Caught

[muscularguy4F]

Caught (M for F)

Jay wasn't at all interested with the conversations of the other teens downstairs, yes he liked his friends, but there was something far more appealling to him upstairs.
Jay had known tyra for years and for each of those years he had fantasised about her older sister rachel. Nobody could blame him, at 19 she was 3 years older than he and the other girls he knew. She was curvier, with athletic legs and stomach and an impressive cleavage.
So when Jay caught a glimpse of rachel leaving, 'just popping out apparently', so he took what he thought was the only opportunity he would ever get, he snuck away and went upstairs to her room.
He had been up there for only a couple of minutes now, looking at pictures of her with her friends, when he found one of her and tyra on a beach earlier this year. Both were pictured in bikinis, and although Tyra looked far more curvy than he had ever imagined, Jay could not remove his eyes from Rachel's cleavage. As he looked, his heart sped, thumping, racing in his chest, and he felt his cock throb. He couldnt bare it any longer, he was too turned on, he reached down to his jeans, unbuckling his belt in one smooth motion and gripped his cock tightly, squeezing it

OOC: sample reply please, dont mind if you are playing as tyra or rachel

 

[phoenixlore]

"Excuse me." Rachel left the small group of girls quickly as she remembered something she had forgotten in her room. They were having a blast together and she hated to miss out on anything but she could have sworn she left her light on. It was silly, yes, but she always had a thing about saving electricity. In a rush, she ran upstairs and followed the familiar path to her room. Her hands instinctively moved to her skirt once she was out of sight of her friends. The mini skirt she had chosen for the day had been sliding steadily up since she sat down downstairs. She pulled it down then moved to the tight shirt. Both articles of clothing showed of her beautiful natural curves wonderfully and that was the only reason she wore them.

Just as she made it to her bedroom and looked up from fussing at her clothing, her eyes locked on the sight of her sister's friend on her bed. She had no problem with Jay. He always seemed to be a nice boy besides his continued glances at her body. She never mentioned it because she kind of liked the attention. She never expected this though. Her eyes widened in shock as she peeked in from the corner of her door and watched him masturbate in her room.

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay's hand gripped even more tightly, his face flushing red as he stared intensly at the picture of rachel and tyra. His right arm sped up, imagining the girls taking their tops off. His cock thickened, growing in his hand, throbbing, pulsing. Huge now, bigger easily than both of his hands put together.
His muscles started to tense as his heart thumped harder and harder in his chest, the precum that hard formed was now giving his hand a good lubricant, speeding up his action. His breathing sped up, making it sound like he was sprinting for his life. After only 3 minutes he tensed even harder, letting out a series of loud moans he pumped his cock, his thick, creamy white spunk spurting over the picture, covering Rachel's face and tits, and spraying slightly onto her sister.
He gasped, exhausted. Looking at the pic he smiled, then wiped his thick, bulging head over the picture spreading the rest of the cum onto rachel and tyra's faces

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel's eyes were stuck on Jay's cock. It was big, larger than any she had ever seen. As he pumped his cock faster, she watched as if spellbound. Without realizing it, her hand moved down the front of her skirt then disappeared under it. She slowly rubbed the front of her mound through her underwear. As she watched him, she suddenly noticed that her bedside picture of her and her sister on their trip to the beach was missing. Her eyes locked on the picture in Jay's hand. Her eyes widened all over again. He was jacking off to a picture of her and her sister. That made this even hotter and creepier all at the same time. Jay's release seemed to come out of nowhere and she gasped as he came all over her picture. "Oh my god," she whispered.

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay gasped and gasped, trying to recover his breath, his face felt flushed, but was slowly draining back to its usual skin tone. He watched just a little longer as he pretended to spread cum over the girls with his cock. He smiled as he imagined the cum really dripping off the face and tits. Slowly he woke himself from his dreamworld, placing the picute on the bed and getting to his feet, returning his still throbbing cock to his jeans and redoing the buckle of his belt.
He gave the picture one more proud glance and then picked it up, searching for a tissue

 

[phoenixlore]

As Jay got up, she backed further into the hall but she continued to watch him from the side of the door. She quickly pulled her hand from under her skirt, but not before noticing how wet she was just from watching him. She watched as he replaced her picture on the nightstand, not even bothering to clean it off. Her cheeks burned red with embarrassment. But suddenly, she started to wonder why she was so embarrassed. He was the one who sneaked into her room and came all over her favorite picture. Rage filled her body and before she realized how bad of a situation she could be creating, she walked into the room. "You're just gonna leave that there?" Somehow, she still remembered to whisper so that none of the girls downstairs heard, especially Tyra. What would Tyra think if she saw what her friend did? "Jay, what the hell are you doing? That's my picture! That's my sister! You sick pervert!"

