Creativity and Mental Illness

I'm bi-polar and when I'm manic, I write from an entirely different vantage point. It's as though I am being propelled forward by the crest of a great wave and the force takes me high enough to write words that do not even occur to me when I'm not manic. When depressed, I cannot write at all. I can't prove to anyone that there is a correlation between mania and creativity, but I've read quite a lot of information that indicates I'm not the only person that has been true of.
But if you were a stockbroker, you wouldn't want to do any stockbroking when depressed. And when you were manic, you would want to do it. I mean, the question is, how high a percentage of bi-polar people become artists and are hugely creative during their manic phases vs. how many bipolar folk are average joes--who in their manic phase can get the lawn mowed and the house painted, taxes done and their in-and-out box at work emptied?

Mania allowing you to write vs. depression when you can't only says you're bi-polar. Not that this mental illness (and, again, I'm not sure at what point we should classify such things that way) is required for someone to be an artist. If you see what I mean.
 
For my purposes I define 'creativity' as adding something new to the fund of knowledge or the state of the art, depending on what your medium is. If I use popsicle sticks in a novel way I've been creative. If I fingerpaint with shit I havent been creative.
 
But if you were a stockbroker, you wouldn't want to do any stockbroking when depressed. And when you were manic, you would want to do it. I mean, the question is, how high a percentage of bi-polar people become artists and are hugely creative during their manic phases vs. how many bipolar folk are average joes--who in their manic phase can get the lawn mowed and the house painted, taxes done and their in-and-out box at work emptied?

Mania allowing you to write vs. depression when you can't only says you're bi-polar. Not that this mental illness (and, again, I'm not sure at what point we should classify such things that way) is required for someone to be an artist. If you see what I mean.

Oh I definitely see what you mean. It's difficult to classify it at all.

I have no idea what the percentages are or what it all means, but Kay Redfield Jamison who wrote the book Vana referenced "Touched by Fire" and another fine book called "An Unquiet Mind" spent quite a long time studying the correlation between artistic temperament and bi-polar disorder. She doesn't by any means go so far as to say that being bi-polar CAUSES you to be more artistic. But, she definitely shows interesting correlations between the two states.
 
For my purposes I define 'creativity' as adding something new to the fund of knowledge or the state of the art, depending on what your medium is. If I use popsicle sticks in a novel way I've been creative. If I fingerpaint with shit I havent been creative.

Totally agree.
 
Just for goofs I checked a few online sites pertaining to creativity and mental illness. Almost all of them base their claims on a study done by perfesserat at University of Toronto and Harvard.

As I supposed, creative people are less inhibited than others. That is, if you gave creative people the MMPI test they'd score high for psychopathological deviancy (novelty seeking), which isnt the same thing as psychosis. Many of the websites confuse the two. Just as many people construe schizophrenia to be a dual personality; it isnt.

Creative people are receptive to novelty and the rest of us are OCD.
 
Just for goofs I checked a few online sites pertaining to creativity and mental illness. Almost all of them base their claims on a study done by perfesserat at University of Toronto and Harvard.

As I supposed, creative people are less inhibited than others. That is, if you gave creative people the MMPI test they'd score high for psychopathological deviancy (novelty seeking), which isnt the same thing as psychosis. Many of the websites confuse the two. Just as many people construe schizophrenia to be a dual personality; it isnt.

Creative people are receptive to novelty and the rest of us are OCD.

That's really interesting stuff to me, James. I read an article the other day about geniuses. Apparently, those blessed with genius (the article mentioned Einstein as an example) have been shown to have a real charm with the ladies. And, since geniuses are usually so bookish and reputedly without great social skills, this surprised the fella who wrote this article. He suggested that the reason they have this charm may be because they take more risks, thus they are more exciting to women. I think that's pretty intriguing.
 
That's really interesting stuff to me, James. I read an article the other day about geniuses. Apparently, those blessed with genius (the article mentioned Einstein as an example) have been shown to have a real charm with the ladies. And, since geniuses are usually so bookish and reputedly without great social skills, this surprised the fella who wrote this article. He suggested that the reason they have this charm may be because they take more risks, thus they are more exciting to women. I think that's pretty intriguing.

