education

pabloback said:
schools are not just about academic learning , they also teach the social skills that humans need to interact properly with each other , how many child prodigies , home schooled go onto have severe social difficulties in later life often ending in suicide , trying to escape the pressures of bullying parents and unable to cope with the problems of social interaction .

Tsk.Tsk.

Pabloback, do you also discuss how to perform neurosurgery and try to pretend you have a clue?

You obviously have none whatsoever.

The "social skills" that are taught in the public school is one of the main reasons for avoid it according to most homeschoolers. How does it teach "normal" interraction by taking people and segregating them by age and IQ? Is this how we live our lives and choose a job? I don't think so. I have always interracted with all of society EXCEPT when I was in the public school system. (Many private schools are the same.)
The idea that your child shoul learn how to behave in society by sticking him in with other people who don't know how to behave and assuming that niceness and a loving attitude will be the result is as stupid as assuming that sticking a kid in front of the piano without giving him the guidance to understand the music will always produce a Mozart.

I am a homeschooler. I have researched all options and did this as a last resort. Now, I would not change for any reason.--except the insistance of my son. Historically, family-taught "homeschooling" is the time tested and proven method of educating a child--one on one--with guidance all the way. He doesn't learn that people who are different are worth of social hatred. He doesn't learn that labels on clothes are more important than your family or your education. Etc.
My son is a lovely person who can interract with any person at any age. He has not been taught the "use and them" mentality. He can approach and carry on a conversation with anyone-regardless of age or "social standing". He is mostly unaware of the ways people are judged solely on the exterior.

If you wish, I can post the statements on homeschooled employees that is the official statement of the Chick-fil-A corporation.
 
My child goes to a public school. My husband and I picked it, and the neighborhood that we live in, for the diversity. He is going to need to interact with all people in a successful way. Being a beautiful blond boy, he is going to be the minority in his lifetime. I also home school him, as a parent that is my responsibility. I don't have to be responsible for all of his academics, but I am a partner and I am the one who helps him to interpret his learning of the world around him by helping him to be a critical thinker.

Being in a service profession, I have to agree with Mr. Peale, education does not make you smart or creative or happy. Being able to problem solve and dream make you intelligent. Being responsible for your own actions make you intelligent.

Common sense helps. :)
 
Last edited:
Besides the fact that ther is more than one China.

They have always had the ability to separate government from knowlege.

Why do you think they have caught up so quickly?

Bill Clinton can't take all the credit.


Social skills are overvalued in American Education. We keep talking about them, but somehow we have not eliminated bullies or Columbine wanna be's.


There are many good thoughtful posts here.

I almost hate to participate...
 
My children

attend and have attended public school.

The oldest is in college (Sophomore) and is doing quite well. The other two are getting good grades and progressing nicely. They are also learning (NOT being taught mind you) how to interact with their peers on all levels, good and bad. They are learning limits in their behavior and also what they must accept from others.

Their school is not perfect, but from my contacts with the teachers and staff, they do care. The principal is a wonderful man that runs a tight ship. He is not afraid to point a finger at parents and challenge them. Same with teachers and students.

A students success is, in my opinion, 90% dependent on parents and home environment. All a teacher can do is present the material. Poverty is a huge factor in academic achievement. If mom is out working two jobs just to make the rent, she will have little time to supervise little Jane/Johnny's schoolwork. Even a simple thing like breakfast, or a lack of it can affect performance.

The public schools regularly turn out highly achieving students.

I don't see any of the "dumbing down" that Todd has implied. Setting minimum requirements doesn't hold anyone back. No one is penalized for trying harder, or learning more. It just gives administrators a yardstick with which they can guage performance and see what factors may or may not affect the process.

Biggest thing schools could do to improve the situation right now...more teachers, good ones, so that class size can be reduced. This has been proven time and again to be effective.

A little something from my daughter
Discipline
A new school teacher injured his back and had to wear a plaster cast around the upper part of his body, but it fit under his shirt so he dressed up and went to school.

His first class was full un unruly students who were giving him a rough time. He gave the students a reading assignment and sat at his desk, but a
strong breeze from an open window made his tie flap annoyingly. He kept rearranging the tie as the entire class laughed at him.

Finally, the teacher got so frustrated with his flapping tie, he took a big stapler off his desk and stapled the tie to his chest in several places.

From that day on, discipline was never a problem in his class.
 
Last edited:
I have to deal with the cuurent education system all the time.

I went to college at an advanced age. The professors were busy reading the textbooks to the students. I soon stopped attending class. I can read and comprehend. I assume others, who were younger could not.

I teach. I teach fighters. Young people have changed. When I ask them questions. they look at me dumbly. They cannot think. They wait for me to give them the answers so that they can regurgitate them. Who teaches them that? The modern educational system. It fawking sucks.

I make the little fawkers do pushups until they will think for themselves.
 
The modern educational system

is the same one we grew up with.

And therein lies one of the problems. It hasn't been able to adapt much to the changes that have taken place in society and the workplace. Granted the pace of change has been withering. Hell, when I graduated high school, we had three networks that signed off at 1AM and things like VCR's or compact discs were unheard of. That is a lot of new information to assimilate in such a short time.

As far as students being "dumb fawkers", I think that is every generations opinion of the ones coming up behind them. Natural I think. Can't trust the young ones ya know, they will be competing, and invariably kicking our old asses in attracting suitable mates.
 
Re: The modern educational system

Thumper said:
is the same one we grew up with.

And therein lies one of the problems. It hasn't been able to adapt much to the changes that have taken place in society and the workplace.

It's NOT the one I grew up in. Attempts to "improve education" since I started in school in 1955 have made it a much different experience than what I went through.

Some of the changes are good, and many of them are bad (IMHO) but it's nowhere near the same as what I experienced.

I suspect that is true for everyone here that is over 25, because I know that what my grandaughter is going through in first grade doesn't match my memories of what my daughters went through or I went through. Some of that is regional differences, but I think most of the differences are because of changes in educational theories and political pressure to "improve" education without a firm understanding of what needs to be fixed and what works.
 
Back
Top