Circumcision

Is male circumcision gential mutilation?

  • Yes

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • No

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • Other (explain)

    Votes: 1 1.6%

  • Total voters
    61
Rubyfruit said:
Mecha, because it's completely unnecessary. It's not the norm the world over and wasn't even routine in this country until, I think, the 30s or 40s. People are at the point where they just do it without giving it real thought, in my opinion.

The cleanliness issue is ridiculous and insulting when you think about it. Men aren't smart enough to figure out how to pull the foreskin back and wash? Please.

The rates of penile cancer in intact men is slightly higher, yes, but the chances of getting it are still pretty rare. Breast cancer is far more prevalent, but nobody suggests giving baby girls radical mastectomies at birth to prevent it.

Actually there was a period of about 10 years when I had no idea I was supposed to pull back the foreskin. Man, was I shocked.

Mastectomies drastically affect the way women look and feel. Plus, it probably wouldn't do much for breast cancer.

I feel that circumcision is neither ridiculous nor insulting. Antiquated? Yes. Unnecessary? Maybe. Painful for babies? Definitely. I have occasionally wished I had it done, though you think doctors would start anesthesizing babies before they do it.
 
floridaguy64 said:

When they did my six year old, I had to go to a seperate floor of the hospital...

They didn't do it at birth? They normaly do those things at birth. I have had all my boys done. Mostly becuase of the serious infections my oldest brother has had. Him and his wife have had a lot of problems with it and my oldest brother is like the cleanest person I have ever met. He is obsessed with cleanliness.
 
MechaBlade said:

I feel that circumcision is neither ridiculous nor insulting. Antiquated? Yes. Unnecessary? Maybe. Painful for babies? Definitely. I have occasionally wished I had it done, though you think doctors would start anesthesizing babies before they do it.

Working with babies has brought a whole new light in my mind with circumcision. I decided 14 year ago it is barbaric. Downright barbaric. Even the pediatricians I work with discourage it.

I refused have my son circumcised. Teach them hygiene. That goes a long way. It's highly unnecessary, puts great stress on the baby afterward to point it won't eat, and then you have a whole plethora of other problems that come from that. Some babies can't even pee after it's done. Why would anyone do this to a baby? If they witnessed one, I'm sure parents would change their mind. It is painful, even with the use of anesthetics. I've NEVER seen the procedure done without it.

I don't know about the slip of the scalpel thing. Maybe that's only in the movies.
 
floridaguy64 said:
I am because I'm Catholic and it's a normal ritual thingee...



What part of Catholicism tells us that we have to be circumcised? Ya know, I used to be a Director of Religious Education, and I never once encountered a paragraph or anything for that matter telling us that we have to all be circumcised...

I think this only applied to the Jewish culture...
 
I had my son circumsized as an infant & he didn't seem to suffer any lasting effects. They brought him to me a few minutes after it was done, he nursed just fine, slept for a bit & I took him home a few hours later. My mom works with a girl whose son isn't & it has been 6 months of nonstop doctor's visits. The baby has had several infections, I don't know if the mother doesn't clean him thoroughly or what. I haven't ever been with a man who wasn't, so not sure about sensitivity & things like that.
 
I cast a vote vote for mutilation. Why cut off some part of a person just because it isn't seen as necessary? Teach boys to wash and that will take care of the hygiene factor. I have had sex with both varieties of penises and have no personal preference as far as pleasure or sensation goes. There is certainly more to amuse yourself with if your partner has a foreskin. Anybody see *Puppetry of the Penis*? As far as the looking funny part goes, don't all penises look funny anyway? They are no more amusing uncircumcised than they are circumcised.

Maybe the foreskin is the part of a man that gets him to ask for directions or reminds him to put the toilet seat back down. I suggest a moratorium on circumcision just to test out my theory.



Minout
 
I'd get my son done if I had one - which I won't be, so it's a moot point. But my reasons for choosing that are for esthetic reasons only - I prefer a man who has been done, and I think they are ugly when they are not. And I have heard of more issues with babies uncut, as compared to ones who were cut.
 
Freya, call it what it is then: Cosmetic surgery on human beings without their consent.

I wonder how people would feel about surgery at birth to make the vagina more visually appealing.

I think an uncut cock is a beautiful thing to look at and play with.
 
Sure it's mutilation. But it's a weird subject. I was born in Ireland in the mid-50s, where it wasn't customary. When I got to the States in the late 50s, the pediatrician convinced my parents it was necessary, so I was snipped rather later than normal. Now that I go to the Y (and get a chance to compare), I find that there's a break point about five years older than I am--say about 50. Older than that, uncut, younger, cut.

When my half-brother-in-law was born, his dad (one of the over 50s) insisted that it was the thing to do, 'though no one else could really figure out why he was so adamant. But he was the only one from the uncut camp who could speak with any authority.

I'd rather (in a strictly philosophical sense) go out with everything I came in with, but as many have already said, it's not something I miss.
 
Rubyfruit said:
Freya, call it what it is then: Cosmetic surgery on human beings without their consent.

I wonder how people would feel about surgery at birth to make the vagina more visually appealing.

I think an uncut cock is a beautiful thing to look at and play with.

Yes, I understand your point. Like I said, mine is a personal opinion based strictly on esthetics - and one that has no impact anyways, as I won't be having any more children.
 
Pardon the pun but this one rears it's head every few months and the same arguements always come out.

1. it cut's penile cancer rates....so does cutting your cock off, and if we're gonna get into preventive surgery then why not yank out babies tonsils and apendix while we're at it ?

