Here is one good example.

In general relativity there is the principle of general covariance. There is a formal mathematical definition of this principle, having to do with the formulation of the theory using the language of tensor calculus which is coordinate independent. But more important for our purposes is its physical and philosophical content. General covariance can be read as implying the independence of frames of reference, of observers, from any particular coordinate system. Which is to say, as long as our spacetime manifold consists of the same collection of events, it matters not how we define our spacetime geometry.

But connecting events are sequences of dynamic trajectories. If we identify a connection between two events in which a ballistic object intercepts two observers, and further identify a third party which observes these intersections by means of exchanged signals, we have identified the events which define our local spacetime manifold, by way of example. Relativity postulates the relativity of simultaneity, so what one observer perceives as an event occurring prior to some other event, such as the intercept of the ballistic object by one observer then the other, is accounted for by the relativity of simultaneity. This may occur when the signal of an intercept by the ballistic object with the first observer arrives at a second observer after its intercept with the second observer.

But in quantum physics our dynamics are now uncertain. In the quantum physics measurements such as those of distance and time are recorded as observables which are ad hoc extracted from the model of whatever system we are considering. These observables are nonabelian, which is to say they obey the uncertainty principles attributed to Heisenberg. For any two "conjugate" observables there exists a minimal uncertainty in their value.

When you attempt to rectify a spacetime manifold in the face of nonabelian observables, you find yourself in the awkward position of failing the test of general covariance. How can you construct a set of events when your observers cannot even agree upon what is or is not an event? Nevermind that the sequence of those events is now arbitrary to uncertainty? This should give a more robust explanation for the problems introduced to causality by quantum physics. It also shows why the problem of quantum gravity can seem so intractable: a quantum gravity theory must account for these incompatibilities and be consistent in its postulates, but it also must accommodate the vast body of evidence which supports both quantum physics and general relativity.

Aside from not having a truly proper quantum gravity theory, the nature of time also depends on what theory you ask the question. For quantum physics it is both an independent parameter and a physical observable. For general relativity it is one component of the spacetime manifold, and a symmetry exists between it and the spatial dimensions. One can hear a physicist say what we perceive as the passage of time is merely an artifact of our memory, that past, present and future exist as regions of spacetime determined by the light cone of observers. Physicist Lee Smolin has offered his explanation for much of the difficulty in formulating a quantum gravity theory has to do with our improper treatment of time. Some theorists would reify time, others would banish it as illusory or approximation. My own sense is time is a "random walk" between quantum states.
 
Last edited:
Why is stupid able to move faster than light? More than once I can tell that the stupid in some posts was there long before the words made it to the screen.
 
Why is stupid able to move faster than light? More than once I can tell that the stupid in some posts was there long before the words made it to the screen.

The stupid force is carried by stupid tachyons, which always travel at the speed of light and cannot decelerate below it.
 
satindesire, I'll return this (my) evening for more posts to you and others. In the meantime, thank you for your thoughts!



Yes I did! I remember watching as a kid the wide eyed bewilderment of Thomas Edison at the small light bulbs of the future world. Scott Bakula was wonderful for the part, conveying both determination and the sense that he was often out of his depth. Fun show!

By the way, I've heard conflicting reports about whether the Mississippi makes winters along it more temperate. Do you know? I'm a Florida boy, and the thought of another long winter is not a nice one.

Oh babe, I live literally on the bank of the Mississippi and I don't believe it makes the winters here any more temperate. Living on Lake Superior or Lake Michigan does alter the weather but the river just isn't wide enough up here to make a shift in the weather patterns. However, I can say this, summer storms tend to go around the river which I find fascinating. You can watch them break up right before they hit us then gather steam right after they've gone by.
 
Oh babe, I live literally on the bank of the Mississippi and I don't believe it makes the winters here any more temperate. Living on Lake Superior or Lake Michigan does alter the weather but the river just isn't wide enough up here to make a shift in the weather patterns. However, I can say this, summer storms tend to go around the river which I find fascinating. You can watch them break up right before they hit us then gather steam right after they've gone by.

Well damn, that stinks on two counts. Looks like I'll be on the opposite side of the Mississippi from you, and not only are my hopes for a temperate winter dashed, but you're also telling me thunderstorms are going to skirt around? Central Florida was the best for a lightning show. The sea breeze fronts from the Gulf and Atlantic would collide over the interior and put on something spectacular.
 
Well damn, that stinks on two counts. Looks like I'll be on the opposite side of the Mississippi from you, and not only are my hopes for a temperate winter dashed, but you're also telling me thunderstorms are going to skirt around? Central Florida was the best for a lightning show. The sea breeze fronts from the Gulf and Atlantic would collide over the interior and put on something spectacular.

They either skirt or the drop golf ball sized hail.
 
My son saw something where he thinks that if the sun just disappeared we'd be able to live for a few years on residual foodstuffs, but I think that's kinda bullshit.

If the sun didn't go nova or nothin', but just ceased to be (a wizard did it) what happens? No gravity well means no orbit, right?

Do we collapse in on the vacuum or spin out into space with our residual foodstuffs?
The earth would go flying off into space and we would all freeze in the dark in short order.
 
The earth would go flying off into space and we would all freeze in the dark in short order.

Isn't it nice to be right about the important things. "No, honey, you wouldn't linger for three years. No hope. You should keep a gun ready, nobody needs to go through that."

Mostly my argument was about the science, but I'm tough on the hope when it isn't warranted.
 
There have been long periods with no sun and people survived then, mainly off food storage and the oceans. However, there are now probably too many people and not enough accessible ocean life, plus we don't all live near it.
 
