"Consternation", ideas and advice.

RhumbRunner13

No alts, no "Iggy"
Joined
Jan 4, 2002
Posts
3,463
Many years ago I had considerable time to do little but think. My interest in M. C. Escher’s work led to the eventual concept of a puzzle I called “Consternation”.

Consternation appears to be a “jig saw” puzzle on the surface, but has some unique properties that, to me, make it something quite different. I was wondering if any others would see it as interesting and challenging, I’d like to hear your thoughts.

Consternation is designed such that ALL pieces are identical in shape and size; they interlock and can be oriented (turned) in any of four directions. The edges and corners are typical in that they have one or two straight sides. The result is a puzzle that begins to mystify the mind. A typical puzzle as I envision it would be, say, 26 X 32 pieces. That yields four corners, 116 edge pieces and 720 center pieces.

Here is where it gets interesting! Since the central pieces are able to be turned and still fit in, there are in effect 4 X 720 or 2880 pieces! Now it gets REALLY, REALLY interesting! Because all of the three types of pieces are identical they can be placed into the puzzle anywhere and they will fit perfectly. The corner pieces, for example can be arranged in 24 different ways but only one way for the “picture” to be correct. That number is calculated by using the factorial (exclamation point, ! on your calculator) of 4. That is 4 x 3 x 2 x1 = 24. The possible combination of edge pieces is 116! and central pieces 2880!. Note: My computer calculator will calculate both numbers, most “hand helds” will display “error” because the numbers are too big.

The total number of combinations to assemble the puzzle is something in the neighborhood of 10 followed by 10,000 zeros! Only one combination would be correct.

Would any of you find this interesting or challenging enough to attempt?:eek:

Rhumb:D
 
I like puzzles like that sometimes, but if they're too rediculously complex, then I get frustrated and bored with them.
 
I am more into instant gratification than that. I have done the Impossibles puzzles and they will sit on the puzzle table for months. I much prefer one that I can do in a week or two.
 
RhumbRunner13 said:
Many years ago I had considerable time to do little but think. My interest in M. C. Escher’s work led to the eventual concept of a puzzle I called “Consternation”.
...
Would any of you find this interesting or challenging enough to attempt.

If you're thinking of marketing this concept, you're too late -- there are puzzles like that on the market already.


Some are even designed so that you can lift a row of pieces off on side of a puzzle and fit them onto the opposite side -- as if the Puzzle were a cylinder or globe -- and shift the picture from side to side or up and down. (i.e. no straight edges pieces to guide you in framing the puzzle.

They're apparently not very popular except with real puzle fanatics -- at least they're not very easy to find in the stores except for specialty puzzle and game stores.
 
hello rhumb

I have a sister who is a puzzle fanatic. WH is correct, this idea is already on the market. I've seen a few of my sister's puzzles that fit your description and they look to be really difficult. The picture on one all marbles, on another, it's nothing but clouds in the sky.

I don't know if it's a patentable idea, but if it is, it's probably already patented.

sorry.
 
"They're apparently not very popular except with real puzle fanatics -- at least they're not very easy to find in the stores except for specialty puzzle and game stores."

Just from comments so far it appears that you and Texan have hit the nail on the head. It would be to complicated for most people to hold their interest and there aren't enough "puzzle nuts" to make it worthwhile.

Another dream of wealth and fame down the drain!:p

Rhumb;)
 
Back
Top