cruelty

cruel?


  • Total voters
    65
Oh, I see what you mean. Yes, hunt them down, into the cracks and crevices of their ip addresses, and finally to their homes and workplaces. Night and day without rest. Until they are layed low.
 
kbate said:
It is never proper to bully someone and that is the disease of Lit. The bully can, without penalty, operate indefinitely in this environment - while others flock to the scent of blood - hoping to improve their own low self esteem by belittling the target of the day.

It is a porn/erotica based bulletin board - I laugh at those who claim moral superiority by bullying those who have been indiscrete. Esteem comes through esteemable actions, not through the moral destruction of others.
Wow.

(If emoticons weren't frowned on here I'd insert a heart one.)
 
CrackerjackHrt said:
find a thread. make a point of demonstrating your superior skills.
Well, I did click on the link and go to the thread. I went back several times. I didn't make any assumptions about superior skills. That's your story. I was truly astounded at the inanity of the thread, and also somewhat curious about the motivation. If I thought I had superior skills, it wouldn't annoy me.

And no-one there wanted to get into it. So I left.
 
Last edited:
My answer to the poll: Not as nice, which is not really accurate in the context of the theme here, but in another way is accurate. I don't think I am ever deliberately cruel, and when I see others being cruel I don't hesitate to defend the victim. But - In real life I am not as sympathetic as I should be. I tend to be stoic myself, and my first reaction to someone who's hurting is to think they should be the same. Which might be cruel of me - certainly some of those who have been on the receiving end of this think so. (I would insert a sad emoticon here.)
 
Olivia_Yearns said:
Well, I did click on the link and go to the thread. I went back several times. I didn't make any assumptions about superior skills. That's your story. I was truly astounded at the inanity of the thread, and also somewhat curious about the motivation. If I thought I had superior skills, it wouldn't annoy me.

And no-one there wanted to get into it. So I left.

i suppose.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't have done it if it was a forum for people with 'special needs'. I assumed intelligence. That's what makes it inane to me.
 
of course it's not.

who shall we belittle next?
 
Some excellent comments in this thread. Really worth reading. It makes for an excellent mirror.

As a lot of folks here have commented from time to time, I lay the smack down pretty hard on some people and, while I don't think I'm a bully, I certainly push really hard on some people at times.

A bully is someone who gets their rocks off by being stronger than somene else because they don't feel so strong themselves. That's not me. I'm not saying I'm perfect or even all that great, but that much I can say isn't me.

The degree to which I "take pleasure" or if I'm "cruel" is a complicated thing to establish.

The reason I start behaving aggressively is always the same: If I see some asshole bullying someone else, they end up going on something of a "mental shit list" for me. My trigger is seeing someone beating up on someone else... mainly if it's another Lit member who doesn't deserve to get batted around, but sometimes flat-out racism or religious prejudice flips my switch. Anyone that I really go after on Lit is someone who I perceive to be funadamentally careless with things of value to others. I don't feel cruel doing it, because I think cruelty is about savoring someone else's suffering. For me, it's more of an impulse to make someone lie down and stay down so they don't attack anyone else. I don't have an urge to destroy them; just neutralize them by taking away their teeth.

I'm not saying that my gauge for when it's right to do that is reliable. I'm just telling you what pulls my trigger.

I also can't say I take "pleasure" in it. It's more something that comes from the gut. It's not done for the rush of pleasure. It's done for different reasons that I can't articulate any better than I already have.

I'm somewhat like this in person, too... though, just as people rarely say in person things that get said on Lit, I also don't react the same way. I will say, however, whenever I see someone attacking someone else in real life, I tend to go to the place of balancing it out and taking their thunder away. And sometimes I really do act in real life the way I do on Lit. As I said... it's my trigger. All my life I've been the guy who polices bullies. When I have my wits about me, it can be a good thing. When I falsely identify who the bully is, it's bad.

Generally, I don't feel much remorse. When Killswitch is a complete asshole to someone who obviously doesn't deserve it, I don't even think twice about tearing him to shreds. When Matthew Craig decides it's time to talk about some poor girl's smelly cunt, I dive right in without hesitation. What, exactly, is there for me to feel remorseful for in those situations?