Oh babe, I live literally on the bank of the Mississippi and I don't believe it makes the winters here any more temperate. Living on Lake Superior or Lake Michigan does alter the weather but the river just isn't wide enough up here to make a shift in the weather patterns. However, I can say this, summer storms tend to go around the river which I find fascinating. You can watch them break up right before they hit us then gather steam right after they've gone by.

I heard there was sort of a heat dome over the cities which helped moderate storms, it doesn't seem to effect the temperature however.
 
There have been long periods with no sun and people survived then, mainly off food storage and the oceans. However, there are now probably too many people and not enough accessible ocean life, plus we don't all live near it.

No sun means the sun is there, you just can't see it.

NO SUN in this case means...sun gone. Ambient heat gone, gravity well gone. I'm assuming without tides, without heat, without a gravity well, we're essentially fucked in short order.
 
I heard there was sort of a heat dome over the cities which helped moderate storms, it doesn't seem to effect the temperature however.

I believe it! I'm sure you've watched the radar when storms move through, it fascinates me, breaking up right before it reaches us.
 
How does an implosion of a dying star become an explosion?
^ Most fun question of thread.

There are four fundamental forces postulated by physics' Standard Model: Strong nuclear, weak nuclear, electromagnetic, and gravity. The first three operate on the scale of subatomic particles. But gravity, at that scale, is too weak to have any effect. If you get enough mass together, something on a scale of the earth for example, then its effect is evident. You can't jump off it. All chemical compounds are molecules which consist of atoms of different elements. Atoms consist of a nucleus, containing protons and neutrons, while electrons spin around the nucleus at various distances in different patterns depending on their energy level. Protons have a positive charge, electrons are negative, and neutrons have no electrical charge. Atoms generally have the same number of electrons as protons, and it's the electromagnetic force that holds the electrons in orbit around the nucleus. Protons and neutrons are made up of quarks. A proton is two "up" quarks and one "down" quark, a neutron is two downs and one up. The up quark has a +2/3 electrical charge, and the down quark has a -1/3 charge. So, the neutron's charge is the sum of -1/3 -1/3 +2/3, or zero, and the proton's is +2/3 +2/3 -1/3, which sums to one. (There are quarks of greater mass than up and down, which don't occur often in nature because of how rapidly they decay, the high energy levels need to produce them.)

Three fundamental forces, electromagnetism, gravity, and the weak force, decay as distance increases between the particles they act on. The strong force increases with distance, and it is this force that holds quarks together in pairs (mesons), or triplets (hadrons), protons and neutrons being the naturally occurring examples of hadrons. Free neutrons are not stable, but protons are, and because they are electrically charged, they can be accelerated by magnets in a circulular vacuum tube like the Large Hadron Collider. Because the strong force increases as quarks are pulled apart, eventually the energy required to pull them further apart becomes greater than the energy required to produce a new particle pair, and matter is created from energy between the two particles. The greater the energy input, the greater the mass of the particles created, and this is how colliders create exotic particles like strange quarks, charm quarks, and so on, and by observation of how these particles interact and decay, the rules that govern the universe can be deduced.

What does this have to do with stars? I was hoping you'd ask that. At the beginning of the universe, it is thought that there was only one fundamental force. As the universe expanded and cooled, the forces differentiated into four. Gravity was the first to split from the others, then the strong force, and finally the weak and electromagnetic force split. It is understood how the last three are related and at what point they split but because gravity became a separate force so early, and doesn't interact at the quantum level, how it relates to the others isn't understood. A theory which integrates gravity with the other forces is the Holy Grail of Physics. The strong force is by far the strongest but its range is short, since beyond about the diameter of a nucleus, its strength is so great that the energy to push past it creates more matter. The electromagnetic force is 1/137th as strong, but its range is infinite, decreasing over distance. The weak nuclear force is one millionth the strength of the strong force, and its range is only one-thousandth the width of a proton. Gravity's range is infinite, but its strength is only 0 point (imagine 39 zeros here) 6 times as strong as the strong force. Although gravity is the weakest force by far, at accumulations of matter the magnitude of solar masses, it gets to play with the others.

On the astronomical scale, only larger stars have the mass necessary to create black holes. When they're burning, they are giant fusion reactors, the gravitational pressure in their interiors fusing light elements into heavy ones and creating heat which keeps gravity at bay. Initially, and for smaller ones like our sun, stars fuse Hydrogen into Helium, larger ones fuse Helium into elements like Oxygen and Carbon, and very large stars (over 8 times the size of our sun) enter the Silicon burning sequence which lasts only a day and ends with Nickel. Each step in this fusion process yields less energy than the one before until with Nickel and Iron, any further fusion requires an input of energy, and the core of a star of that size becomes a victim of gravity. Gravitational pressure overcomes the Electromagnetic force, causing the electrons of the core to combine with the protons of the atoms' nuclei making neutron soup and release vast quantities of energy which blow away the star's outer layers in a spectacular display we call a Supernova.

For even larger stars, 15 times the size of our sun or more, gravity is so strong that there is no explosion. Gravity overcomes the strong nuclear force, the quarks can no longer maintain themselves as neutrons, and they are crushed into who knows what, because man, they're gone. All that's left is a black hole where a star used to be.

A rude exit certainly, but what can ya do?

At least they still have the courtesy to radiate.
 
Last edited:
Ok I'll bite.
Oxigen feeds flame right.
Hydrogen boom right.
exsplain H2O
Why isn't the planet engolfed in flame.

I know it's the way the molicules are arranged but still.
 
I was engolfed once, I hit the windmill, the ball bounced back and smacked me in the head.
 
Is there a bound in universe? What is it out of the bound?

no, it is infinite. there is no 'out of' infinite.
the universe is expanding and becoming less dense, but it's not growing (as you can't get bigger than infinite. which is a weird concept to get your head around.
 
Back
Top