DCL - I Beg To Differ

Texan's quoted statement above is true. So is the last line, which calls into question the definition of "knowing" somebody. So, if we can know them in RL, we can know them here. Of course, not universally.

BTW, what was DCL's argument to support his point? Besides "I'm DCL and I'm always right".

Wait, did he consult the magic 8-ball? And I don't mean snorting it...
 
In this case, I think DCL forgot his own advice about economy of expression. He should have just said: Nobody knows anybody.
 
See that?

Lavy gave a logical premise to illustrate her point. And quite well.

Your rebuttal, DCL?
 
lavender said:
You get what you give in life.

(not always, but a great deal of the time)

Why shouldn't the same be true online?

DCL doesn't let anyone in like that - so of course he's not going to find any meaningful type of friendship/relationship.

I didn't give that of myself for a great deal of time. Sure I'll banter and talk politics and even befriend individuals. But, when you give of yourself and another gives of themself in return. I don't see how, no matter what the medium, that gift is unreal.

Exactly, i don't give of myself to many online, but those that i do everything about the relationship is real.

I have met truly wonderful friends online and my life would be much poorer without them. Several of them know me better than those that would be considered my best real life friends.

Don't bother telling me to get a life, i have one. A part of it is spent with people online, and part offline. It's about balance, as is everything else.
 
Texan said:
DCL doesn't need my support, but I agree with him in this case.

You might be able to become acquainted with people online. And once you get to really know someone in real-life, you might be able to maintain a friendship online. But it is too easy for people to hide too much of themselves online. You can only know what a person wants you to know. Hell, this is even true in real-life up to a point.

I don't know how many times I've heard people say that it's easier to get to know the "REAL" person online. That's bullshit (IMO). Some people seem to think that "appearances" only distract from the "beautiful" person inside, and that online we can get to know the inner beauty of a person without appearances interfering. IMO, this is also bullshit.

Appearance is a part of a person, just like posture, table manners, facial expressions, hygene, grooming and style. In addition, to really know a person, you have to know how they handle stressful situations, as well as, how they interact with other people of all types. All of these aspects of a person, are just not a part of the person you get to know online.

More importantly, you can not possibly know if a person is HONEST, through online communications. Many people spend a lot of time online because they have real-life problems that can be hidden when they are online. If you don't believe that, you are either blind or naive.

How many times have you heard stories about people that were friends or lovers online; but when they actually met, the relationship self-distructed? That shouldn't surprise anyone.

just one man's thoughts...

then why are you here?
 
This isn't the personals board. It is one of the few places in the world where freedom of speech 99.9% allowed. You get a wide enough spectrum of freaks, normal people, elderly folks, younger people, lefters, righters, anarchists, hypocrits, blowhards, PC junkies, and it is true that this forum has a high literacy rate without being formally proper. No matter what bullshit spews outta anyone's fingers it is good to write everyday plus it is an active motivator to read and study various topics that the typical person doesn't think is important. Thinking you know more than 42% about a person by only chatting severely underestimates the expansiveness of the human brain. You can see some things you might have in common but not so much more.
 
Siren said:
I guess I dont know my husband then.

Since I never really know anyone online.


but, since I know him offline, does that take me OUT of the loop?

Who are you again?
 
I'm a little queasy about absolutes myself, but I'll mostly have to put myself in DCLs column on this one.

You can come to know alot about a person online. But at some point if a relationship is going to develop it has to develop offline.... There are just too many questions about a relationship that ONLY exists online for someone to say they REALLY know someone that way.
 
lavender said:
You get what you give in life.

(not always, but a great deal of the time)

Why shouldn't the same be true online?

DCL doesn't let anyone in like that - so of course he's not going to find any meaningful type of friendship/relationship.

I didn't give that of myself for a great deal of time. Sure I'll banter and talk politics and even befriend individuals. But, when you give of yourself and another gives of themself in return. I don't see how, no matter what the medium, that gift is unreal.

Welcome to our side of the fence, Lavy. Marxist won't be happy that you switched teams on this one! :p

As I said so long ago, it sometimes has to happen to you first before you can believe in it.
 
lavender said:
You get what you give in life.

(not always, but a great deal of the time)

Why shouldn't the same be true online?

DCL doesn't let anyone in like that - so of course he's not going to find any meaningful type of friendship/relationship.

I didn't give that of myself for a great deal of time. Sure I'll banter and talk politics and even befriend individuals. But, when you give of yourself and another gives of themself in return. I don't see how, no matter what the medium, that gift is unreal.

I agree (though it may seem like I'm contradicting my earlier post).

While I think it is true that each of us is, to some extent, "unknowable" (even to ourselves), I think it is wrong-headed and simplistic to link knowledge, per se (about anyone or anything) with a particular medium through which we communicate.
 
Siren said:


No one.



And Lasher, your point was well said..........and I will have to agree with it, in order for any relationship to become solid and move forward, it must move offline and into a real face to face encounter.

So, I suppose I must agree with DCL to some degree as well.

Yes, but your point also suggests that whatever was developed on-line is going to be, or at least COULD be, a solid foundation for a lasting relationship. And that whatever was gained on-line was valid, meaningful, and worthwhile.

And to devalue what can be gained on-line also devalues the power of the written word in general.