What I do think, however, is that I should stop and count to ten more often... or (*gasp*) even let some battles go, as Lit is full of many, many people who never change and are inured to all kinds of sanctions or abuse. The problem situations are like this: I'll start off trying to be a "defender" of sorts (go ahead and roll your eyes now. It's ok), and the next thing I know, I've been calling someone a cunt over and over for 15 pages, just in different words... with no change or forward motion at all. At that point it begins to dawn on me that if I'd just let the cunt go, it would have fizzled out many pages ago. That's embarrassing. That's when reasonable people whom I respect step in and say "Jailhouse, what is wrong with you? You're just as bad as he is" and, in a lot of ways, those people are right. And that really hurts. I think if anything can mitigate the positive effects I might be going for (if those are even possible), it's this habit of locking on like a Pitbull and not letting go. I write extremely quickly and accurately, and I can burn through 10 pages in an hour or less if I'm really on fire. That's sometimes a blessing, but more of a curse if I'm not doing anything to make the thread better.

I'm sometimes called a troll... and for a while I thought there might be some truth to that, but I've since changed my mind. I don't seek to disrupt threads just for the joy of watching them crash and burn. I don't post things just to make people angry or to lay a perfectly good conversation to waste. That's what a troll does, and that's not me. Also, you might notice that I tend to go after those who are, themselves, looking to troll others. Really, if I get into a thread by Matthew Craig with a title like, oh... I dunno... "Would you lick a cunt if it had shit on it?"... is it even possible to troll in a thread like that? I'm not saying everything I do around here is genius or anything, but I no longer give serious credit to those who call me a troll. That's not me.

So I guess what I think is that I'm not cruel. I don't take pleasure in making someone suffer for its own sake. Do I need to remind myself of my civility when I engage the "mean" side? Yes. Yes, I do... if only to preserve my own humanity.
 
Last edited:
CrackerjackHrt said:
of course it's not.

who shall we belittle next?

I'll gladly help the two of you, but I'm too tired for that or anything else.

so goodnight, and I'll be back. Was an interesting thread.
 
CrackerjackHrt said:
of course it's not.

who shall we belittle next?
I don't know. I have to wait until the mood strikes me. It's got to really come from my gut, you know?
 
Jailhouse said:
Some excellent comments in this thread. Really worth reading. It makes for an excellent mirror.

<snip>

Do I need to remind myself of my civility when I engage the "mean" side? Yes. Yes, I do... if only for my own sake.

outstanding post.

outstanding summation.
 
Batchoohus said:
My cruelty is manifested by not helping people, just watching them suffer and feeling not much

but..oh well, look what a mess you've gotten in.

I must admit I feel satisfaction it when people who have casually and cruelly hurt others over and over again get the tables turned on them and find themselves the object of intense derision or attacks. People who make others feel despair and rejection on a regular basis always respond with shock, like they're thinking "Have you all lost your minds? Why are you attacking sweet, dear, kind, wonderful ME?" It's quite an interesting pattern.
 
When will you accept cruelty from someone, if ever?

I don't mean backing down in a forum arguement, or letting someone get the last word in, in real life. There are plenty of practical reasons for doing these things that have nothing to do with accepting the other's cruelty.

I think I accept it under two conditions, and both have to be present--just one element isn't enough:

--I acknowlege to myself that this person is dominant over me
--I've known them a long time, like them, and have a lot of positive experiences saved up in their inner karmic bank account in my heart, so they get all kinds of slack that no one else gets.

This is kind of like your two kittens, isn't it, Olivia?

Do I like such cruelty? I don't know the answer to that. Consciously I hate it, especially as it tends to come (not by accident) at times when I am least able to bear it. But it's clear, given my actions, that I don't (or can't?) follow through with ultimatums like "Cut this shit out, or you're history."
 
stirbird said:
When will you accept cruelty from someone, if ever?
I like the way you answered your own question - it was interesting. And I like the question itself.