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay froze, shocked. He stared at Rachel, then to the picture, then back at Rachel. His cheeks blushed heavily again and he started to stammer.
"I I I dont know what y y you mean" He tried to say with an air of rebellion, but still he backed away from Rachel and the photo. "I I havent d d ddone anything wrong"

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel felt ready to explode. "Nothing wrong?" she almost shouted. She looked back towards the door as if she would know whether her sister and her friends heard that just from that look. Her eyes returned to Jay as she continued to chastise him. "I watched you while you jacked off to my picture of me and my sister. She trusts you and you're just so sicko who just came all over a picture of us." She looked over at her picture with an unsure expression. Part of her was grossed out but part of her was a little enticed by this weird situation.

 

[muscularguy4F]

"i i im not a sicko. I didnt hurt anyone!" jay replied, pleading with her, not entirely confident of what he was say himself.
" I I wont tell anyone, I'll just w w wipe it off and its ok?" he continued, worried, not just of finding out, but of having to wipe away the spunk which he thought decorated the picture so well

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel shook her head. No, this was just wrong. She tried to sound sure of herself but she was sure she sounded extremely nervous. "If you think I'm not telling Tyra, you are sadly mistaken." She turned and headed back to the door. She wasn't sure if she would really be able to tell Tyra what just happened but she couldn't stay in this room any longer.

 

[muscularguy4F]

"No, wait!" jay tried to stop rachel, but his legs felt heavy, almost frozen and by the time he had managed to move them he could hear Rachel was already at the bottom of the stairs. His heart thumped in his chest, he panicked, he couldnt run down the stairs and out the house, they would see him. He looked behind him, the window was locked but it wasnt far above the roof of the conservatory, if he could just find the key! He started to scramble furiously around the room, looking for the key in drawers and pots, completely forgetting about the picture

 

[phoenixlore]

Ooc: sorry I'm really tired and it is way too late. I would be glad to finish this another time though.

 

[muscularguy4F]

sure, I have to go soon anyway, I should be on within the next 24hrs. Wanna just post each reply when you are next on regardless of whether the other person is?

 

[phoenixlore]

Ooc: sure thing

 

[muscularguy4F]

OOC: sleep well, looking forward to your reply

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel stopped at the bottom of the steps. Her heart was racing and her pussy was wet. She didn't know what to do. She told Jay that she was going to tell her sister but she couldn't bring herself to do it. This would cause a huge scandal for her sister during a great party. As a protective older sister, she wanted to do her best to make her sister not have to deal with bad situations. Unfortunately, this one wasn't in the big sister manual. At the last second, Rachel decided to go back and confront Jay. As soon as she saw him going through her things, she exploded all over again. "What the hell are you doing?"

 

[muscularguy4F]

Rachel's voice stopped Jay in his tracks. He panicked, knowing it didnt look good and immediately tried to explain himself, but it was going to be a lose lose situation.
"Its not what, I know how this looks, its not that! I was just l l looking for the key to the window."
He said, pointing at the window with a rabbit in the headlights look on his face. He was surprised. He hadnt completely expected to get away, but neither had he completely expected to be confronted by just Rachel. He wondered if this was a good sign, if it meant she would let him go, but the anger in her voice had convinced him otherwise, causing fear to brew inside him

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel walked into the room and closed the door behind her. "Listen perv, I don't want Tyra getting hurt. Sit down." She quickly reconsidered that. Her hands rose as she spoke again. "Don't. God you were already jacking off in my bed." She sighed. "How long have you been getting off on me and my sister? Or is it just her? Or me?" The entire situation confused the hell out of her and she was freaking out.

