Especially for Marxist..

PowerOfOne

Literotica Guru
Joined
Oct 30, 2001
Posts
918
Marxist, I ran across this and you came to my mind. Enjoy!!
:D

FUTURE IN THE PAST

The man looked a little worried when the doctor came in to
administer his annual physical, so the first thing the doctor did
was to ask whether anything was troubling him.

"Well, to tell the truth, Doc, yes," answered the patient. "You
see, I seem to be getting forgetful. No, it's actually worse than
that. I can never remember where I park my car, where I'm going,
or what it is I'm going to do once I get there -- if I get there.
So, I really need your help. What can I do?"

The doctor mused for a moment, then answered kindly, "Pay me in
advance."

Actually, forgetfulness isn't all bad...especially when we decide
to forget all that pain from the past that threatens to ruin the
present. Like one song says, "There ain't no future in the past."

The past is to be remembered -- how else will we learn from it
and keep from repeating it? But why would I want to remember
every time I felt hurt because of my spouse, my children or my
friends? Why would I want to fill my mind with a detailed
catalogue of past pain? Better to remember the times they brought
me joy or love or feelings of warmth. Unfortunately, even those
wonderful and magical moments too easily fade away.

A friend of Clara Barton, founder of the American Red Cross,
asked her about a particular traumatic event in her life. Miss
Barton seemed perplexed.

"Can't you remember?" the friend prodded.

Clara Barton replied, "I distinctly remember forgetting it."

Dwell on the past -- but not the negative past, not the pain of
the past nor the sadness. Dwell on the good. Be consumed by past
joys and obsessed with gratitude. Dwell upon the moments that
uplifted you, the times you laughed and the memories of love
shown to you by friends and family.

Not everything should be remembered, and those who live well know
what to forget and what to cherish. Like the song says, "There
ain't no future in the past." But there IS joy there. And love.
And kindness...if we choose to remember.

© 2001 Steve Goodier
 
The author presents a fallacious argument. Forgetting individual slights and painful memories is not analogous to a society forgetting the pains it has inflicted upon a population. Following his logic, we should forget the Holocaust and the A bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. We should set aside the Cultural Revolution and the Rape of Nanking. I flatly disagree with this.

You have stated your opinion several times that you do not feel personally responsible for the pains minorities have endured in the founding of this country. As long as we are active members of a society, it is our duty to keep a vigilant watch to ensure that such atrocities are not repeated, and to eradicate the effects of past atrocities.

Discrimination is still a very real part of society. It is not as overt or damaging as it was in the days of slavery or segregation, but it still adversely impacts all of us. When you think of certain negative stereotypes, and they bring to mind a specific racial group, that is the lingering effect of discrimination. We may not consciously act upon such stereotypes, but they are there, and they do influence our behavior.

The next time you are in a store, and you see a black person and a white person shopping, notice the sales clerks. Most likely, they will be more attentive to the needs of the white person, but will stand watch over the actions of the black person, without offering assistance. I've seen it in several cities. There is no name calling or open hostility, just a distinct difference in the treatment. Forgetting about our past, as this article so blithely suggests, will not correct this inequality. Only awareness will.
 
Last edited:
Mischka said:
The author presents a fallacious argument. Forgetting individual slights and painful memories is not analogous to a society forgetting the pains it has inflicted upon a population. Following his logic, we should forget the Holocaust and the A bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. We should set aside the Cultural Revolution and the Rape of Nanking. I flatly disagree with this.

You have stated your opinion several times that you do not feel personally responsible for the pains minorities have endured in the founding of this country. As long as we are active members of a society, it is our duty to keep a vigilant watch to ensure that such atrocities are not repeated, and to eradicate the effects of past atrocities.

Discrimination is still a very real part of society. It is not as overt or damaging as it was in the days of slavery or segregation, but it still adversely impacts all of us. When you think of certain stereotypes, and they bring to mind a specific racial group, that is the lingering effect of discrimination. We may not consciously act upon such stereotypes, but they are there, and they do influence our behavior. Next time you are in a store, and you see a black person and a white person shopping, notice the sales clerks. Most likely, they will be more attentive to the needs of the white person, but will stand watch over the actions of the black person, without offering assistance. I've seen it in several cities. There is no name calling or open hostility, just a distinct difference in the treatment. And that is a shame.








