Electrical Interference and Laptop Modems

Calamity Jane

Reverend Blue Jeans
Joined
Sep 19, 2001
Posts
18,421
I don't know if that's the right way to phrase it, but I've basically come to the conclusion that the reason my laptop modem doesn't work at home, but seems to work everywhere else, is because there's just too much 'stuff' around here to let it get a good connection. The manufacturer is more than happy to agree with me, since they can't discover the problem. I tried a friend's laptop and can't connect with it either, but my desktop connects fine (though very slowly) through the same jack.

Would the following 'noise' affect a laptop modem, but not a desktop one? And, if so, would an external modem, like Marxist's 'fix' the problem?

We have...

Underground fencing for the dogs which is basically an antenna that runs through the ground, and each dog wears a receiver on their collar.

We have a heavy duty electric fence charger for the pasture fence. I know that occasionally, this interferes with the TV, because the picture will flicker at exactly the same rate as the fence pulses.

There is a cell tower 1/2 a mile away.

There is a small airport across the road that I assume engages in some radio traffic.

There is a doplar radar about a mile away.

We live very near the interstate, which would involve a lot of radio traffic.

Other than developing all kinds of weird diseases because I'm living under powerlines of my own creation... would this have any affect on my computer?


Is it worth buying an external modem just to see if it helps?
 
Better to get the phone lines rewired... they are notoriously picky with the internet, the older they are.. .and yours arent new.
 
I know when I have to test modems, we make sure that the electrical appliances in that specific location are limited. As well, we recommend that they remove any 900mHz phone from the same area as the computer. I deal primarily with desktops as opposed to laptops though.
 
i would of said noise on the line but is weird if your other modem works through the same jack

it could be still noise on the line maybe the other modem isn't as sensitive as the lap top one

i had a problem with noise on the line that was caused by water or something in the ground so it might not be to do with electrical stuff in area ... i didn't think that was meant to affect it as the lines have protection against it i think but who knows :)
 
Jim_Henson said:
Better to get the phone lines rewired... they are notoriously picky with the internet, the older they are.. .and yours arent new.
They're about the only things in the house that ARE relatively new darlin!

Actually, the one the PC is plugged into was just run in from the box last year. Wonder if I can get the phone company to replace the box and run a new line in from the road?

I've tried teh modem without the cordless phone plugged in at all, and with, no difference.

I've also had my lines checked for noise, supposedly they're fine. I suppose that it could just be that the phone company doesn't want to fix them, but I have tried using a filter, and it doesn't seem to make any difference either.
 
Next time you are on with the phone company ask them how old THEIR lines are... cause you may not be able to do fuckall if they are still copper cable...

Oh and from your box to the front is probably an idea... its basically what I meant in the first place. It wasn't till we put got a totally new number installed with a new line that our modem on our computer at home worked at all.
 
pagancowgirl said:
I tried a friend's laptop and can't connect with it either, but my desktop connects fine (though very slowly) through the same jack.

Would the following 'noise' affect a laptop modem, but not a desktop one? And, if so, would an external modem, like Marxist's 'fix' the problem?

We have...

The Doppler Radar installation is the only place putting out enough power to cause serious interference, but it should effect the desktop's modem as well. I don't think RF interference is the problem -- I think it's your phone lines; specifically, the distance between your house and the phone company.

Check out v90.com -- they have a good FAQ page on how your phone lines/company afects v90 connections (the typical dial-up modem connection.)

56K.com has a troublshooting guide for bad connections, but I don't think it will help solve the problem -- although it might help you to understand the problem.

An external modem could resolve your problem -- external modems have their own power supply and aren't limited to the power saving requirements of laptop modems.


Another possiblity is a phone line amplifier. About the only difference I can think of between a desktop and laptop is the power-saving requirements of a laptop. I suspect that the laptop modems just aren't "loud enough" to deal with your phone lines.

Try using a shorter phone line from the laptop directly to the wall outlet -- if RF/electrical interference is a problem, the typical 8-12 foot phone cable for a laptop increases the chance of it picking up interfering signals. A short (2-4 ft) phone cable would reduce the chance.
 
Originally posted by pagancowgirl
I don't know if that's the right way to phrase it, but I've basically come to the conclusion that the reason my laptop modem doesn't work at home, but seems to work everywhere else, is because there's just too much 'stuff' around here to let it get a good connection. The manufacturer is more than happy to agree with me, since they can't discover the problem. I tried a friend's laptop and can't connect with it either, but my desktop connects fine (though very slowly) through the same jack.

Would the following 'noise' affect a laptop modem, but not a desktop one? And, if so, would an external modem, like Marxist's 'fix' the problem? . . .
I'm aligning with WH here. Your note about the desktop modem connecting slower indicates the problem is likely the lines between the phone box and the Central Office (phone company's site where your lines connect).

Three miles is about the longest run they usually make and if those lines have been around for twenty years or so, that is most likely the problem; degradation of the insulation on the copper line.

Getting those replaced is NOT something that is likely to happen. The phone company is required to guarantee good voice quality but unless things have changed recently, they aren't required to provide adequate support for the sophisticated modem protocols in use nowadays.

The V.92 might help but if the lines are deteriorated badly, probably not. If you can get one of these modems on a loan, buy-if-it-works agreement, give it a shot.

And look carefully that the modem is V.92 already. I was looking at a modem yesterday which said V.92 prominently and in small print said "READY". reading further, I could flash the modem's memory and upgrade to V.92 by downloading a file from the 'net.
 