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay went to sit, then quickly jumped back up at Rachel's command. He felt like she was playing with him until she spoke again.
he was finding it very hard to think, not only was he in an awkward situation, but he was also faced with an incredibly attractive older girl, wearing a shirt skirt and top that showed off all her curves. He knew he shouldn't be thinking about them now, especially since he should have relieved some of that tension just minutes ago, but he couldn't help it. He couldn't help but stare slightly at her long, athletic legs, at her busty cleavage pressing against the tight shirt. 'No, no no, not now, think about something else, anything else'. He thought, feeling his cock throb again and struggling to regain control of his attention. 'Quick, she asked you a question! reply! Before she thinks you're perving again!' his own voice shouted at him from inside his head.
How long? Her? Tyra? Both of them? He looked at her confused, he didnt know how to answer, to be truthful, he wasn't entirely sure of the answer anyway.
"it was j j just you mostly, until... until then, when I was on the b b bed and I ..."
Jay trailed off, thinking it a better not to finish the sentance

 

[phoenixlore]

"Jacked off to a picture of me and my sister?" Rachel finished his sentence for him. She glanced at the picture than gasped. "You have't even cleaned it off!" Rachel approached and picked up the picture by one of the smaller parts not covered in spunk. "This is one of my favorite pictures. It wasn't meant to be your porn." She paused then thought about what he said first. She just looked confused as she asked him, "So you had a thing for me?"

ooc: Sorry I took so long. I've been busy today

 

[muscularguy4F]

"jacked off to a picture of me and my sister?" Rachel said and Jay blushed heavily. In truth, he had jacked off to her, but the extra cleavage that Tyra added to the picture had probably sped him up. Though he wasnt sure he had really noticed her that much until a few sprays of his spunk had decorated her in the picture.
"You haven't even cleaned it off! This is one of my favorite pictures. It wasn't meant to be your porn"

" I, i thought it looked better like that?" Jay answered, shrugging his shoulders, trying to brush off the awkward situation. though he couldnt help but notice how close her hand was to his cum stains, he stared at them momentarily before the voice in his head chastised him 'No, focus on something else, you've got yourself in enough trouble so far today by thinking disgusting thoughts like that you dirty perv!'
"I really have have to be going now" Jay murmured looking at the floor, trying to walk to the door.

He completely ignored her final comment, not wanting

 

[phoenixlore]

"You leave right now and I tell Tyra and she'll probably never want to see your pervy ass again." Rachel held the picture up, still gripping the tiny corner not covered in cum. "I have your spunk right here and I'm not afraid to use it against you." Rachel gained some confidence as she suddenly had him by the balls, figuratively anyway. Rachel sat down on the end of the bed and looked up at him. "Now.... what about me do you like?"

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay gulped and sighed, he was between a rock and a hard place and worried. Yet part of him was turned on slightly and no matter he tried to imagine, he couldnt relax.
He watched as Rachel looked at him wickedly. He wasnt sure, but it seemed like she was enjoying putting him on the spot and watching him squirm.
"w well you're....you're hot"
jay stuttered, slowly looking up at Rachel. The anger on her face told him instantly that his answers needed far more detail.
"you h have amazing legs" Jay said, forcing it out, attempting not to look at her legs when he said it " a a and incredible boobs." He added, trying to ignore his cock pulsing and growing in his jeans and he let his left hand slip to his crotch, covering it.
It wasn't a romantic sonnet, nor was it meant to be, there was nothing romantic about the situation. But at least he was telling the truth, which is probably all he could be expected to do considering he had just been found out as a complete perv

 

[phoenixlore]

Rachel tried not to smirk while Jay complimented her. No one had ever complimented her so bluntly. Despite her good looks, she hadn't had many relationships before. Beyond hanging out with her family, she was slightly shy and it didn't help that she mostly spent her time with her sister and her friends. The two were inseparable. She loved her sister more than anything and that was why she felt kind of bad for what she was doing now. She never had this kind of control before. It was fun.

Rachel couldn't help smiling when she noticed Jay's hand move to his crotch. "Haha, you're already hard again?" She looked glanced down at the cum covered pictured. "Just talking about me." Her devilish gaze returned to him. "You just can't help yourself, can you?"

 

[muscularguy4F]

Jay blushed. "no...I'm not. honestly" he pleaded, in anything but a convincing tone. He felt embarrassed, not just that she had noticed his pressing hard on, but also that she seemed to be enjoying the control she had over him. He tried to move his gaze away from the devilish gleam in her eyes, but that only lead to staring at her large tits pressing through her top and that was no help at all