education

Todd

Virgin
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Posts
6,893
Is it better to have everyone having the same level educational intelligence or for people to strive to be the best they can be.

Is it better to achieve for individual success, or group mediocricy{sp?}?



I am for individual growth/success.

I personally think that if an individual succeeds it inspires those around the individual to strive harder for success.

I think that if you try to get a group all to the same level of equal success you never truely succeed cause each holds the other back.

Thoughts opinions
 
Individual success is important, but it's also important that the group as a whole succeed to a certain point. When I first came to the board, Weird Harold had a wonderful thread about what it means to be a literate person. There is a point that everyone needs to reach and after that point everything else is individual drive and ambition.


Oh, by the way, why do you assume that if everyone in the group is on the same level it is mediocre? That's not necessarily true, it all depends on what group you're talking about.
 
morninggirl5 said:
Individual success is important, but it's also important that the group as a whole succeed to a certain point. When I first came to the board, Weird Harold had a wonderful thread about what it means to be a literate person. There is a point that everyone needs to reach and after that point everything else is individual drive and ambition.


Oh, by the way, why do you assume that if everyone in the group is on the same level it is mediocre? That's not necessarily true, it all depends on what group you're talking about.

I get your point.

When I say group I mean everyone as a whole the entire poulation. I don't believe its possible to get every one all successfully equal unless the bar of successful equality is brought down to a mediocre level
 
I disagree strongly with that group thing

An individual who is capable should be allowed to soar and not be tied to the earth by those not capable. Classes should be segregated by ability. Just like real life. While we are all created equal, we do not have equal ability in every endeavor.
 
Re: I disagree strongly with that group thing

SINthysist said:
An individual who is capable should be allowed to soar and not be tied to the earth by those not capable. Classes should be segregated by ability. Just like real life. While we are all created equal, we do not have equal ability in every endeavor.

I can agree with everything you said EXCEPT that classes should be segregated by ability. Ability grouping (the educational term) harms all students, high achievers, low achievers, and average achievers. It's brought up again and again as a suggestion to improve education but research has shown again and again that it truly doesn't work.

If you'd like to see it, I'd be happy to link you to research on the Success For All Program. It's a reading program that is supposed to lead to all students reading and it's ability grouped so that the higher students won't be held back by the lower students. It's a complete and total failure based on all the independent research done on the program.


Todd, with realistic expectations we can teach each student to a level of basic literacy. Based on all my work this summer the #1 thing that needs to happen to improve education is that we raise our expectations and COMMUNICATE those expectations to students and parents. It isn't enough to say we want all kids to succeed, we have to make it possible for them to succeed by teaching them and rewarding their efforts.
 
I was in it in the 60's

I was allowed to explore and grow unencumbered by the future defensive linemen of the world :) .

I was in college by the time I was 16 and in the Marines at 17.

Even in high school, I was in an advanced curriculum (sp? too drunk to care). The only time I was ever in equally grouped classes was in junior high school where those who were not up to my level were only interested in chasing girls and disrupting classes.

I think you should read Hesse's Magistre Ludi, The Glass Bead Game. That is how education should be handled. The rest of the drones should be put into a place where they will be happy and can excell to thier talents, whatever they may be (or at least get extensive counseling and therapy).
 
Re: Re: I disagree strongly with that group thing

morninggirl5 said:
Todd, with realistic expectations we can teach each student to a level of basic literacy. Based on all my work this summer the #1 thing that needs to happen to improve education is that we raise our expectations and COMMUNICATE those expectations to students and parents. It isn't enough to say we want all kids to succeed, we have to make it possible for them to succeed by teaching them and rewarding their efforts.


I agree but how can we communicate this to parents who have been washed to believe that the teachers should hold all the responsibility and the teachers who have been washed to believe that the parents are fault of anything wrong with the pupil?

those i see are the two biggest difficulties.
 
No the biggest difficulties are the fear of teaching the excellent and the fera of hurting the feelings of those who care not a whit about academics.

That's why my girl is already in home school.
 
Re: Re: Re: I disagree strongly with that group thing

Todd said:



I agree but how can we communicate this to parents who have been washed to believe that the teachers should hold all the responsibility and the teachers who have been washed to believe that the parents are fault of anything wrong with the pupil?

those i see are the two biggest difficulties.

I wish I had the answers to that Todd.

A piece of the puzzle is communication and that varies tremendously across grade levels. I have a sheet in my students' homework folders and give a daily conduct report and notes if there was something the student had a problem with in class that day. My students and parents KNOW what I expect behavior wise and academically. There are still students who never do their homework and I'm sure there are parents who never look at my reports. That doesn't change what I do, though.

Another piece of the puzzle is the incessant complaining parents and teachers do about each other. We have to stop trying to find the scapegoat to blame and figure out how to help the student learn what they need to learn.
 
SINthysist said:
No the biggest difficulties are the fear of teaching the excellent and the fera of hurting the feelings of those who care not a whit about academics.

That's why my girl is already in home school.

