Crossing Over with John Edward

tyme

Just me
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Posts
1,170
Has anyone seen this show? This guy says he can communicate with the world beyond. So people come to his show to and hope they get to hear something.

He is good. If you have not seen this show and can watch it just for a few.
 
tyme said:
Has anyone seen this show? This guy says he can communicate with the world beyond. So people come to his show to and hope they get to hear something.

He is good. If you have not seen this show and can watch it just for a few.


He's a good FRAUD
Master of the cold read......I find people who exploit the grief & longing of those who've lost realtives disgusting
They did a GREAT "South Park" episode ripping him, pointing out how he commits his fraud, and explainign succinctly between the poop jokes why what he does is wrong & morally reprehensibe

but that's just me ;)
 
I have the strong urge to take a day off and go to a taping and fake him the fuck out.

But alas, they screen audience members for those who are "readable" by getting their stories beforehand.
 
badasschick said:
I have the strong urge to take a day off and go to a taping and fake him the fuck out.

But alas, they screen audience members for those who are "readable" by getting their stories beforehand.

< shrug >
He'd just edit you out anyway
the phoney
 
Fake or real he is good at it. I would never pay money because I do agree with James
I find people who exploit the grief & longing of those who've lost realtives disgusting

The BIG thing is I do think there are really people out there that can do these things.

I hope that came out right.
 
Penn and Teller declared him "The Biggest Douche in the universe"

it takes THREE HOURS to film ONE thirty minute episode of his show, people who go to them come back unimpressed, and he requires that you bring a FAMILY TREE. He also has microphones over the auidience picking up what people say and assistants asking you "Who would you like to contact"

Penn and Teller RoX0r
 
tyme said:
really? wow.

Yeah, you wouldn't believe how many of those 'misses' that he edits out.

Then he blames them on the people "Oh, they just didn't remember"
 
I'd ask him to use his psychic abilities to contact the chia pet I murdered.

The box said I shouldn't water. But I didn't listen.
 
I'm a skeptic, so when my mother-in-law, who is a bright, educated, rational woman, told me she loved the show, I thought, I'll give it a try.

I don't think I made it through three episodes. It all seemed so fake to me.

Did somebody here lose someone they love by the name of Jim? June....oh wait, it's .... a J name for sure .... anybody? Could be the middle initial. Or last name. Or the name of their favorite teddy bear as a child.

Anybody?
 
Compare the number of questions he asks, compared to the number of declarations...he never actually tells anyone anything, he lets them answer, and then says he saw what tehy tell him.
 
One of the few I had seen had these two women and he had kept talking about a conection between the two. turns out both of then lost husbands in 9-11

I never though of the people asking questions before hand.

Like I said I still think its a good show to see the way he does it is pretty good (or edited good) I would not want to see it everyday but if you catch it on one day and have not seen it......
 
What is everyone's opinion of James Van Pragh??? My mother is quite into watching him...you see him on the talk show circuit... 20/20, Larry King...

He does something similar to John Edwards... but he seems far more believable...

I somewhat agree with what was posted about taking advantage of the grief and suffering... however...

Imagine yourself as a grieving mother to a baby that has died... you feel very disconnected from God, spirituallity, and everything of the sort... you hear of this man that can "contact" people that have passed... Would you not find comfort in anything he could tell you about your child?

My mom is that mother... my sister died when she was 6 months old... and my mother... for the past 10 years.. has had a heavy heart.. she really just needs to know that my sister is okay...

I would pay any amount of money if someone could "believably" tell my mother that my sister is with her.. and that she is still as beautiful as she was the day she died... and that she is with God... just to give my mom that peace of mind... would be worth every penny.

~daisee
 
daiseelady said:
Imagine yourself as a grieving mother to a baby that has died... you feel very disconnected from God, spirituallity, and everything of the sort... you hear of this man that can "contact" people that have passed... Would you not find comfort in anything he could tell you about your child?

Daisee, yes, you are right. I believe people do take comfort in him and others for this reason. I'm not going to pass judgment on it. If there is any way to give a grieving mother some comfort, I'm all for it.

My mother in law lost her mother when she was a teen, and she readily admitted that she was drawn to John Edward hoping he would supply a connection.
 
ohhh... just for the record... I only made it through 2 or 3 of the John Edwards shows, too

I really think he is not as good at it as others are... faking it or not... LOL
 
I hate to say it...but if you have heard of them, they are a phony.