WHAT A CAT>>>>>>>>>>>>LMAAOOOOOOOOOOO





:D :eek:
 
If you intend it only for one recipient, and not for general discussion, then use e-mail or a PM. Posting it on the General Board implies that it is for general consumption.
 
Thank you Mishka, and you generally replied. ~laughing~ This thread is not about discrimination. But thank you for your thoughts anyway. :)
 
Sorry for the confusion. The last discussion I saw you had with marxist regarding history dealt with responsibility for the involuntary servitude and eradication of populations, the lingering effects of which are discrimination. I naturally assumed that an article suggesting to forget the pains of the past followed your argument that you are not responsible for pains caused in the past.
 
Eradication of populations? No, Mishka, I have posted no such thing. The post you are talking about had to do with what I thought was the racial connotation of the names of the NAACP and the UNCF. Eradication of populations??? Now that is a reach.

Also, if you re-read this thread you will see it does not say to forget the past, it says to learn from it but move forward.
 
Wanna know whatsa hoot

Even African Americans discriminate amoungst themselves based on skin color.

It's true!

Even my daughter's godmother prefers lighter skin and they are both Chinese!
 
Especially for Marxist on a general boards doesnt imply 'only' for Marxist.

The last exchange I saw involving Marxist and Pow1 was about past sins, responsibility, etc, etc. I dont want to put words in either Marxist or Pow1's mouth but I drew conclusions as to intent and to reception that I think are reasoable.

Out of context, I still dont like new age morality tales with sugary toppings.
 
PowerOfOne said:
Also, if you re-read this thread you will see it does not say to forget the past, it says to learn from it but move forward.
The article states: "Not everything should be remembered, and those who live well know what to forget and what to cherish."

Marxist discussed the eradication of the Native American populations through disease and war in his threads.
 
Mishka, Mishka...please do not take it out of context. The article also states:

The past is to be remembered -- how else will we learn from it
and keep from repeating it? But why would I want to remember
every time I felt hurt because of my spouse, my children or my
friends? Why would I want to fill my mind with a detailed
catalogue of past pain? Better to remember the times they brought
me joy or love or feelings of warmth. Unfortunately, even those
wonderful and magical moments too easily fade away.

As for what Marxist posted only he is responsible for his posts. I am responsible for mine and I never said anything about eradication of anyone.

I posted this, especially to Marxist, because it did hit a chord when I read it that reminded me of him and our discussion. It is not meant to offend and as I re-read it I cannot find one thing offensive contained in it. I am truly sorry that you, as well as others, took it that way. It is simply a way of telling Marxist how I feel. It was NOT meant to make anyone angry. Actually I think it is a great message and you do not have to read it if you do not want to. So if you are offended by what the message contains, my sincere apologies but I happen to like it and I think Marxist would know what I meant also, not that he would agree with it, just that he would know.
 
I was not offended or angered by the article. As applied to an individual's life, it's a fine message. I merely pointed out the fallacy of attempting to extrapolate the message to a society, which is what I presumed (incorrectly) was your intent in posting it. I simply mentioned the historical examples because they were part of your previous discussion with marxist; I did not mean to suggest that you made the remarks, just that the remarks were made in the previous discussions and seemed relevant to adiscussion on lingering discrimination.

(This may sound nitpicky, but my name is Mischka with a "c." I've seen a Mishka around here, so I'm a bit more sensitive to the spelling of my name. :) )
 
I apologize for the misspelling. I can certainly understand why you would be sensitive about it. Thank you for your comments but the thread was started for a much simpler reason. It is not deep by any means. Just a way of telling Marxist the way I feel about it, nothing deeper than that. Thank you! :)
 
Pof1, I appreciate the thought.