I have no fear of teaching the excellent. My advisor has suggested again and again that I get a certification in gifted and talented. I won't do it, though. My students NEED me much more than the gifted students do. My students are those that would be thrown in that category of "not caring about academics." They are poor, minority and attend a school with a history of low performance. I can't change any of that, but I guarantee that not one of my students will leave my classroom and not be ready for the next grade.

You indirectly hit on one of the big problems with education. The good teachers go to the suburban districts for better pay and to teach the "excellent students who care about academics." The new and less skilled teachers are left to take the jobs in urban districts and in suburban areas with minority or poor populations. Is it any wonder then that school success is so dependent on a students poverty and race?
 
I dissagree

I was not in one of those good nieghborhoods. I was in the working-class white trash enclave of Wyandotte county. Only that segregation allowed me to escape and go on to one of the most excellent lives that a person could have. think of the disruptions of those whom by nature or family values were destined to stay trapped in that hellhole.

I think there were as many dummies in the affluent Johnson county as thier were in the poor Wyandotte county.
 
We're comparing apples and oranges here. You're talking about your life. I'm talking about generalities in education and how I tackle them in my classroom.

Your experience is colored wholly by your success and your own achievement. Look back and think honestly, did you even need a teacher? I don't think so. You would have succeeded and done well without a teacher even being present.


There are students with all levels of abilities in every county. But if you look closely at the data and analyze it, poverty and race do play a significant factor in test scores of students. As much as I hate it, those test scores are the judge and jury of student success.
 
<<<"
with realistic expectations we can teach each student to a level of basic literacy.
">>>

The above exceprt is untrue. To believe that, you must believe that we all magically start with the exact same basic level of physical and emotional capacity. Even with something so "basic" as reading--that is not something that every human is capable of. We each need to strive to be the best we can be. And each child needs to be encouraged to do the same. Of course, adults need encouragement too. Not every adult has the ability to become Bill Gates. Many are being their best when they are at the "bottom of the social scale."
 
Todd said:
I think that if you try to get a group all to the same level of equal success you never truely succeed cause each holds the other back.

Todd,
I gather you're ranting against standardized testing here, and like most oponents of standardized testing, you're confusing minimum standards with limiting educational achievement.

Minimum educational standards are a bit like the sign with a pointing finger at amusement park rides -- "Youmust be this tall to ride."

You would have us believe that finger points at the only height allowed to ride, when it fact it points to the minimum heighth and anything above that level is permitted.

Standardized testing does NOT mean that is all that is permitted (or will be) taught. It means that if you don't learn at least that much, you don't get a diploma.
 
BlondGirl said:
<<<"
with realistic expectations we can teach each student to a level of basic literacy.
">>>

The above exceprt is untrue. ... Not every adult has the ability to become Bill Gates. Many are being their best when they are at the "bottom of the social scale."

This is telling me that you believe that Bill Gates is only "financially secure." That's the level of income one should expect from "a level of basic literacy."

Like Todd, you're equating "minimum" with "only people this tall can ride."
 
Re: Re: education

Weird Harold said:


Todd,
I gather you're ranting against standardized testing here, and like most oponents of standardized testing, you're confusing minimum standards with limiting educational achievement.

Minimum educational standards are a bit like the sign with a pointing finger at amusement park rides -- "Youmust be this tall to ride."

You would have us believe that finger points at the only height allowed to ride, when it fact it points to the minimum heighth and anything above that level is permitted.

Standardized testing does NOT mean that is all that is permitted (or will be) taught. It means that if you don't learn at least that much, you don't get a diploma.

I understand what your getting at Harold, but the theory you present were working that way I wouldn't have anything to complain about but what I see in my neck of the woods, Maine and Eastern Canada, and maybe its not every wheres and I am just jaded in this North Eastern exposure.

But I see as you say the finger pointing to the "you must be this tall to get on" sign.

But what I am seeing is not a cooperation as MornngGirl said of Parents and teachers working together to get students to that minimum of level.

What I do see is either people are falsely putting elevator shoes and top hats on the kids putting them to that level or to the other end lowering the level all together to the lowest denominator.

I remember in my short tenure in school when I started passing grade were 85% by the time I graduated that standard had been lowered to 49%.

We are living in a time like no other, education and knowledge is like it was no other time before, there should be no reason why the bar of minimumcy should be lowered and lowerred and lowered, likely to be removed all together because as some would have us believe holding people to a level of expectancy is discrimatory action.
 
Re: Re: Re: education

Todd said:
I remember in my short tenure in school when I started passing grade were 85% by the time I graduated that standard had been lowered to 49%.

We are living in a time like no other, education and knowledge is like it was no other time before, there should be no reason why the bar of minimumcy should be lowered and lowerred and lowered, likely to be removed all together because as some would have us believe holding people to a level of expectancy is discrimatory action.

Can you document that 49% is considered a passing score as a general rule, or are you talking about a specific test?

As far as I know, the general standard for a passing score in most educational situations is 60-80% (nominally 70%.) This is the standard I was taught was the ideal to aspire to when designing a test to cover material presented in a class. (Taught in a military class on training others, BTW, NOT a civilian class although drawn from civilian research and practices.)

