Circumcision

Is male circumcision gential mutilation?

  • Yes

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • No

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • Other (explain)

    Votes: 1 1.6%

  • Total voters
    61
peachykeen said:


I understand what you're saying Marxist, but remember that there are an awful lot of single moms out there who will be making the decision to have their sons circumsized or not, so it's not entirely irrelevant for women to discuss.

I get it too. I'm inviting a few of my closest buds over for a roundtable on infant ear piercing.
 
The American Academy of Pediatrics has decided that the procedure is not medically necessary. Therefore, they do not routinely recommend it for every male infant. (They used to)

Some hospitals are starting to use anesthetic for the procedure now, but many doctors still do not. The needles used to administer the anesthetic can cause swelling and cause problems. I saw a movie of a circumcision - it was frightening.

My brother's son had to undergo two surgeries after his procedure to correct mistakes. Luckily, my husband and I had already decided not to subject our son to the same thing before that happened. If he wishes, he can always have the procedure done when he is older. But - it will be his choice.

And by the way - my husband is cut - but he made the final decision not to circumcise our son.
 
Marxist said:


I get it too. I'm inviting a few of my closest buds over for a roundtable on infant ear piercing.

now that is just wrong. I cringe everytime I see a baby with pierced ears, want to go over to the mother/father and just shake them and say 'what the fuck, you selfish shitbird?'
 
peachykeen said:


now that is just wrong. I cringe everytime I see a baby with pierced ears, want to go over to the mother/father and just shake them and say 'what the fuck, you selfish shitbird?'

Get your panties out of a wad. It's a common procedure in many places throughout the world and not remembered or regretted.

WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE? IT'S CALLED BEING A PARENT. YOU DO WHATEVER YOU AND YOUR CULTURE (RELIGION, CASTE, HOMIES) DEEM FIT FOR YOUR CHILD.

To lay everything at the feet of the child for him or her to choose is ridiculous.
 
Marxist said:


WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE? IT'S CALLED BEING A PARENT. YOU DO WHATEVER YOU AND YOUR CULTURE (RELIGION, CASTE, HOMIES) DEEM FIT FOR YOUR CHILD.

all true but religeon, caste and culture all change over time and the catalyst for change is often discussion and thats what about here, seeing if a cultural norm is still valid
 
OUTSIDER said:


all true but religeon, caste and culture all change over time and the catalyst for change is often discussion and thats what about here, seeing if a cultural norm is still valid

Mutilation? Why don't we just call it "infant rape?"

I love how words are appropriated to make a case seem more gorey than it actually is.

I've seen a a bris and it's no fucking big deal.
 
If I have a daughter, then I'm going to make sure her pussy flaps and clit get cut off, because, hey, it looks nicer that way and I won't have to worry about her not wiping properly. Obviously God/Nature was wrong to include that extra skin, so I'll take it upon myself to mutilate my kids how I see fit.

</tasteless sarcasm>

Yes, I'm against circumcision. People who insist on having it done to their kids are either ignorant or fucked up in the head. :mad:
 
Last edited:
TumbledLove said:
If I have a daughter, then I'm going to make sure her pussy flaps and clit get cut off, because, hey, it looks nicer that way and I won't have to worry about her not wiping properly. Obviously God/Nature was wrong to include that extra skin, so I'll take it upon myself to mutilate my kids how I see fit.

</tasteless sarcasm>

Yes, I'm against circumcision. People who insist on having it done to their kids are either ignorant or fucked up in the head. :mad:

The foreskin is not equal to the clit. You're a happy idiot.
 
Tumbled Love, I don't consider myself ignorant or fucked up in the head, despite my son having been circumsized. I was a very good mother & he was a normal kid. And you have how many children to be such an expert? :rolleyes:
 
Marxist said:



I've seen a a bris and it's no fucking big deal.
I've seen one too and I beg to differ- it IS a big deal. However, I'm really on the fence with this topic.
 
Marxist said:


The foreskin is not equal to the clit. You're a happy idiot.

Thank you for saying that much nicer than I would have.

What an absolutely assholish thing to say Tumbled. There are plenty of parents on here who have made that decision for a number of reasons, and for you to sit on your friggin high horse calling them names because of a personal decision they made is just fuckin ignorant. Others have managed to get on here and state their opinions for or against this procedure without it resulting in a name calling expedition - thank you for being the first idiot to change that.

Thats how I would have said it, Marxist.
 
I don't think it is mutilation - my personal opinion is that it is a body modification that is not needed.

I've read about the entire issue from both sides, medical articles, and the like - there seems to be such a strong argument for both sides that all I can see it as is a choice based on the parents' beliefs and opinions.

I won't do it to my son for the simple fact that I can't see removing skin from his penis that does not need to be removed. I'm perfectly capable of keeping it clean, and teaching him to do so when he is old enough. If at some point in time he would rather have it done, he can make that choice himself, although I still don't see a reason to do it. My ex was not cut, and it didn't bother me at all. There are much bigger issues in a relationship than a foreskin. :rolleyes:

I know someone who made the choice to have it done when he was 16 years old for religious purposes. He went in, was asleep, had the procedure done, woke up and went home with no pain and no complications. He said he would still do it again, having gone through it once, but that if it wasn't for religion he would have been happy leaving it alone as well.
 