I will accept people who are capable of being cruel, because I don't know any other kind of person. Some people who would never knowingly act cruel to others are almost proud of how cruel they are to themselves, putting themselves down at every opportunity. If you've ever been very close or intimate with someone like that, you know that there is a lot of collateral damage. People who direct all their hate at themselves actually take a great amount of energy and exert a lot of power if you love them and feel pain for their hurt.

It isn't easy to be aware of your own cruelty. It has disguises. So I tend to feel safest and most trusting around people who acknowledge their own. That's what makes for genuine kindness. When do I accept it? I accept it in people who stop when they see their impact. So if I got it, and I felt it, they don't become relentless. In small doses, it's an anti-venom - a flash that can bring incredible insight. 'Nice' people don't recognise that they hurt, so they don't know when to stop. They were just being helpful, after all, right?
 
I've been mulling it over in the back of my mind since yesterday. People see me as a "nice guy," but if they look closely they'll see I'm not all sunshine and fucking dandelions. I can be a sarcastic, snide bastard. In general, I think my targets deserve my wrath, and in the more extreme cases I'm positive that they do. My main trigger to unleash my snide side is an attack on someone I care about. If the attack actually hurts my friend, then my claws and teeth will come into play. I still try to eviscerate my target with humor, but it's a very caustic humor. Do I enjoy unleashing this aggression? On some level, absolutely. I loathe bullies, and it's a joy to leave them whimpering in the dirt.

There are times when I'm snide, snarky, and belittling when it is not deserved, though. It's a rare occurence, but it does happen. I am wary of this, and especially wary of doing it as part of a mob.
 
Just to add, in my controlling way: along with talking about how much we dislike seeing cruelty, or being victims of cruelty, I did start this thread to address the cruelty we find in ourselves - at least alongside repugnance for cruelty in others.

Jailhouse's post is excellent on that point. It seems it is so much easier to brush over it and get on to talking about one's righteous repugnance, where we are all more comfortable.
 
tortoise said:
I've been mulling it over in the back of my mind since yesterday. People see me as a "nice guy," but if they look closely they'll see I'm not all sunshine and fucking dandelions. I can be a sarcastic, snide bastard. In general, I think my targets deserve my wrath, and in the more extreme cases I'm positive that they do. My main trigger to unleash my snide side is an attack on someone I care about. If the attack actually hurts my friend, then my claws and teeth will come into play. I still try to eviscerate my target with humor, but it's a very caustic humor. Do I enjoy unleashing this aggression? On some level, absolutely. I loathe bullies, and it's a joy to leave them whimpering in the dirt.

There are times when I'm snide, snarky, and belittling when it is not deserved, though. It's a rare occurence, but it does happen. I am wary of this, and especially wary of doing it as part of a mob.
I haven't seen you be cruel to anyone at lit. I doubt anyone else has either. I have seen you be wickedly funny.
 
Olivia_Yearns said:
Just to add, in my controlling way: along with talking about how much we dislike seeing cruelty, or being victims of cruelty, I did start this thread to address the cruelty we find in ourselves - at least alongside repugnance for cruelty in others.

Jailhouse's post is excellent on that point. It seems it is so much easier to brush over it and get on to talking about one's righteous repugnance, where we are all more comfortable.

http://www.thevillager.com/villager_40/mean.jpg

/profundity
 
Olivia_Yearns said:
I haven't seen you be cruel to anyone at lit. I doubt anyone else has either. I have seen you be wickedly funny.
have seen him

get close
 
Olivia_Yearns said:
Just to add, in my controlling way: along with talking about how much we dislike seeing cruelty, or being victims of cruelty, I did start this thread to address the cruelty we find in ourselves - at least alongside repugnance for cruelty in others.
I'd also like to add that stirbird might be taking your original idea (which has gotten a fairly good workout) and adding what might be a new, interesting dimension with which to make the conversation even more compelling and personal than it already is. Just sayin'. :)

Personally, I'm more interested in the original topic, as what's wrong with other people has been done to death, but I'm open to hearing about it
 
Back
Top