Cross burning.

G

Guest

Guest
The US supreme court will be ruling on this matter. What do you think?

A. should be protected under the first ammendment.

B. should be illegal because its done to intimidate others.
 
Are they discussing whether or not to outlaw all cross burning, or regulate when and where it can happen?

While I in no way support the KKK, if they wanted to go in Klan leader, Bubba John's back 40 to burn a cross and rant a bit, shouldn't they be allowed to?

Assuming it didn't violate any other laws...i.e. open burning permits and things might be required.
 
What I don't understand (not being from U.S.) is, aren't the KKK supposed to be Christian fundamentalists? Given their faith, isn't burning a Christian symbol sacrilegious?
 
guilty pleasure said:
What I don't understand (not being from U.S.) is, aren't the KKK supposed to be Christian fundamentalists? Given their faith, isn't burning a Christian symbol sacrilegious?

The KKK isn't a "Christian Fundamentalist" organization. I'm sure there are probably CF's in there but they are primarily a white supremist group. Religion isn't their big push, "racial purity" (blech..) is.

But, as Miss Taken said, if they want to make asses of themselves with their own crosses on their own property its their own business. Once they step onto someone else's property or attempt to coherce anyone else then they run afoul of the 1st Amendment and should be subject to whatever penalties the law provides.
 
Of course you can burn a cross. You just can't go it in my kitchen or on the roller coaster at Six Flags.
 
MissTaken said:

Assuming it didn't violate any other laws...i.e. open burning permits and things might be required.

Do you have polluton laws?
 
The KKK is against catholocism.

Anyhow, one has to wonder what the burning of a cross represents. I say that it represents the destruction of the way that they think things should be. My great grandmother had a cross burnt in her yard, because my great grandfather (a doctor) treated black families in their home. They were avid christians.
 
At any rate... I think people should be allowed to burn whatever they want, excepting that they are endangering others. Note, that I DO NOT agree with their ideals, but if any extreme group is to be protected, they all need to be protected as long as they are functioning within the law and not harming others.
 
I say if people want to burn a cross in public where it can be seen by others then it should also be legal to burn a klan suit at a major street intersection.
 
Unregistered said:
I say if people want to burn a cross in public where it can be seen by others then it should also be legal to burn a klan suit at a major street intersection.

Please explain what "public intersection" has to do with anything?

Ishmael
 
ChilledVodka said:
So, are they, in theory, into buggery?

But that would make them pro-Catholic, right?



My politically incorrect statement for the day!
 
This is my understanding...and opinion...

Under the First Amendment, anyone has the right to burn a cross. The KKK is a private organization; whether they are considered religious or not does not matter.

Since they are a private organization that does NOT rely on government funds, if they have rituals or certain acts that are particular to their organization, they make the rules. They do not have to answer for their way of doing things as long as their actions are not: illegal or infringing on the rights of someone else.

Does burning a cross infringe on someone else's rights? The stereotype of a burning cross is there, yes. But does it actually infringe on the rights of a person? No.

It might piss people off. It might remind them of a time when burning crosses meant danger and hatred. Even if that is what it means today, anyone has a right to state their opinion. If someone does not agree or believe the same way, that DOES NOT mean it is illegal.

I personally do not support the KKK. I simply do not believe in their doctrines. However, if they choose to burn a cross on their own property, and they do not harm anyone while doing it, then by all means. It is their right.

S.
 
Isn't burning a cross a terrostic threat?

Isn't it similar to chambering a round in a shotgun? Doesn't it imply impending lethal force just the same?

Why should an action be protected as "free speech" when words aren't when they are considered terroristic threats?

Certainly an act is more deliberate than a sentence, it should be taken more seriously.
 
Back
Top