Standardized tests are a different animal than tests to cover material presented in class. Tests should be designed and scored based on the purpose they are intended for. Any test designed to test for a minimum level of knowledge should be designed so that 100% is the norm with a very high pass level -- 90-100%. A test to rank scores should be difficult enough that 100% is nearly impossible. That should put the median raw score around 50%.

How the scores are ranked makes a big difference as well. A test for minimum proficiency should never be scored with percentiles (ranking among others taking the test.) They should always be scored with raw percentages because if they are designed properly everyone would be 99th percentile anyway.

Politicians do NOT understand testing theory (for the most part) and should stay OUT of determining what test and what scores are acceptable. They should only require that the educators define, and test for, minimum standards of literacy and guarantee that funding will NOT be predicated on (those) test scores.
 
test scores

Are basically only usefull as a measure of a societies ability to force every pigeon into the deemed appropriate hole. They eliminate creativity by forcing the best to prepare for the test.

Furthermore, I believe that what we have witnessed over the past few decades is that when the tests do not produce the desired scores, they are re-formulated to produce the diesired scores, i.e., dumbed-down to the lowest common denominator.

Pleas don't take this personally, but the teaching schools are not the home of the best and brightest. Several stories in the last months have highlighted how poor the students are, in general, in the field of teaching. It has become the bastion of the unimaginative and easily manipulated.

My child is being home-schooled and then will be sent to Chinese schools since they still at least believe in a first-rate education and promoting the best. American schools are increasingly designed not to offend, which means that being smart hurts the feelings of those who are not. And there are some out there who are not smart.
 
schools are not just about academic learning , they also teach the social skills that humans need to interact properly with each other , how many child prodigies , home schooled go onto have severe social difficulties in later life often ending in suicide , trying to escape the pressures of bullying parents and unable to cope with the problems of social interaction .
yes the chinese education system is wonderful , tell me about their policy of teaching human rights and equality for all
of course the chinese are not racists at all are they . how can any one nation be racist when it is all too obvious to all and sundry that they are so superior to the rest of the world
it is sooooo obvious , i wonder how i never saw it before
 
Weird Harold said:

This is telling me that you believe that Bill Gates is only "financially secure." That's the level of income one should expect from "a level of basic literacy."

WH,

I did not such thing. You entirely misread what I stated. I am talking of nothing that has to do with society-omposed limits.

Let me give you an example.

I have a nephew. He is not 31 years old--wife, 3 kids, jobs, etc. He is a contributing member of society. But he never learned to read. He tried and tried and tried. He is just stuck in the deciphering stage. It is still a foreign language to him (which, BTW--it what reading is--the symbols ARE another language and there are 2 stages--the deciphering stage and the comprehension stage. The first takes an average of 2 years for most kids and the 2nd is the goal.).
My nephew will never learn to read. I am sure it is even more frusterating to him since he is in a family of readers and is married to one. Somewhere, in the hardware of his brain, he was never able to "get it". That is okay. Not everyone is born with the same capabilities.

Another example. One of the docs I used to work with has a son with an anxiety disorder. There are some other things that are miswired in his brain too. He can read. He loves to read. He, at 8 years old, has a touch that animals simply respond to. He goes into the woods near his home and always brings back birds or other creatures. (Yes, LOL--their home is nearly a zoo.)
But the child can't carry on a conversation. He is not able to process how to respond. He likely never will. The doctor is trying to find ways to lead a child who is so different from herself. She has stated that she wishes her son would have been born before this century when he could be a homesteader.

To say that "each student" can be taught "basic literacy" is very inaccurate. Most people have the physical capability. Not all do. It is no different than assuming that all people can do algebra. While most can be trained to do it--some will never, ever see more than just a jumble of numbers.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: education

Weird Harold said:


Politicians do NOT understand testing theory (for the most part) and should stay OUT of determining what test and what scores are acceptable. They should only require that the educators define, and test for, minimum standards of literacy and guarantee that funding will NOT be predicated on (those) test scores.

WH,
In my experience the politicians are exactly the ones who are determining the way out kids should be taught. And then they don't want to give the appropriate funding. If they want your kids to have an appropriate education they should be willing to pay for it.
 
Todd said:
Is it better to have everyone having the same level educational intelligence or for people to strive to be the best they can be.

"Education" and "Intelligence" are disparate concepts. Having a good education is not in and of itself a measure of intelligence; correspondingly, being intelligent often has nothing to do with your level of education.

I know a lot of stupid MBAs; I also know a lot of very bright people that never went to college.

It is interesting that North America (primarily the US) is one of the few places in the world where not only is Higher Education considered a right, people associate some level of hegemonic prominence with having attended college.

Yet I read somewhere that only 27% of Americans have any sort of degree. They must all live on my block!

Todd said:
Is it better to achieve for individual success, or group mediocricy{sp?}?



I am for individual growth/success.

Question - am I the only one that finds the placement of these two sentences ironic?
 
Back
Top