2. "I want my kids to look like their friends" thats just weak man 80% of the world is uncut if your gonna go by numbers then thats the one to go by, also it's only normal to cut babies in the USA, no body else except Israel does it as the "norm".

3. "I'll never fuck a man with an uncut cock" well thats ok cause theres plenty of women who will, you just alienated yourself from 80% of the worlds male population....enjoy the 20% your left with.

4. it stops infections.....duh!....so does washing, and frankly if a guy can't be bothered to wash his cock regularly then he deserves everything he gets or doesn't get......like a sexual partner.

5. "I had mine done and I don't miss it" thats the stupidest thing anybody can say, of coarse you don't miss it because you never had it long enough to get used to it, ask a person who's born blind if they miss sight and they'll say "no"

6. and heres a positive one for women and circumcised men alike, cut men last longer in bed.....why you ask well you see the head of the penis is a semi wet membrane and when you cut the prtective cover (foreskin) the skin over the glans of the penis thinkens and a shit load of nerve endings die off.
so the penis becomes less sensitive and takes longer to reach the critical mass of sensation that leads to orgasm, but you'll never know that cause you've never known it any other way (see point 5)

and lastly I have a friend who had his foreskin removed to marry a girl from another religeon, he had been sexually active before the operation and he reports that there was a definite lessening of sensation during sex, and from what I've read this is the norm amongst men who have had their penis circumcised in adulthood.

So on the hole you can see I'm against it and am thankful it's not one Americanism thats made it's way over here.
 
my husband and I ahve talked about whether or not to do it when we have a kid if it's a boy. Jury's still out.

Personally I have been with men with and without, I have no preference. My husband is and I love his dick but i'd love it the other way too.
 
Minout said:


What does that mean?


Minout

Stoopid Thread Of The Day.

Get this, a collection of women are sitting around wondering about mutilation on a part of the OTHER gender's body that they barely understand.

Call me when a cabal of dudes gets down to the nitty gritty on abortion.
 
OUTSIDER said:
Pardon the pun but this one rears it's head every few months and the same arguements always come out.

1. it cut's penile cancer rates....so does cutting your cock off, and if we're gonna get into preventive surgery then why not yank out babies tonsils and apendix while we're at it ?

2. "I want my kids to look like their friends" thats just weak man 80% of the world is uncut if your gonna go by numbers then thats the one to go by, also it's only normal to cut babies in the USA, no body else except Israel does it as the "norm".

3. "I'll never fuck a man with an uncut cock" well thats ok cause theres plenty of women who will, you just alienated yourself from 80% of the worlds male population....enjoy the 20% your left with.

4. it stops infections.....duh!....so does washing, and frankly if a guy can't be bothered to wash his cock regularly then he deserves everything he gets or doesn't get......like a sexual partner.

5. "I had mine done and I don't miss it" thats the stupidest thing anybody can say, of coarse you don't miss it because you never had it long enough to get used to it, ask a person who's born blind if they miss sight and they'll say "no"

6. and heres a positive one for women and circumcised men alike, cut men last longer in bed.....why you ask well you see the head of the penis is a semi wet membrane and when you cut the prtective cover (foreskin) the skin over the glans of the penis thinkens and a shit load of nerve endings die off.
so the penis becomes less sensitive and takes longer to reach the critical mass of sensation that leads to orgasm, but you'll never know that cause you've never known it any other way (see point 5)

and lastly I have a friend who had his foreskin removed to marry a girl from another religeon, he had been sexually active before the operation and he reports that there was a definite lessening of sensation during sex, and from what I've read this is the norm amongst men who have had their penis circumcised in adulthood.

So on the hole you can see I'm against it and am thankful it's not one Americanism thats made it's way over here.

Go brush your teeth.
 
Marxist said:


No, just infusing you with more American traditions.

Then you shoulda told me to go buy a gun and go kill a couple dozen high school kids
 
IrishWolfhound said:
I seem to recall there are some health benefits, besides hygeine. Something about a recuced rate of cervical cancer for their partners?

I know I've never missed mine. (I didn't have it long enough to get really attached.)

Me,too.

Yes, there was an influential study that showed a correlation between circumcision & reduced rate of cervical cancer.

As it happens , that was an Israeli study. Most of the participants were circumsized for religious reasons. Of course, circumcision wasn't the only ritual in the religion. There also happened to be a lot of religious laws that tended to improve sanitation & hygeine.

So it was a study of groups with different standards & practices of cleanliness, not just circumcission. It may merely have affirmed that fewer feminine infections per lifetime result in fewer cases of cervical cancer.

To answer your question, leXie, it's ( mild )genital mutilation without consent.

I don't know why we aren't more accepting of bodies as they are naturally. Why is that a wrong choice? WetMarlene got a lot of negative feedback on her avatar, too. At Literotica. Go figure.
 
OUTSIDER said:


Then you shoulda told me to go buy a gun and go kill a couple dozen high school kids

Not familiar with Thomas Hamilton?
 
Marxist said:


Stoopid Thread Of The Day.

Get this, a collection of women are sitting around wondering about mutilation on a part of the OTHER gender's body that they barely understand.

Call me when a cabal of dudes gets down to the nitty gritty on abortion.

I understand what you're saying Marxist, but remember that there are an awful lot of single moms out there who will be making the decision to have their sons circumsized or not, so it's not entirely irrelevant for women to discuss.
 
Back
Top