I may just bring the fork back, only cuz you asked. :)

It's probably the lines between me and the phone company. Dammit. They put in new copper last summer, but the company is about 6 miles away, and nothing between the new lines and the house has been upgraded in who knows how long.

Thanks, I'll put an external on my wish list for Christmas or something.
 
pagancowgirl said:
We have...

Underground fencing for the dogs which is basically an antenna that runs through the ground, and each dog wears a receiver on their collar.

We have a heavy duty electric fence charger for the pasture fence. I know that occasionally, this interferes with the TV, because the picture will flicker at exactly the same rate as the fence pulses.

There is a cell tower 1/2 a mile away.

There is a small airport across the road that I assume engages in some radio traffic.

There is a doplar radar about a mile away.

We live very near the interstate, which would involve a lot of radio traffic.

Remind me to make a donation to cancer research in your name.
 
Re: Re: Electrical Interference and Laptop Modems

Unclebill said:

Getting those replaced is NOT something that is likely to happen. The phone company is required to guarantee good voice quality but unless things have changed recently, they aren't required to provide adequate support for the sophisticated modem protocols in use nowadays.

If you can say that they're interfereing with voice calls then you're very likely to get them replaced.
 
Re: Re: Re: Electrical Interference and Laptop Modems

Originally posted by Spinaroonie


If you can say that they're interfereing with voice calls then you're very likely to get them replaced.
The problem is, they'e going to check out any problems you report thoroughly, VERY thoroughly, before they replace 6 miles of copper.

And I'll bet we ain't talkin' about a 2-pair or 3-pair cable from the CO. Very unlikely PCG is the only customer out that leg and certainly not the only potential customer.

PCG, if you have cable service, you might look into I'net over that medium. Lots faster and maybe not too much more expensive. Where I am, it's $24.95/mo and the bandwidth my sister-in-law got when she signed up is about 1.8 Mbps (better than a T1 line). Of course, that may decline if more people sign up on her loop, though.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Electrical Interference and Laptop Modems

Unclebill said:
The problem is, they'e going to check out any problems you report thoroughly, VERY thoroughly, before they replace 6 miles of copper.

And I'll bet we ain't talkin' about a 2-pair or 3-pair cable from the CO. Very unlikely PCG is the only customer out that leg and certainly not the only potential customer.

However... If her lines are that crappy, they may need replacing anyways. It's worth a shot ;)
 
Unclebill said:
The problem is, they'e going to check out any problems you report thoroughly, VERY thoroughly, before they replace 6 miles of copper.

I think you misread PCG's statement, "They put in new copper last summer, but the company is about 6 miles away, and nothing between the new lines and the house has been upgraded in who knows how long. "

I read that to mean that there IS new copper up to the pole/junction where PCG's line(s) break away from the branch line -- something less than 6 miles, probably only about 1/2 mile of old copper.

a modem that is "v.90" ready -- like my USR exeternal -- is fine for PCG's needs since her ISP probably doesn't support v.92 yet anyway and upgrading the flash ROM only takes a few minutes (plus download of about 2 MB of update.) A v.92 (or v.92 ready) modem would be helpful becaue it remembers line characteristics and negotiates much fater than a v.90 -- but that's the only advantage v.92 has until the ISP puts up a v.92 server.
 
Weird Harold said:

I read that to mean that there IS new copper up to the pole/junction where PCG's line(s) break away from the branch line -- something less than 6 miles, probably only about 1/2 mile of old copper.

Right-O WH. New copper from town to my driveway.

I'll call the phone company and have them come out and do more tests. We don't have great voice quality either... the cordless is VERY fuzzy if I'm more than a few feet from the base.
 
pagancowgirl said:


Right-O WH. New copper from town to my driveway.

The cordless problem sounds more like problem with the positioning of the base station than it does anything related to the modem problems.

Is the line from the road to the house buried? How long is the line from the road to the house?

It's probably an expensive solution, but burying a new line form the house to the road might solve most of your problems.

A friend of mine ran a new 12 pair shielded cable from the street to his house to get an additional phone line -- moving the existing phone lines to the sheilded cable made a very noticeable improvement in modem performance and voice quality in just a 25 yard stretch.

I think the phone company connected the shielded cable for just the $40 service charge for connecting the new line -- nothing additonal for moving the old lines to the shielded cable.

The phone company even provided the cable to make sure that it was compatible with their requirements.
 
It's maybe 100 feet from the road to the back of the house where the phone box is. And yeah, it's buried. I'm 99% sure though, that it hasn't been upgraded from the main line to the box in over 30 years.

I'll start checking into what we can do here, and what the phone company can do. Maybe in the next 40 years or so, we'll get something worked out. ;)

Oh, what I wouldn't give for cable service out here!
 
pagancowgirl said:
It's maybe 100 feet from the road to the back of the house where the phone box is. And yeah, it's buried. I'm 99% sure though, that it hasn't been upgraded from the main line to the box in over 30 years.

1970's era buried phone lines were usually six-pair or eight-pair unsheilded cables. I would expect that replacing that with shielded cable will make a BIG difference in your phone service.

An external modem is going to be cheaper, but a pain to configure so you can still use the internal when you're on the road.

Installing more phone capacity -- upgrading to a shielded 12-pair cable -- on the other hand will cost more up front, but add to the value of the house. (about $1000 in the case of my friend's new cable.)
 
Back
Top