While many might hide behing the anonimity of on-line interactions, others might just as well find enough comfort in it to open up to people in an honest manner that they would not in RL for whatever reason. Are people honest in RL all the time?

I've told Siren more in a few short PM's than I have to any of my RL friends at work, for example. And she even scares the bejeepers out of me.

You get what you put in.
 
Cheyenne said:
Excellent post, Storm! :)

See? I know enough about Chey to realize that she's kissing my ass here.

My reply is for her to shut the fuck up and get a new computer. I hear Schotz is offering overtime to bottlecappers this month. Sign up, hon! You will be able to afford it in no time!
 
storm1969 said:
I've told Siren more in a few short PM's than I have to any of my RL friends at work, for example. And she even scares the bejeepers out of me.

That's one of the things that makes me wonder, though. If you're extremely open with someone who "scares the bejeepers" out of ya online, but in face to face conversation you're much more reticent and less likely to share intimate details... Is the person you know online getting to really know you?

I think that's the point I was really trying to make. You can get to know THINGS about a person online. You can get to know alot of THINGS even, but that doesn't mean you actually KNOW the person.

And when it does come to interpersonal communication so much of what we communicate to others is done by tone of voice and body language. I know alot of the old "Lasher" reputation developed because people on a BB like this just don't see that so much of what I say is done with a smile in my voice (or at least in my eye), and they take way to many things way too seriously.

So just so we're clear on this, I believe you can begin to develop a relationship with someone online, but if you're relationship exists ONLY online then you can't REALLY know someone, but you can know ALOT about them.
 
Start with one part representing yourself to the world as you would like to be seen. Sexier. Wilder. Bolder. More fun. Able to come up with witty one-liners -- even if you don't think of them until fifteen minutes later. The person you would like to be.

Mix that with someone else who sees who you want to be. Someone who is also a bit lonely. Likes very much who you want to be. And, unconsciously, fills in the gaps. Projecting somebody even better.

Mix that with the ability to, from comparative anonymity, behind the safety of the keyboard, to share parts of yourself you don't share with real life acquaintances. Your hopes, dreams and fears. The opportunity to be more honest, and more intimate.

Remove the need for physical chemistry, that pesky little thing in real life that so often keeps us from dating people.

Mix well, and you have a very seductive combination -- which is why on-line romances are notorious for becoming sizzling so fast. Are they real? Reality is in the eye of beholder. If two real people have real feelings, then it is real. While I use it, I am not that fond of using the term "real life", because it implies that somehow the people here are less than real -- when they are very real. Physical reality and virtual reality may be a better way of putting it.

But virtual reality is not the same as physical reality, I agree with DCL on that. Sometimes virtual is all you need, and if it meets a need for you -- great. Sometimes virtual becomes real, and they live happily ever after. But, way, way more often, someone's heart gets broken. Because the image they create of the other person, in intimate, sharing conversation after another -- doesn't stand up to the realities of the physical world. In the unlikely event it ever even gets there.

Just my opinion.
 
Lasher said:


That's one of the things that makes me wonder, though. If you're extremely open with someone who "scares the bejeepers" out of ya online, but in face to face conversation you're much more reticent and less likely to share intimate details... Is the person you know online getting to really know you?


I had a smile on my face with that "bejeepers" comment. See your own second to last paragraph. ;)

And I didn't say "extremely", I just said moreso than in RL.

And yes, they ARE getting to know me if what I tell them is truthful. Which in pm's, I am.
 
storm1969 said:


See? I know enough about Chey to realize that she's kissing my ass here.

My reply is for her to shut the fuck up and get a new computer. I hear Schotz is offering overtime to bottlecappers this month. Sign up, hon! You will be able to afford it in no time!

See and I know Storm well enough that I know he is joking. :)

p.s. I just saw a strange creature in my backyard that I don't know what it is- a nice digital camera would have come in handy.
 
Siren said:


As so many of us have seen with online relationships here on literotica..........so many are made from false information given to us by someone we trust and think that we know.


and then we are betrayed and hurt by the discovery that we really didnt know that person at all.

we can only know as much of a person online, as they want us to know.........and if it is all lies......that is all we get to know.


Gee, I've lost friends in RL this way, too... including my lying, two faced bitch of a sister.

As I said before, it's all what you put into it. I can control me, not anyone else. If I tell someone something privately, it is real and truthful. If they are not honest with me, that's their shortcoming. Not mine. But like I said, that happens in RL just the same.

Say, how does a telephone relationship fit into this mix?

The premise of this thread was calling into question, in a black and white manner, whether we CAN know anybody via on-line relationships or NOT. Not love, or any other tangents this went on.

My answer is YES.

Does that mean we know all, or know enough? NO.

But to discount ALL of what we can gain on-line is inaccurate to me.

But then again, I'm insane. What the fuck do I know anyway. See disclaimer below.

Can anyone actually validate DCL's point with a logical argument?
Every response that seems to support him only supports DEGREES of knowledge gained on line, and of course supports the necessity of RL interactions. None seem to suggest that what we gain here is pure crap.
 
Cheyenne said:


See and I know Storm well enough that I know he is joking. :)

p.s. I just saw a strange creature in my backyard that I don't know what it is- a nice digital camera would have come in handy.

Schlameel, Schlamozzle,........ somethingorother incorporated....
 
Back
Top