Marxist said:


The foreskin is not equal to the clit. You're a happy idiot.

Now now, Marxist. You have no right to assume Tumbled Love is happy. Idiot I will grant you. Ignorance is not always bliss. I know many sad idiots.
 
lilminx said:

I've seen one too and I beg to differ- it IS a big deal. However, I'm really on the fence with this topic.

Any minor operation can be botched (including ear piercing). If handled correctly, it's nothing to think about.
 
Marxist said:


Any minor operation can be botched (including ear piercing). If handled correctly, it's nothing to think about.

This would explain the brain damage I sustained in mine.
 
so tell me again why it's ok to mutilate an innocent baby??

oh, that's right, because of religious reasons. or because it looks better and his daddy and all his brothers are mutilated too. and I forgot about all the so called health benefits. :rolleyes: If kids knew how to probably clean their foreskins, then health wouldn't even be an issue.

Maybe we should be cutting off ears too, because they can be hard to clean and sometimes get infected.

I'm sorry about the name calling, but it amazes many people think circumsision is an ok thing to do. I imagine for most parents, they never give a second thought about it, and it's like yeah, whatever, cut it off - doesn't effect me any. Hell, cut off his whole dick, I wanted a girl anyway.
 
Last edited:
mu·ti·late Pronunciation Key (mytl-t)

To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue.
To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.

1. To cut off or remove a limb or essential part of; to maim; to cripple; to hack; as, to mutilate the body, a statue, etc.

2. To destroy or remove a material part of, so as to render imperfect; as, to mutilate the orations of Cicero.

Foreskin is not a limb or essential part - circumcision does not cripple, maim or destroy.

It's a personal choice of parents - some do it for religious reasons, which is not up to you or anyone else to dispute. Would you tell people not to baptize a child because dropping water on their heads scares the baby and makes it cry?
 
Marxist, my friend, resist temptation.

Remember, you can't teach a pig to sing. It only wastes your time and annoys the pig.
 
I don't consider it multilation. And there is no right or wrong way to go cuz frankly, guys don't get a say in it when they're born. Actually, it shouldn't matter but in a country where its believed to be normal, it gets done and that's fucked up. I'm not cut and I don't have ANY problems with it in any aspect of daily life...

...except for the women who run away (but I think that's just me and not mini-me)
 
Freya2 said:
mu·ti·late Pronunciation Key (mytl-t)

To disfigure by damaging irreparably

Foreskin is not a limb or essential part - circumcision does not cripple, maim or destroy.

It's a personal choice of parents - some do it for religious reasons, which is not up to you or anyone else to dispute. Would you tell people not to baptize a child because dropping water on their heads scares the baby and makes it cry?

Being an essential body part has nothing to do with it. and by your definition, circumcision does indeed "disfigure by damaging irreparably," ... Also, getting a kid wet and cutting part of his body off aren't even comparable.
 
I did think about it & chose to have it done. Quite honestly, kids don't really want to look different from their friends, despite their claims of wanting to be individuals. Group showers in PE can be very embarrassing for kids. Something like this is a very personal decision & should be left to the parents. My son got both of his ears pierced in the 9th grade. His grandfather hates all kinds of piercings, but it was Justin's decision & he paid for it himself. I really don't think my son suffered any ill effects from the circumcision or the ear piercings. If I were to have another child, I might make a different decision, but since I can't have any more children, it is kind of a moot point. I do take offense at the name calling. You don't us, you don't know what kind of parents we are or were, so why are you so angry? When you have children, you can make that decision, but don't condemn us. Your last remark is extremely offensive, is that your way of saying you wouldn't want a girl? Most of us are thrilled with our children, whether a boy or girl.


Stepping down from my soapbox.
 
OK, you people have become boring now.

(Except Freya, who is making me her love slave on a different thread.)
 
teresafannin said:
Quite honestly, kids don't really want to look different from their friends, despite their claims of wanting to be individuals.

I really don't think my son suffered any ill effects from the circumcision or the ear piercings.

Your last remark is extremely offensive, is that your way of saying you wouldn't want a girl? Most of us are thrilled with our children, whether a boy or girl.

You help prove my point.. it all about LOOKS. Everybody's doing it, so why not go along with the crowd. Afterall, we don't want our son feeling "different".

My concern isn't about the potential damage, physical or mental, that a circumcision can cause. It's about leaving your baby's body INTACT and letting nature take its course (barring any medical condition that requires intervention).

and, I love kids and would be thrilled with a girl or a boy. actually, I think I'd like a girl a little more though. :)
 
Tumblelove,

Back down babe. People aren't going to listen to you if you sound like a rabid dog and allow no room for other opinions.
 
Back
Top