He's obviously confusing Mensa Morons and Rainman with the Real Deal.

Genius is generally fun to be around, clever, and has a great sense of humor. Sometimes not.

There are plenty of definitions of genius but I define it as the ability to recognize whats rare in the world. I mean, you can be a genius quarterback or receiver or coach or have a knack for making divine omelletes from dirt and weeds.

Curiously, it always seems to be the average Joe's who recognize genius first.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I may be insane, but that doesn't make me stupid....

As a retired family doc in a smaller city that never had enough psychiatrists, I've done my share of dealing with 'the walking wounded', the vast number of people who are almost, but not quite, emotionally ill enough for hospital psychiatric care. Also, when those people who were ill enough for in-patient care were well enough to go back home, if they had one, it was us family docs who carried on trying to keep them walking. If a condition is written up in the DSM-IV, I've had a hand in trying to help. (As an aside, it was the DSM-II when I started out.)

Are gay people more creative? Damned if I know, but gay has nothing to do with emotional illness, except perhaps, for the ongoing load of crap that a lot of straights keep piling on, which sometimes leads to emotional exhaustion and depression. At least it was so in my salad days. Fortunately, I saw less of it in my autumn years of practice.

Are bi-polar people more creative? Damned straight! At least during manic episodes, when I saw creativity of various descriptions. Unfortunately, when mania becomes severe and thoughts become fragmented, the results are almost always tragic.

As for schizophrenia, trust me, this is an illness you don't want. After a decade or so of working, I decided that the only illness I truly feared, was schizophrenia. Breaking down this illness into my usual three variations, mild, moderate and severe, I came to be heartbroken by all of them. Because schizophrenia is in essence, a dissociation between though and affect, (Think: what you are thinking and what info you are processing versus how that makes you feel) mild schizophrenia can perhaps lead to unusual creativity by putting a vary unusual (to the rest of us) spin on writing, art, design and whatever. As long as the schizophrenics' thought processes are not too dissociated, the rest of us see creativity. When those processes are sufficiently dissociated, we see madness.

Is genius connected with mental illness? In a word, no. Some famous geniuses have become mentally ill. John Nash comes to mind. He was a world-class mathematician who made crucial breakthroughs in the field of Game Theory, work that eventually lead to a Nobel Prize (in Economics of all things). Whatshizname played the role of John Nash in the film "A Beautiful Mind". I don't know of anyone who became mentally ill and turned into a genius, delusions of grandeur not withstanding.

Autism effects people of all intellectual stripes. If you accept that Asperger's Syndrome is a variation of autism, then you shouldn't be surprised that some individuals with autism are intellectually brilliant. Paul Dirac comes to mind. He was a theoretical physicist, Nobel laureate and a founder of Quantum Mechanics. He was also totally incapable of carrying on a typical conversation. His social skills were non-existent. All of which suggests Asperger's Syndrome. That said, the number of Nobel laureates with Asperger's syndrome can be counted on two hands.

So, is there a connection between mental illness and creativity or genius? I'll give you my best and favourite answer. Yes and no.
 
Doogie Houser you are so full of shit and must be one of the ER clowns who used to send me patients with headaches cuz 'its in the brain.' Couldnt recognoze a phenobarbital addict looking for drugs.

Schizophrenia is about identical to taking recreational doses of ether. Remember ether? You get vivid visual and auditory hallucinations, and kinda blend real stuff into the mix. Confabulating the experience is a snap. Schizophrenia is a thought disorder combined with intense emotions, usually fear or anxiety. Can you say paranoia! But less than schizo-affective disorder. I personally believe its schizo-affectives who use axes to deal with the world. Regular schizophrenics simply soil themselves or use it as a bonding agent with new friends.

Occasionally, anti-histamines give you schizophrenia-lite if you hit the 90 minute dream cycle on the nose.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top