No celebrity psychic has ever been anything but a fraud, and they are teh worst kind, preying on the grief of bereaved families for financial gain.
 
It's false comfort
he's profiting off people's grief
I don't think it gives the sort of true closure that accepting death for what it is & allowing the living to go on with their lives can bring
I wish I could remember the one quote about it
I'll have to hunt & come back
 
tyme said:
One of the few I had seen had these two women and he had kept talking about a conection between the two. turns out both of then lost husbands in 9-11

I never though of the people asking questions before hand.

Like I said I still think its a good show to see the way he does it is pretty good (or edited good) I would not want to see it everyday but if you catch it on one day and have not seen it......

That's what's known as a "hot" reading.

Basically he has an agent who talks to these people a bit and says that they should come on John's show. John then mysteriously knows everything that they told the agent. Imagine that.
 
James G 5 said:
It's false comfort
he's profiting off people's grief
I don't think it gives the sort of true closure that accepting death for what it is & allowing the living to go on with their lives can bring
I wish I could remember the one quote about it
I'll have to hunt & come back

We have all accepted death for what it is... and we do go on with our lives... but a there is this need my mom has to know that my sister has grown up... or that there is someone taking care of her... that may seem silly and unrealistic to you, but unless you have known how empty your arms feel when the life you nurtured is suddenly gone... you could not understand how a small amount of peace is bliss for you... even if you are lying to yourself about it...

I am not trying to argue this point with anyone.... just offering a view from this side of the spectrum...
 
James G 5 said:
It's false comfort
he's profiting off people's grief
I don't think it gives the sort of true closure that accepting death for what it is & allowing the living to go on with their lives can bring

I know what you're saying, James, but I feel like, who am I to say what's false comfort and what's real comfort to somebody else?

Know what I mean?
 
James Van Praagh is the biggest fake of all. My youngest sister & I both received emails from a staffer at his show inviting us to a reading to be taped for his show. The only way his people could have gotten both of our emails was from one of the websites for victims/survivors of murder. My sister & I are very close & she was very close to my son. Of all my family & friends, she is the one who has been with me every step of the way & visits the same sites I do. Those sites are the only ones that have my main email & that I use my real first name. It is very easy to find out information about what happened to my son. I typed my name into the MSN search engine & came up with at least 15 references to my son, what happened to him & to me. It would be very easy for a psychic to do a reading for me. The information is all out there & his people obviously knew where to look. I saw John Edward a few months after the murder of my son. He didn't speak to us & I am skeptical of psychics, but it was interesting to watch. Television evangelists are just as dangerous & prey on people's grief as well. I had a lot of invitations from them, too, but IMO, they are worse than the psychics. For me, there is no true closure, I go on living, but it can never be the same. I just do the best I can.
 
Rubyfruit said:
I know what you're saying, James, but I feel like, who am I to say what's false comfort and what's real comfort to somebody else?

Know what I mean?


I call it false becuase for many it DOESN'T give true comfort
Read some of the stuff about Houdini & his debunking of pstchics, or James Randi's modern work debunking these frauds

Many of the people who feel the need to go to psychics can't let go and the phoney "contacts" only make it worse......Some of the peopel accept it and move on but many more go again & again, spending all their money on charlatans, looking for the "fix" of hearing from someone who's gone

It denies the reality of moving on for both parties

I'm not saying it's ALWAYS negative
But that it often will do more harm than good
 
Okay, I'm ready to start......

(inhale-exhale) I'm being pulled in front of this monitor......I'm being told about someone that has the first initial of "R"....Ru....Rub....is there a ruble in here? Ruby? Yes, and they're telling me you use a..ticky thing..who uses a keyboard?
Oh, you use a keyboard, and who cruises the internet and talks to people? Oh, it's for you I'm sure. They're telling me you converse with people that aren't there...the inner...inter...internet?
Okay, now I know I'm here for sure....and you had someone that you love that was very special to you, sign off of the internet?
They say that you were coming back to their post, but they had to go and we're not there anymore leaving you hurt and disappointed?
They say it's okay, and that they'll p.m. you soon.
(applause)
Thank you, okay now I'm being drawn over to this monitor......


**People sometimes seek external answers to their internal sorrow, sometimes it's drinking/drugs/abuse, or sometimes it's someone that gives them a little peace until the pain goes away. I happen to believe in an existence beyond this lemon of a vehicle, and that's for me, maybe not for you. Freedom to choose what gives me happiness. :D
 
Back
Top