Like Mish and Modest Mouse, I don't walk around disgruntled at the cards the world has dealt me. I appreciate a good bit of what I've been blessed with.

I will say though, that the more I speak with folks, the more I know the struggle is far from over. The question I addressed in the other NAACP thread was one of how to effectively contribute to the cause, not necessarily a debate over the existence of the cause. Maybe you should revisit my Auburn frat turd thread in which members of two Auburn frats held a party in which they came in blackface with ropes around their necks. Oh yeah, one came as klansman too. No one batted an eye until the pictures showed up on the web. Future leaders of America.

We can't forgive or forget with the nonchalance you propose. Did you not read 1984? Those that controlled the constantly re-edited history of Oceana controlled its destiny. It was a parable not only of Communism but Western culture.

That's why the debate over Columbus and the Civil War and the Holocaust are vital not just to academics but everyone, and effect the perception of the future and how its achieved.

How can anyone say that we don't owe another a culture a debt? Your parents or grandparents may not have been born in America but does that prevent you from taking advantage of the color of your skin and subjugation of an entire continent? Nope. I live in Georgia (the land of the Creek and Cherokee) and live here because my white forefathers snatched it from my Indian forethathers' hands.
 
Last edited:
"Nope. I live in Georgia (the land of the Creek and Cherokee) and live here because my white forefathers snatched it from my Indian forethathers' hands."

It's ok, Marxist. We, the Cherokees, don't want the land back. It's all icky, now. :p


*Disclaimer : Just a bit of humour, poking fun at myself, while trying to recover from no sleep and too much time to think about serious matters.
 
Thank you Marxist...

Thank you for your reply, Marxist. I do HEAR what you are saying and to some extent, I agree. But if we continue to look for people that have been wronged in the past instead of the ones that are being wronged today, are we really doing the best that we can for all people?

I stand by my original position. I refuse to pay for something that I had nothing to do with. I want to correct what is wrong today and not what was wrong years ago and have since made major leaps in being righted and continues to do so. I want to only use the past as a learning tool and go from there instead of trying to make reparations which includes changing the names of the associations that you mentioned.

Let me ask you, Marxist. If we could make amends for slavery in a monetary value who do we pay? How much do we pay? There is no one alive today(that I know of) that was an actual slave in the United States. Would this be enough or would we still be having the debate we are now? At what point can we consider the debt paid?

Amends cannot be paid for, Marxist so what other compensation would you suggest? Treating you as an equal, my peer, and respecting you and your opinions would not be the ultimate goal, Marxist? If so, then my debt is paid for I respect you and your opinions and consider you very equal to me and consider you my peer and thoroughly enjoy the debates that we have.

The American Indian (and Raindancer, I love your post..~laughing~) also have my respect and admiration. I offer the same respect to people of all races/culture unless someone, individually, shows me that the respect is misplaced. Isn't this the ultimate goal of all races/cultures? In everything that I have ever read about the atrocities commited against the American Indian or the Afro-American, the need for equality and respect is the goal, not money.

My point, in our original thread, Marxist, is that you cannot have it both ways. To continue to have organizations with names that clearly are intended to seperate the races is not a balance to achieve equality. To realize the delicate balance of equality means gaining but also forfeiting. I do not think by asking that the names be changed to include all people would be a loss but would be an achievment towards the ultimate goal of these very agencies.

Of course I realize that there are many agencies that are directed at only one segment of the population. But the equlity is that you can have the exact opposite (most of the time) of the agency without offending. A simplified example of this would be the Boy Scouts of America/the Girl Scouts of America. It would be very offensive to most people to have something called the United White College Fund and the opposite of that offends me. I am searching for the balance to equality, Marxist, nothing more.

Marxist, this thread has gone all over the place when it only started out as a way to tell you how I feel but the rest of what I have posted here is for that very reason so I suppose that it fits.

Thank you, Marxist and all that have read the thread and/or responded to it, for the replies. I do read each one and think carefully about what each person is saying. Thank you for your time as well as your impressions.
 
Back
Top